Blog Archives

Picture Picture

Only 2 Pars players have taken part in every game this season when they have been named in the match day squad: Lee Ashcroft and Nicky Clark. Sean Murdoch and Andy Geggan are almost in the same category, but have both been an unused sub once, having played in every other game when in the squad. 

Picture

Nicky Clark is Dunfermline’s top scorer this season, with 8 League and 1 Cup goal. Using League goals only, here is how he compares to previous season’s leading scorers in terms of minutes played per goal (goals scored against total minutes played). Listed from best ratio to worst:

Picture

Despite being the leading scorer with the fewest goals in a season, Gozie Ugwu has the best minutes per goal ratio of any Pars top scorer of the past 10 seasons. ​

Picture

Martin Boyle’s 6th minute goal for Hibs on Saturday was only the second goal that Dunfermline have conceded in the opening 15 minutes of League games this season.

Picture

The Pars have lost just once in the past 11 League games, after losing 8 of the opening 13 games.

Picture Picture

All photos by Pars Review

Picture

The East Stand, minutes before kick-off

Picture

The teams come out

Picture

McMullan’s team mates congratulate him on scoring

Picture

Nicky Clark takes a free-kick

Picture

McMullan and Clark applaud the Pars support at the end of the game

Picture

The team celebrate Kallum Higginbotham’s equaliser

For long periods in this game, this was as good a performance as I have seen from a Dunfermline team. Given the huge lift that Hibs went into the game with, after their midweek win over Hearts, and backed by a big home support, the fightback after going 2-0 down and the way the game was taken to the home side, was great to see, and has set a standard that these players are capable of reaching, and possibly exceeding. 
There was one change to the starting 11 that lost on a penalty shoot out to Hamilton in the Scottish Cup – captain Andy Geggan replacing the injured Lewis Martin, a change that was anticipated even had Martin been fit. The sixth minute saw Hibs take advantage of space left by Geggan on the wing, with the ball then played over the Pars central defence and met by Martin Boyle who ghosted in past a static Jason Talbot to score. 
Hibs second goal was also the result of slack defending, Talbot pulling down Boyle for a definite penalty. Jason Cummings scored the kick with ease, with 24 minutes gone. 
At this point a drubbing looked on the cards but 2 minutes later Dunfermline were given a lifeline when Nicky Clark flicked a pass to Paul McMullan that was missed by Hibs’ David Gray. McMullan took full advantage and scored his first League goal for the Pars, on his 21st birthday. McMullan then brought out a great save from Hibs keeper Ofir Marciano with a well struck shot that was heading for the top corner. Halftime came with Dunfermline showing signs of getting something from the game, which had earlier seemed highly unlikely. 

Picture

Paul McMullan and Nicky Clark at the end of the game

The Dunfermline equaliser came a minute into the second half with a piece of Kallum Higginbotham brilliance. The winger received the ball inside the penalty box and placed his shot firmly past Marciano. 
From this point onwards, for at least the next 20 minutes, Dunfermline took a firm hold of the game, and created multiple chances, with Moffat, McMullan and, especially, Clark seeing shots cleared off the line and saved by the excellent Hibs keeper. Some of the Pars’ efforts on goal seemed certain to go in, and it was with a sense of disbelief that the scoreline stayed 2-2. Sean Murdoch was assured and made one save of significance, tipping a header over following a long punt upfield from the home side. Geggan was having a very good game, while Talbot recovered from his poor start to have a storming game up the left side, linking with McMullan. Ashcroft and Morris in central defence were dominant and restricted Hibs to long range efforts.  Wedderburn was the main presence in midfield, and on the right Higginbotham showed the maverick ability he has, frustrating at times but capable of great skill. In attack Clark will wonder how he did not score. Moffat had one of his best ever games for the club, showing his intelligence and being a focal point of most of the Pars’ attacks. Both strikers worked tremendously hard for the team. 
The final 15 minutes lacked the drama that had preceded, but the despicable antics of Neil Lennon on the touchline, ranting and raving and waving imaginary cards, showed how rattled the League leaders were. 
A great game, and as stated above, for a long period this was as good a performance as any Pars fan has witnessed in recent years. 
Starting 11, with marks out of 10: 

Picture Picture Picture

Scottish Championship – Saturday 25/02/17 – KO 5.15pm – Easter Road
Odds (Ladbrokes): Hibs: 4/9; Draw 10/3; Dunfermline 6/1
​Two teams that have enjoyed a run of good results in recent months suffered meet at Easter Road on Saturday evening, a game that is being shown live on BBC Alba with a 5.15pm kick-off time. Hibs have won both previous meetings with Dunfermline this season. The first game, in Edinburgh in August, seemed to be heading for a draw until a defensive slip-up allowed Jason Cummings to score Hibs’ winner. The return game at East End Park was also evenly matched until a deflected goal gave Hibs their opener, after which they went onto completely dominate the second half. 

Picture

Lewis Martin challenges for a high ball in the Hibs v Pars game at Easter Road in August 2016. Photo: Pars Review

Hibs
1 defeat in 18 League games; undefeated in the past 9; 7 points clear at the top of the Championship; and having just recorded a resounding win in the Scottish Cup over city rivals Hearts: all facts that make Hibs a formidable opponent for almost any team in Scotland. With a home support that potentially ranks as the third or fourth biggest in the country, and being the current Scottish Cup holders, Hibs have the Premiership in their sights and will provide a huge test for Dunfermline tomorrow. However, it was only 6 days ago that manager Neil Lennon publically criticised his players following a 1-1 draw in Kirkcaldy against Raith – a venue that saw Dunfermline win, convincingly, by 2 goals to nil last month. Lennon got the reaction he was looking for in the midweek Cup win over Hearts, and has his main players John McGinn and Jason Cummings on form going into tomorrow’s game.
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

Dunfermline
​The Pars return to League business for the first time since February 4, when they lost their 9 game unbeaten League run (11 games in all competitions) with a 2-0 loss at Falkirk. The following 2 games resulted in a pair of 1-1 draws against Premiership Hamilton in the Scottish Cup, games that saw enough chances created to win, and only a wrongly-awarded penalty in the replay with 3 minutes remaining depriving Allan Johnston’s team a quarter final place. A trip to Easter Road will be the biggest test faced for several months, and anything taken from the game will be seen almost as a bonus. The bookies’ odds (Dunfermline are 6/1 to win) reflect the difficulty of the fixture.
Injuries: Ben Richards-Everton, Ryan Williamson, Callum Fordyce
Suspensions: None
Allan Johnston prefers a settled team and rarely deviates from a 4-4-2 formation. This might be a game where a more pragmatic approach is required – playing with 2 wingers could see the central midfield overrun, and there could be a case to add a third central midfielder and play a less expansive game. 
Preferred line-up:
Andy Geggan, who missed the Cup replay at Hamilton through injury, is likely to be fit, and I would have him replace Lewis Martin at right back.
I would play a 4-1-3-2 formation for this game, with Nat Wedderburn guarding the back 4, and Rhys McCabe brought into midfield, alongside John Herron, and with Kallum Higginbotham as a third central midfielder as opposed to playing on the wing in a 4-4-2. This would see Paul McMullan drop out. Had there been a taller, more physical option in attack, I would have gone with one striker and retained McMullan. However, none of the current strikers are suited to playing alone up front.
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

An in-depth look at the club we are about to face. Tomorrow’s regular Friday match preview will cover the game itself from another angle. 

Hibernian
Hibernian were formed in 1875 and joined the Scottish League in 1893, the same year that they moved to what is still their home, Easter Road. The club have won 10 major trophies – the League Championship 4 times, and both the Scottish Cup and League Cup 3 times. Last season’s Scottish Cup win ended a 114 year wait to win the trophy, after they had previously won the competition in 1897 and 1902. The current team are 7 points clear at the top of the Championship, with Premiership football their aim after 2 failed play-off attempts in the past 2 seasons. 

Last 3 seasons
2013/14: 11th, Premiership (relegated)
2014/15: 2nd, Championship (lost promotion play-off semi final)
​2015/16: 3rd, Championship (lost promotion play-off semi-final)

Picture

Easter Road main stand. Photo: Pars Review

Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 3 Draws: 2 Hibs wins: 5

Last five outings:
22 February – Scottish Cup replay – Won 3-1 v Hearts (H)
18 February – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Raith (A)
12 February – Scottish Cup – Drew 0-0 v Hearts (A)
04 February – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Ayr United (H)
28 January – Championship – Won 1-0 v Queen of the South (A)

Numbers game
Hibs have the best defensive record in Scottish football this season, having conceded only 13 League goals.
Hibs are currently undefeated in 9 League matches, and have scored in all 9 games.
They have scored in all 11 home League games this season.

Connections
There are surprisingly few connections between the current Pars and Hibs playing squads.
The only current Hibs player with Pars connections is striker Lewis Allan, who is currently on loan to Edinburgh City. He played 8 games for Dunfermline, on loan from Hibs, in 2015.
Sean Murdoch is the only current Pars player to have played for Hibs (2012-2014), making 2 appearances for the Edinburgh club.

Picture

Dunfermline’s Joe Cardle takes on Hibs’ Marvin Bartley during the last game between the clubs at Easter Road, in August 2016. Photo: Pars Review

Key player
Jason Cummings
With 17 goals already this season, including 1 in last night’s Scottish Cup win over Hearts, Jason Cummings is one of Scottish football’s most exciting young talents. Already attracting interest from English clubs, Cummings has scored 63 goals for Hibs in 116 starts since making his debut for the the club as an 18 year old in November 2013. 

In the dugout
Neil Lennon: a controversial figure who can often infuriate fans of opposition clubs, but undoubtedly someone who demands the highest standards from his players, as he did from his team mates during his successful playing career. A Celtic legend who was an integral part of the Martin O’Neill era team, after retiring as a player Lennon returned to the club to achieve more success as manager. Although his period in charge at Bolton ended in him leaving through “mutual consent”, this was perhaps a case of the right manager at the wrong club, given Bolton’s well-documented financial problems at the time.

Legend
​Lawrie Reilly
A member of the great Hibs forward line “The Famous Five”, Lawrie Reilly played for Hibs between 1946 and 1958, scoring 185 goals in 253 League games. He holds the record for most international caps won by a player during their time at Hibs (38).  His 22 goals for Scotland include 6 goals against England – no other player in world football during the 20th century scored more goals against England. His goal ratio for Scotland is better than the joint top scorers for the Scottish national team, Denis Law and Kenny Dalglish. After scoring a late equaliser against England in 1953, he gained the nickname “Last Minute Reilly”. He had also scored Scotland’s other goal in that game, which ended 2-2. He retired through injury at the age of 29.
​Video of the England v Scotland game, with Reilly’s goals, can be seen below. The Scotland goalkeeper is future Pars manager George Farm.

Picture

A round-up Championship news, latest results, statistics and a look ahead to this week’s fixtures  

Despite going 7 points clear at the top of the Championship table, Hibs boss Neil Lennon was highly critical of his players following the 1-1 draw at Raith Rovers on Saturday. Rovers had gone ahead with a goal from Ryan Stevenson – his first for the club. Top scorer Jason Cummings equalised with a supern free kick, but Lennon was angry with his team, saying: “We were an absolute disgrace. We totally disrespected the opponent. The overall performance, the lack of physicality, belief and urgency. I am not happy.”
Second placed Dundee United were not in League action last weekend due to their Irn Bru Challenge Cup semi final against fellow Championship side Queen of the South. United won 3-2 and will face St Mirren in the final, after the Paisley Saints defeated Welsh side The New Saints 4-1 in the other semi final. 
The other teams in the top 4, Morton and Falkirk, played each other and drew 2-2. Morton went 1-0 ahead through Thomas O’Ware – the defender’s 10th goal of the season. Falkirk responded with goals from James Craigen and Aaron Muirhead to take the lead. Ex-Par Ross Forbes scored to rescue a point for Morton and keep them levels on points with Falkirk and with a game in hand.

Picture

Ryan Stevenson scores for Raith against Hibs

With Dunfermline’s game against Queen of the South postponed due to Queens’ involvement in the Challenge Cup, the only other Championship game on Saturday was an eventful match at Dumbarton, where visitors Ayr United were reduced to 10 men after 27 minutes when Ross Docherty was sent off. Dumbarton then went 2-0 up with goals in 62 and 75 minutes from Sam Stanton. A win would have put Dumbarton into 6th place and 7 points ahead of Ayr, who occupy the 9th place relegation play-off position. However, Ayr scored twice in injury time through a 25 yard free kick from Michael Rose in the first minute of added on time, and then a penalty from Craig Moore 2 minutes later. 
Ayr manager Ian McCall said: “I didn’t see it coming. It says a lot that they never gave in. It could be an important point but we’ve got to turn draws into wins and to do that we’ve got to keep 11 men on the pitch.” Ayr are still without a win in their last 14 League games, a sequence that includes 8 draws.
​​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture Picture

Pars full back Ryan Williamson and Hibs striker James Keatings, during the Hibs v Pars game on 13 August 2016. The teams meet again at Easter Road this weekend. Photo: Pars Review.

This weekend’s Championship fixtures:
Ayr United v St Mirren
Dundee United v Morton
Falkirk v Dumbarton
Hibs v Dunfermline
Queen of the South v Raith Rovers

Championship top scorers (League games only):
14 goals – Jason Cummings (Hibs)
12 – Stephen Dobbie (Queen of the South)
9 – Tony Andreu (Dundee United)
8 – John Baird (Falkirk)
8 – Nicky Clark (Dunfermline)
8 – Ross Forbes (Morton)
8 – Derek Lyle (Queen of the South)

Odds to win the division (Ladbrokes):
Hibs 1/9
Dundee United 5/1
Morton 28/1
Falkirk 33/1

In numbers:
Hibs are undefeated in their past 9 League games – the longest current unbeaten run in the Championship.
Dundee United are undefeated in their last 11 home League games.
Morton are undefeated in their last 12 home League games.
Hibs have the best defensive record in Scottish football – having conceded just 13 League goals this season.
​Ayr United have the longest current run of League games without a victory (14). Raith Rovers are a close second, with 13 games without a win.

Picture

Michael Paton

In wet and windy weather at Kelty’s New Central Park ground, John Potter’s Under 20s recorded an impressive win over a Motherwell side that would have gone top of the SPFL Development League table, had they won today’s game. Instead, Dunfermline climb to 6th place in the table, 5 points behind leaders Hibs. The full table is posted below. 
The Pars began with Cammy Gill in goals, Reece Duncan and Conner Duthie at right and left back, Stuart Morrison and Paul Allan in central defence, Robbie Crawford in right midfield, Evan Horne and Lewis Spence in the middle, and Michael Paton on the left midfield. David Hopkirk and Callum Smith were up front. Spence, Hopkirk and Paton were over-age players. 
It was Smith who gave Dunfermline the lead after just 4 minutes. A Motherwell defender misplaced a pass in the penalty box and it fell to Smith who put the ball in the net from a few yards out. Motherwell then scored twice in 2 minutes: the first was a thunderous finish by Blyth in the 11th minute. Turnbull then put the visitors ahead after some slackness in the Pars defence. 
David Hopkirk equalised for the Pars after 26 minutes, taking a pass from Conner Duthie and confidently placing the ball beyond the reach of Motherwell keeper Griffiths.
The winning goal, and the best goal of the game, came in the 31st minute. Conner Duthie gathered the ball on the left side, ran forward and hit a fantastic shot into the net. 
The second half produced no further goals, although Smith came close for Dunfermline, while Mackin had a good effort for Motherwell that narrowly missed. 
SPFL Development League table:

Picture

Match photo gallery (all photos by Pars Review): 

Picture

Outside New Central Park before the game

Picture

Evan Horne on a run up the left wing

Picture

Michael Paton

Picture

Michael Paton lines up a free kick

Picture

Johnny Galloway, on as a sub for the injured Lewis Spence

Picture

The end of the match

Picture Picture

Dunfermline have scored in both halves of away League games just once this season (in 12 away games) – the joint lowest of all clubs in the Championship, along with Ayr United. Hibs, who have gained 11 points more than any other club from away matches, have only scored 3 times in both halves in the 13 away games they have played.

Picture

In all competitive games this season, here are the top 5 Pars players in terms of minutes played:
Lee Ashcroft (3000 minutes)
Andy Geggan (2379)
Jason Talbot (2223)
Lewis Martin (2214)
Kallum Higginbotham (2198)

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham has the most goal assists of any Pars player this season: 9. Michael Moffat is in second place, with 7 assists.

Picture

3 Pars players have been selected in every match day squad this season (34 games in League and Cups) – Paul McMullan, Michael Moffat and David Hutton. Lee Ashcroft missed out on 1 squad due to a 1 match suspension, as did Kallum Higginbotham. 

Picture

Michael Moffat and Nicky Clark have been substituted more than any other Pars players this season – both have been subbed 12 times. 
​

Picture

Photo by Pars Review

Picture

Join the Moff as he travels through time and space to visit Pars games from the past, in his PARDIS time travel machine.
Over the weekend, the PARDIS touched down in Peterhead, (as seen in photo above, in Balmoor Stadium, Peterhead FC’s ground). The PARDIS then travelled back in time to Rugby Park, Kilmarnock, in 1974 to see Dunfermline play Killie in a Scottish League match. 

November 16, 1974 – Division 1 – Kilmarnock 2, Dunfermline 4
Season 1974/75 was the final term in Scottish football to have 2 divisions. The following season would see a new Premier League, comprising of the 10 clubs who finished 74/75 in the top 10. There would be 3 divisions, and the rewards for finishing in the top 10 meant that many clubs had a great deal to play for over the season. Dunfermline had aspirations of being in Scotland’s new top division from 1975 onwards, but won just 1 of the opening 8 League games. Results improved towards the end of October with 2 wins and a draw, before they travelled to Rugby Park to take on Kilmarnock. 
Killie took the lead in the 4th minute when a cross by McDicken was headed in by Fleming. Graham Shaw craeted the Pars’ equaliser in the 11th minute, making a good run into the box and being grabbed round the waist by McDicken. It was a certain penalty but the referee played advantage as the ball fell to Kenny Watson who put the ball in the empty net. 
Two minutes before half time, Killie winger (and future Celtic and Scotland star) Davie Provan, making his debut, set up Fleming to score Killie’s second goal. 

Picture

3 of the Pars players who played in the win at Killie were featured in these football cards from 1974

Dunfermline came out at the start of the second half and took a grip of the game. After 54 minutes Shaw had another good run fand his pass to Kenny Davidson was finished expertly, to make the score 2-2, The same pair were involved 3 minutes later in the third Dunfermline goal – Shaw headed the ball to Davidson, who put an unstoppable shot past Stewart in the Killie goal. 
Gordon Forrest then hit a shot that took a deflection off Kenny Watson to put the Pars 4-2 ahead in the 63rd minute. Dunfermline continuted to dominate the game but there were no further goals.
Pars team: Karlsen, Scott, Markey, Kinninmonth, Thomson, Evans, Watson, Reid, Forrest, Shaw, Davidson. 
Sadly, the Pars’ hopes of being part of the new Premier League were ended by a poor run of results in the closing months of the season: in the final 16 League games, they won just once, drew 2, and lost 13, including the last 4 games, finishing 15th of 18 teams, and 10 points off the top 10. This meant that Dunfermline became one of the 14 clubs to form the new Division 1. 
​
On the same week this game was played, the UK number 1 single was Gonna Make You A Star, by David Essex. The UK number 1 album was Rollin’ by the Bay City Rollers.

Picture Picture Picture

Pars players per-match warm up

Picture

Taken in the away stand showing the other 3 sides of the ground

Picture

The home stand, showing the Hamilton support minutes before kick-off

Picture

Pre-match handshakes

Picture

John Herron (facing) in the middle of a Pars defensive wall

Picture

Lewis Martin

Picture

The teams prepare for extra time

Picture

Double substitution: Cardle and Paton for Higginbotham and McMullan

Picture

Michael Paton takes the Pars’ second missed kick of the shoot-out

Picture

Pars players await Gavin Reilly’s penalty, the final Dunfermline kick of the shoot out

Picture

Pars players wait on Rhys McCabe taking Dunfermline’s first kick of the penalty shoot-out.

Against a poor Premiership side that had won 1 of its last 14 League games, and who were missing 8 first team players, Dunfermline blew the chance to progress into the Scottish Cup quarter finals and a money-spinning tie against Rangers at Ibrox. Just as in the first game at East End Park, the Pars were 1-0 up at half time but were unable to add a second goal due to poor finishing. Inevitably, Hamilton equalised. The game ended in farce when Dunfermline missed their first 3 penalty kicks in a penalty shoot out after the scoreline remained 1-1 after extra time. Accies, despite missing one themselves, went through as Dunfermline fans streamed out of the ground. 
There was just one change to Saturday’s starting line-up, with injured captain Andy Geggan missing, and Jason Talbot in at left back with Lewis Martin moving to Geggan’s right back position. 
The Pars had the better of the early play with Paul McMullan coming closest with a shot that was turned round the post by Accies’ keeper Remi Matthews. 
Dunfermline went ahead in the 25th minute when Callum Morris forced the ball over the line after a mini-stramash in the Hamilton penalty box. Pars keeper Sean Murdoch had to be alert when Accies were allowed to take a free kick quickly, making a save at his post from a Redmond shot. On the stroke of half time, Lewis Martin misjudged a header and gave Imrie a sight of goal from a few yards out but the Accies striker put the ball wide.

Picture

Lewis Martin

Dunfermline had chances in the second half to double the lead but in a repeat of Saturday’s game, saw Michael Moffat fluff a chance when in on the goalkeeper. John Herron sent a lob over the bar with the keeper stranded. Nicky Clark was played in but took a bad touch and the chance was gone. 
Lewis Martin then did what Lewis Martin does: hands all over his opponent in the penalty box, but luckily escaped a penalty being awarded against him. A free kick from Accies’ Danny Redmond narrowly missed the goal. Johnston then took off Clark, who stormed up the tunnel, clearly angry at being substituted. Moffat was then subbed, with Rhys McCabe taking his place, leaving Reilly up front, a clear effort to see the game out by adding an extra midfielder. 
With 3 minutes remaining, Accies’ Scott McMann broke into the Pars penalty box and was fouled by Callum Morris. Rakish Bingham scored from the kick, and the game went into extra time. 
Joe Cardle and Michael Paton were brought on in place of Kallum Higginbotham and Paul McMullan. Cardle was now the team’s creative threat, and he played a great ball through to McCabe, whose cross was missed by Reilly a few yards from goal. 
Extra time ended 1-1. What followed was an embarrassment to the club, with McCabe, Paton and Reilly all failing to score. Of the last 13 penalties taken, Dunfermline have scored 4.
Pars starting 11 and subs, with marks out of 10:

Picture

Photos by Pars Review.

Picture Picture

Scottish Cup 5th round replay – Tue 14/02/17 – KO 7.45pm – The Superseal Stadium
Odds (Labrokes): Hamilton 11/10; Draw 12/5; Dunfermline 12/5
This evening’s Scottish Cup fifth round replay gives the winner the right to play Rangers at Ibrox in the quarter finals. Both Dunfermline and Hamilton had chances to win Saturday’s game outright but the game ended with a goal apiece. 

Picture

Nicky Clark battles for possession against Accies on Saturday

Hamilton
Accies will now be considered favourites to win the tie, being the club from the higher division and now having home advantage. Boss Martin Canning thought a draw was a fair outcome on Saturday, telling the media after the game that, “If we had better decision making, we could probably have scored again to win the game, but we’ve got to do it all again on Tuesday.” Canning praised his side’s goalscorer, midfielder Danny Redmond: “We know he has got the quality to find the bottom corner and thankfully for us he did.”
Hamilton were missing several first team players in the game at East End Park. The injured players – Jesus Garcia Tena, Georgios Sarris, Ali Crawford, Greg Docherty, Louis Longridge, Darren Lyon, Alex D’Acol and Shaun Want – are all still likely to be missing for the replay. 

Picture

Joe Cardle

Dunfermline
At 1-0 up on Saturday, Dunfermline had 3 chances to double the lead in a 6 minute period, but Paul McMullan, Michael Moffat and Kallum Higginbotham all failed to capitalise, leading The Scotsman’s match report headline to read: “Accies rescue replay against wasteful Pars.” While Hamilton then came into the game and forced Pars keeper Sean Murdoch to make 2 excellent saves.
The artificial surface at Accies’ stadium will help Dunfermline’s more creative players, after Saturday’s game was played on an East End Park surface that was cutting up badly and had goalmouths covered in sand and mud. 
Allan Johnston will be without injured captain Andy Geggan, and may decide to start with the same team that played the bulk of Saturday’s game after Geggan’s injury. Jason Talbot replaced the injured Geggan, with Lewis Martin moving to left back. Kallum Higginbotham was named the sponsor’s man of the match on Saturday but played below the standards he has set, a continuation of the patchy form he has showed over the past few weeks. Joe Cardle (pictured above) could be in line for a start, with Michael Paton also in contention. 
Preferred team:
I would retain the team that played on Saturday, minus the injured Geggan, but would make use of the substitutes if Higginbotham’s form does not pick up. 
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Photos by Pars Review.
Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Picture Picture

Other quarter final games:
Aberdeen v Partick Thistle
Celtic v St Mirren
Hearts or Hibs v Ayr United or Clyde

Picture

Murdoch makes a clearance

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

The Moff

Picture

Andy Geggan puts a cross into the Accies’ box

Picture

Nicky Clark keeps his eye on the ball

Picture

Paul McMullan and team mates celebrate his goal

Picture

Nat Wedderburn and Accies’ Danny Redmond

Picture

Pars legends Willie Callaghan and Bert Paton with the winner of the 50/50 half time draw

Picture

Higginbotham prepares to take a corner

Picture

Edited image of McMullan’s goal celebration

Picture

The Moff

A home team with only 1 win in the past 8 home games, against an away team with no away wins in their League this season, ended almost predictably in a draw, although both sides had several chances to score what would have been a decisive second goal. 
Pars boss Allan Johnston made 1 change to the starting line up following last week’s defeat to Falkirk: Lewis Martin replaced Jason Talbot at left back. This was, perhaps, a surprise as Talbot was far from the worst performer last week, but this was also the third Scottish Cup game this season where Johnston has benched Talbot. 
The game began in a freezing temperature, with the rain contributing to the pitch cutting up badly. Hamilton were handed 2 early opportunities, both after Kallum Higginbotham had lost possession. Nat Wedderburn then had an effort from outside the box that whistled past the post. 
Andy Geggan was having a very good game at right back, a marked improvement from recent weeks, and was instrumental in many of Dunferrmline’s attacks, linking up well with Higginbotham on the right. 
The Pars appeared to take the lead in the 28th minute when Callum Morris’ header found the net, but referee Craig Thomson disallowed the goal for an apparent push. Two minutes later, Dunfermline did go ahead when Paul McMullan was played in by Michael Moffat and showed good composure to finish. 
Geggan was injured in the 38th minute and sadly had to be substituted. Jason Talbot came on, with Lewis Martin switching to right back. 

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

The second half began with the wind still biting and it was Dunfermline who created the first chances of the half. McMullan was put through but his shot was scuffed and went past the post. Moffat was then put in on goal but looked around for a team mate to pass to rather than shoot. With no pass possible, he was then forced to shoot and brought out a great save from Accies’ keeper Remi Matthews. Moffat then created an opening for Higginbotham, but the winger screwed his shot wide. These chances all fell in a 6 minute period and really should have been capitalised on. 
Hamilton then came into the game, with Murdoch making a great save from Eamonn Brophy. Jason Talbot then hit his own crossbar with a header. Murdoch then tipped another Accies’ effort over the bar. Hamilton equalised after 75 minutes when Daniel Redmond, an impressive midfielder, was given too much space on the right and placed his shot beyond Murdoch and into the corner of the net. 
Both sides were still pressing forward to avoid a midweek replay but there were no further goals. 
​
​Pars starting 11 and subs, with marks out of 10:

Picture

​Photos by Pars Review.
​Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.

Picture Picture

Scottish Cup 5th round – Saturday 11/02/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park
Odds (Ladbrokes): Dunfermline 7/4; Draw 23/10; Hamilton 6/4
The Scottish Cup brings together 2 teams from different divisions who will both view Saturday’s game as a good chance to progress into the quarter finals. Hamilton have no away wins in the Premiership this season while Dunfermline, despite the recent 11 game unbeaten run, have only won 1 of the past 8 games at East End Park in all competitions. This all points towards a draw, and as the betting odds above confirm, neither team is an overwhelming favourite to win the game. 

Picture

John Herron

Hamilton
Hamilton’s visit to East End Park will give them a welcome break from their Premiership relegation battle, which sees them occupy the 11th place relegation play-off position, 3 points ahead of bottom of the table Inverness. Accies recorded a crucial 3-0 home win over Inverness last week, and although as stated in 11th place, such is the congested nature of this season’s top division that they are only 3 points off 6th position. 
The win over Inverness ended a run of 12 games without a win (6 draws and 6 defeats). Manager Martin Canning has been criticised by some of the Accies’ support, and there was talk in January of fans boycotting a game to show their displeasure at the team’s performances this season. To many outsiders, Accies would seem to be doing as well as could be expected, with a small home support and a budget that is smaller than many of their rivals.

Picture

Michael Paton

Dunfermline
Injured: Ben Richards-Everton, Ryan Williamson
Suspended: none
The Pars’ 11 game unbeaten run ended with a whimper at Falkirk last weekend, with an insipid display. Manager Allan Johnston admitted the performance was not good enough and fell below the standards that had been set during the unbeaten run. Hard work and organisation were key components of the results over the past few weeks. The team has also been fairly settled, but there are still areas that are a concern, especially right-back, where Andy Geggan had a particularly poor game last week. This highlighted again the decision not to sign a recognised right back during the January transfer window. 
Callum Morris has yet to play in a Pars team that has kept a clean sheet since his return to the club, but neither he nor Lee Ashcroft are likely to be replaced, despite Callum Fordyce being in good form prior to Morris’ arrival. In midfield, John Herron’s form has shaded in recent games and he could be under pressure from Rhys McCabe for a central midfield role. On the wings, there are options open to the manager: 5 players for 2 positions (Higginbotham, McMullan, Cardle, Paton and Hopkirk). Hopkirk can also be played as a striker. 
Preferred line-up
I would make 2 changes from the team that lost to Falkirk: Lewis Martin replacing Andy Geggan at right back, and Michael Paton in place of Paul McMullan on the right wing. Paton has played in all recent Under 20s games, scoring twice in 3 games. McMullan has been impressive this season but has struggled slightly in the past few games. 
Preferred line-up, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Photos by Pars Review.
Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

In a new feature for the blog, we take take an in-depth look at the club we are about to face. Tomorrow’s regular Friday match preview will cover the game itself from another angle. 
​
Hamilton Academical
Commonly referred to as Accies, Hamilton were formed in 1874 and play at the SuperSeal Stadium, previously known as New Douglas Park, which has been their home since 2001. With a capacity of 5510, it is the smallest stadium in the Premiership. Accies’ original home, Douglas Park, was less than a hundred yards from their current stadium. They played there from 1888 to 1994. After selling the ground, they spent the next 7 seasons ground sharing with Albion Rovers and Partick Thistle. 
Last 3 seasons 
2013/14: 2nd, Championship: promoted via play-offs
2014/15: 7th, Premiership
2015/16: 10th, Premiership

Picture

Accies’ Superseal Stadium. Photo taken at a Pars Under 20s game in December 2016.

Head to head record: last 10 meetings
Pars wins: 2   Accies wins: 6   Draws: 2
Last five outings
4 February – Premiership – Drew 1-1 v Kilmarnock (h)
31 January – Premiership – Won 3-0 v Inverness (h)
28 January – Premiership – Lost 3-0 v St Johnstone (a)
21 January – Scottish Cup  – Won 1-0 v Kilmarnock (a)
31 December – Premiership – Drew 1-1 v Motherwell (h)
Numbers game
Hamilton have failed to win any of their 11 away games in the Premiership this season.
The 3-0 home win over Inverness on January 31 was Accies’ first Premiership win in 13 games.
Accies have conceded 63% of their League goals in the second half.
Despite winning only 3 League games out of 24 matches this season (12% win percentage), Hamilton have spent more time on average ahead in matches than behind: scoring more first half goals than their opponents, but conceding more than the opposition in the second half, the majority of which have come in the last half hour. Accies average 23 minutes per game in the lead (26%), 47 minutes level (53%), and 19 minutes behind (21%): an early lead, an equaliser, and often late opposition goals. 
They played for both
​Of the current Pars and Accies squads, 3 current Pars players have played for both clubs. None of the Accies squad have played for Dunfermline. Pars forward David Hopkirk made 9 appearances for Accies as a teenager from 2010 to 2011. Sean Murdoch, currently in his second spell at East End Park, started his professional career at Dunfermline in 2005. Sean left East End Park in 2008 for a 3 year period at Hamilton, having also played on loan at Hamilton a year earlier while under contract with Dunfermline. The third player who has played for both teams is David Hutton, who made 21 appearances for Hamilton in 2011/12.

Picture

Sean Murdoch

Key player
Midfielder Ali Crawford is Accies’ top scorer this season with 6 goals. Thought to be the target of clubs during the January transfer window, Crawford is crucial to Accies’ hopes of avoiding relegation. The 25 year old midfielder has been with Accies since turning professional in 2009, and has now played 235 games for the club. Crawford is an injury doubt for Saturday’s game. 
In the dugout
Martin Canning is still registered as a player for Accies, but in recent months has concentrated almost exclusively on his managerial duties, having not made a first team appearance this season. Canning joined Accies in 2008 and has played 244 games for Hamilton. He has played a total of 456 games in his career, which began at Ross County in 1999.
Legend
Rikki Ferguson has made more appearances for Hamilton than any other player. Making his debut at age 18 in 1974, the goalkeeper played in 527 games over the next 14 years, with 150 clean sheets. He won a Scotland Under 21 cap in 1977, playing against England. The highlight of his Accies career was winning the First Division in 1986, which allowed him to play the following season in the Premier League for the first time in his long career. He left Accies in 1988, signing for Queen Of The South, where he played 1 season before retiring. 

​Photos by Pars Review

Picture

The Championship continues to be a division that can provide coupon bursting results, with leaders Hibs relying on a second half equaliser by Jason Cummings to secure a point against relegation battlers Ayr United at Easter Road. Earlier this season, Ayr defeated Hibs in Edinburgh and came very close at the weekend to completing an unlikely double. 
It was no surprise last night that the Wee Team eventually sacked manager Gary Locke. After losing 1-0 at home to Morton, which extended their winless run to 14 games (including 6 consecutive defeats), Raith fired their manager. Locke was an unpopular appointment to begin with – unsuccessful spells in charge of Hearts and Kilmarnock did nothing to excite the Kirkcaldy public when he was appointed last summer. After a reasonable start to the season, Raith have not won a game since October. The Championship tables below show their decline: 2 points gained in the 9 match period between the tables below:

Picture

So who will be Raith’s next manager? Names being mentioned include John Hughes, Steven Pressley and Darren Young. Prior to Locke, Raith appointed 2 younger managers (Grant Murray and Ray McKinnon) with mixed success – Murray was sacked after 3 years but McKinnon did an excellent job in his 1 season at Raith, before taking up the Dundee United job. Before that, the experienced John McGlynn was Rovers’ manager, from 2006-2012. 
Here are all the incoming transfers to Championship clubs during the January transfer window:

Picture

St Mirren have been the most active club, with 10 players signing, and 7 leaving the club permanently plus 1 on loan. Manager Jack Ross has overhauled his squad and will hope that what is essentially a new team will knit together quickly enough to climb out of the automatic relegation place. 
​In the past week, since the transfer window closed, Morton have signed Celtic striker Luke Donnelly on loan, and ex-Par Farid El Alagui has joined Ayr United. Loan deals and moves for out of contract players can still be completed outwith the transfer window.  

Picture

Josh Todd (left), seen playing for Dunfermline as a trialist in a pre-season game at Alloa, has moved from Dumbarton to St Mirren, while Farid El Alagui (right) has signed for Ayr United. Both photos by Pars Review.

Championship top scorers (League games only):
13 goals – Jason Cummings (Hibs)
12 – Stephen Dobbie (Queen Of The South)
9 – Tony Andreu (Dundee United)
8 – Nicky Clark (Dunfermline)
​8 – Derek Lyle (Queen Of The South)

Odds to win the division (Ladbrokes):
Hibs 1/5
Dundee United 7/2
Morton 16/1
Falkirk 40/1

In numbers:
Ayr have failed to win any of their last 13 League games.
Dunfermline’s 11 game unbeaten run ended at the weekend. The Pars scored at least 1 goal in all of those 11 games, a sequence that also ended with the 2-0 defeat at Falkirk.
Dundee United and Morton are both unbeaten in their last 11 home games. 
Falkirk have scored in all 10 of their home games.
1-1 is the most common scoreline in Championship games this season: 18% (21 games) of the 116 League games played involving all teams have resulted in that score. 

Picture

Andy Smith

Picture

Once vilified by the Pars support during his time as an Airdrie player, striker Andy Smith (pictured above) became a huge favourite with Dunfermline fans, winning them over with goals and his tireless work ethic. Such was his initial lack of popularity in Dunfermline, he was jeered on his Pars debut, a pre-season friendly against Bolton in 1995, during which he suffered a broken leg that kept him out of action until December that year.
Almost half of his 129 career goals were to be scored during his 5 seasons as a Pars player, with a total of 59 goals in 130 starts (plus 10 sub). He became club captain in his final season but was unable to prevent the team being relegated from the Premier League. He was one of the survivors of the team who had won promotion in 1996. 
In 2004, as a veteran playing for Clyde at Broadwood in a Scottish Cup match against Dunfermline, he was given a standing ovation by Pars fans in a pre-match warm up at Broadwood. Quite a contrast from the reception he was given upon arriving at the club, and an indication of how highly he came to be regarded by Dunfermline supporters. 

Picture

Andy on the cover of 2 Pars programmes

​Edited photo of Jason Talbot by Pars Review.

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture

The North Stand, Easter Road

Picture

The main stand

Picture

Another view of the outside of the main stand

Picture

Match programme and ticket

Picture

Callum Morris and Lee Ashcroft

Picture

Big Nat with AJ

Picture

Sean Murdoch and Callum Morris before kick-off

Picture

The Pars team re-group after losing the opening goal

Picture

Nicky Clark

Picture

Paul McMullan gathers the ball after scoring

Picture

Tempers rise in midfield

Picture

Moments after Higginbotham’s equaliser

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

Referee John Beaton has words with Neil Lennon

Picture

Higginbotham, always appreciative of the fans

Picture

Sean Murdoch, solid as always in goal

Picture

The players walk from the dressing room to the pitch

Picture

Pars keeper Cammy Gill

Picture

Paul Allan

Picture

David Hopkirk and Callum Smith

Picture

David Hopkirk

Picture

Conner Duthie

Picture

Callum Smith

Picture

Pars coach John Potter

Picture

Outside the stadium before the game

Picture

The away stand and food kiosk

Picture

Allan Johnston

Picture

Pars sports scientist Gary McColl

Picture

Sean Murdoch was captain in the absence of Andy Geggan

Picture

Murdoch claps the Pars travelling support

Picture

Murdoch makes a clearance

Picture

The captain was one of the best Pars players yet again

Picture

Dunfermline players celebrate Callum Morris’ goal

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

Michael Paton prepares to take a corner

Picture

Rhys McCabe with a long throw

Picture

Walking up to EEP before the game

Picture

Inside the concourse in the Norrie

Picture

Match programme and ticket

Picture

Big Nat

Picture

Sean Murdoch

Picture

John Herron

Picture

The teams come out

Picture

Handshakes before kick-off

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham, with Andy Geggan behind

Picture

Lewis Martin makes a forward run

Picture

Callum Morris challenges Rakish Bingham

Picture

Lewis Martin

Picture

Higginbotham wins a header

Picture

Andy Geggan goes off injured

Picture

Jason Talbot

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

The Moff runs at the Accies’ defence

Picture

Fans leave EEP at the end of the game