Blog Archives

MATCH REPORTS

​​Updated every gameday.

Picture

A desperately poor performance with part time Dumbarton unlucky not to win all 3 points

TEAM NEWS:
With Aaron Splaine and Andy Ryan injured, Allan Johnston brought Callum Smith into the starting 11 to replace Ryan, despite Declan McManus being free from suspension. Joe Cardle was dropped, with Fraser Aird moving to the left wing. Kallum Higginbotham returned to the team after serving his 1 game suspension.

Picture

MINUTES THAT MATTERED:
The first half was so woeful, so chronically bad, that there were almost no moments of any real significance that are worthy of noting. I will not waste my time, or yours, by describing how Big Nat fell on his backside or how Higgy was continually dispossessed etc. Callum Smith had a goal-bound shot cleared; that was pretty much it. 
Second half:
50′ Tom Walsh puts Dumbarton ahead with a shot into the corner of the net from 25 yards
55′ Joe Cardle and Michael Paton replace out-of-form pair Kallum Higginbotham and Dean Shiels
56′ Callum Morris equalises after bringing the ball down and hooking a shot past the keeper
68′ Dumbarton sub Dimitrios Froxylias hits an incredible shot from outside the box into the top corner to put Dumbarton 2-1 up
71′ Declan McManus comes on in place of Fraser Aird. Johnston moves striker Callum Smith to the right wing
89′ Nicky Clark equalises with a close range header 

Picture

Fraser Aird

OPINION
Apologies in advance to the reader who told me he “doesn’t like reading match reports after we lose”. Today’s report has been written with the feel of a defeat despite the late equaliser. I have also allowed 3 hours to pass since full time to reflect on the performance, so as not to vent and rant, and to give a (hopefully) considered response to the game, the team selection and other issues. 
No team has a given right to 3 points but the expectation of a home win was high pre-match, partly due to our excellent recent record against Dumbarton. It was, sadly, clear from the opening minutes that Dunfermline were flat, sloppy, and not in a mindset that would suggest a morale-boosting win, after just 1 League victory in 6 games, stretching back to September.
Kallum Higginbotham, brought back into the team after suspension, had a dreadful game, as did Dean Shiels, who always wanted far more time on the ball than he could possibly have expected. Johnston was correct to sub the pair before the hour, but his final substitution was baffling to say the least: Declan McManus on (no problem there) but Fraser Aird off, and striker Callum Smith moved to the wing, a return to the centre forward played wide nonsense of a few weeks ago when Cardle was injured. Taking off 2 wingers and then playing a striker on the wing either says that he has no faith in his actual wingers, or he is needing help with his team selection. 
Credit to Dumbarton for being very well organised, and for Froxylias’ magnificent goal. The Greek, who was on trial with the Pars in the summer, scored a goal that will surely be his team’s goal of the season. 
The Pars defence were almost blameless, and there was nothing Sean Murdoch could do about either goal. Midfield was abysmal. Aird was the best of the bunch but Shiels and Higgy, as noted above, had games to forget. Big Nat looked bigger and more immobile than ever. Up front, Nicky Clark could not be criticised for lacking effort. Callum Smith was somehow awarded the sponsors’ man of the match. 
I take no pleasure in criticising the team or the manager but as an independent website that exists to give a balanced and objective opinion, I cannot pretend that it was better than how I have described. There is no vendetta against the manager but I am losing faith in his ability to take the team further.

Picture

Photos and edits by Pars Review
​
Tomorrow:
Match photo gallery
Stat Pack ​

Picture

Dismal game that will not live long in the memory

TEAM NEWS:
With Kallum Higginbotham and Declan McManus serving 1 game suspensions, their places were taken by Fraser Aird and Andy Ryan. The rest of the starting 11 was as per Saturday’s game at Queen’s Park. With only 17 players available, the subs bench was not full but did see the return of Michael Paton to the matchday squad.

Picture

MINUTES THAT MATTERED:
10′ Nicky Clark’s free kick is palmed away by Morton keeper Derek Gaston
21′ GOAL! Andy Ryan reacts instinctively when a Fraser Aird cross hits a Morton defender and falls to the Pars striker, who shoots first time and gives Dunfermline the lead
34′ Gary Oliver equalises for Morton after slackness in the Pars defence
40′ Callum Morris loses concentration and possession causing Sean Murdoch to leave his goal and foul Morton’s Andy Murdoch, avoiding a certain goal
41′ From the free kick for the above foul, Gary Harkins’ shot hits the Pars defensive wall and reaches Oliver who scores from an offside position, with the goal not given
69′ Dunfermline are awarded a free kick outside the penalty box for a Morton handball. Some Pars players protest to referee Finnie that the handball had been inside the box
81′ Morton sub Robert Thomson’s close range header is saved by Sean Murdoch
87′ Pars sub Michael Paton hits a his 20 yard shot just wide of the post

Picture

Fraser Aird (no.17) celebrates with goalscorer Andy Ryan

OPINION:
​Too many passes straight to a Morton player, high balls played to 5’9” strikers, lack of communication in defence and attack – some of the main issues that arose from this evening’s dire game at East End Park. On a positive note, Andy Ryan showed how instinctive he can be when given a chance, while Fraser Aird did reasonably well in right midfield, in the absence of the suspended Kallum Higginbotham. The 2 “replacements” were among the better Pars performers, while Jason Talbot was my man of the match for another good, solid game, driving forward when possible and trying to inspire the team. Nicky Clark played well alongside Ryan and the pair should be given another chance together at the weekend against Dumbarton.
Less positive was captain Callum Morris, who – just as in the previous meeting with Morton this season – let his concentration wander in areas that could have, and should have, resulted in Morton goals. Meanwhile, centre midfield was once again devoid of meaningful creativity. Big Nat and Dean Shiels spent another game doing everything but score or create a pass that led to a goal – both players have yet to either score or have a goal assist all season. 
Joe Cardle was hugely frustrating. Possibly over-compensating for the absence of Higginbotham, Joe was all around the pitch and rarely made himself available on the left wing. When he did get the ball, he often lost it, and although there is no doubting his enthusiasm, this game was reminiscent of his manic substitute appearances from last season, when he tried to do too much in an effort to impress. 
A disappointing game of football and from a Dunfermline standpoint, not one that suggested the team are capable of a serious promotion push – it’s now 1 win from the past 6 League games. 

Picture

Photos and edits by Pars Review
(No photo gallery for this game)
​Tomorrow: 5 Things We Learned v Morton

Picture

Scoreline flatters Pars as they progress to round 4 of the Scottish Cup

TEAM NEWS:
Same line-up and bench as in the last game, 2 weeks ago, at Falkirk. 

Picture

MINUTES THAT MATTERED:
17′ Lee Ashcroft’s header from a Kallum Higginbotham corner appears to go over the line but the goal is not given
37′ The home side’s David Galt beats Ryan Williamson and swings in a cross that hits off the post
47′ GOAL! Nicky Clark’s header from a Joe Cardle cross puts Dunfermline 1-0 ahead
59′ GOAL! Jason Talbot rattles in a shot from 25 yards to make it 2-0
63′ Galt pulls a goal back for Queen’s Park with a free kick played into the box that is deflected into his own net by Ryan Williamson
66′ Almost 2-2 when Dominic Docherty’s 20 yard strike hits the Dunfermline cross bar
75′ Another chance for Queen’s Park when slack play from Callum Morris puts Robbie Leitch clean through on goal, but he delays his shot and the chance is gone
83′ GOAL! Aaron Splaine’s shot is saved by Michael White. Andy Ryan is quickest to react and scores from close range to make it 3-1
89′ GOAL! Declan McManus places a shot beyond White from the edge of the penalty box: 4-1 to Dunfermline
90′ Splaine is unlucky not to make it 5 when his deflected shot hits the post. McManus taps in the rebound but is clearly offside

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham and Andy Ryan congratulate Declan McManus on his goal

OPINION:
Ultimately, progression to the next round of a Cup competition is all that matters (ask Raith Rovers, who lost 3-0 away to League 2 Peterhead today), but the scoreline was not a true reflection on the game at Hampden today. Allan Johnston picked the same 11 players and 7 subs as in the last game, but it was Queen’s Park – bottom of League 1 and who had lost their last 3 games by a combined score of 9-0 – that started the brighter side. Dunfermline were disjointed and sluggish in a poor first half that briefly lit up when Lee Ashcroft’s header seemed to cross the line but no goal was given. 
Hampden is a poor stadium to view football in at the best of times, far less a cold afternoon in November, with just over 1000 fans in the ground. Supporters feel detached from the play, and the inflated catering prices (£5.50 for a cheeseburger) did little to warm up the hardy souls who sat shivering in the national stadium. 
The second half had more incidents, with 4 Pars goals, and chances for the home side who were unlucky not to pull back a 2 goal deficit. Yet another free kick beat the Pars defence, this time a flighted ball into the box that Ryan Williamson diverted into the net. I felt that Sean Murdoch, standing next to Williamson, should have made the ball his. Late Pars goals put a false sheen on what was, really, a struggle. 
Mention has to be made of referee Steven McLean who gave a series of non-existent fouls and made hard work of a very easy game. 

Picture

Photos and edits by Pars Review
​
Tomorrow:
Match photo gallery
Stat Pack 

Picture

Lack of discipline costs Pars a rare win at Falkirk as two see red

TEAM NEWS:
Dean Shiels, Joe Cardle and Declan McManus came back into the team at the expense of Aaron Splaine, Fraser Aird and Callum Smith, who were all named among the substitutes. 

Picture

MINUTES THAT MATTERED:
28′ GOAL! Nicky Clark was fouled in the box and Kallum Higginbotham scored from the resultant penalty.
30′ Higginbotham booked; almost given second yellow in 2 separate incidents before half time.
55′ Higginbotham received second yellow card – sent off and Pars down to 10 men.
63′ Jordan McGhee equalised for Falkirk from a free kick. 
90+2′ Pars broke upfield and Dean Shiels fouled as he was set to make a decisive pass to put a Dunfermline attacker through on goal. In a tussle that followed, Declan McManus received a second yellow card and was sent off. Pars down to 9 men.
90+4′ Falkirk’s Nathan Austin saw his header hit the post and into Murdoch’s arms.

Picture

Falkirk fans show their love for ex-player Higginbotham after his first half goal

OPINION:
Indiscipline on the field, arguments between fans in the away stand, a first half lead thrown away, yet another goal conceded from a free kick and a failure to make a suitable tactical adjustment from the manager after going down to 10 men; yet the team (or what was left of it) pulled together despite being under pressure in the second half and came away with a valuable point. Dunfermline’s winless run at Falkirk’s stadium is now set to extend to a 7th year, with today being a wasted opportunity to end the poor run of results at the home of our rivals. 
The first half saw Dunfermline take the lead through a Kallum Higginbotham penalty but there was little else to get enthused about. Both sides had a couple of half chances but the game was yet to ignite. That would come in the second half when Higginbotham, always a red card waiting to happen in this type of fixture, was sent off for a second booking and immediately the whole balance of the game swung in Falkirk’s favour. The home side had almost total possession for the final half hour, with Dunfermline under siege, out numbered and not helped by the manager’s refusal to bring on an extra midfielder to shore up the middle of the park. The ineffective Clark was a poor choice to play as a lone striker – with McManus, better suited to that role, pushed out wide after the team were reduced to 10 men. This meant that the pressure on the defence increased further. Centre half Jean Yves M’Voto, eventually brought on as a sub for Joe Cardle in the 82nd minute, had been sent to warm up midway through the second half, which would have been a better time to make a change. Clark was subbed with 4 minutes remaining, replaced by midfielder Fraser Aird. Only luck and resolute defending had prevented Falkirk scoring a winning goal prior to the all-too-late substitutions. 
Falkirk’s equaliser was another example of a free kick from outside the box beating Pars keeper Murdoch. Johnston later claimed that Murdoch had slipped as he dived to try to make the save. 
The defence fought hard as a unit to keep Falkirk out, while in midfield Nat Wedderburn and, especially, Dean Shiels had good games. Shiels was enjoying his best game for Dunfermline but was, understandably, less involved in a creative sense after Higginbotham’s sending off. 
McManus was also red carded in added on time after Falkirk had cynically fouled Shiels, who was about to release a through ball in a Pars breakaway. 
The team showed that they are prepared to dig in and secure what was, ultimately, a good point given the events of the second half. 

Picture

Photos and edits by Pars Review
​Tomorrow: StatPack feature plus match photo gallery