Pars Review – Match Previews

MATCH PREVIEWS

Updated the day before gameday.

Picture

Scottish Cup – Saturday 20/01/18 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

50th anniversary Cup campaign begins against familiar opposition

After defeating Queen’s Park in the last round of the Scottish Cup, Dunfermline’s reward was a home tie against fellow-Championship club Morton. The teams have met twice this season already, and have a third League game scheduled in a fortnight. In that respect the cup draw was underwhelming, when it could have given us a money-spinning tie against Celtic, or an away day at a rarely-visited venue such as Brora, Cove, Formantine or Fraserburgh. The match-up does, however, give both sides a good chance of progressing to the next round, with the recent head to head record between the teams fairly even, as covered later in this article. 

THE OPPOSITION: MORTON
​Last 6 League results:
WLWDDL

Picture

Familiar opponents over the past few years, this will be the 21st meeting with tomorrow’s opponents since 2010. The current Championship table separates the clubs by 5 points (Dunfermline with 33, Morton 28) but with a game in hand, plus a League game against the Pars to come on 3rd February, Morton can still be contenders for a play-off position. Their recent form will have to improve if that is to happen, with only 1 win in their past 5 League games. 
Manager Jim Duffy has been in charge at Morton since 2014 and has overseen a League 1 title win in 2015, consolidation in the Championship the following season, then securing a promotion play-off place last season. Although Morton were defeated in the play-off quarter finals, Duffy was shortlisted for SPFL Manager of the Year, and won the Championship Manager of the Season award.
During this month, Duffy has strengthened his squad with the loan signing of Frank Ross from Aberdeen. Luca Gasparotto’s loan deal from Falkirk has now been confirmed as a permanent signing for Morton. 
Some other facts about Morton this season:
They are unbeaten in their last 5 away games
They have scored in all of their last 8 away games
They have the best defensive record in the Championship
In League games this season, they have the same points home and away (14 points, 28 points in total)

DUNFERMLINE
Last 6 League results
LLWWWD

Picture

Joe Cardle – Morton v Pars, Cappielow, 9 September 2017

Fifty years ago, on January 27 1968, Dunfermline faced a Scottish Cup tie at the home of the then-current European Cup holders, Celtic. The Pars won 2-0, the start of a journey that ended with a victory in the Final against Hearts and a second Scottish Cup win in 7 years. While we can dream of a repeat of that achievement this season, tomorrow’s game, albeit not the most exciting match-up possible, is still a decent opportunity to progress into the next round. The Pars’ home record this season gives confidence that a positive result can be achieved tomorrow, with 21 of our 33 Championship points gathered at home, plus a 100% record in the 3 League Cup and Challenge Cup games played at home this season.
Dunfermline have lost just 1 of the past 5 games against Morton – and that was the entirely avoidable 3-2 defeat at Cappielow this season. Overall, Morton have the slightly better record in meetings between the teams since 2010, largely due to results in the 2014/15 season. 
Here are the outcomes of all matches between the teams during this decade:

Picture

James Craigen became Dunfermline’s second signing of the January transfer window (after Lee Robinson) when he signed a contract to the end of the season this morning. The squad has needed more athleticism in central midfield for some time and Craigen will provide that, together with his obvious ability. My preferred line-up (below) sees Craigen come straight into the team at the expense of Dean Shiels. 
As always on Pars Review, the lead-up to our next game began with the “Onto The Next One” feature, which was posted yesterday.The article goes into detail about the possible team formation, tactics and line up for the game (written before Craigen signed). Rather than repeat the content of that article, it can be read here.
​Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Joe Cardle photo and Jim Duffy edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 13/01/18 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

The hoodoo has to end sometime…. doesn’t it?

Another opportunity to end an almost 7 year wait for a victory over Dundee United presents itself tomorrow at East End Park. If hoodoos exist, for Dunfermline this is surely such a thing: an opponent who we consistently fail to defeat, including one game when we were awarded 3 penalties against them in the first half and missed them all. Logically, there is no reason we cannot defeat United: the gap between the teams could be narrowed to 4 points with a Dunfermline win, with United coming off a 6-1 loss to Falkirk – the team that the Pars defeated 2-0 just over a week ago.
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

THE OPPOSITION: DUNDEE UNITED
​Last 6 League results:
WWWLWL

Picture

Pressure to gain promotion has been felt not only on the pitch but also in the Tannadice boardroom. Csaba Laszlo replaced former boss Ray McKinnon in November 2017, becoming United’s third “permament” (if there is such a thing) manager since Jackie McNamara was sacked in September 2015, when the club were still in the top division. McNamara was followed by Mixu Paatelainen and then McKinnon. During that period, there were also 3 different temporary/stand-in managers, covering the job until the next future ex-boss was appointed. Laszlo will require promotion to be safe in the job past this summer. His job was not made easier by the loss of key midfielders Fraser Fyvie and Scott Fraser to injury that will likely sideline both players for the remainder of this season. Laszlo has added 3 new players to his squad during the current transfer window: 2 loans signings –  left back Brandon Mason, from Watford, and midfielder Craig Slater, from Colchester; and Emil Lyng, a Danish winger, signed on a six month deal.
Some other facts about United this season:
​Prior to their defeat at St Mirren on 29 December, United had won 6 and drawn 1 in a run of games going back to late October, after the sacking of Ray McKinnon. The first 2 wins in that sequence were under caretaker boss Laurie Ellis. 
United have gathered 25 points at home as opposed to just 14 away from home, in the same number of games (10).
4 of their 5 League defeats have been in away games. 
Last week’s 6-1 defeat to Falkirk was the first time United had conceded 6 goals in a League game since August 2014, when they lost 6-1 to Celtic.

DUNFERMLINE
Last 6 League results:
LLLWWW

Picture

Pars keeper Lee Robinson

Three consecutive wins have restored some confidence to the Pars team, after a poor run of results in the second quarter of the League campaign that included a 7 match period without a win. Manager Allan Johnston has seen new keeper Lee Robinson make a good start to his time at the club, with clean sheets in both his games so far. The introduction of Jean Yves M’Voto in central defence has also been positive. Big Jock, who has watched most of the season from the subs bench, replaced the suspended Callum Morris against Falkirk on 2 January and kept his place in the next game, the 1-0 win at Dumbarton last week, despite Morris being available again.  It is encouraging to see AJ make such decisions: like many managers, he was guilty of keeping faith with “regulars” even when their form dipped. He has now shown that he will play players based on form rather than on reputation. The manager has also shifted from an over-reliance on  a 4-4-2 formation, with last week’s line-up shifting from 4-1-3-2 to 4-3-3 during the game, as it did during the Falkirk game a few days before. 
Dunfermline’s recent record against Dundee United is very poor, with just 1 win in the past 12 League and Cup games. That solitary win was back in 2011, so we are long overdue a victory. United will be aware of our goalscoring threat – Dunfermline are the division’s second top scorers, and have scored in every home game this season.
Here are the outcomes of all matches between the teams during this decade:

Picture

As always on Pars Review, the lead-up to our next game began with the “Onto The Next One” feature, which was posted yesterday.The article goes into detail about the possible team formation, tactics and line up for the game. Rather than repeat the content of that article, it can be read here.
​Here is my preferred starting 11 for tomorrow’s game:

Picture

Lee Robinson photo and Csaba Laszlo edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 06/01/18 – YOUR Radio 103FM Stadium – KO 3.00pm

Pars return to an away venue that has been good to them in recent seasons, looking to build on Tuesday’s derby win

Two consecutive victories might suggest that Dunfermline have regained some of the early season form that saw the team top the division during part of the opening quarter. While there were encouraging signs against Falkirk, there is still more to come, and hopefully the recent improvement will continue against an opposition team that the Pars have done very well against over a 20 year period. Home side Dumbarton, one of only 2 part time teams in the Championship, are again defying any relegation worries and are currently 6 points clear of a relegation play-off place, and 17 points from the bottom of the table.
Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

THE OPPOSITION: DUMBARTON
Last 6 League results:
​DWLDLD

Picture

It is very easy to be condescending towards Dumbarton; they are the perennial survivors in Scotland’s second tier, often (as is the case this season) being one of only 2 part time clubs in the division, competing against full timers with Premiership aspirations. Plucky wee Dumbarton, perhaps. However, they are worthy of far more than a patronising pat on the head. Under manager Stephen Aitken, they have recruited some of the very best part time professionals in Scotland and further afield, players who are able and willing to play part time as they often have another income from outside the game. It’s not so much the quality of player that is an issue for Dumbarton, but – like every other part time club – the limited time they have to train together, something that Aitken has mentioned but has not complained about.
Dumbarton’s recent form is not great – they have 1 win in their last 6 League games, but it’s worth noting that the solitary win came against St Mirren away, which was Saints’ first home loss of 2017. While Dumbarton have not won many games recently, neither have they lost many either, suffering only 2 defeats during November, December and into January. A team who draw more than most, they know that preventing the opposition from winning can ensure survival; lack of victories means they will never be promotion contenders; 8th place is their trophy. 
Some other facts about Dumbarton this season:
They are the Championship’s second lowest goalscorers, having scored 15 goals.
They have a decent defensive record, conceding 25, which is only 2 more than leaders St Mirren and 1 more than Dunfermline.
Dumbarton haven’t won any of their past 5 home games. 

DUNFERMLINE
​Last 6 League results:
​DLLLWW

Picture

Pars fans have had many enjoyable away days at Dumbarton in recent history. Dunfermline have won 5 and drawn 1 of the last 6 games at The Rock (the stadium which changes names every few months depending on which company are sponsoring it). Currently the YOUR Radio 103FM Stadium (yes, the YOUR is in capitals, as it’s the type of cosy wee station that appeals to Clyde 2 listeners), there are ongoing plans to move to a different location in the town, despite only moving to their current site in 2000, after 121 years at Boghead. Such is the transitory nature of modern life.
Pars manager Allan Johnston’s brow was less furrowed than of late after the Falkirk win. Johnston has been willing to change the team’s formation over the past few weeks, something that would have been unthinkable, or maybe impossible, just a couple of months ago. Clearly putting the Soccer Skills & Techniques DVD that his wife bought him for Christmas to good use, the manager’s 4-1-3-2 formation against Falkirk was the most effective for some time, allowing Big Nat to provide extra defensive insurance as defensive midfielder, while still retaining enough bodies further up the park to provide an attacking threat, rather than the loan striker line-up that was used in a couple of recent games.
The Pars have promotion aspirations despite a poor second quarter – they currently have the third worst away record in the Championship, with just 9 points gathered on the road. The team is at their best when they are set up to attack, and they are second top scorers in the division with 36 goals, 2 behind St Mirren.

Recent history between the teams: in season 1995/96, Dunfermline defeated Dumbarton in all 4 League games, with a combined score of 14-2. 13 years then passed until the teams next met, in 2009. Here are the outcomes of all matches between the teams since then, with Dunfermline winning 73% of the games played:

Picture

As always on Pars Review, the lead-up to our next game began with the “Onto The Next One” feature, which was posted earlier today.The article goes into detail about the possible team formation and line up for the game. Rather than repeat the content of that article, it can be read

here.

​Here is my preferred starting 11 for tomorrow’s game:

Picture

Nicky Clark photo and Stephen Aitken edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

​SPFL Championship – Tuesday 02/01/18 – East End Park – KO 7.45pm

Third League meeting of the season sees both sides looking for points for different reasons

One of only 2 true derbies in this season’s Championship (the other, of course, being St Mirren and Morton), tomorrow’s game at East End Park could provide a dramatic start to the new year. Both teams ended long winless runs in their last games – Dunfermline’s win over Brechin was the first in 8 League games (4 defeats and 3 draws), while Falkirk’s 3-2 victory over Queen of the South ended an 8 game period without a win. The Pars remain in fourth place in the table despite a disappointing second quarter of the season. For Falkirk, the next few weeks are about gathering enough points to get out of the relegation play-off position that they currently occupy.
Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

THE OPPOSITION: FALKIRK 
Last 6 League results:
​DDLLLW

Picture

Falkirk have endured a miserable season to date, after being one of the pre-season promotion favourites yet unabale to record a first home victory until 2 days ago, when they defeated Queen of the South 3-2. Falkirk’s only other win in the Championship this season was away to Morton. Coincidentally, both wins were achieved with veteran Alex Smith in the dug-out; the Morton game was his sole League match in charge as temporary manager, in between the sacking of Peter Houston and the appointment of Paul Hartley; he was then trackside again at the weekend in the absence of Hartley’s assistant Jimmy Nicholl, who is set to join Rangers as assistant manager and who missed the win over Queens. Clearly, 77 year old Smith still has something to offer. 
The long-rumoured clearout of the under-achieving Falkirk squad began last week when striker Nathan Austin left the club by mutual consent. Hartley is set, or at least would like to, have the same type of squad overhaul as carried out this time last year by St Mirren, which elevated the Paisley club from bottom of the division on 12 points to eventual end of season safety, and set them up for this season’s table topping success. While Falkirk are not bottom of the league (thanks mainly to having winless Brechin in the division), they are only 2 points better off than St Mirren were last New Year, and occupy the relegation play-off position, 5 points adrift of 8th place Dumbarton. 

DUNFERMLINE
Last 6 League results:
​DDLLLW

Picture

Tempers rise during the first meeting of the teams at EEP this season, on 19 August 2017

After a long overdue and much needed win in the last home game, against Brechin City 9 days ago, Dunfermline will go into tomorrow’s derby with a 12 point advantage over Falkirk and having taken 4 points from 6 in the 2 League games between the teams so far this season. All of this should breed confidence, yet that is one key commodity that is lacking at the moment. Tomorrow gives everyone associated with the club a chance to start a new year with a morale boosting win. Let’s see passion on the pitch and an ending to the blame culture that has spread around the stadium, from parts of the stands and into the dugout. If the team show fight, spirit and determination, the fans will respond positively – and as fans, let’s get behind the team from kick-off and truly be the twelfth man. 
The squad remains thin for numbers but Allan Johnston can still call on almost all of his regulars – the same players who had the team sitting at the top of the Championship in the early weeks of the season. The same team who defeated Falkirk in the League back in August. The same team that won 5 of the opening 7 Championship games, scoring 21 goals in the process. That team needs to turn up tomorrow. 
Callum Morris will miss the game through suspension and is likely to be replaced by Jean Yves M’Voto. 
As always on Pars Review, the lead-up to our next game began with the “Onto The Next One” feature, which was posted earlier today and can be read here. The article goes into detail about the possible team formation and line up for the game. 
​Here is my preferred starting 11 for tomorrow’s game:

Picture

Pars v Falkirk photo and Paul Hartley edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 8.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

Following a 4pm pitch inspection today (Friday 29 December), tomorrow’s game at the Tony Macaroni Arena has been postponed. This was always likely with reports of Livi’s pitch being frozen all this week. At least it’s been confirmed early and will save fans a wasted journey.
Confirmation: twitter.com/officialdafc

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 23.12.17 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

The very definition of a must-win game for Dunfermline against the division’s last placed team

A home game against the only team in Scotland without a League victory could put Dunfermline back into 3rd place in the Championship, should Queen of the South and Livingston both lose to the division’s top 2 teams, St Mirren and Dundee United.This is despite the Pars recording just 1 League win since September. Brechin will feel they are due a win at some point and will look at recent games against the top sides in the division to give them confidence, drawing against Dundee United and losing 2-1 to St Mirren, the winner coming from a disputed penalty.
Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​THE OPPOSITION: BRECHIN CITY
​Last 6 League results:
LLDLLL

Picture

It was never expected to be anything other than a hard slog for Brechin in this year’s Championship, and so it has proven to be. One of only 2 part time teams in this division, Brechin gained promotion from League 1 last season through penalty kick wins in both the play-off semi final and final, after finishing fourth in the division.
As mentioned above, Brechin have made life difficult for the Championship’s top 2 sides in the past month, and frustratingly for them have lost 8 League games this season by a single goal. Their away form, with tomorrow’s game in mind, has seen plenty goals scored for and against – they have scored in 5 of their 7 away games, but have also conceded at least 2 goals in all of their last 5 away games. They have yet to keep a clean sheet in any of their 16 League games. Although they have come close to getting more points in many games, their current points tally of 3 is the lowest of all 42 SPFL teams this season.
Usually in match previews, I like to include comments from the manager of our weekend’s opponents. Unfortunately, there have been been no interviews or news on Brechin’s official site, local press or through national media this week (source: newsnow.co.uk plus several other searches). The club’s official website was last updated on 20 December (an article on Scottish Cup tickets) and before that, last Saturday, when they confirmed their game against Falkirk had been postponed. It does not even contain a match preview for tomorrow’s game. 

​DUNFERMLINE​
Last 6 League results:
DDDLLL

Picture

Dean Shiels seen here, with Kallum Higginbotham & Nat Wedderburn, during the Brechin City v Pars game on 23/09/17

Tomorrow’s game features the Championship’s bottom 2 teams in the current form table. While Brechin are marooned at the foot of the table, 5th place Dunfermline have ambitions of moving up a place or 2 with a win, while also glancing over their shoulder at the group of clubs that have circled them like zombies scenting fresh meat during the current winless run. It’s been 61 days since the last Pars’ League victory, and going back further, the team have won just once in the past 10 League games. Manager Allan Johnston has tried a rare formation change during that period, reverting to 4-1-4-1 for one whole game and part of another, before shifting back to 4-4-2 for last week’s defeat in Paisley. 
Yesterday’s “Onto The Next One” article (which can be read here) goes into detail about the possible formation and team line up for the Brechin game. Safe to say, we will line up with 4-4-2 but it’s unclear if the same starting 11 as last week will begin the game. The manager confirmed yesterday that an unnamed  player picked up an injury in training that could prevent them playing tomorrow. In my preferred line up (below) I have selected 9 of last week’s starting 11. The 2 changes are on the wings, with Michael Paton and Fraser Aird replacing Kallum Higginbotham and Joe Cardle. I would prefer to make changes to central midfield, but options are severely limited, something that hopefully will be remedied in the January transfer window.
Our form has to improve – we have had no clean sheets in the past 8 games, but are still scoring capable of scoring goals, and indeed are joint top scorers in division. We have also scored in every home game this season. With games against Livi and Falkirk coming up, we must win tomorrow – anything else is completely unacceptable.
Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Dean Shiels photo and Darren Dods edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 16.12.17 – Paisley 2021 Stadium – KO 3.00pm

Pars hope for Paisley pre-Christmas present of a much-needed 3 points

Two clubs with pre-season aspirations of promotion meet tomorrow, with the Pars desperate to win a first League game since 21 October, and to avoid falling into the bottom half of the division for the first time this season. Hosts St Mirren, currently second in the table, could go top with a victory. 
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

THE OPPOSITION: ST MIRREN
​Last 6 League results:
DLWWLW

Picture

Since the first meeting of the sides (September 16), which Dunfermline won 3-0, St Mirren have gathered 20 League points to Dunfermline’s 10 in the same period. Saints were unbeaten in Paisley until their last home game, a surprise 1-0 loss to Dumbarton. They then ground out a 2-1 win at Brechin last week. They have the joint best home record in the Championship and are second highest scorers (1 goal less than Dunfermline, who still top the goalscoring table in the division). Saints have conceded more goals than their League position might suggest, and have only the fifth best defensive record, with just 4 clean sheets in 16 games. Three of those shut-outs were away from home, with their only home clean sheet coming back on 26 August, in a 3-0 win over Dundee United. Leading scorer Gavin Reilly has 17 goals in 24 games, and averages a goal every 109 minutes based on total time on the field. Last season during a miserable loan period with Dunfermline he scored just twice in 1468 total minutes playing time.
A major threat will come from the highly-rated Lewis Morgan, who in addition to scoring 10 goals this season, is the team’s main playmaker and arguably the best player in the division. St Mirren will also be boosted by the signing this week (initially on an emergency loan, which will be converted to a permament transfer in January) of Danny Mullen, from Livingston.

DUNFERMLINE​
Last 6 League results:
LDDDLL

Picture

Lewis Martin

One win in the past 9 League games and no clean sheets since the middle of October are just 2 of the issues facing Dunfermline before a visit to the division’s second top team tomorrow. Last week’s humiliation at home to Queen of the South saw the team line up with several players being played out of position and a starting formation that was so unsuited to that particular game, that the manager changed it before half time and substituted his only natural central midfielder, both after 35 minutes. The drop in form of some of Allan Johnston’s “mainstays”, including Callum Morris, Lee Ashcroft, Kallum Higginbotham and Nat Wedderburn, has resulted in performances and results plummeting. A shallow squad, which was trimmed so much that the subs bench could not be filled in the past month, has insufficient quality to replace the recognised first picks, and so the team has remained largely the same, with some tweaks here and there. The January transfer window cannot come quickly enough and it has to be wondered why the emergency loan system has not been utilised when there is such a glaring problem in midfield especially.
Tomorrow’s game calls for a return to a more pragmatic system, and I went over possible formations and line-ups in yesterday’s article, which can be viewed here.  I would start with Lewis Martin in a defensive (not central) midfield role would expect Nat Wedderburn not to start, after his recent sub standard displays. Fraser Aird is overdue a start, and I have selected him as part of a more compact 3 man central midfield. As noted above, the Pars are still the division’s top scoring team, and so if recent defensive errors can be eliminated, there is still reason to believe that the team has enough goals in it to win the game. 
​Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Lewis Martin photo and Jack Ross edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 9 December 2017 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

Pars look for first League win since October, level on points with opponents Queens

With 7 points separating the top 6 teams in the Championship, tomorrow’s game between 4th place Dunfermline and 6th place Queen of the South gives both teams a chance to move up the table with a top 4 place in mind. A win would also prevent Dunfermline potentially dropping into the bottom half of the table. 
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

THE OPPOSITION: QUEEN OF THE SOUTH
​Last 6 League results:
WWWLDD

Picture

With just 1 defeat in their past 8 League games, Queens travel to Fife with confidence. Their away record is impressive (the third best in the division), undefeated in their last 4 away games. Having failed to score in just 1 of their 8 away games this season, they will clearly not come to sit in. 
Their goal threat comes from a familiar source: the veteran pairing of Stephen Dobbie and Derek Lyle. Dobbie has 15 goals this season (9 of which came in Cup games) and Lyle 8. Despite having a combined age of 71, the pair are still dangerous and along with fellow veterans James McFadden and John Rankin, both 34, bring great experience to the Queens team while still delivering on the pitch. 
Queens last match was a goalless draw at home to Inverness last Saturday. Manager Gary Naysmith commented after the game that, “this was the type of game that could have been decided by a bit of brilliance or a mistake. I asked the players at half time to make sure it wasn’t us who made the mistake and we didn’t. Unfortunately we didn’t get that bit of brilliance to win the game.”

DUNFERMLINE
​Last 6 League results:
WLDDDL

Picture

Fraser Aird

Dunfermline go into tomorrow’s game on a disappointing run of just 1 win in past 8 League games, and with no clean sheets in past 6 games. The Pars are in fourth place but the table is becoming increasingly congested; 3 points won or lost tomorrow could see a rise to 3rd or a drop to 6th.
Last week saw a resilient Pars team lose to Dundee United but there were positives to take from the game in terms of attitude and application. What was lacking, and will definitely be required tomorrow, was creativity. The change in formation to 4-1-4-1 was appropriate for the game at Tannadice but a home game against a team in 6th place calls for a more attacking system. This will probably see Lewis Martin drop out and Big Nat move from defensive midfield back into central midfield. Dean Shiels, who was due to start last week before being delayed in traffic, is an option for Allan Johnston but I can only hope that Michael Paton does not miss out, after his good performance last week which saw him named man of the match in my match report. 
I would start with Fraser Aird on the right wing in place of a badly out of form Kallum Higginbotham. Up front, Nicky Clark is fit again and after playing 1 up (Declan McManus) last week, Clark should partner McManus in the familiar 4-4-2 formation. Andy Ryan is unavailable having not fully recovered from injury.
​Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Fraser Aird photo and Gary Naysmith edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 2 December 2017 – Tannadice Park – KO 3.00pm

Pars go to Tannadice hoping for first win there in 10 visits

Since Dunfermline’s last victory over Dundee United, in August 2011, the teams have met 10 times in League and Cup games, with United undefeated. The Pars have lost 9 and drawn 1 of those 10 games, a Championship game at East End Park. The teams also drew over 90 minutes in a 2015 League Cup game at Tannadice but United won in extra time. Tomorrow represents another opportunity for Dunfermline to end that sequence of results and prevent United moving 7 points ahead of us in the table, and an even wider gap opening at the top of the division, where St Mirren are currently 2 points ahead of United.
Here is the current Championship table:

Picture Picture

THE OPPOSITION: DUNDEE UNITED
Last 6 League results:
​LLWWWD
Promotion is the only acceptable outcome for Dundee United’s chairman Stephen Thompson this season, evidenced by the sacking of Ray McKinnon when United were in fourth place in the Championship in October, 5 points off the top. Caretaker manager Laurie Ellis then achieved a 100% record in his 2 games in charge before the appointment of ex-Hearts manager Csaba Laszlo as boss. To date, Laszlo has overseen a win and a draw in his 2 League games.
The draw came last week at Brechin – a disappointing result which led Laszlo to comment on the close proximity of his players to the United supporters standing in front of Brechin’s hedge at the side of the pitch: “The spectators were very close to the players on Saturday and they heard everything. The players were thinking: ‘Oh my God, I have to get that right.’ They were getting told to get the ball forward. There are times when that can be a positive thing but it can be the opposite too. I talked to the players and told them that they are professional footballers and should not be noticing what people are talking about. What the people want after 90 minutes is a victory but I am the coach and I have the plan.”
United’s strength is mainly in their defence – with 13 goals conceded, they have the best defensive record in the division, although they have only had 2 clean sheets in their 7 home games.

Picture

Michael Paton

DUNFERMLINE
Last 6 League results:
DWLDDD
As noted above, Tannadice – scene of crucial Pars wins in 1996 and 2005, among others – has not seen a Dunfermline victory for over 6 years. Dunfermline have a poor recent record home and away against Dundee United, and that, coupled with the recent form of Allan Johnston’s team, does not give much cause for optimism going into tomorrow’s game. Although the Pars have the Championship’s joint best offensive record, with 29 goals scored, 21 of those goals came in the opening 7 league games, and only 8 in the past 7 matches. Defensively, Dunfermline have remained fairly steady, conceding 6 goals in the first 7 games, and 9 in the past 7. Despite scoring fewer goals in the past 2 months, Dunfermline have still scored 11 more League goals than United.
Allan Johnston could decide to keep faith with his familiar starting 11 tomorrow, with everyone except Aaron Splaine and Andy Ryan (both regular substitutes) unfit. However, the form of regulars such as Kallum Higginbotham and Dean Shiels has faded, and so while it would have been almost unthinkable at one time to choose to start without those 2 players against Dundee United at Tannadice, I have selected a team (below) with neither player beginning the game. The defence are automatic choices, with no real challenges from the bench; Fraser Aird takes Higgy’s place in right midfield, while Michael Paton replaces Shiels in the middle. Big Nat retains his place and I would have Joe Cardle back in the starting 11, after he was harshly dropped last week. Up front, I have selected Declan McManus alongside Nicky Clark. 
Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Michael Paton photo and Csaba Laszlo edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

SPFL Championship – Saturday 25 November 2017 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

Another home game and another chance for Dunfermline to secure 3 points and maintain a challenge at the top of the division

After the relative disappointment of Tuesday’s home draw against Morton, the Pars face Dumbarton at East End Park, aiming for 3 points to stay in the promotion hunt. If the title or a promotion play-off place is Dunfermline’s target, this is the type of fixture that simply has to be won. A victory would set the team up for the trip to Tannadice next Saturday.
​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture Picture

THE OPPOSITION: DUMBARTON
Last 6 League results:
WLLDLW
The perennial survivors in Scotland’s second tier, this is part time Dumbarton’s 6th consecutive season in the Championship, a testimony to astute management and very successful player recruitment. They currently sit in 8th place, averaging just over 1 point per game. Maintaining that average would place them anywhere between 7th and 9th based on recent Championship end of season tables. 
Strengths: decent defensive record with 16 goals conceded – 1 less than second placed St Mirren. 
Weaknesses: Only scored 9 goals in 12 League games, the second worst record in the division. Top scorer in League & cup competitions is Mark Stewart with 4 goals in 17 games. They have won just once away from home in the League, at Brechin 3 weeks ago. 
Ex-Pars: Andy Dowie and Kyle Hutton. Midfielder Dimitrios Froxylias was on trial with Dunfermline during the summer. 

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

DUNFERMLINE
Last 6 League results:
LDWLDD
The struggle to regain the form and goalscoring form of the early weeks of the season continues tomorrow, with Dunfermline achieving just 1 win in the past 6 League games, a period that includes only 1 shut-out and 6 goals scored, well down on the average of the 6 League first games, when 18 goals were scored. Results against Dumbarton in this decade have been very good, with 7 wins, 1 draw and 1 defeat.
The squad will be boosted by the return from suspension of Declan McManus and Kallum Higginbotham. Aaron Splaine will be missing long-term after his leg break in the Fife Cup game on Wednesday, and every Pars fan will wish the young midfielder a speedy recovery. 
Most of the team picks itself (there are only 18 available players – against Morton on Tuesday, with 2 players suspended, we were unable to fill the subs bench). The defence has to tighten up, with slackness creeping back into their play both against Morton and in the Scottish Cup game against Queen’s Park last weekend. Michael Paton made a welcome return as a sub on Tuesday, and should be an option both in central midfield and on either wing. It would be a mistake to continually select the same players every week regardless of form, and Paton is one player who the manager should consider as a replacement for any out of form or under-performing current starters. Kallum Higginbotham, back from suspension, has not been in great form recently but still has more goal assists (13) than any other player in Scotland this season, and is likely to start the game tomorrow. 
Up front, the area of the team where there is most competition, Declan McManus, also free from suspension, may not regain his starting place after Andy Ryan’s goalscoring appearance against Morton. I would retain the Clark and Ryan partnership, with Ryan deserving an extended run in the team. 
​Preferred line-up, based on comments above:

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham photo and Stephen Aitken edit both by Pars Review.
​Match report/option with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.