Blog Archives

Picture

Tuesday’s 1-0 win over Dundee United saw John Potter’s Pars Under 20s team record their  7th victory in 14 SPFL Development League games this season. The team are in 7th place in the 17-team division, and of the 10 teams below them, 8 are Premiership clubs. The transformation from last season, when Dunfermline finished last in the division, is remarkable and is due to several factors. 
Last season’s Under 20s were a very young group of players, mostly aged under 18 and so giving away 2, 3 and sometimes almost 4 full years to their opponents. Physically the team was under-developed, and the progress made on that front in 12 months has seen players such as Johnny Galloway, Reece Duncan (pictured, left) and Stuart Morrison, who all played in the 2015/16 season, now look and play more like young men instead of boys. Centre-half Morrison has been called up twice in recent weeks to the Scotland Under 19 squad, and Galloway – the Pars Under 20s regular team captain – cannot be far away from joining his team mate in the international squad. 
New players have also been added to the squad in 2016, some this season and others towards the end of last term. Scott Lochhead, Euan Spark and Evan Horne joined from Dundee United and Ciaran Lafferty from Celtic. Lochhead has been one of the team’s best performers this season and was rewarded with an extended contract this week, with his original deal due to end in January. He made his first team debut as a substitute in the Betfred Cup game against his former team Dundee United in July. 

Picture

​Galloway (pictured, above) and Spark have been first team substitutes in a handful of games in recent weeks, although  are yet to play. Young strikers Callum Smith and James Thomas also made brief first team sub appearances earlier this season, while goalkeeper Cammy Gill was on the bench, deputising for David Hutton, during the period when Sean Murdoch was injured. The first Under 20s player to start a first team game this season was Conner Duthie (pictured, below), who also made 3 first team appearances last season, after signing for Dunfermline in March. Duthie has been converted from a striker/winger to a left-back this season, and his appearance at Buckie Thistle, playing the full 90 minutes, was his first performance in the senior team at full-back. 

Picture

​The Under 20s play an attractive brand of football, based on a passing game, utilising the skills of Galloway, Lochhead and Duthie, in addition to other players such as Robbie Crawford and Brandon Luke. Smith has taken on the role of the team’s main striker – with James Thomas leaving the club earlier this month, only Smith and the currently injured Lafferty are recognised strikers for the Under 20s. 
At times, John Potter has brought in first team squad players into the Under 20s team for league games – rules allow up to 5 overage players in Development League games. The inclusion of older players has not always been for the betterment of the team. The 4-0 defeat against Motherwell this season saw the maximum 5 over-age players selected from the first team squad, most of whom had a poor game, and on that occasion had a negative impact on the team’s natural game. In contrast, the recent wins over Rangers and Dundee United saw only 1 overage player in the team for each game. In the Scottish Youth Cup, no over-age players are allowed, and the Pars team have progressed to the fourth round, where they travel to face Ayr United on Sunday 4 December. 
The team’s home fixtures are now being played at Kelty Hearts’ New Central Park ground. Although the afternoon weekday kick-offs will make it difficult for some supporters to attend, if you to get the chance it is well worth going to watch the young team. Having been at 14 of the team’s games this season (league, cup and friendlies), I have often enjoyed them more than first team matches, certainly from a purely football standpoint. Potter is proving to be an excellent coach of young players, and can be heard talking them through games in a positive manner which is reflected in his team’s performances. 

All photos in this article by Pars Review.

Picture

Taking on the Hibs defence at Easter Road on 13/08/16

Picture

At Glebe Park, Brechin in the Irn Bru Cup game on 03/09/16

Picture

Celebrating after scoring his first Pars goal, a penalty v Hibs at EEP, 22/10/16

Picture

Taking the applause of the Pars fans after scoring v Hibs 22/10/16

Picture

v Dumbarton (away) 29/10/16

Picture

v Raith 05/11/16

Picture

Always looking to create something for himself or his team mates

Picture Picture

15. Paul McMullan after scoring his second and the Pars’ fifth goal

Picture

​All photos by Pars Review. 
​Follow Pars Review on Twitter at
https://twitter.com/ParsReview
and on Facebook at
https://www.facebook.com/parsreview/

Picture

Callum Fordyce congratulates Paul McMullan on his first goal of the game

Picture

Eight goals and a victory in the far north represents another case of “job done” for Dunfermline. After last week’s win at St Mirren this was another positive result at a difficult venue but not a great performance. After suffering bad luck (mixed with poor play) earlier in the season, manager Allan Johnston has now seen his side lose just once in the past 5 games, a period when good fortune has swung back in the Pars’ favour. 
Conner Duthie, Rhys McCabe, Paul McMullan and Michael Moffat were selected to replace Jason Talbot, John Herron, Kallum Higginbotham and Farid El Alagui from the team that faced St Mirren last week. 
The first goal of the game came in the 12th minute when a cross from Paul McMullan was headed down by Lee Ashcroft, then hit Buckie’s Hamish Munro and spun into the net. 
Two minutes later, Buckie equalised after a slack pass from Nat Wedderburn was gathered by Buckie’s McLean, who passed to top scorer John McLeod who shot past Sean Murdoch. 
Barely two more minutes had gone when Dunfermline regained the lead. Michael Moffat was played through and was upended by Buckie keeper Ross Salmon. Michael Paton (pictured, right) took the resulting penalty and sent Salmon the wrong way. 
The home side equalised again in the 33rd  minute. McLeod played a good ball to Chris Angus down the left. The Buckie forward sent a well placed shot into the opposite far corner of Murdoch’s goal to make the score 2-2.  Murdoch then made an excellent save to prevent Buckie going ahead at half time. 
Michael Paton was replaced with Kallum Higginbotham at the start of the second half. The Pars midfield was misfunctioning, with Rhys McCabe – back in the team at the expense of John Herron – having a poor game, mastering the art of passing the ball to the opposition. The Pars strikers were largely ineffective, with Moffat reluctant to shoot, and Nicky Clark’s only notable effort on goal being one second half effort that hit the woodwork. 
Higginbotham scored his first Pars goal from open play (his other goal being a penalty) after 58 minutes to put Dunfermline ahead for a second time. Taking a pass from Clark, Higginbotham took a touch, and hit a shot from 15 yards that Salmon seemed slow to react to. Referee Charleston booked Higginbotham for his celebration. 
McMullan, Dunfermline’s standout player by some distance, then scored the goal of the game in the 60th minute. He weaved past the Buckie defence and slipped the ball past Salmon for one of the best individual goals scored by a Dunfermline player for some time. 
​Buckie got back into the game with a third goal in the  68th minute. McLeod’s shot spun in the air and Angus was quicker than any Pars defender to react, heading the ball in from a few yards out. 
The home side were now dominating possession, and almost equalised when McLeod’s back-header missed the goal by inches. Murdoch was required to gather two good efforts from the edge of the box, with Buckie looking more likely to get the game’s next goal. 
Ultimately it was a late Dunfermline breakaway that put the game out of Buckie’s reach. A  clearance found Moffat and the striker, clean through on the goalkeeper,  played a pass to McMullan to score his second and the Pars’ fifth. 
An upset avoided but the home side will feel hard done by.
Pars starting line-up, with marks out of 10:

Picture

​All photos by Pars Review.
A match photo gallery will be posted on Sunday.

Picture Picture

 Scottish Cup   – Saturday 26/11/16 – KO 3.00pm – Victoria Park, Buckie
Odds (Skybet): Buckie 13/2; Draw 4/1; Dunfermline 1/3
Dunfermline make the long trip north tomorrow for the Scottish Cup 3rd round tie against Buckie Thistle. The Pars are strong favourites to progress to the next round but are up against a side that are in  great goalscoring form.
Buckie qualified for this round  after defeating Gretna 6-2 in a 2nd round replay. Top scorer John McLeod scored 5 goals in that game, and has now scored 32 goals this season, the most recent of which came in Buckie’s win over Clachnacudden last week when McLeod scored twice. Buckie lead the Highland League and have scored 79 goals in 17 League games, an average of 4.6 per game. Their only defeat, to Keith 2 weeks ago, ended an unbeaten run of 22 League games (18 of which were wins) that stretched back to last season. ​

Picture

Pars line up:  the manager’s selection
Injured players: Andy Geggan, David Hopkirk, Gavin Reilly, Ben Richards-Everton, Ryan Williamson
Allan Johnston (pictured above) has 5 players injured and 1 suspended, but has Nat Wedderburn now free from suspension, and Kallum Higginbotham also available, after it was confirmed he has already served a suspension in the Scottish Cup during his time with Kilmarnock. The injured players would have given room for rotation, but from those 5 players, only Andy Geggan would be considered a definite starter. Johsnton still has options within his squad and will likely go for an attacking formation.

Preferred Pars line-up:
For once, I would line up with the manager’s favourite 4-4-2. The defence virtually selects itself. Nat Wedderburn will come back into midfield to provide some defensive cover in the middle of the park, with the rest of the team being very attack-minded. Higginbotham should start, leaving Joe Cardle, Michael Paton and Paul McMullan in contention for the other 2 wide place. I would select Cardle to give him game time and a chance to regain his form. Up front, the Moff could come in for Farid, although I would still start with the majority of the team who played at St Mirren last week, with Cardle and Wedderburn replacing Paton and McCabe. 
​Line-up (with squad numbers):

Picture

​Photo by Pars Review.
Tomorrow: Game Day image and full match report/opinion, photos and Pars player ratings. 

Picture Picture

A 344 mile round trip awaits the Pars team, management and fans on Saturday as Dunfermline travel north to Buckie, Moray for the 3rd round tie in the William Hill Scottish Cup. This is what is often called the romance of the Cup -a chance to visit a remote and unfamiliar place, thankfully avoiding yet another trip to a well known Scottish league ground. This would have been the game that many fans hoped for before the draw was made, and the prospect of a journey to the far north, with some fans staying for the weekend, has seen over 340 tickets sold already to Pars fans. 

Picture

Buckie harbour

Buckie is a fishing port with a population of around 8100. The fishing industry has declined in recent years although there is still an active harbour in the town. The town’s shipyard repairs lifeboats for the Royal National Lifeboat  Institution, and also repairs and creates vessels for the Ministry of Defence. Many of the town’s population work offshore in the oil industry.
The town’s football team were formed in 1889 and play in the Highland League. The similarity of their kit to Celtic is thought to go back to 1910, when Buckie Thistle were in financial hardship, and accepted a gift of team kits and footballs from Celtic. In 1989, Celtic travelled to Buckie to play a game to mark Buckie’s centenary year.
Buckie are based at Victoria Park, their home ground since 1919, which has a capacity of 5000, of which 400 are seated. 
​The club have won the Highland League 10 times in their history, and are currently joint top of the league. Their top goalscorer is John McLeod, who scored 5 times in the previous round of the Scottish Cup in Buckie’s win over Gretna. McLeod scored twice in Buckie’s most recent game, a 5-1 win over Clachnacuddin, to take his tally to 32 for the season. 

Picture

Victoria Park, Buckie’s home ground

Prior to the Clachnacuddin game, Buckie lost 3-2 to Keith, ending a 22 match unbeaten run in the Highland League, which began with 6 games remaining of last season and included the opening 16 games of this season. 
The game on Saturday will give the depleted Dunfermline squad (5 players injured and 1 suspended) a welcome break from Championship football. The game will be Buckie’s biggest of the season so far, and the game has all the makings of a classic Scottish Cup tie. 
​Full match preview will be posted tomorrow. 

Picture Picture

After the Pars’ League 1 season ended in April , the football drug that many of us need led to my son and I going to watch Kelty Hearts three times. One reason for going was to see one of my favourite ex-Dunfermline players, Stephen Husband, who joined Kelty in 2015. I enjoyed the games and returned to see the Pars Under 20s and Kelty take part in a pre-season tournament this summer at Kelty’s New Central Park home. I was impressed with the tidy ground, the friendly welcome, and the attractive football played by Kelty. This season, Dunfermline have forged closer links with Kelty through the use of New Central Park for the Pars Under 20s home games and announced a partnership agreement in October:
(www.dafc.co.uk/story.php?t=Partnership_with_Kelty_Hearts_Announced&ID=9567 ).

Picture

The two new enclosures built in the summer this year are part of the development of New Central Park

Kelty Hearts were formed in 1975. They played in the Fife Junior League until 2002, when the Scottish Junior FA restructured the League system, by which time Kelty had won the competition 6 times. Kelty joined all other Fife Junior clubs in the East  Region, along with clubs from Lothian, Central and Tayside. The new pyramid system would be a top division (East Region Super League), Premier League, and then North, Central and South Divisions. Kelty were promoted to the Super League in 2006 and became champions in 2014/15. Last season they were runners-up. Kelty have also been runners-up in the Scottish Junior Cup twice. They have made a tremendous start to this season, as the League table shows here: ​

Picture Picture

One of the driving forces behind Kelty’s success is player/manager Thomas Courts (pictured, left). A former Livingston and East Fife player, Courts first joined Kelty early in his career, in 2002, and has remained at the club since his return in 2007. Capped at Junior level by Scotland, he captained his country in 2013. The same year he became manager of Kelty and has led the club to top 2 finishes in his 2 full seasons in charge to date. I contacted the Kelty boss when preparing this article, and asked him if he would comment on his ambitions for the club and how he feels about the season so far. This is what he said:
“Our season so far has surpassed expectations with us being in the latter part of November and still undefeated in all competitions. Our squad is currently fit, healthy and full of positive competition so we’re enjoying the challenge of maintaining our spot at the top of the league and navigating our way through three cup competitions.
​My relentless ambition is to make Kelty Hearts the very best semi-pro team in the country. I aim to do that with a very clear identity that draws on the community spirit of the village people that we represent, whilst playing in a manner that excites the fans and allows them to relate to my players and their style of play.”

PictureBrian Ritchie completes his first half hat-trick

Before going to Paisley to see Dunfermline play St Mirren on Saturday, I went to watch Kelty’s Scottish Junior Cup 3rd round game against Ashfield. Kelty swept their opponents aside with a brand of football that was very good to watch: skillful, fast and incisive. 4-0 up at half time largely due to Brian Ritchie’s hat-trick, the final score was Kelty 7, Ashfield 1. 
The photos below were taken by Pars Review during the game.

Picture

Stuart Cargill scores Kelty’s sixth goal from the penalty spot (above) and is congratulated by his team mates (below)

Picture

Kelty are very proactive on social media and can be followed on Twitter at ​twitter.com/KeltyHeartsJFC.
​The club’s official website is at www.keltyhearts.co.uk/home/4584810869 , which also contains links to their Facebook page and YouTube channel. 

Picture

​There is much to be admired about the on and off-field activities at Kelty Hearts. The development of their ground continues – a 4G artificial pitch was laid in 2015, and this summer 2 enclosures were built – and they have a popular social club within New Central Park. As noted above, Dunfermline Athletic have close ties to Kelty which includes back in the 1990s with the signing of Kelty’s prodigal son, Andy Tod. A visit to New Central Park will not disappoint when kick-off times allow Pars fans to watch what could easily become every Dunfermline fan’s second team. 
Thanks to Thomas Courts for his contribution to this article, and to Kelty Hearts for the great work they are doing on and off the park – they are an example to all provincial clubs on how to conduct their business.

​All photos by Pars Review.

Picture Picture

All photos by Pars Review. 
​Follow Pars Review on Twitter at
https://twitter.com/ParsReview
and on Facebook at
https://www.facebook.com/parsreview/

Picture

Captain Callum Fordyce leads the post-match celebrations

The result ultimately is all that matters, in what was a battling, determined performance, lacking in quality but full of heart and grit, aspects of the team that had been questioned lately. Manager Allan Johnston made 3 changes, with Andy Geggan missing through injury, Callum Fordyce started, Farid El Alagui came in for Michael Moffat, and Michael Paton took Joe Cardle’s place on the left – the first time Paton has played on the left for Dunfermline. 
St Mirren had not won in the Championship all season, and for most of the first half it was obvious why both teams were struggling. Dunfermline looked the better of the 2 sides, marginally, and got the goal that ultimately won the game through Nicky Clark from close range after 26 minutes. 
Callum Fordyce’s first start since the previous League game against St Mirren in September saw him eliminate unforced errors and turn in a great performance, clearing the ball in a McCathie-esque fashion  when required, and leading the team very effectively. 
Sean Murdoch made a crucial save on the stroke of half time when Saints’ striker John Sutton headed the ball towards the corner of the goal. Murdoch got down to turn the ball round the post, when a goal looked certain. 
The first half seemed to fly past, but the same was not true of the second period. Dunfermline were put under continuous pressure at times, and a combination of great goalkeeping, resolute defending, and some luck that has often deserted the team this season. Murdoch was confident in goals, and Fordyce an inspiring figure in central defence. Saints had chances through Sutton, Mallan and Shankland.
The Pars had a great chance to go 2-0 ahead in the 63rd minue when Higginbotham set up Clark, clean through on goal, but he hit his shot straight at Gallacher in the Saints goal. 
Pars sub Paul McMullan almost scored when he placed a shot into the right corner, but saw it saved by Gallacher. 
As the game went on, Saints spent the majority of the game camped in the Dunfermline half, with no success despite putting the Pars defence under huge pressure. A breakaway in the 5th minute of added time almost gave Dunfermline a second goal – the Moff, on for El Alagui, broke through and hit the post. The rebound fell to Clark, who hit the goalkeeper, and then struck the second rebound at a Saints defender. Referee Walsh then blew for time up and the Pars players celebrated with the travelling support. 
Pars starting line up with marks out of 10:

Picture

All photos by Pars Review.
A match photo gallery will be posted on Sunday.

Picture Picture

​Designed by https://www.instagram.com/dunfermlineloyal/   
Photo features John Sutton (St Mirren) and Jason Talbot. The Jason Talbot image was  edited from a photo by Pars Review (seen here).
Match report with player ratings and photos will be posted this evening.
Full match photo gallery will be posted tomorrow. 

Picture

Scottish Championship – Saturday 19/11/16 – KO 5.15pm – Paisley 2021 Stadium
Odds (Skybet): St Mirren 13/10; Draw 5/2; Dunfermline 9/5
The teams propping up the Championship table take on each other in Saturday’s televised game in Paisley. St Mirren have not won a League game this season, have no clean sheets, and have scored less goals per game than Dunfermline (0.83 to Dunfermline’s 1.15) and conceded more (2 goals per game on average, to Dunfermline’s 1.85). Despite this, the home side are favourites to win and to close the gap at the bottom of the table to 2 points, and with a game in hand on Dunfermline.  

Picture

Michael Paton takes a free kick in the meeting between the teams at EEP earlier this season

St Mirren manager Jack Ross has seen his new side lose all 3 League games since he left Alloa to take over the Paisley club. Previous manager Alex Rae was sacked after no wins in the opening 6 games, which was followed by youth coach Allan McManus filling in on a temporary basis for 3 winless League matches until the appointment of the new permanent manager. Saints will take encouragement from last week’s Challenge Cup victory over Ayr United at the Paisley 2021 Stadium, a game that saw their midfield comprise of 4 players aged 20 or under: Stephen Mallan (20), Lewis Morgan (20), Kyle Magennis (18) and 17 year old Kyle McAllister. The young players added energy to the team according to reports, but it was experienced striker John Sutton who scored both Saints goals to win the match. Sutton will be a threat to the Pars defence tomorrow, alongside on-loan Aberdeen striker Lawrence Shankland, who had a successful loan spell at Dunfermline in 2014. 
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

Dunfermline go into the game with no League wins since the last time St Mirren were the opposition, in September, when the Pars won 4-3 at East End Park. Allan Johnston has seen his team gather just 2 points from all away games this season. Saturday’s game also provides Dunfermline with the chance to break the unwanted record of not having defeated a full time club away from home in all competitions since April 2013. 

Picture

Paul McMullan could come into the starting 11 this weekend

​Pars line up:  the manager’s selection
Injured players: David Hopkirk, Gavin Reilly, Ben Richards-Everton, Ryan Williamson. 
Suspended: Nat Wedderburn
The injured players listed above are all definitely out of tomorrow’s game, and although it is debatable whether any would have started the game, their absence does limit the manager’s options in certain areas of the team. One certain starter would have been the suspended Nat Wedderburn. Johnston has the option of putting Andy Geggan back in midfield and playing Lewis Martin in the right back position that Geggan has covered so well recently, with Callum Fordyce coming back into the team in central defence. A less likely option is to play Fordyce at right back, which was not a success in his only game in that role, at Morton in September. If Johnston decides against making any such changes, he will look to Rhys McCabe to play alongside John Herron in midfield. Paul McMullan must be in contention for a left wing role in place of the out-of-form Joe Cardle. 
Preferred Pars line-up:
Midfield is the problem area, with the absence of one player (Wedderburn) and the necessity of playing Geggan to cover the problem right back position, leaving the central midfield very weak. The team I have selected below is based on current form and I do not expect it to be Johnston’s starting 11. I have selected Fordyce who played well in his sub appearance at Dundee United, to allow Geggan to play in a defensive midfield role, in a 4-1-3-2 formation, with McMullan and Higginbotham playing as inside right and left as opposed to wingers. 
Line-up (with squad numbers):

Picture

​​Photos by Pars Review.
Tomorrow: Game Day image and full match report/opinion, photos and Pars player ratings. 

​Before each away game, Pars Review looks at the venue we will be travelling to: its history, with rare photos showing changes to the opposition club’s stadium over the years, and how it looks now. On Saturday we travel to the Paisley 2021 Stadium, home of St Mirren.
St Mirren  moved to their current home in 2009. For the first 17 years of their history (1877-1894) they played at 4 different grounds in Paisley, before moving to Love Street, where they remained until 2009. This article will look at Love Street and their current stadium. 

Picture

In 1894 St Mirren rented a site in Love Street, Paisley from a Mr Fullerton; for the first year, the ground was known as Fullerton Park, and was then renamed St Mirren Park. It was always more commonly referred to as Love Street. The ground had one main stand which held 1000 people. The photo above shows the stadium in 1927, by which time a new main stand had been built, seating around 1800. The stadium remained largely unchanged through the remainder of the 1920s through to the 1950s.  
In the late 1950s, the North Bank (terracing on the opposite side from the main stand) was covered and then the terracing at the home end of the ground  was brought forward to within a few yards of the goal. All terracing in the ground was concreted and barriers installed. The photo below shows the covered North Bank and the home end terracing on the right . The away end terracing remained some distance behind the goal. ​

Picture

In 1991, seats were installed in the North Bank (as seen in photo below). 

Picture

In 1995, a 3000 seater stand was built behind the away end goal, which was also much closer to the pitch (pictured below). 

Picture

In 2000, St Mirren were required to install seating in the  home end terracing, to meet Premier League rules on seated stadiums. The terrace then became known as the East Stand (see photo below).

Picture

The following 2 photos show Love Street in 2005 – a 10,800 capacity all-seated stadium that still featured the 1921 main stand. 

Picture Picture

In 2003, St Mirren, who were experiencing financial problems,  began talks with various supermarket companies to sell the Love Street site. In 2007, the club accepted an offer from Tesco for the site. In addition to keep the club afloat, the money from the sale of Love Street was used to build a new 8000 seater stadium in Greenhill Road, less than a mile from Love Street. The photos below show the site during and after construction, which began in January 2008 and was completed 12 months later, and was named St Mirren Park. It has since been renamed the Paisley 2021 Stadium as part of a sponsorship deal with Renfrewshire Council, who are bidding to have Paisley named as the UK City of Culture in 2021. 

Picture Picture Picture

The next 2 photos were taken by Pars Review – the first in October 2015 when we played St Mirren in the Challenge Cup, and the second photo from this month when the Pars Under 20s defeated St Mirren in the Scottish Youth Cup.

Picture Picture Picture

​Join the Moff as he travels through time and space in the PARDIS, journeying through different dimensions and strange lands such as Cowdenbeath and Airdrie.

24 November 1973, First Division:
Dundee 1, Dunfermline 5
Today, the PARDIS has taken the Moff back to 1973 and a game at Dens Park against Dundee.
Dunfermline manager George Miller had lead the team to promotion from Division 2 in season 1972/73. The opening dozen games in the top division resulted in 3 Pars wins, 4 draws and 5 defeats.  Opponents Dundee were 2 points ahead of Dunfermline in the League table going into the game between the teams. Future Pars boss Jocky Scott was in the Dundee side.

PictureKen Mackie, featured in a Topps Chewing Gum card.

Here is the Evening Times report of the game:
“The confident Fifers turned aside early Dundee attacks and it took defenders to show the way. Tommy Gemmell fired a great drive just over in the 14th minute and then Davie Johnston crashed another first time drive wild. The wind was making matters tricky for the teams and Dundee, with the advantage in the first half, were not cashing in on it. Dunfermline keeper John Arrol was busy enough but seldom in real trouble. 
“Dunfermline burst into the game thanks to a gift goal in the 28th minute. Johnston allowed Denis Nelson to dispossess him in midfield and the winger set off for goal and crashed the ball past Dundee keeper Thomson Allan. 
“Dundee raised their game and after a number of near things they equalised with a great goal in the 37th minute. A Jimmy Wilson cross was headed towards the net by Ian Scott and was well stopped by the keeper. Jocky Scott blasted home the rebound. A minute later Arrol brilliantly turned over a fierce Ian Scott drive from 20 yards. 
“In the 48th minute Dundee keeper Allan charged down a point blank effort by Nelson with the home defence in disarray. 
“Dunfermline’s effort paid off in the 54th minute and  it was a careless blunder by the home defence which lead to a goal. Bobby Ford attempted a back pass to Allan that was yards short and Ken Mackie stepped in to score easily. 
“After 64 minutes, Mackie was allowed to shoot high into the net. Ian Campbell crashed home a fourth for the visitors in the 71st minute after a Nelson corner had been missed by a string of defenders and had cannoned off the far post. 
“Mackie completed his hat trick and made it 5 for Dunfermline in the 75th minute.”
The Dunfermline Press reported that “With a display that must surely rank as their best for years, Dunfermline shattered the pride of Dundee. The Athletic turned on a display of attacking football to demoralise the home side.”
Despite this encouraging victory that left the Pars in mid table, the team then went on a run of 5 consecutive defeats (conceding 16 goals) and achieved only 1 win in the following 4 months. Relegation was avoided on goal difference, with the Pars finishing 16th in the 18 team division. A last day 1-0 win against Dundee United at Tannadice saved the Pars from relegation. Dundee finished in fifth place. 

​Pars team: Arrol, Cameron, Wallace, Thomson, Leishman, Kinninmonth, Campbell, Scott, Mackie, Shaw, Nelson.

Picture

​​On the week this game was played, the number 1 song in the UK singles chart was “I Love You, Love Me Love” by Gary Glitter.

The number 1 album was by David Bowie, with “Pin Ups”.
​
​The UK’s number 1 movie in that week was “The Way We Were” starring Barbra Streisand and Robert Redford.

Picture Picture

​All photos by Pars Review. To see full size photos, please click on images and then move through the gallery using side arrow or by clicking each photo.

dsc00942dsc00943dsc00947dsc00954dsc00955dsc00959dsc00968dsc00972dsc00976dsc00977dsc00984dsc00989dsc00997dsc01000dsc01001dsc01013dsc01018dsc01027dsc01029 1dsc01041 1dsc01052Picture

Follow Pars Review on Twitter at
https://twitter.com/ParsReview
and on Facebook at
https://www.facebook.com/parsreview/

Picture

Lewis Martin leaves the field after being sent off

Dunfermline exited the Irn Bru Challenge Cup with a whimper, in a below average display that once again saw no goals scored and a player sent off. 
Manager Allan Johnston made 2 changes to the side that lost by the same scoreline to the same opponents on Tuesday in the Championship. Rhys McCabe replaced the suspended Nat Wedderburn, and Michael Moffat took Farid El Alagui’s place up front. Dundee United made 8 changes to their line up. 
The Dunfermline defence had tightened up (or eliminated basic errors) in the past 2 games but in the opening minutes of today’s game there was a return to kamikaze defending when Lewis Martin hoofed a clearance high into the air and into his own penalty box, giving United a chance which they failed to capitalise on. It would not take long for the visitors to go ahead though, when in the 8th minute a corner kick was not cleared by the Pars defence, and the ball fell to United defender Mark Durnan who shot home from around 10 yards. 
Dunfermline tried to take the game to United and in the 24th minute a well placed pass from Kallum Higginbotham found Nicky Clark, who scooped the ball over the bar when he really should have at least tested the goalkeeper. 
United striker Simon Murray had scored in all of the previous 3 meetings between the clubs this season, and he came close again midway through the half but could not get a full connection on the ball from a tight angle. Pars striker Michael Moffat had very few chances to score in his return to the team but was unlucky shortly before halftime when his 20 yard shot hit the post.

Picture

Dunfermline’s central midfield duo of Rhys McCabe (number 16) and John Herron

Pars keeper Sean Murdoch had the first of several good second half saves when he blocked a Blair Spittal shot after 55 minutes.  Two minutes later, Dunfermline were reduced to 10 men when a long ball over the defence found Spittal, who was ahead of Lewis Martin. There were still 40 yards to Murdoch’s goal, and with Lee Ashcroft also tracking back, Martin pulled Spittal’s shirt an was red carded by referee Willie Collum. The decision may have seemed harsh given the distance from goal and the covering defender, but Martin gave the referee the option through his actions and can have little complaint. 
Callum Fordyce was brought on to replace Martin, with the completely ineffective Joe Cardle substituted. Two further Pars substitutions were made in the next 15 minutes: Farid El Alagui for Moffat, and Paul McMullan for Clark. 
McMullan was keen to become involved, and a direct run at the United defence when he beat 2 men despite attempts to foul him was brought to an end by the referee, who gave Dunfermline a foul when he should have applied the advantage, as McMullan still had the ball and was running towards the United goal. 
Murdoch then was required to make 2 saves, keeping the Pars in the game. The final 10 minutes saw Dunfermline in attack but unable to test United keeper Luis Zwick. In the final minute, El Alagui was brought down on the 18 yard line but Collum waved play on. 
Dunfermline now go into next week’s important League game at St Mirren without Wedderburn and Martin, a sad legacy, along with the scorelines, of the double header against United. 

​Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:

Picture

​All photos by Pars Review.
A full match photo gallery will be posted on Sunday.

Designed by https://www.instagram.com/dunfermlineloyal/   
Match report with player ratings and photos will be posted this evening.
Full match photo gallery will be posted tomorrow. 

Picture

 ​Irn Bru Cup   – Saturday 12/11/16 – KO 12.30pm – East End Park
Odds (Skybet): Dunfermline 12/5; Draw 12/5; Dundee United evens
The second meeting of the teams in the space of 5 days, and the fourth this season so far, sees Dundee United visit East End Park in the quarter-finals of the Irn Bru Challenge Cup.  After United’s 1-0 win at Tannadice in Tuesday’s League game, Saturday’s fixture is arguably one that Dunfermline especially could do without, given the seriousness of the Pars’ League position and the upcoming Championship games, starting at St Mirren on Saturday 19th November. The Challenge Cup will only be a priority for teams in mid table who have no relegation worries and no realistic aspirations of promotion. For both teams on Saturday, it might be seen as an unwelcome distraction from the real business of promotion and relegation. It is equally important for United to return to the Premiership as it is for  Dunfermline to avoid a catastrophic relegation. 

Picture

Paul McMullan takes on United’s Willo Flood in the League game between the teams at East End Park in September

​Dundee United’s recent good run has now been extended to 8 games without a defeat in all competitions, which includes 5 consecutive victories. It is now 12 games since United failed to score, which is another pointer to their good form. Although they have won all 3 meetings between the teams so far this season, it was only in the first game  – the Betfred Cup meeting at Tannadice – that United won with any degree of comfort. The first League game at East End Park saw the Pars miss 3 first half penalties, and conceded an injury time third goal after dominating possession for most of the game. Tuesday’s Championship game at Tannadice saw Dunfermline put in a gutsy, determined performance that matched the home side until Nat Wedderburn’s red card. 

Picture

Rhys McCabe and Michael Moffat, in the Betfred Cup game at Tannadice in July.

​Pars line up:  the manager’s selection
Injured players: Ben Richards-Everton, David Hopkirk, Gavin Reilly, Ryan Williamson. 
Allan Johnston prefers to keep a settled line up when possible but tomorrow’s game might be the exception. With a far more important League game next week in mind, some players could be rested against United, giving opportunities to Callum Fordyce, Paul McMullan, Michael Moffat and others.  All 4 injured players, none of whom are currently first choice, might have played , so in certain positions options are limited.
Preferred Pars line-up:
A mix of squad players and first team regulars. The League is far more important, and the result on Saturday will have no bearing on the season ahead, unlike next week’s game in Paisley. My preferred line-up reflects that: Cardle, Higginbotham and El Alagui all rested. The defence is unchanged due to lack of options. Had the 4 injured players been available, I would have made further changes.
Line-up (with squad numbers):

Picture

​Photos by Pars Review.
Tomorrow: Game Day image and full match report/opinion, photos and Pars player ratings. 

Picture Picture

A determined team performance almost gave the Pars a deserved point from a controversial game at Tannadice. There were no changes to the Dunfermline starting 11 following the draw with Raith Rovers 3 days before. The early stages of the game saw Allan Johnston’s team more than match their opponents, who were 7 places and 15 points ahead of Dunfermline before the game. 
Both teams had several attacks during the first half. The best Dunfermline effort came when Nicky Clark’s powerful run from the right side of attack ended in a shot on goal that was saved by Cammy Bell. Frustration was creeping into the home side’s play, with United midfielder Willo Flood barking orders at his team mates as the game remained goalless. 
In the 37th minute a bad challenge on Kallum Higginbotham which left the Pars winger injured  was ignored by referee Don Robertson. A throw in was given, after Dunfermline had kicked the ball out of play to allow Higginbotham to receive treatment. United threw the ball back to the Pars defence, only for the referee to make them take the throw in again, 1 yard back, and the ball was once again thrown to Dunfermline. Higginbotham rejoined play in time for the referee to give a straight red card to Pars midfielder Nat Wedderburn. In a packed centre circle, Wedderburn was deemed to have made a dangerous tackle despite winning the ball, and was sent off for a challenge that was not no worse than the ungiven foul on Higginbotham minutes before.
At half time Johnston took off Joe Cardle – who had been having an ineffective game in any case – and brought on Rhys McCabe to fill Wedderburn’s place in central midfield. 
The second half saw Dunfermline defend with great determination, restricting United to long range efforts from outside the box. The Pars were attacking on the break by this point, and Higginbotham came close with a shot across the goal, while a breakaway saw Farid El Alagui play the ball too wide for Nicky Clark, and the chance was lost.
A draw would have been an excellent result before the game, and even more so given the performance of the 10 men. Sadly, it was not to be . In the 79th minute, a United corner kick found Simon Murray who put the ball past Murdoch for the game’s only goal. 
Paul McMullan replaced Higginbotham after 84 minutes. The referee turned down an appeal for a penalty when Nicky Clark was barged in the back. 
United keeper Bell then received a yellow card for running out of his goal to demand that Andy Geggan be booked for a shirt tug on a United defender. 
The game may have ended in defeat, but there was much to take heart from in Dunfermline’s display. 

​​Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:

Picture

All photos by Pars Review.
Match photo gallery: 

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture

In his first start for Dunfermline, v Cowdenbeath (away) in the Betfred Cup 23/07/16

Picture

In action at Tannadice in the Betfred Cup, 31/07/16

Picture

Pre-match v Raith Rovers at EEP, with newly shaved head, 05/11/16

Picture

with Farid El Alagui, v Raith 05/11/16

Picture

1. Outside the ground, pre-match

Picture

3. Victoria Park, Buckie’s ground, before the game

Picture

5. Nat Wedderburn, pre-match warm up

Picture

7. Referee Craig Charleston

Picture

9. The Scottish Cup on display before the game

Picture

11. Pars players celebrate after a Buckie own goal

Picture

13. Kallum Higginbotham is congratulated by Conner Duthie and the Moff after scoring

Picture

2. The match programme

Picture

4. The terracing and the away end of the ground

Picture

6. Michael Paton

Picture

8. Farid El Alagui

Picture

10. Paul McMullan, the game’s best player

Picture

12. Michael Paton, after scoring a penalty to make it 2-1

Picture

14. Paul McMullan after his superb first goal, even raising a smile from the referee

Picture

Ex-Par Stephen Husband, scorer of the third Kelty goal

Picture

Team captain Shaun Greig

Picture

1. Match programme & ticket

Picture

3. Allan Johnston completes his shopping list during a lull in the game

Picture

5. The Pars players celebrate Nicky Clark’s goal

Picture

7. Pars fans at half time

Picture

9. Post match celebrations

Picture

11. Pars fans leaving the stadium after the game

Picture

2. Nicky Clark (no.37) and John Herron (21)

Picture

4. Kallum Higginbotham puts a cross into the St Mirren box

Picture

6. The stadium scoreboard at half time

Picture

8. John Herron

Picture

10. Callum Fordyce does a “Josh” post match

Picture

12. The Paisley 2021 Stadium in the distance after the game

Picture

Joe Cardle, pre-match warm up

Picture

Joe Cardle, with United goalscorer Simon Murray

Picture

Pars captain Andy Geggan

Picture

Paul McMullan replaced Higginbotham after 84 minutes

Picture

Ryan Williamson was injured pre-match

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham takes a free kick

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham had another good game

Picture

Andy Geggan at the end of the game