Blog Archives

Picture

All photos by Pars Review

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

A tremendous display to progress into the next round at the expense of crisis-hit Hearts

Despite being without top scorer Nicky Clark plus Dean Shiels, one of the best footballers at the club, Dunfermline progressed to the last 16 of the Betfred Cup with a fantastic team performance and some outstanding individual displays. It had been anticipated that Shiels would move up front to replace Clark, whose injury was confirmed 2 days ago. Shiels’ absence was a surprise, so while there was an expected return for Nat Wedderburn in midfield, there was also a first start for 17 year old striker Callum Smith. Hearts manager Ian Cathro dropped his best player Jamie Walker due to speculation about a transfer to Rangers, while new signings Christophe Berra and Kyle Lafferty started. 
The Pars began the stronger team, taking the game to a home side that was clearly lacking in confidence, following their defeat at Peterhead in midweek. With a point required to top the group, regardless of any penalty kick bonus point, Dunfermline attacked from the outset, determined to secure a rare win at Tynecastle and win the group convincingly. 
Disappointingly, after such a good opening period, Hearts took the lead in the 20th minute when Don Cowie’s shot beat the outstretched arm of Sean Murdoch. The Pars keeper seemed to get his angles wrong, but he was to atone for that as the game progressed. 
The equaliser came after 29 minutes and was quite simply stunning. Kallum Higginbotham’s pass found Joe Cardle in the inside-right position. Cardle moved to the left to make space then curled a fantastic left foot shot beyond Jack Hamilton in the Hearts goal.  This was Cardle at his very best – a mercurial talent who has the ability to create something very special out of nothing. 
Mention has to made made of the despicable Kyle Lafferty, who needlessly wound up the travelling support after Hearts’ opener, and then disgracefully took a dive in the box later in the first half. He was not booked for either incident. Referee Craig Thomson, who had a shocking game, failed to punish the player, whose career has been full of examples of cheating, diving and feigning injury. 
The game had action at both ends of the pitch, with Callum Smith and Declan McManus working tirelessly in attack, while at the opposite end of the field Murdoch made a fine finger tip save from a Beuben effort, then 5 minutes before the break made an outstanding reflex save to prevent an own goal from a flicked header by Callum Morris. 

Picture

Celebrations after the Pars’ second goal

The second half was 7 minutes old when Dunfermline took a deserved lead. Callum Smith received the ball in space, and showing great composure held the ball up before playing in Declan McManus, who elected to take an extra touch before shooting past Hamilton. The Pars players and fans went wild. 
Dunfermline were denied a chance to go further ahead when referee Thomson refused to award a penalty despite McManus being barged in the back. Thomson seemed intent on playing Hearts back into the game, awarding freekicks for innocuous challenges, from which Hearts resorted to long punts into the Pars penalty box.
Scott Lochhead, who had replaced the excellent Smith, had an effort from distance but it was the home side who were gradually getting more of the ball, partly thanks to the referee, but showing no guile or any semblance of a plan to break down the well organised Dunfermline backline. Captain Callum Morris was an inspirational figure at the back, with the ever-dependable Lee Ashcroft beside him. Fullbacks Ryan Williamson and Lewis Martin continued their fine early season form: Williamson is back to his best and combined solid defensive work with some dangerous runs up the right wing. Martin, a player who excels by doing the simple things simply, had a very good game, clearing his lines when required. The defence were protected by 2 central midfielders who some feel collectively lack the pace to play together against Premiership opposition, but Big Nat and the outstanding Michael Paton both gave excellent performances. Kallum Higginbotham was always involved on the right wing, while on the left, Cardle gave a man of the match performance. 
Hearts fans were leaving the stadium before their team got a late equaliser when Isma Goncalves stabbed the ball in after a mini-stramash in the box. The referee then added over 4 minutes on after the 90 minutes ended, for reasons known only to himself. During that period, Hearts should have stolen a victory but first Goncalves and then sub Cole Stockton missed glorious chances to win the game, which would have been daylight robbery.
The final whistle eventually was blown, and the Pars had the point they needed to win the group. Drawn games in the Betfred Cup groups stage are followed by a penalty shoot-out for an extra bonus point. Although neither side needed the extra point – Dunfermline were through regardless, while Hearts had to gather the full 3 points to progress – it was the Pars who won the shoot-out after successful kicks from Paton, Lochhead and Big Nat. McManus saw his chipped effort saved, but it didn’t matter after only Lafferty scored for Hearts, with McGhee, Martin and Cowie all sending their shots wide or over the goal, not even forcing Murdoch to make a save. 
A great day and a huge confidence booster for the upcoming Championship campaign.
​Pars starting 11 & subs:

Picture Picture

Showdown at Tynecastle between the top 2 teams in Betfred Group B

Betfred Cup – Saturday 29 July 2017 – Tynecastle Park – KO 3.00pm

Dunfermline and Hearts face each other in the final round of fixtures in this season’s Betfred Cup, with the Pars requiring a draw to finish top of Group B. Being a Premiership team, Hearts were – and remain – favourites to win the group, but need to win the game, as the group table below illustrates. Dunfermline last won at Hearts’ ground in 1990 and although a victory is not essential, it would be a huge boost going into the Championship campaign next weekend, as would qualification through avoiding defeat.

Picture

Life as manager of Hearts has not been easy for Ian Cathro. The 30 year old, in his first managerial role, inherited a team that was in second place in the Premiership last December, and somehow led them to a fifth place finish, a massive 30 points behind runners-up Aberdeen. His record in charge until the season ended was played 22, won 4, drawn 5, lost 13. A full article on his tenure was posted here on Wednesday (www.parsreview.org/blog/jambo-cathro-woe). 
Victories in the opening Betfred Cup group games eased the pressure on Cathro, until his team suffered a disastrous 2-1 defeat at League 2 Peterhead on Tuesday evening. This led to renewed criticism from Hearts fans, which will only increase tomorrow if Dunfermline leave Tynecastle with a win or a draw.

Picture

Dunfermline have scored 11 goals and conceded 1 in the opening 3 Cup games, with an avalanche of goals in the 2 home games against Elgin and Peterhead. Just 1 goal in the away game against East Fife would have seen the team safe at the top of Group B already. However, the game at Bayview finished 0-0 although the Pars did win an important bonus point in the penalty shoot out. 
Allan Johnston continues to field trialists in closed door bounce games but has yet to sign any of the trialists he has had training or playing since pre-season began. Frustratingly for a competition that is seen as an extension of pre-season, trialists are not allowed in the Betfred Cup, so the Pars team tomorrow will be along familiar lines. Unfortunately, there will be one enforced change due to an ankle injury to top scorer Nicky Clark, which is obviously a blow to the team’s hopes of progressing. Clark is likely to be out for around 4 weeks (depending on which source is read) and with the team’s other first choice striker Declan McManus suspended for the opening 2 Championship games, the need to add at least 1 other forward to the squad increases. Dean Shiels is likely to move up front alongside McManus at Tynecastle, with Big Nat coming back into midfield after being on the bench last week. 
David Hopkirk is the only other player missing through injury. Jason Talbot is training again and has played in at least 1 bounce game but will probably be a substitute tomorrow. 

Picture

Ian Cathro edit​ by Pars Review.
Match report/opinion with photos will be posted here around 9pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

Big Jock parks the PARDIS outside EEP and has a look outside.

For new visitors to this site, the PARDIS is a regular feature that has a current Pars player going back in time to see a Dunfermline game, in a time machine that is spookily similar to Doctor Who’s TARDIS. For the past 2 years, the Moff was the Commander of the time machine. Now that he has left East End Park, the keys to the PARDIS have been handed to Jean Yves M’Voto, affectionately known as Big Jock.
Whereas the Moff’s journeys were random, Big Jock has decided to set the PARDIS on course to past games involving our next opposition. So today we travel back to 2007 to find out what happened when the Pars faced Hearts, who we will be up against in 2 days in the Betfred Cup. 
Dateline: Saturday 3 February 2007
Competition: Scottish Cup Last 16
Location: East End Park
Result: Dunfermline 1, Hearts 0
A last minute header from centre half Scott Wilson sent Dunfermline into the Scottish Cup quarter finals. Hearts were on top for much of the game against a Pars team who were battling relegation in the Premier League. 
Dunfermline boss Stephen Kenny was without injured captain Greg Shields and the cup-tied Stephen Glass. Hearts manager Valdas Ivanauskas made 6 changes to his line-up and was without defender Christophe Berra through injury (Berra rejoined Hearts this summer after leaving Tynecastle in 2009). 

Picture

Scott Wilson (number 3) powers home the last minute winner

Dunfermline keeper Dorus Devries was required to make several crucial saves, most notably efforts from Saulius Mikoliunas. Pars defender Phil McGuire headed an Andrew Driver effort off the line, while Dunfermline came close to scoring when Hearts keeper Steve Banks fumbled a cross, which fell to Pars winger Adam Hammill. He chipped the ball to the back post to Stevie Crawford, whose on target header hit the back of Lee Wallace on the line.
Just when it seemed that the tie would be heading for a replay at Tynecastle, Scott Wilson ventured upfield in the 90th minute and headed the ball past Banks from a Hammill cross. 
Pars starting 11:
​Dorus DeVries, Greg Ross, Scott Morrison, Phil McGuire, Scott Wilson, Gary Mason, Jim O’Brien, Stephen Simmons, Stevie Crawford, Mark Burchill, Adam Hammill. ​

Picture

Ian Cathro, reacting to news that Tesco have sold out of the Beano before he could get his copy

Hearts’ embarrassing 2-1 defeat at Peterhead last night has given Dunfermline an unexpected opportunity to win Group B of this season’s Betfred Cup by securing a draw when we travel to Tynecastle on Saturday. Had Hearts beaten Peterhead, the Pars would have needed either a win (something not achieved at Tynecastle since 1990) or a draw plus a bonus point for winning a penalty shoot-out. Now a draw would be enough, regardless of penalty kicks. 
The Premiership side’s loss to League 2 Peterhead, who had lost 5-1 at East End Park in their previous Betfred game, increases pressure on Hearts “boss” Ian Cathro. I use inverted commas deliberately when describing Cathro as boss – his position has always been under scrutiny, working under Hearts owner Ann Budge and Director of Football, and ex-Hearts and Scotland manager Craig Levein. Cathro was publically humiliated last season during a game at Pittodrie when Levein, sitting in the stand, was having notes passed to the young manager during the game. The perception of 30 year old Cathro is that of a man-child who is a fish out of water, someone with no previous management experience and who is more skilled in preparing a laptop presentation than in actually putting a team out on the park that wins games. 
Hearts’ experiment in catapulting a novice coach into a management role has, so far, not succeeded. Seen as Levein’s puppet, Cathro took over a Hearts side in early December 2016 that was second in the Premiership at the time manager Robbie Neilson left to take over MK Dons. The subsequent months of the season saw Hearts fall to fifth place in the division, and a massive 30 points behind runners-up Aberdeen. They were also by-passed by Rangers (21 points ahead of Hearts) and St Johnstone (12 points ahead). Cathro’s League record read: played 22, won 5, drawn 4, lost 13. Significantly, they also went out of the Scottish Cup to rivals Hibs.

Picture

Levein tells Cathro about the time he put out a Scotland team with no strikers, a move he later claimed was copied by Barcelona

​Some of Scottish football’s more traditionalist pundits, players and ex-players were sceptical about the Cathro appointment back in December last year. Kilmarnock striker Kris Boyd, who completed a Pro-Licence coaching course alongside Cathro, said in his newspaper column, before Cathro’s first game as Hearts manager:
“He’s one of the up-and-coming, modern-era coaches who can organise a session just by flicking open his laptop. There isn’t a session out there he couldn’t get on to his Macbook. But setting up a presentation to a group of players is all well and good. That does not require man management skills, which is part of the game he knows absolutely nothing about. Time will tell if I’m wrong on that. But if I was a Jambo I’d be worried.
“For me the practical stuff involved in coaching is easy — it’s dealing with highly-charged players that’s the hard part. And for me Cathro is way, way out of his depth.
“I don’t see a confident, charismatic top level coach when I look at him. I just think of the shy lad who hardly spoke to anyone when we were on the same coaching course.”

Hearts’ fans online reactions since the final whistle blew last night have, not surprisingly, been highly critical of their manager. Comments include: 
“We can build a new stand but we will be lucky to fill it with this idiot in charge.”
“Playing for nearly 10 minutes with 10 men while somebody’s scone is being stitched is plain stupid. Getting the shirt numbers of the subs in the team lines wrong is plain embarrassing.”
“The only positive I can glean from it is that it just might accelerate Cathro’s departure. I still think we’re stuck with him until October while we’re sitting in the bottom two or three teams. Please don’t confuse this with a meltdown, I really don’t have an issue with the players, it’s just the manager really is out of his depth and clueless. Your experiment has failed Levein – admit it and get it sorted.” 

Of course, Hearts will still be favourites going into Saturday’s game. However, Dunfermline will not have a better chance to achieve at least the draw that is needed to win the group. It is high time the Tynecastle hoodoo was broken. 

Here’s a gallery of how East End Park has changed over the past few decades, from the 1950s to the present day. 

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

Photos sourced online, except for images 13, 14, 16, 18, 19 & 20 which are by Pars Review

Picture

All photos by Pars Review

Picture

Dean Shiels and Callum Morris

Picture

Pre-match warm up

Picture

Sammy and pals

Picture

Lee Ashcroft and Callum Morris

Picture

Nicky Clark passes to Declan McManus for the opening goal

Picture

Celebrations after McManus scored

Picture

Ryan Williamson

Picture

Joe Cardle celebrates his first goal, with Declan McManus

Picture

Lee Ashcroft

Picture

Clark, Ryzo and Higgy congratulate Joe on his second goal

Picture

Higgy

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Rory McAllister tries to persuade Bobby Madden into giving Morris a second yellow card – and fails

Picture

AJ and Sandy looking glum despite the 3-0 half time lead

Picture

Declan McManus

Picture

McManus lobs the ball over Greg Fleming for his second and Dunfermline’s fourth

Picture

The 2 Pars scorers

Picture

Nicky Clark joins in the celebrations

Picture

Michael Paton with trademark smile

Picture

Team spirit is high at East End Park

Picture

McManus is proving to be a clever signing

Picture

Higgy – always involved

Picture

Dean Shiels with McManus pointing the way

Picture

Dean Shiels – sheer class

Picture

Nothing can stop Ryzo in full flight

Picture

McManus – man of the match

Picture

AJ with Declan McManus after the full time whistle

Picture

McManus and AJ thank the fans at full time

Picture

Captain Morris

Picture

McManus gets his first Pars goals in another convincing home win

Declan McManus and Joe Cardle both scored doubles as Dunfermline easily dealt with Peterhead’s sometimes questionable tactics at East End Park. There was 1 change to the team that started the previous game at East Fife, with Dean Shiels replacing Nat Wedderburn. 
Straight from the kick-off, the Pars took the game to the visitors, almost scoring one of the fastest ever goals in the stadium when McManus burst forward on the right, then moved inside only to have his shot blocked.  The opening goal did not take long to come though, and it was McManus who finished off a move engineered by Nicky Clark after 7 minutes. After impressing with his work rate in the opening 2 games of the Betfred Cup, but without scoring, it was good to see McManus opening his goal account for the club. 
Joe Cardle doubled the lead in the 12th minute after Kallum Higginbotham found him in the box. Cardle swept the ball into the net for his first goal of the season. Dunfermline were dominating the game, with Peterhead resorting to some dangerous lunges that fortunately failed to connect with Pars’ players legs.
Cardle made it 3-0 after 22 minutes following a great run down the wing from Ryan Williamson, who looked up and played a perfect pass to the Pars winger, who finished with confidence.
In the 40th minute, Peterhead’s Rory McAllister conned referee Bobby Madden into booking Callum Morris by going down easily in a tussle with the Dunfermline captain. McAllister himself was booked 4 minutes later for fouling Morris, and compounded the offence by then holding his face as if Morris had hit him. 

Picture

Just as in the previous home game against Elgin, Dunfermline added an early second half goal to a resounding first half lead. This time it was McManus, with a sublime lob over Peterhead keeper Greg Fleming. It was by no means an easy chance, with McManus judging the angle and distance to perfection as the ball sailed over Fleming and into the net. 
Peterhead were a beaten side but did threaten for the first time when firstly fullback Jason Brown missed a great chance to score from a header, then Sean Murdoch made a good diving save from a shot from ex-Par Willie Gibson.
Allan Johnston made 2 changes in the 59th minute with Aaron Splaine and Callum Smith replacing Michael Paton and Nicky Clark. 
Peterhead did get a consolation goal in 61 minutes when Lee Ashcroft handled in the box, and Rory McAllister scored from the resultant penalty. Another Pars change was made with Big Jock M’Voto coming on for Joe Cardle, and the formation changing to 3-5-2. 
A fifth Dunfermline goal came after 74 minutes when McManus’ cross from the right was sliced into his own net by Scott Ross. 
The game was played in poor weather conditions, with a cold wind and heavy showers. The team did well to keep the ball on the ground and comprehensively outplay their opponents. Dean Shiels was efficient in midfield on his first start, Ryan Williamson was always keen to get involved with overlapping runs up the right side, Cardle will be boosted by his double, but it was Declan McManus who was the standout performer. His workrate is exceptional but he is much more than a willing workhorse. He has a good touch and awareness of the play around him, working well within the team and already looking like a clever signing.
​​Pars starting 11 & subs:

Picture Picture Picture

Old rivals meet again in the Betfred Cup

Betfred Cup – Saturday 22 July 2017 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm 

The Betfred Cup group stage continues tomorrow, when Dunfermline welcome old adversaries Peterhead to East End Park. Rivals in League 1 between 2014 and 2016, the clubs are now 2 divisions apart after Peterhead’s unexpected relegation in 2016/17. Manager Jim McInally survived the relegation, after leading his team to the promotion play-offs 12 months earlier. 

Picture

Peterhead were among the favourites for promotion to the Championship a year ago but their season got off to a bad start, losing 5 of the opening 8 League games. They eventually gathered 40 points but ended in the 9th place relegation play-off position. A 4-1 aggregate win over Montrose in the play-off semi final set up a final against League 2 Forfar, which Peterhead lost over the 2 legs by 7 goals to 2. 
McInally, in charge at the club since 2011, has added goalkeeper Greg Fleming and winger Willie Gibson, both ex-Pars, to his squad. A third former Dunfermline player, striker Allan Smith, will be competing for a place alongside club legend Rory McAllister, whose 26 goals last season could not prevent the club’s fall to League 2. McAllister, who has an excellent record of 146 goals in 234 games for Peterhead, has already opened his account for this season, scoring the only goal in his team’s win over East Fife in the opening Betfred Cup game last weekend. Peterhead have played 1 game in the competition so far – clubs play 4 times over 5 matchdays, sitting out 1 matchday each, which in Peterhead’s case was midweek this week. 

Picture

Dean Shiels

Allan Johnston has led his Dunfermline team to 5 points from a possible 6 in the 2 Betfred Cup games so far. The resounding 6-0 win over Elgin last Saturday was followed by a 0-0 draw at East Fife on Tuesday. The competition’s format includes a penalty shoot-out after drawn games for an extra bonus point, which went Dunfermline’s way after a 9-8 spotkick win.
New signing Deal Shiels made his debut at Methil as a second half substitute. His class and ability was immediately obvious, and he is likely to start against Peterhead. Shiels is an adaptable player but if he is used in the same central midfield role as he occupied at East Fife, one of Nat Wedderburn or Michael Paton will drop out. Big Nat is seen as an automatic first team starter, but to drop Paton would be very rough, such has been the good early season form of the converted winger. Paton has been one of the team’s best performers in a more central role. 
Johnston, who stuck rigidly to a 4-4-2 formation last season, has already shown a willingness to try different formations this pre-season and during the Betfred Cup game against Elgin. As I have suggested in the line-up graphic below, the addition of Shiels gives more options to the manager, and a 4-1-3-2 formation could be tried, meaning Wedderburn and Paton retain their places, with Joe Cardle dropping out.
Injury update: 
David Hopkirk (back running) & Jason Talbot (nearing full fitness) are both missing from the squad this weekend. 
With the players available, here is my preferred starting 11:

Picture

Dean Shiels photo & Jim McInally edit​ by Pars Review.
Match report/opinion with photos will be posted here around 9pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

All photos by Pars Review

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

Stalemate in Methil with a bonus point for penalty shoot-out success

After the resounding 6-0 win over Elgin at East End Park on Saturday, Dunfermline again faced lower division opposition in the Betfred Cup group stage, this time East Fife. Not surprisingly, the Methil team provided stronger opposition than Elgin, being a division above Saturday’s opponents and having home advantage. However, the Pars dominated possession and had more attempts at goal (17 to East Fife’s 3) but wasteful finishing and the failure to test the 2 East Fife goalkeepers (one each half) meant that the game finished in a draw. The Betfred Cup awards a bonus point for winners of a penalty shoot-out after drawn matches, and it was Dunfermline who won, by 9 penalties to 8. 
Allan Johnston selected the same team that faced Elgin, with new signing Dean Shiels on the bench after international clearance was received. Aaron Splaine was also fit again, and also listed among the substitutes. 
The beautiful summer evening had the expected cool breeze from the sea just over the New Bayview boundary walls, and Dunfermline soon established superiority in terms of ball retention. The home side, who had manager Darren Young among their subs due to missing several players through injury, were unable to test Pars keeper Sean Murdoch. Dunfermline also did not trouble either of East Fife’s goalkeepers too greatly, with the home side playing Tom Codery in goals in the first half, and ex-Par Ryan Goodfellow in the second period. The closest Dunfermline came to a goal in the first half was when Nicky Clark had the chance to shoot, but delayed, and the opportunity eventually was lost. Kallum Higginbotham also had a goal attempt after a pass-back to the keeper was penalised, but the East Fife defensive wall stood firm and blocked Higginbotham’s shot. 

Picture

Callum Smith scores the Pars’ ninth, and winning, penalty kick

The second half began in much the same manner, with the Pars having plenty of the ball and launching continuous attacks, which ended either in a shot hit over the bar or a move fizzling out before Goodfellow in the East Fife goal could be tested. Midway through the half, Johnston made a double substitution, giving Shiels his debut, and also putting on Scott Lochhead, with Higginbotham and Big Nat being withdrawn. It became immediately obvious that Shiels, who was positioned alongside Michael Paton in central midfield, is still a quality player, and looked a level above most of the other players on the pitch. Lochhead also made a positive contribution, as did the third sub, Callum Smith, who had a late shot that Goodfellow saved. Smith had replaced the hard working Declan McManus, who was the team’s best performer.
And so the game went to penalties, which last season would have been Dunfermline’s worst nightmare. Both teams scored their opening 8 attempts, with the Pars scoring through Shiels, Paton, Clark, Cardle, Lochhead, Morris, Ashcroft and Williamson. Smith then scored the Pars’ ninth, after which East Fife’s Ben Gordon hit the post with his effort. 
The bonus point could be important come the end of the group stage and Dunfermline now have 5 points from a possible 6. They also have a class act in Shiels, who will be a great asset in the season ahead. 
​Pars starting 11 & subs:

Picture Picture

Potentially the only Fife derby for the Pars in League or Cups this season takes place in Methil this evening

Betfred Cup – Tuesday 18 July – New Bayview, Methil – KO 7.45pm

With Dunfermline being the only Fife club in this season’s Championship, today’s Betfred Cup game could well be the only Fife derby this season in competitive games. The Pars go into the game topping Group B, following the 6-0 win over Elgin City at the weekend. East Fife lost 1-0 at Peterhead, a disappointment to manager Darren Young, who had emphasised before the game how important it was to get off to a winning start, with games against Dunfermline and Hearts to come. Young, a member of the Jimmy Calderwood era Pars team that reached 2 Scottish Cup finals and a League Cup final, is now in his second managerial role, after previously taking Albion Rovers from League 2 and consolidating their place in League 1. He left Coatbridge to take over East Fife and is one of Scotland’s most promising young managers. 

Picture

Edit by www.instagram.com/thedunfermlineway/

East Fife finished last season in fifth place in League 1, missing out on the top 4 promotion play-off place by 4 points. Five players made their debuts in the loss to Peterhead, and manager Young has said that the rebuilding of his squad still has some way to go, and has been hampered already by early season injuries. In addition to the comment in the image above, he also said after the game: “We created a few chances but need to create more from the middle to front. We don’t want make excuses but there are also five first team regulars out, guys who have been there and done it at this level.”

Picture

Nicky Clark. Photo: Pars Review

Allan Johnston’s Dunfermline got off to a confidence-boosting start to the season on Saturday, overwhelming Elgin City and scoring 6 times. Nicky Clark scored 4 of the team’s goals and along with new striking partner Declan McManus, will once again be the main hope for goals in Methil. The Pars squad that defeated Elgin was very light on experienced alternatives to the 11 players who started, with only 3 players over the age of 20 in the squad who were not starters – and 2 of those 3 (Jason Talbot and David Hopkirk) were injured. The addition of new signing Dean Shiels adds quality and experience to the squad. Shiels was playing regularly for FC Edmonton until last week, so is fit, but may start on the bench in Methil. 
Injury update: 
Expected to miss out: With no updates from the club (at time of writing), it is assumed that David Hopkirk & Jason Talbot are still not ready for selection.
With the players available, here is my preferred starting 11; there is an obvious temptation to select Shiels but Saturday might be a better time to play him from the start, given that he recently travelled from Canada and may not yet even have trained with the new team mates.

Picture

Match report/opinion will be posted here around 11pm this evening.
​Match photo gallery will be posted on Wednesday around 3pm.

“He’s a leader and a quality player” – Colin Miller on Dean Shiels

Dunfermline confirmed what could be a very significant signing today, when Dean Shiels joined the club on a 1 year contract. The former Northern Ireland international, who has 14 caps, left North American Soccer League side FC Edmonton, who he had joined in February. He had moved to Canada after completing a season with Irish team Dundalk, during which the team won the League of Ireland Premier Division. Shiels also played 4 times in the Europa League with Dundalk.
Dean Shiels began his career with Arsenal without making any first team appearances. At the age of 19, he signed for Hibs, and had 5 successful years at Easter Road. In 2009, he moved to Doncaster, before transferring to Kilmarnock in 2011, initially on loan, and then on a permanent basis. During his 1 season with Killie, he was shortlisted alongside 3 other players for the SPFA Players’ Player of the Year award, in 2012. He was a key member of the Killie team that won the League Cup that season, defeating Celtic in the final.

Picture

New Pars signing Dean Shiels will be reunited at with his former Rangers team mate Nicky Clark

His next destination was Rangers, where he remained for 4 seasons, from 2012 to 2016, as the club moved up the divisions of the SPFL. Shiels played 120 games for Rangers but left the club last summer after winning the Championship, but then losing the Scottish Cup Final.
Shiels can play as a striker, winger or as a traditional inside forward, or attacking midfielder. His game is more about providing goals that scoring, although he has a respectable 92 career goals, and will be hoping to hit the 100 mark this season with the Pars. At the age of 32, he brings experience to the squad – Sean Murdoch and Joe Cardle (both 30) and defender Jason Talbot (31) are the only other players in their 30s. Shiels has an impressive pedigree and this signing is a clear statement that the club are seriously aiming for promotion this season. 
Former Dunfermline defender Colin Miller, now boss of FC Edmonton, said this when Shiels joined the club in February: 
“I’ve done a lot of research on Dean, and spoke to a lot of people in Scotland about him. Everything came back glowing. He’s a leader and a quality player who wants to attack and score goals, so I’m very excited to have Dean here.”
Announcing that the club had agreed to release Shiels from his contract last week, Miller had this to say: “When Dean arrived we knew he had genuine quality about him, however his family are in Scotland. That was the sole reason he’s leaving us. He enjoyed the club, the staff and the players, but his family situation needed to be resolved and he had to leave. It’s unfortunate and we wish Dean and his family the best of luck in the future.”
Pars fans will be hoping that the player can bring the type of excitement and quality to the Dunfermline team that Miller spoke about back in February, now that he is settled back in Scotland with his family. 

Picture

Shiels in action for Dundalk

Picture

Pars’ goals 1, 3 and 6 v Elgin. Captured on camera and converted into video format.

Goal 1 – Nicky Clark header from a Kallum Higginbotham cross

Goal 3 – Michael Paton with a simple finish from close range

Goal 6 – A well placed pass from Scott Lochhead finds Callum Smith, who coolly slots home

All photos by Pars Review

Picture

Pre-match

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham, Nicky Clark, Declan McManus, Joe Cardle & Callum Smith

Picture

Callum Morris leads the Pars team out

Picture

Ryan Williamson

Picture

Clark’s second goal

Picture

A rare moment of involvement for Sean Murdoch

Picture

Callum Morris challenges his opponent, watched by Big Nat & Nicky Clark

Picture

Michael Paton makes it 3-0

Picture

Paton celebrates his goal

Picture

Clark scores his fourth goal

Picture

Clark celebrates his fourth

Picture

Paton leads the congratulations

Picture

Higgy

Picture

Good view of Higgy’s corner kick

Picture

Scott Lochhead

Picture

Joe Cardle

Picture

Joe Cardle, always involved

Picture

Callum Smith scoring his first senior goal

Picture

Lochhead joins the celebrations. It was his pass that set up Smith’s goal

Picture

Higgy hugs Smith

Picture

Big Jock, Big Nat, Smith and Paton after the final whistle

Picture

Clark with his man of the match award and match ball

Picture

4 goal Nicky Clark spearheaded a clinical Dunfermline performance as the first competitive game of the season resulted in an emphatic win. The team lined almost as predicted (goo.gl/DPsi2L) except for the missing Aaron Splaine, who was replaced by Michael Paton. The starting 11 included every available player over the age of 20 with the exception of substitute Jean Yves M’Voto. 
Elgin were pitiful, but that should not detract from the ruthlessness of the Pars attack and the complete domination that we enjoyed for the entire game. Credit has to be given, as pre-match there were doubts as to the ability of the current team to dispose of a lower league opponent in such a clinical way.
The goals came mainly in the first half, with Clark scoring a hat-trick of headers, from crosses by Kallum Higginbotham (twice) and Ryan Williamson, after 10, 20 and 35 minutes. Paton also drilled in a shot from 15 yards in between Clark’s second and third goals, in the 33rd minute. 

Picture

Only the main stand was open for the game, and the majority of Pars fans were housed in the west (home) end of the stand. It was to that end of the stadium that the team attacked in the second half. After 48 minutes Clark got his fourth goal, connecting first time with a shot from a low-driven Higginbotham corner. Although there was to be no repeat of the first half goals total, it was not due to lack of effort. The team did not go easy on their hopelessly-outclassed opponents – there were goal attempts from Higginbotham, Joe Cardle and substitute Scott Lochhead. The other young substitute given game time, Callum Smith, could have added a sixth when he shot straight at the goalkeeper after good play by Cardle. Smith did get on the scoresheet, in the final minute, when he took a precise pass from Lochhead, looked up, and placed a shot in the corner of the net – his first goal in senior football. For those of us who saw Lochhead and Smith in last season’s Under 20s team, this was an especially pleasing moment. 
While Clark was clearly man of the match, mentions must also go to Higginbotham, who had 3 assists, and Declan McManus, who despite not scoring, worked tirelessly and was well-received by the crowd when he was withdrawn in the 80th minute.
​Pars starting 11, plus substitutes:

Picture Picture Picture

It’s Fife v Moray in the opening competitive fixture of 2017/18, with Allan Johnston’s team looking to improve after a disappointing pre-season

Betfred Cup – Saturday 15 July 2017 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

Dunfermline’s pre-season games have raised more questions than answers, with 11 goals conceded in 3 first team warm-up matches and a completely disjoined display in the final game, a 3-0 defeat in Kirkcaldy on Tuesday evening. The Betfred Cup provides a further 4 games before the League season starts in August, and is almost an extension of the pre-season although with much more at stake. 

Picture

Elgin boss Jim Weir

​Elgin City make the 160 mile journey from their far-north base having signed 3 new players on Thursday, all trialists who did enough to impress manager Jim Weir: Cammy Eadie, Ross McKinnon and Stephen Bronsky are all defenders, and join other new signings midfielder Jon-Paul McGovern and striker Calum Ferguson at the club. Weir aims to sign another striker, as he will be without last season’s top scorer Shane Sutherland, who is recovering from a cruciate knee injury. Sutherland scored 24 goals in 31 games in his first season at Elgin, joining the club from Peterhead last summer, and will obviously be a big loss for Elgin.

Picture

Callum Morris. Photo: Pars Review

A home win would be a good morale-booster following the series of defeats in pre-season, and while the Pars squad lacks quality and depth in certain areas, the core of the team remains relatively strong, based on last season’s form at least. Sean Murdoch, Callum Morris, Nat Wedderburn and Nicky Clark are the spine of the Dunfermline side and are among the players that Allan Johnston will rely on most. Led by Morris, the new club captain, they will be keen to rid themselves of the defensive lapses that helped Raith to score 3 times on Tuesday. Last season, with largely different personnel, the Pars team gave away too many cheap goals in the initial weeks of the campaign, and there can be no repeat of this if the current side are to make any progress. 
Saturday is when the players must perform as a team and not a collection of individuals. Slack passing, a reluctance to want the ball from throw-ins, temper tantrums and wasteful play all have to be eliminated.
Injury update: 
Expected to miss out: David Hopkirk & Jason Talbot
With the players available, here is my preferred starting 11:

Picture

Match report/opinion with photos will be posted here around 9pm tomorrow evening.

Dunfermline have now completed all scheduled pre-season games and although results in what are essentially warm-up games are not season-defining, there has to be an element of concern in the performance of the “team”, or more accurately, the set of players that have played so far. Moulding these players into a team will be one of manager Allan Johnston’s challenges.
Pars Review was at the 3 games that were viewable – including the “close door” game at Garscube Sports Complex in Glasgow. The only game that was not seen (or even reported on by the official DAFC site) was the 3-0 defeat at Cowdenbeath, when the Pars played mostly trialists, teenagers and players who did not feature heavily in the previous evening’s game against Hibs. 

Picture

v Partick: “Big Jock” – Jean Yes M’Voto

The opening game, at Garscube (on the University of Glasgow grounds) saw 21 Pars players get game time, with a completely different line-up in each half, except for goalkeeper Cammy Gill, who played the 90 minutes in the absence of Sean Murdoch, who was injured. Opponents Partick Thistle fielded almost all their first team squad yet it was Dunfermline, with a stronger/more experienced first half line-up, that were more threatening, with efforts from Joe Cardle and a bad miss by David Hopkirk. Thistle won the game 4-2. Dunfermline’s second goal came from trialist Filip Duris, who along with Lawrence Shankland, were informed that the club would not be pursuing any interest in them after the game. The 2 other trialsts, Michael Coulson and Cameron King, were given time on the pitch as subs in the next game, against Hibs, plus the Pars XI line-up at Cowdenbeath. They have both since left, presumably, as there has been no comment from the club about them, and they were not in the squad for the final pre-season game at Raith.

Picture

v Hibs: Aaron Splaine

The second game, at home to Hibs, saw Dunfermline again press for a first half opener only to go behind. As the game went on, the Pars weakened, partly due to the use of 6 substitutes, although the flip side to that argument is that the use of substitutes in warm-up games could galvanize the team. Instead, it highlighted the chronic lack of strength in depth in the squad. New signing Aaron Splaine did well, showing effort and an ability to deliver long-range passes, but was withdrawn at half time after a booking late in the first half, when his natural aggression got the better of him. Hibs won the game 4-0.
By-passing the “ghost” game at Cowdenbeath, the final first team pre-season match was a derby in Kirkcaldy against the Wee Team. A truly dire 90 minutes was to follow for Pars fans, with the players looking lost and unfamiliar with each other. Raith won 3-0.
More detailed reports, with opinion, can be found in the Pars Review match reports from these games:
​v Partick: www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report1091036
v Hibs: www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report2335655
v Raith: www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report1409738

The blog’s “5 Things We Learned” feature also went over aspects of all 3 games:
v Partick: www.parsreview.org/blog/5-things-we-learned-v-partick-thistle
v Hibs: www.parsreview.org/blog/5-things-we-learned-v-hibs1145730
v Raith: www.parsreview.org/blog/5-things-we-learned-v-raith

The Betfred Cup game against Elgin on Saturday will be the Pars’ first competitive game of the season. With the obvious need for extra bodies, and quality, balanced against the reality of the club’s financial restrictions, Allan Johnston has much work to do. All the trialists are gone (apparently). Early summer targets – confirmed by Johnston – including James Keatings and Simon Murray have signed for other clubs – time spent on those players was time wasted. It has been repeated many times online, and also by the manager, that we captured certain players later in the transfer window last year. What is often overlooked when making that point is that by then, we were out of the Betfred Cup and had lost 3 of the opening 4 League games. Inevitably, the new players then took time to gel in the team, and we then lost the following 2 League games after the transfer window closed, and so gained only 3 points from the first 18 available. Lessons must be learned from that.

Here are some photos taken by Pars Review from the 3 games that were not included in the Match Photo Gallery articles for the games:

Picture

v Partick: trialist Michael Coulson

Picture

v Partick: trilaist Filip Duris

Picture

v Hibs: pre-match – trialist Cameron King

Picture

v Hibs: Callum Morris

Picture

v Hibs: Aaron Splaine

Picture

v Hibs: Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

v Raith: Lewis Martin

Picture

v Raith: Callum Smith

Picture

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture

Callum Smith made another impressive sub appearance

Picture

Dean Shiels had a quitely effective game

Picture

AJ

Picture

Ryan Williamson

Picture

Higgy

Picture

Declan McManus

Picture

Joe Cardle & Big Nat

Picture

Sammy and others

Picture

John Herron (right) was a spectator

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Higgy hugs Clark

Picture

Clark, with McManus

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Ryzo

Picture

Clark scores again

Picture

Joe Cardle

Picture

Higgy hugs Clark after goal 4

Picture

Big Nat

Picture

Declan McManus

Picture

Higgy

Picture

Higgy again

Picture

Scott Lochhead replaces Paton

Picture

Lochhead prepares to shoot

Picture

Lochhead shoots while Joe jumps

Picture

Hard working Declan McManus

Picture

Joe Cardle

Picture

Callum Smith replaces Clark

Picture

Callum Smith, 17 years old

Picture

Ryzo

Picture

McManus is applauded off

Picture

Big Jock M’Voto

Picture

Herron tries to sneak out unnoticed

Picture

Smith enjoying the moment

Picture

Ryzo congratulates Smith