Pars Review – Stat Pack

STAT PACK

UPDATED THE DAY AFTER GAMEDAY.

Picture

Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

A game against the only team in the 4 SPFL divisions that had yet to win a match this season ended in a less than comfortable 2-1 victory. The first half saw Dunfermline clearly on top and they should have gone in at the break with more than a one goal advantage, supplied by Declan McManus’ 10th goal of the season. Brechin had zero threat up front in the opening half, with lone striker Isaac Layne doing a lot of running around to little effect. The Pars’ opening goal was well worked, with Nat Wedderburn’s pass finding Nicky Clark, who headed the ball back across goal for the incoming McManus to slide in and score. There were other good moves involving Joe Cardle, Michael Paton and Clark that almost led to a second goal. As the stats above show, while the Pars had 15 attempts at goal, Brechin (eventually, as the game went on) also had a reasonable amount of goal efforts themselves, with 11. Both teams were lacking accuracy with their goal attempts, with 40% of Dunfermline’s shots/headers finding the target, and only 27% of Brechin’s. 

Picture

Michael Paton

Another good team goal early in the second half doubled Dunfermline’s lead, finished off by Michael Paton after good work by Clark and Cardle. Paton, who has been impressive since coming into the team in recent weeks, thrashed the ball high into the net off the underside of the bar. He has the ability to finish and will probably be disappointed not to have scored more goals in his time at East End Park – this was only his seventh goal for Dunfermline in 2 and a half seasons at the club. 
Brechin brought on Connor McLennan after 55 minutes and 4 minutes later the sub scored a fantastic goal from distance to cut Dunfermline’s lead in half. For the third game out of the last 4, Wedderburn was culpable, losing out in a midfield tussle, then being too slow to chase the more mobile McLennan who then ran forward and struck home a great shot from 25 yards. Lack of pace in midfield is killing Dunfermline’s season, something that is entirely the manager’s doing. Rather than acknowledge this or take responsibility for his poor transfer dealings in the last transfer window, he turned on the home support in a post-match interview, blaming the fans for making the team anxious after Brechin’s goal. Here is the outcome of a Twitter poll that we ran on the Pars Review Twitter page after the game, regarding the manager’s comments:

Picture

Unity is required and while the manager’s comments were basically a plea for that, he went too far and risked alienating the people who turn up to watch what is an under-performing team each week, something he should consider along with his role in the matter . 
Stat Pack aims to look at a game comparing statistics to how the game felt and if the stats reflect the outcome. Ultimately, we won the game and if we can repeat this result in the next 2 games, the fans and the manager will both be happier. 

Picture

Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

A performance that was a marked improvement on the shambles of last weekend but still not enough to win a game against a very average table topping St Mirren side. Dunfermline lined up with Allan Johnston’s preferred 4-4-2 line up, with all his early season mainstays in the team. While at no stage did either team dominate, possession was in Dunfermline’s favour. The Pars also had more goal attempts than the home side and more corner kicks – and therein lies one of the team’s main problems – crossing the ball, in open play and from dead ball situations. Kallum Higginbotham rarely found a team mate with any of his chip/crosses, and typically, and infuriatingly, played the ball to the nearest St Mirren player, never beyond his team mates, always under-hit. Corner kicks were no better: Joe Cardle was given the job this week and once again the deliveries barely made it past the front post. 

Picture

Joe Cardle

The yellow card count was indicative of how referee Craig Charleston handled the game. There was little disputing most of the Pars bookings but referee Charleston was suspiciously lenient with St Mirren, with no bookings for the home side despite giving numerous free kicks to Dunfermline. How Adam Eckersley avoided at least a yellow card is a mystery – he kicked out at Declan McManus in front of the same linesman who had a big role in the non-penalty controversy, and then made a 2 footed lunge later in the game, which resulted in a foul given but not even a word from the referee. 
The only statistic that matters is the scoreline but a draw would have been a fairer reflection on how the game went. Unfortunately, this game also added to another awful statistic for Allan Johnston’s team this season – they have now lost the first goal on 11 occasions, and have still not come back to win any of those games. They have gone onto lose 8 of the 11 and draw the other 3. The central midfield pairing of Nat Wedderburn and Dean Shiels have also extended their run of no goals and no assists this season to 43 (Wedderburn 24 games, Shiels 19).

Picture

Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

A shameful display from the players and an example of awful team selection, with muddled thinking on and off the pitch, all contributing to the worst home performance in years. After last week’s loss at Dundee United, when I erroneously praised the players for showing a bit of back bone, simply because they hadn’t done so at that venue in the recent past, when in fact that should be a given, this latest embarrassment saw them basically give in and stop trying as the game went on. One yellow card was issued by Willie Collum, to the hapless and hopeless Callum Morris, who was then shown mercy by Collum for a foul when play was waved on, and then conceded a penalty later in the game. Collum, who loves a red card, took pity on Morris, which is quite sad to contemplate.  
Queen of the South had 15 efforts at goal, their attacks orchestrated by the superb Stephen Dobbie, who had just celebrated his 35th birthday but who on this form, and against this type of opposition, could play until he is 50. Rarely will Dobbie meet such little resistance, and indeed he was helped by Pars sub Dean Shiels, whose role in Dobbie’s first goal, could almost be described as an assist. Meanwhile, Shiels has yet to create a goal for Dunfermline this season – a total of zero assists. 

Picture

Lewis Martin and Nat Wedderburn: “the midfield”

56% possession means very little when your midfield consists of a centre half, Lewis Martin, who is behind Jean Yves M’Voto in the pecking order for a place in the defence, and Nat Wedderburn, whose bulk has reduced his mobility to that of a sunken treasure chest trapped on the ocean floor. Wedderburn is the only available actual central midfielder at the club (the only other one, Aaron Splaine, is injured), and although he was partly at fault for Queens’ opening goal, to sub him after 35 minutes and leave the fourth choice centre half on, alongside former striker Shiels, was a strange move by the manager. Johnston seemed to believe that in Martin he had discovered an unearthed midfield gem, one which he had stumbled across last week when Martin was a late addition to the starting line up at Tannadice because Shiels was stuck in traffic. Unfortunately, Martin, despite plenty of effort, looked very much like a fourth choice centre half being played out of position. He was not alone; Johnston started the game with the same 4-1-4-1 formation as last week, but with his favourite player Nicky Clark now fit and back in the team in the lone striker role, something he is completely unsuited for, with last week’s lone forward Declan McManus being shunted to the right wing. Meanwhile, there were 2 right wingers on the subs bench (Fraser Aird and Kallum Higginbotham) plus Michael Paton, a right winger who started and ended this game in central midfield plus a period on the right wing in between after Johnston changed the formation to 4-4-2 after 35 minutes. At that point, McManus joined Clark up front, and must have wondered why “left winger” Joe Cardle was also frequently seen in that area of the pitch. Cardle’s role in the team is undefined – he’s certainly not playing as a winger – and his absence on the wide left resulted in his team mates having no outlet to pass to out wide. 
The stats for this game cannot tell the full story and cannot explain the manager’s muddled thinking, or his players’ lack of leadership. Downing tools after the fourth goal was inexcusable, a move which recalled the Stephen Kenny era, when it appeared as though several players had lost faith in their manager. 
Queen of the South ended the game with ex-Pars under 20s player Scott Mercer at right back and another former Dunfermline player, fullback Shaun Rooney, on the right wing. Both players were released by Johnston a couple of years ago. Their direct opponent for the latter part of the game was Fraser Aird, brought on to good effect last week on the right wing and whose penetrating run won a penalty. This week, when many expected him to start the game in his natural position, he was given the last 5 minutes as a sub – at left back. 

Picture

Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

There was a greater physical edge to the Dunfermline team that faced Dundee United yesterday, with a change in formation designed to make the midfield more robust. There was also the introduction of defender Lewis Martin as a central midfielder, which pre-kick off seemed part of a plan but Allan Johnston’s post-match comments seemed to suggest that it was due to Dean Shiels being delayed in traffic. Shiels, who was sharing a car with Fraser Aird, may have started otherwise. Shiels and Aird got to Tannadice before kick off but missed the start of the pre-match warm up and were named among the substitutes. Martin’s only other recent midfield appearance was as a substitute against Queen’s Park in the Scottish Cup. Deliberate or not, his inclusion had a positive effect, with the spine of the team being bolstered by the use of Big Nat in front of the defence in a 4-1-4-1 formation. Going with an extra midfielder meant playing one up front, which raises another question: had Nicky Clark not missed the game through injury, would Johnston have played Clark as the lone striker, a role better suited to Declan McManus, who did well in that position?
Dunfermline conceded 21 free kicks to United’s 12, and committed more than twice as many fouls as their opponents. While this was mainly because the team did not allow themselves to be bullied, it was also partly due to yet another overly-fussy referee and a home side who went down at the first opportunity, and whose goalkeeper was, embarrassingly for them, time wasting after only 30 minutes. 

Picture

Sean Murdoch

While the attitude of the team and their willingness to more than match their opponents physically was pleasing, the stats do also confirm weaknesses. Dunfermline had just 1 shot less than United but rarely troubled the 20 year old home side’s keeper, Harry Lewis. Kallum Higginbotham had 2 first half chances that he failed to finish off, and there were other efforts, mainly from distance, that did not cause Lewis any problems.                                                                       
At the other end, Sean Murdoch was once again beaten by a free kick from outside the box. The well-placed shot, from Scott Fraser, was on Murdoch’s stronger left side, and although he made a full length dive, it was not enough to prevent the ball sailing past him. Free kicks have now become as good as a penalty kick to opposition teams, with average players suddenly transforming into Zico circa-World Cup 1982. The odds are usually against the taker scoring but for a reason that is up to the coaching staff to identify and correct, Dunfermline are losing goals almost every time a free kick is conceded within 30 yards of the goal. 

Picture

Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

Statistics do not always reflect form and attitude, and yesterday was a classic case of this. Dunfermline had more possession, as expected, and Dumbarton committed twice as many fouls, which is natural for an away team, part -time, in a lower league position and who lost 5-1 on their last visit to East End Park. Additionally, one of Dumbarton’s 5 yellow cards was for their goalkeeper time wasting. Despite this, Dumbarton did not come to merely defend, and they looked a well set-up team that were highly motivated and determined to take something from the game. Dunfermline, in contrast, were ponderous and disjointed, with the achingly slow centre midfield pairing of Big Nat and Dean Shiels seeing balls chipped past them, around them, and also caught in possession themselves by their eager visitors.

Picture

Nicky Clark

Another telling statistic is that Dumbarton had just 1 shot on target less than Dunfermline. They attacked through the middle, identifying the weakness in the Pars team – a slow midfield – and all the time knowing that the Pars’ formation would never change from 4-4-2. It is one thing sticking to a philosophy, but the lack of tactical flexibility is hurting Dunfermline. Every opposition manager knows how we will line up. We are predictable in the extreme. Even after substituting 2 actual wingers, the manager moved striker Callum Smith to the right wing in order to keep the 4-4-2 in place, rather than go to a 4-3-3 or 4-3-1-2 set-up, something that would have forced Dumbarton into, at the very least, assessing who was marking who and how we would utilise certain players within a changed formation. 
Nicky Clark’s late equaliser was his second goal in 3 games (the other being in the Scottish Cup game at Queen’s Park last week) and his first League goal since 23 September. Clark is the first Pars player to get into double figures for goals this season, with his tally of 10 coming from 17 games. He has scored in 6 of those 17 games, with all his goals coming against part time teams in League and Cup competitions (v Elgin, Dumbarton, Buckie, Brechin, Queen’s Park and Dumbarton again).
One final stat: Although having achieved just 1 win in 7 League games, Dunfermline are still just 4 points off the top of the table. If the current leaders’ (Dundee United) points total – 27, after 14 games – was recalculated over 36 games, the title would be won with 69 points. That’s 2 points less than last season’s winning total; 12 less than 2015/16; and 22 less than 2014/15. You have to go back to 2008/09 to find a lower winning points total for this division, although Dundee did equal that total in their Championship winning season of 2013/14.

Picture

​Key statistics from yesterday’s game and how the stats compared to my view of the 90 minutes.

Picture

The Championship’s highest scoring team met League 1’s lowest scorers and so a 4-1 scoreline could have been seen as a likely outcome pre-match. Almost every Pars attempt on target resulted in a goal and it was pleasing to see the strikers scoring again: Nicky Clark’s goal was his first in 7 games and took his season tally to 9; Declan McManus’ late goal ended a run of 5 games without a goal and was his 7th of the season; while Andy Ryan, with much less game time than any other Pars striker this season, got his 5th Pars goal to add to the 2 he scored for Airdrie prior to his transfer. Here are the minutes played and goals scored by the top 6 Pars scorers this season (Andy Ryan’s stats are for Dunfermline games only):
Joe Cardle: 1110 minutes; 9 goals; 123 minutes per goal
Nicky Clark: 1181 minutes; 9 goals; 131 minutes per goal
Declan McManus: 1290 minutes; 7 goals; 184 minutes per goal
Kallum Higginbotham: 1645 minutes; 6 goals; 274 minutes per goal
Andy Ryan: 272 minutes; 5 goals; 54 minutes per goal
Callum Smith: 854 minutes; 3 goals; 284 minutes per goal

An overly-fussy referee awarded a total of 30 free kicks in what was a tame match. The only pleasing aspect of referee Steven McLean’s display was that he wasn’t card-happy, issuing just 2 yellow cards (both to Queen’s Park). Dunfermline committed more fouls – according to the referee, anyway – but avoided any bookings, which is important given the impact suspensions would have on a first team squad that numbers just 19 players (5 other players are on loan to other clubs). 

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham at Hampden yesterday. Photo: Pars Review

Although Kallum Higginbotham’s form has dipped in recent weeks, he was still able to play the final pass to Jason Talbot, who hammered home Dunfermline’s second goal. This was Higgy’s 13th goal assist of the season – more than any other player in Scotland in League and Cup competitions this season. Last season, he had more assists (11) than any other Pars player, and has already passed that total this season in mid-November. He will sit out the game against Morton on Tuesday when he serves a 1 game suspension and the team will miss his creativity, even if he can be wasteful in possession at times. 
Ending this week’s Stat Pack looking at assists within the squad, after Higgy with 13 comes Ryan Williamson (6) and Joe Cardle (5) – which included a perfectly weighted cross for Nicky Clark’s goal yesterday. 

Picture

The top 50 players in my time as a Pars fan: a post-Kozma era list. I attended my first Pars game in September 1991 and started going regularly from the spring of 1992 shortly after Istvan Kozma left for Liverpool.
Talent alone is not enough to be included: based on pure ability, the list would look different. Instead, while ability is the main consideration, I have selected and then rated the players based on ability plus attitude, impact and overall contribution to the club.

​Part 1 of this feature can be read here
Now here’s Part 2, with the top 25:

​​25. Josh Falkingham

Picture

23. Faissal El Bakhtaoui
22. George O’Boyle
21. Andy Rhodes
20. Ian Ferguson
19. Lee Bullen
18. Joe Cardle
17. Ivo Den Biemen
16. Barry Nicholson
15. Marco Ruitenbeek
14. Paul Smith
13. Andy Smith
12. Scott Thomson

Picture

10. Jackie McNamara
9. Andrius Skerla
8. Ian Westwater
7. Andy Tod
6. Craig Robertson
5. Stewart Petrie
4. Hamish French
3. Stevie Crawford
2. Craig Brewster

Picture Picture

The top 50 players in my time as a Pars fan: a post-Kozma era list. I attended my first Pars game in September 1991 and started going regularly from the spring of 1992 shortly after Istvan Kozma left for Liverpool.
Talent alone is not enough to be included: based on pure ability, the list would look different. Instead, while ability is the main consideration, I have selected and then rated the players based on ability plus attitude, impact and overall contribution to the club.
​Part 2 of this feature will be posted tomorrow.

​50. Steven Bell
49. Lee Ashcroft
48. Danny Grainger
47. Gerry Britton
46. Michael Moffat

Picture

44. Jason Talbot
43. Andy Geggan
42. Dorus De Vries
41. Darren Young
40. Derek Fleming
39. Allan McGregor
38. Willie Gibson
37. Marc Millar
36. Callum Morris
35. Kenny Ward
34. Scott Wilson

Picture

​32. Ryan Scully
31. Ryan Williamson
30. Greg Shields
29. Allan Moore
28. Paul Gallacher
27. Andy Kirk

Picture

Continued tomorrow 

On this day… in 1988, Dunfermline drew 0-0 with Queen of the South at Palmerston Park, one of only 2 games in a 13 game period that striker Ross Jack (pictured) failed to score. He scored in 11 out of 13 games between October 1988 and January 1989. 
The Pars team that drew with Queens was: Westwater, G.Robertson, R.Smith, Holt, Watson, Beedie, M.Smith, P.Smith, Jack, C.Robertson, Irons.

Picture

Ross Jack in his playing days with the Pars (left) and as he looks today (right).

Ross signed for Dunfermline in October 1987 and went onto become one of the best strikers at the club in the Leishman era. His 18 goals in 1988/89 helped the Pars win the First Division and promotion to the Premier League. Although born in the town of Avoch, in the Highlands, he began his professional career as a 16 year old at Everton, before moving to Norwich and then Lincoln. In 1985 he signed for Dundee where he spent 2 seasons. His period at East End Park, from 1987 to 1991, was the most successful of his career, scoring 46 goals in 130 games. He was the club’s top scorer in all of his 3 full seasons, and in 1989/90 he was just one goal behind Hearts striker John Robertson at the top of the Premier League goalscoring chart at the end of the season. He played on for a further 3 years after leaving Dunfermline before moving into management. He is currently the boss at Turriff United, in the Highland League.

In addition to new articles every day on this site, Pars Review is also very active on Twitter and Facebook, where site updates are posted, plus extra features and DAFC new stories that are not always posted as articles here on the Pars Review site itself.
Already this week, there have been Twitter and Facebook posts on subjects not seen here on the main site: these include the 8 match ban handed to Falkirk’s Kevin O’Hara and the departure of David Hopkirk from East End Park. There’s also other DAFC-related material that is posted on the 2 Pars Review social media sites, plus shares of football news stories and other updates. 
This site will always be the “home” of Pars Review but you may enjoy our social media activity for extra bits and pieces, polls, opinion and discussion.
You can follow us through clicking on these links:

Pars Review Twitter
Pars Review Facebook

Many thanks for making this week the second biggest for site visits by Pars fans in the 28 month history of Pars Review! 

Picture