Blog Archives

All photos by Pars Review.

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

In many ways a typical end of season game, livened up by 4 goals and a win that was a good final game of the season at home. Fifth place is now in Dunfermline’s hands, and will be achieved if defeat is avoided at 6th place Queen of the South next weekend. 
In a stark contrast to last week’s high octane battle with Falkirk, today’s game was more of a leisurely Sunday drive with the grandparents. Ryan Williamson, Callum Fordyce and the Moff replaced the injured Andy Geggan, Callum Morris and David Hopkirk. Williamson was one of the team’s main attacking threats and also had 2 shots on goal. He defended well and just edged out several other players for my man of the match. 
As noted in the match preview on this site yesterday, Morton had only conceded 1 goal in the opening 15 minutes of their League games this season. Today they lost a second early goal, when the Moff passed to Rhys McCabe. His shot was saved, and when the rebound fell to Nicky Clark, the striker scored with his second attempt after his first shot hit the bar. Morton then dominated possession but were unable to create many clear openings. The Pars defence were solid with Fordyce looking as though he’d never been away. 
Morton equalised in the 37th minute when former Pars loanee Lawrence Shankland finished off a move.
Both teams had efforts before half time, with the Moff firing in a shot that hit a defender’s leg on the way to goal, and at the other end Jason Talbot clearing a Morton attempt off the line.

Picture

The Moff looks up and prepares to pass to Rhys McCabe, which helped to create Dunfermline’s first goal.

The second half began in much the same way as the first. This time it took 6 minutes for Dunfermline to score, when Kallum Higginbotham showed trickery and skill on the right, and put a perfect cross into the box for Moffat to score. As in the first half, Morton then had most of the ball but were met by a resilient Pars backline. 
Michael Paton replaced Paul McMullan on the left wing and the game progressed without much of note happening. While it wasn’t a poor game, it lacked intensity. The referee was also reluctant to book anyone, and it began to feel more like a pre-season friendly at times. 
Callum Smith, the Pars Under 20s top scorer, replaced Nicky Clark in the 81st minute and had a hand in the third Dunfermlime goal, laying the ball off for Rhys McCabe, whose 22 yard shot was helped into the top corner by a slight deflection.
A satisfying win and an indication that Dunfermline are ready to compete at the top end of the division next season.

Picture

Photos and edits by Pars Review.
​Full match photo gallery will be posted tomorrow.

Picture Picture

Scottish Championship – Saturday 29/04/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park
Odds (McBookie): Dunfermline 6/4; Draw 5/2; Morton 13/8
(www.mcbookie.com/en/sports/football/coupons/100/6265610/822133000/0/0/PE/0/0/0/0/0)
​Tomorrow’s game has limited significance for both teams, with Morton already certain of a play-off place, but unlikely to bridge the 5 point gap to second place with 2 games remaining, and so avoid a 3rd v 4th place play-off quarter final meeting with either Falkirk or Dundee United. Dunfermline could have been going into the game with a chance of taking 4th place from Morton, had last week’s game against Falkirk resulted in a win. 

Picture

John Herron. Morton v Pars, Cappielow, 25 March 2017. Photo: Pars Review

Our opponents​ – 
Morton
Last five outings:
22 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Ayr United (H)
15 April – Championship – Lost 2-0 v Raith Rovers (A)
11 April – Championship – Lost 4-1 v St Mirren (H)
8 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Hibs (H)
1 April – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Dumbarton (A)

​Pre-game comments
After a run of just 1 defeat in 12 was ended by Dunfermline in February, Morton’s form has slumped with no wins in the past 7 games. They are guaranteed a play-off place but their recent form almost certainly means they will face a 2 legged quarter final meeting with whichever team finishes 3rd. Second place would have meant avoiding that extra round of games on the way to a play-off final against the 11th placed Premiership team. 

Numbers game
Morton are bottom of the current form table (last 8 games) in the Championship, with just 6 points from a possible 24.
Morton have the second best defensive record in the Championship.
They have conceded just 1 goal in the opening 15 minutes of their 34 League games to date.

In the dugout
Jim Duffy
A Morton legend as a player, Jim Duffy was a talented central defender who won the Scottish Players’ Player of the Year award in 1985 when playing for a Morton team who were relegated from the Premier Division. Injury curtailed his career progress and he entered management with Falkirk at the age of 29. He has since managed Dundee (twice), Hibs, Brechin and Clyde, and was a temporary manager at Norwich, in addition to coaching jobs at Chelsea and Portsmouth. 

Picture

Paul McMullan puts in a cross: Morton v Pars at Cappielow, 25 March 2017. Photo: Pars Review

Pars & Morton facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 3
Draws: 0
Morton wins: 7

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

17 September 2016 – Morton 2, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-morton-2-pars-1

10 December 2016 – Pars 2, Morton 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-2-morton-1

25 March 2017: Morton 0, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report5118098​​
​
Connections
Two Morton players have previously played for Dunfermline: Ross Forbes was at East End Park from January 2014 until the end of season 2014/15. He spent the second half of that season on loan at Morton before signing for them in July 2015. Lawrence Shankland scored 7 goals for the Pars in a 14 game loan spell from Aberdeen in 2014.
From the current Pars squad, Paul McMullan was at Morton on loan from Celtic from February to June last year, while David Hutton played 3 games for Morton in season 2012/13. ​

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
22 April – Championship – Lost 2-1 v Falkirk (H)
15 April – Championship – Won 2-0 v Dumbarton (A)
11 April – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Dundee United (A)
8 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith (H)
1 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Hibs (H)
​
Pre-game comments
Safe from relegation and unable to overtake Morton in 4th place, Dunfermline go into tomorrow’s game with only the financial incentive of finishing 5th rather than 6th as an achievable goal. It could all have been so different, but a top half finish in the division would still represent a very good first season back in the Championship. 
Preferred line-up:
Manager Allan Johnston confirmed there are players struggling with injuries, with Callum Morris definitely out. Sean Murdoch and Andy Geggan are also injury doubts, and whether there are any others remains to be seen. Lewis Martin is suspended, so Callum Fordyce will come back into central defence, with Ryan Williamson at right back if Geggan is missing. Michael Paton scored twice for the Under 20s on Tuesday and I have selected him – this game is a good chance for squad players to get some game time. 
Possible starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Picture Picture

Based on League games this season, Dunfermline have spent an average of 19.6 minutes in the lead in games, virtually the same average time as they have spent trailing opposition teams (19.8 minutes per game). The vast majority of each game has been spent level with the opposing team (50.7 minutes).

Picture

The Pars goals for and against in each half are very evenly split. In the first half of Championship games this season, the Pars have scored 20 goals and conceded 19. In the second half of the 34 League games to date, Dunfermline have scored 22 and conceded 23.

Picture

Dunfermline have lost more penalty kick goals than any other Championship team this season (6). Surprisingly, the only team not to have lost a goal to a penalty is bottom of the table Ayr United. 

Picture

The Pars have the worst record in the division for clean sheets in home League games this season, with just 2 shut outs at East End Park. However, they are second in the division for clean sheets in away games (7 shuts outs), just 1 less than Hibs. 

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham leads the Pars goal assist chart, with 10 assists in all competitions this season. The Moff is second, with 9. 

Picture

The home game against Falkirk on April 22 marked Bobby Robertson’s last official involvement with Dunfermline Athletic. There was a half time presentation on the pitch to mark Bobby’s retirement by club chairman Ross McArthur, and honorary director Jim Leishman, who was Bobby’s manager between 1983 and 1988. This ended an association with the club that stretches all the way back to 1975 when Bobby joined the Pars on a schoolboy contract. Two years later, aged 18, he signed his first professional contract. The part-time deal was ideal for the young player, as he was also studying medicine at Edinburgh University. The combination of football and medicine would dominate the next 40 years of his life, with Dunfermline at the centre of both pursuits. 

Picture

Edit: Pars Review

Bobby played most games as a full back, but was a versatile player who could also play in central defence and midfield. His first season as a first team player, 1977/78. saw him make 40 appearances in all competitions, with Dunfermline finishing third in the Second Division, missing out on promotion. The following season, 1978/79, Bobby played in 47 games, including a last-day game against Falkirk at East End Park. The Bairns had to win to over take Dunfermline into second place. The Pars secured a 1-1 draw and were promoted to the First Division.

Picture

Bobby captained the Pars in the club’s centernary match against Aberdeen in August 1985. Here’s Bobby with Dons captain Alex McLeish.

He gained promotion 3 times in his Pars career – the first, in 1979, as noted above; then 2 consecutive promotions: 1985/86, his first season as club captain, and again the following season when he led the Pars to the Premier League. Although still just 29 years old, 1987/88 was to be his last season with Dunfermline, as he was still part time, and this proved to be less practical with the Pars now a top flight team. He was loaned to Alloa, and then signed for the Wasps for a further 2 years before he retired from playing to concentrate full time on his work as a GP. 

Picture

Presentation at hakf-time on Saturday: Ross McArthur, Bobby, and Jim Leishman. Photo: Pars Review

In 2009, Bobby was inducted into the DAFC Hall of Fame. Six years later, he was presented with an Outstanding Service Award by the Dunfermline board of directors, for his efforts both as a player and as the club doctor, a position he held from 2007 until this month. 
Bobby made a total of 410 appearances for Dunfermline. In 1988, when he reached 354 League appearances, this set a new club record at the time. He made a total of 410 apparances, including 154 consecutive games, a testimony to his ability, fitness and also his excellent disciplinary record. 

Picture

Photo: Pars Review

In February this year, Bobby joined former team mates Kenny Thomson, Bonar Mercer, Ian Westwater plus Willie Callaghan at a Supporters Council meeting at East End Park. It was a privilege to watch and listen to all these Pars legends talk about their time at the club. Bobby was a gentleman: quietly spoken, with a good sense of humour (his story about how he beat a traffic jam when running late for an away game at Ibrox was hilarious). He represents all the is good about DAFC, and although he will return to the club as a supporter, he will be much missed in his official capacity. The Doc: a Pars great. 

Picture

Bobby waves to the crowd for the last time as a Pars employee. Photo: Pars Review

Picture

Sean Murdoch clearly gets a hand to the ball before Myles Hippolyte dives to win the penalty. Photo: News Group Ltd

In the past hour, Falkirk winger Myles Hippolyte has been issued, and has accepted, a 2 game ban from the SFA Compliance Officer for diving in the Pars v Falkirk game on Saturday. This proves what we all knew, but does not help Dunfermline losing a crucial goal, and in the process being denied the chance to achieve a promotion play-off place. 
After the game, Falkirk manager Peter Houston refused to criticise his player. Losing 1-0 and without a serious effort on target, Hippolyte dived without making contact with Pars keeper Sean Murdoch, and was rewarded with a penalty kick which Falkirk equalised from. The Scotsman reported the incident as follows: ‘Dunfermline Athletic were left fuming after Falkirk were awarded a penalty following an elborate dive from Myles Hippolyte, which involved a somersault. The Pars were leading 1-0 through a first half Nicky Clark goal when Hippolyte took a tumble in the box as Dunfermline goalkeeper dove at his feet to push the ball out for a corner. The incident was picked up by footage from Dunfermline who shared it on their official Twitter account. It shows Hippolyte spotting his opportunity, planting his foot beside Murdoch’s hand before springing forward then over.’
Instead of condemning his player, Houston merely said: “I didn’t see it. But if the referee gives it, it’s a penalty.”
This is the same Houston who has a history of alleging refereeing corruption against his own team. In December 2016, after Dunfermline were awarded a penalty against Falkirk, Houston had this to say:
“The referee gave them a bit of help. How he can tell the ball hit our player on the hand, I don’t know. I thought they needed a bit of help to get the goal and the referee was willing to do that.”
So much for, “if the referee gives it, it’s a penalty.”
In October 2015, after a Rangers v Falkirk game, Houston accused referee John McKendrick of being influenced by the Rangers manager and coaches: “The Rangers manager and backroom staff were having a right pop at the referee going up the tunnel at half time about giving them nothing,” said Houston. “He certainly gave them something in the second-half. You wonder if pressure like that has got to the referee. I don’t know. I am totally aggrieved with the fact that he gave a foul against us when Tom Taiwo clearly won the ball and the man fell into him and went down. It was never a free-kick in a month of Sundays. It was not a foul. Shocking decision. It cost us the match, 100 per cent. For me the referee has cost us a couple of points today. I went into see him. He is reporting me to the association for my language.” 
So much for, “if the referee gives it, it’s a penalty.”

Picture

Peter Houston

In October 2010, when manager of Dundee United, Houston had this to say about referee Dougie McDonald:
“He always awards penalties against us and could not point to the spot quickly enough. I don’t know what goes through his head, but it looked like he couldn’t get his finger pointing at the spot quickly enough when he awarded the penalty. I’ve seen it again on the monitor, and it was never a penalty. The referee’s performance today was below average. I need a more consistent performance than that from a referee.”
So much for, “if the referee gives it, it’s a penalty.”
Meanwhile, in another incident involving his own team, Houston had this to say in May 2016 when referee Alan Muir failed to award Hibs a penalty against Falkirk in a promotion play-off semi final game. TV footage showed that a penalty should have been awarded. Houston said: “I didn’t see it.” (Sound familiar?).  He then trotted out that old cliche: “These decisions even themselves out over a season.” 
There is no honour in cheating, or in inventing conspiracy theories, as Peter Houston is on record doing. His denial of the Hippolyte dive reflects very badly on him and his club.
Finally – and this is particularly Falkirk fans who have read this blog this week, many of whom have been abusive, I want to make the following very clear:
I have no time for cheats: I would never want to see our club resort to such behaviour in order to win a game. Football should be won fairly, even if mistakes contribute towards a goal. Without fair play, the game is dead. ​
In October 2016, Joe Cardle was booked for diving in a Challenge Cup game against Queen’s Park. Here’s what Pars Review said about it:
“The first half’s main incident was when Joe Cardle tried and failed to get a penalty by diving, only to be correctly yellow carded by referee Nick Walsh. It was an embarrassing dive, and a deserved yellow card. This has to stop.” 
Diving has no place in football. Neither does hypocrisy. I would rather lose than win a game by cheating. 

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

A game that should have been won was dominated by a referee who made one game-changing decision and showed complete bias throughout, to the disgust of the Pars fans, management and players. I have avoided criticising referees this season, even after poor displays by Craig Charleston and Stephen Finnie, but the performance by Gavin Duncan today was impossible to ignore and not comment on. 
Nicky Clark returned to the Dunfermline line-up after injury, and was joined in attack by last week’s goalscoring substitute, David Hopkirk. The team was unchanged apart from that and with a promotion play-off place still achieveable, Dunfermline had as much to play for as second-placed Falkirk. 
Paul McMullan had a good early run that ended in Nicky Clark’s header being saved by Falkirk keeper Robbie Thomson. McMullan then had a great chance himself but delayed a shot inside the box, and the chance was gone. 
The referee then gave a yellow card to Mark Kerr after an outrageous challenge on Andy Geggan. It was a clear sending off but the referee decided otherwise. Falkirk’s goal attempts in the first half were restricted to a couple of breakways and a long range effort by Craig Sibbald. 
The first major incident of the second half changed the game and saw Falkirk’s Miles Hipplolyte awarded for a blatant dive in the penalty box. Duncan instead awarded a penalty, and booked Sean Murdoch. Before the kick was taken, Murdoch and Callum Morris were substituted, to the amazement of the Pars support. Murdoch later appeared with a strapping on his knee. They were replaced by David Hutton and Lewis Martin. Hutton’s first involvement was to see Aaron Muirhead’s kick give Falkirk the equaliser. Lewis Martin then received a third yellow card in his last 5 appearancres for pushing an opponent in a goalscoring position. John Baird fell under Martin’s challenge and the defender was sent off. 

Picture

Referee Gavin Duncan and the main stand side linesman

Nathan Austin got Falkirk’s second against a Pars defence that included big Nat as a makeshift centre half. 
Hippolyte then took encouragement from the penalty decision to commit a series of fouls on Pars players, knowing he would escape punishment. Duncan then gave Falkirk a free kick when Kallum Higginbotham was the victim of the foul; then told Hopkirk to get up after he was tripped by Peter Grant; and then finally booked Hopkirk for alleged diving after the Dunfermline forward was fouled. Falkirk keeper Thomson was then told off for timewasting, and proceeded to waste more time, with the referee disinterested and running away with his back to the goalkeeper. 
Andy Geggan came close to scoring an equaliser with a header from a Higginbotham corner. Falkirk’s players then fell to the ground under any slight contact, always refusing the physio so as not to have to leave the field. The referee was content to join in with the farce, and when he blew the final whistle, he was surrounded by irate Pars players and management. Nothing will be done – just as in the Hamilton cup tie, when Craig Thomson gave a penalty with a minute remaining after a dive, no mention was made by the media. The same thing will happen here. ​
An official complaint must be made against this referee. As for Falkirk FC, they have proved that filth has no conscience.
​Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:

Picture

All photos and edits by Pars Review.
​Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.

Picture Picture

​​Scottish Championship – Saturday 22/04/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park
Odds (McBookie): Dunfermline 15/8; Draw 12/5; Falkirk 29/20
www.mcbookie.com/en/sports/football/coupons/100/6265610/819859000/0/0/PE/0/0/0/0/0
​

The First Division (now Championship) season of 2010/11 was the last period that Dunfermline had the upper hand over Falkirk for a consistent run of games, winning 3 and drawing 1. Since then, the teams have played each other 9 times, with Falkirk winning 7 and the other 2 games ending in draws. The first meeting of the teams at East End Park this season ended 1-1. Both games at the Falkirk Stadium have been very disappointing from a Dunfermline viewpoint, with Falkirk winning both with minimal effort required. The teams built up a rivalry during the 1980s and 90s which has, in more recent years, started to fade. This was covered in yesterday’s blog article (www.parsreview.org/blog/falkirk-do-we-care-any-more).  While tomorrow’s game may lack the previous edge of games between the sides, there is enough dislike still remaining on both sides to make the game matter more than any other average Championship match. 

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham: Falkirk v Pars, 4 February 2017. Photo: Pars Review

Our opponents​ – 
Falkirk
Last five outings:
15 April – Championship – Drew 2-2 v St Mirren (H)
8 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Dundee United (A)
1 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith Rovers (H)
25 March – Championship – Lost 2-1 v Hibs (A)
18 March – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Morton (H)

​Pre-game comments
Falkirk are once again in the promotion play-off positions, hopeful of finishing second and avoiding having to participate in a 3rd v 4th quarter final play off. Manager Peter Houston commented this week that the team’s fans need to get behind their team, after last week’s home draw with St Mirren: “The home fans are looking for scapegoats”, Houston claimed. “That’s disappointing for me. Yes, we’re at home and we should be lifting them, but we need them to help us along and the support hasn’t been as good as it normally is.” Midfielder Mark Kerr, an ex-Par, was jeered by Falkirk fans after being substituted last weekend. Houston was unhappy with that: “There are periods when someone is picked out and I’m very disappointed. Mark Kerr has been sensational for us. His form could be better but he’ll never hide. It’s times like this he could do with some support.”

Numbers game
Falkirk have scored most goals of any team in the Championship this season (53).
They have scored in all of their last 11 away games.

In the dugout
Peter Houston
A former Falkirk player, Houston has been manager of the Bairns since 2014. He guided the team to the promotion play-off final last season, losing to Kilmarnock, and to the Scottish Cup Final in 2015 where they were defeated by Inverness. Houston has also managed Dundee United. 

Picture

Rhys McCabe scores from the penalty spot: Pars v Falkirk, 26 December 2016. Photo: Pars Review

Pars & Falkirk facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 1
Draws: 2
Falkirk wins: 7

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

15 October 2016 – Falkirk 2, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-falkirk-2-pars-1

26 December 2016 – Pars 1, Falkirk 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-falkirk-1

4 February 2017: Falkirk 2, Pars 0
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-falkirk-2-pars-0​
​
Connections
The previously mentioned Mark Kerr is the only current Falkirk player to have played for Dunfermline, making 13 appearances in the second half of the 2011/12 season.
From the current Pars squad, only Kallum Higginbotham has played for Falkirk, playing 61 games in an 18 month period from July 2010 to January 2012. ​

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
15 April – Championship – Won 2-0 v Dumbarton (A)
11 April – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Dundee United (A)
8 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith (H)
1 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Hibs (H)
25 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Morton (A)
​
Pre-game comments
Realistically, looking at both ends of the Championship table, all Dunfermline have to play for over the 3 remaining games is pride and fifth place. Technically, a place in either the promotion or relegation play-offs is still possible (8 points outside 4th place; 7 points off 9th, with 9 points still available) but it would take not only 3 straight wins or defeats for the Pars, but also a highly unlikely set of results for several other teams for either play-off place to become a reality.  A long overdue win against Falkirk should be motivation enough. 
Preferred line-up:
Nicky Clark and John Herron are still injury doubts for tomorrow. I would retain Rhys McCabe in midfield even if Herron is fit. Clark would take Gavin Reilly’s place if he is ready to play. Both Clark and the Moff are struggling for goals and so David Hopkirk, scorer of the Pars’ second goal last week, will come into contention from the bench. I would still have Hopkirk as a substitute, however. On the basis that Clark is fit, here is my preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

In the 1990s, Dunfermline and Airdrie built up a rivalry that began when the Pars were awarded a dubious penalty kick late in a 1991 League Cup semi final between the teams. After Derek McWilliams scored, Dunfermline then went onto win the tie after extra time in a penalty shoot out. From that moment, the clubs – not linked geographically or for any other reason historically – became rivals for a few years, and meetings were often bad-tempered affairs. Dunfermline had 2 players red carded in a 1993 League game at East End Park when Airdrie visited, and in 1994, at the last game at Airdrie’s Broomfield ground, the home side defeated Dunfermline 1-0 to damage Dunfermline’s First Division title hopes, which the Airdrie fans celebrated as if they had won the league themselves. A couple of years later, a section of the Airdrie support then showed disrespect during a minute’s silence to mark the death of Norrie McCathie. As years passed, however, and the group of players and managers that had taken part in most of the early/mid 1990s clashes left each club or retired, Airdrie gradually became just another club to Dunfermline. Their move to the Shyberry Excelsior Stadium also diluted the atmosphere between the clubs during games. All of the factors and changes covered above could now also apply to an even bigger rival, and our opponents on Saturday – Falkirk.

Picture

View from the home end at Brockville, with the covered terracing to the right. Home fans occupied one half, away fans the other. Photo: The Scotsman

Dunfermline and Falkirk’s rivalry grew through the 1980s into the 90s. Relations between the 2 sets of fans reached a low point in 1996, at Falkirk’s Brockville ground, when a section of Falkirk fans on the terracing made the sound of gas escaping, a reference to Norrie McCathie’s death. I was on the terracing that evening, and a riot almost broke out such was the fury among the Pars support. Some tried to get to the other side of the fence that separated the supporters. The atmosphere was dangerously ugly, and this continued for several years. In many ways, Falkirk became Dunfermline’s fiercest rivals, even more so than the traditional Fife rivalry with Raith Rovers. While we always wanted to defeat Raith, their position as the “Wee Team” is summed up in the lyrics of a song that is still sung by Pars fans to this day – “we don’t even hate you, you’re just a wee team.”

Picture

John Hughes, Norrie McCathie and Paul Smith in a Pars v Falkirk game from 1994. Photo credit: Alamy Stock Photos

Not so with Falkirk – the clubs, similar in size and supporter base, and both having ambitions to establish themselves in the top division, continued to have an active dislike of each other.
Then something gradually began to change. The comparison with the Airdrie situation could be made again. Falkirk moved from Brockville to a modern, purpose built new stadium on the edge of town, imaginatively titled The Falkirk Stadium. Away days at Falkirk, so full of fire and venom at Brockville, now became almost soulless in the new stadium, which has never been completed, one side of the ground missing a stand, and the 2 sets of fans being kept apart before, during and – for the most part – after games. Pars fans occupy the away stand behind a goal, and although songs are sung back and forward, the distance between the supporters has the effect of watering down the atmosphere. What also hasn’t helped is the Dunfermline team’s awful record at Falkirk in recent years, typified by this season’s timid displays, losing 2-0 and 2-1, and with the on-field temperature rarely rising above lukewarm. Games between the teams at East End Park have also been largely forgetful, and lacking in the feel and emotions of past decades. ​

Picture

Views from the away stand at the Falkirk Stadium this season, with a fence, and 2 distant stands for the home fans. Photo: Pars Review

The Airdrie and Falkirk comparisons could be due to the sanctification of modern football. Were the Bairns to have remained at Brockville – as Ayr United have done at Somerset Park – the chances are we would still relish an away day at Falkirk on the terracing, in pie-hurling distance of our rival’s fans. Instead, we are a hundred yards apart and the action on the pitch also fails to raise the temperature, a pale shadow of the battles of Brockville. There is also the theory that there was never a solid foundation or concrete reason for the former intense rivalry, and so it was inevitable that it would eventually fade away. 
In 2017, the Pars and the Bairns are like a divorced couple who once hated each other but, with the passing of time and no real foundation for continuing any bad feeling, now meet up at mutual friends’ weddings or parties 4 times a year, and while they will never be friends, they tolerate each other. 
3 points on Saturday would still be relished, even if games against our visitors from across the Kincardine Bridge no longer have the same passion. ​​

Pars 1, Hamilton 4

Picture

John Potter’s Under 20s fell to a disappointing defeat in the SPFL Development League match against Hamilton yesterday afternoon. The game was a Pars home fixture, played at the now regular Under 20s home venue of Kelty Hearts’ New Central Park. Four over age players were in the Dunfermline starting 11 – Ryan Williamson, Lewis Martin, Callum Fordyce and Lewis Spence. The team have only 1 recognised striker, Callum Smith, and he was joined up front for the majority of the game by midfielder Lewis Spence, who played just behind Smith. 
Hamilton’s recent signing David Templeton scored 2 goals in the space of a minute to shock home side. Templeton, the former Rangers and Hearts winger, has been out of football for over a year after having injury problems while at Ibrox. Hamilton have taken a chance on the player, and on this evidence it could very well pay off. Both his finishes after 11 and 12 minutes were clinical but he was helped by some slack defending on the right side of the Pars defence. 
Brandon Luke was unlucky to see a shot hit the post after some good skill inside the Accies penalty box. Callum Smith brought Dunfermline back into the game with a composed finish after 33 minutes. Three minutes before the break, Hamilton regained their 2 goal lead when Ryan Tierney’s penalty was saved by Cammy Gill but the rebound fell to the same player who scored to make it 3-1. 
Callum Fordyce came closest to getting a second Pars goal when his powerful header was well saved by Accies keeper Darren Jamieson (see photo in gallery below). John Potter then made 2 changes, with Robbie Crawford replacing Lewis Spence after 67 minutes, and Reece Duncan coming on for Brandon Luke 4 minutes later. Crawford took Scott Lochhead’s place in right midfield, with Lochhead moving into attack alongside Smith. The second substitution saw a change in formation, from 4-4-1-1 to 3-5-2, with Lewis Martin moving from left back to join Stuart Morrison and Callum Fordyce in central defence, and Reece Duncan and Ryan Williamson being played as wing-backs. The scoreline did not accurately reflect the quality of Dunfermline’s play, but it did confirm that (Smith apart) the team were not as clinical as their visitors in the final third of the pitch. That was confirmed after 78 minutes when Tierney scored Hamilton’s fourth goal, to make the final score 4-1 to Accies.
Pars starting 11 & match photo gallery: 

Picture

Match photo gallery
All photos by Pars Review

Picture

Lewis Martin (centre)

Picture

Lewis Spence

Picture

Stuart Morrison (centre)

Picture

Scott Lochhead

Picture

Cammy Gill saves Ryan Tierney’s penalty but Tierney netted from the rebound

Picture

A half time chat between AJ, Sandy Clark and Stevie Crawford

Picture

Callum Fordyce’s (far right) header brings out a great save

Picture

Ryan Williamson takes a throw in to Johnny Galloway

Picture

Johnny Galloway (nearest) with Robbie Crawford behind

Picture

Robbie Crawford

Picture

Pars scorer Callum Smith

In what has been a very settled Dunfermline team, one player has been able to move from the bench to the starting 11 in recent games and has fully taken his chance – Rhys McCabe. As is often the case in football, an opportunity can arise due to the misfortune of someone else. McCabe’s chance came when first team regular John Herron was suspended for one game, at the same time as he picked up an injury. McCabe himself had lost his starting place due to illness in December, after scoring a penalty equaliser against Falkirk. In the past month he has grasped his chance and looked like a player who now has a future at the club. Those are words which seemed highly unlikely in the early weeks of this season, when a McCabe and Andy Geggan midfield pairing struggled badly. McCabe reached a low point with a very poor performance in the home defeat to Queen of the South on 27 August, when pass after pass went astray, and he also inexplicably played Queen’s striker Stephen Dobbie through on goal with a perfectly weighted throughball. 
McCabe’s form improved after Nat Wedderburn came into the side, but Herron soon established himself as Allan Johnston’s preferred partner for big Nat in the centre of midfield. For the first 2 months of 2017, McCabe sat on the bench and was rarely used. 

Picture

v Morton, 25 March 2017

His chance came following Herron’s injury and suspension, but in the weeks leading up to that, he had made 2 impressive substitute appearances: on 4 March, when replacing Herron in the 59th minute of the home game against Dumbarton, with the score at 2-1, he was a lively presence in midfield during the last half hour that saw 3 further Pars goals. In the next League game, he once again replaced Herron, this time at Morton, in the 73rd minute, and had one good attempt at goal and contributed to an excellent Dunfermline victory. In the next game, Herron – who had already picked up several knocks during games that caused him to be substituted – went off after 80 minutes at home to Hibs. McCabe replaced him as the Pars gained a creditable draw against the future title winners. The following week, McCabe played the whole 90 minutes in the 1-0 home win over Raith. A few days later, he was the Pars Review man of the match in the narrow defeat at Tannadice, during which he played a superb pass to the Moff, which should have resulted in a goal with the game at 0-0. 

Picture

With different hair style, v Arbroath, 19 July 2016

Saturday’s away victory at Dumbarton saw McCabe turn in another man of the match display. His willingness to shoot from distance, so often a missing element in Dunfermline’s play this season, was eventually rewarded when his 20 yard shot gave the Pars the lead with 10 minutes remaining. His ability on the ball is now in evidence, he can pick out a pass, isn’t afraid to shoot, and has a very good long throw. He looks a more confident player than at any other time since he joined the Pars 2 summers ago. 
It is always heartening to see a player recover from a prolonged spell of indifferent form, and show why the manager had faith in him, particularly after the summer of 2016, when it was a surprise to some that he was given another 1 year contract after being little more than a squad player in the division below in 2015/16. It is only now that we are seeing the best of Rhys McCabe, and at 24 years old he could go onto become a vital player for Dunfermline over the next few seasons. ​​​

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

A satisfying victory and a lesson learned: if you shoot, eventually you will get your reward. Dunfermline’s visit to the stadium beneath the Rock began without top scorer Nicky Clark, missing through injury. He was replaced by Gavin Reilly, while David Hopkirk returned to the first team matchday squad as a substitute.
Dunfermline kicked off against a high wind. With the stadium having just one stand, and only fences around the other 3 sides, there was no protection from the conditions and much of the play was spoiled by the ball being blown off course. Sean Murdoch’s goal kicks barely made it 40 yards upfield before being held in the wind. Too many balls were being passed in the air and it resulted in periods of disjointed play. This did not prevent chances being created, with Lewis Vaughan and Sam Stanton coming close for Dumbarton, and Rhys McCabe almost scoring with a long range effort. McCabe adopted a shoot on sight policy throughout the game, and was unlucky not to have scored with any of his first 4 attempts. Big Nat had a shot from 12 yards tipped round the post by Dumbarton keeeper Alan Martin, who also did well to turn Callum Morris’ header over the bar, both chances coming from Kallum Higginbotham corners. The Moff then had a good turn and shot from inside the box that just missed.
The best chance of the opening half fell to ex-Par Gregor Buchanan, when some slack defensive play gave the centre half a chance to score from a few yards out. Murdoch saved his weak shot, and also the follow up from Vaughan. 

Picture

Andy Geggan celebrates the victory at full time

The second half saw Dunfermline have the wind advantage for a short spell, until it died down. This was to the team’s advantage – despite not having any wind behind them, as Dumbarton had in the first half, the calmer conditions suited Dunfermline more, particularly players such as Kallum Higginbotham and Paul McMullan. It was McMullan who carved open the Sons’ defence after 54 minutes, but his shot hit the side netting.
Dumbarton passed up another great chance to score, and it was another ex-Par, Andy Stirling, who was wasteful in front of Murdoch’s goal. A third former Dunfermline player, Robert Thomson, also had an opportunity to open the scoring but saw his shot deflected for a corner.
Rhys McCabe was the focal point for the Pars in midfield, and he had several shots from distance, all just failing to find the net. McCabe’s time came with 10 minutes remaining when his 20 yarder flew past Martin into the corner.
Substitute David Hopkirk then added a second, finishing confidently from a McMullan pass. 
Big Nat then treated the Pars fans to a moment of brilliance on the touchline directly in front of the visiting support, pirouetting past 2 Dumbarton players. The fans and his team mates clearly loved it, with captain Andy Geggan laughing as he congratulated Nat on the move.
This was an important win, and saw the Pars move up to fifth place in the Championship, 8 points outside the 4 place play-off position with 3 games still remaining.

​Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10: ​

Picture

Photos by Pars Review.
​Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.

Picture Picture

​Scottish Championship – Saturday 15/04/17 – KO 3.00pm – The Cheaper Insurance Direct Stadium
Odds (McBookie): Dumbarton 15/8; Draw 5/2; Dunfermline 11/8

With Pars goals hard to come by (just 3 in the past 6 games, and only 1 of those from open play), tomorrow’s opponents Dumbarton could seem like the ideal opposition, with Dunfermline having scored 11 goals in the 3 previous League games against them this season. However, as they have done for the past 4 seasons, Dumbarton have proved to be a well-drilled team, looking likely to avoid relegation despite being one of just two part time clubs in the Championship. A win for either side tomorrow would ease any lingering relegation fears for the remaining games of the season. 

Picture

Lee Ashcroft: Dumbarton v Pars, 29 October 2016, the last time the teams met at Dumbarton

​Our opponents​ – 
Dumbarton

Last five outings:
8 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v St Mirren (A)
1 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Morton (H)
25 March – Championship – Lost 2-1 v Ayr United (A)
18 March – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Hibs (A)
11 March – Championship – Won 4-0 v Raith Rovers (H)

​Pre-game comments
With only 2 defeats in their past 10 Championship games, Dumbarton are proving to be a resiliant, organised and well-managed team, capable of taking points against clubs with greater resources, and overcoming their part time status in what is their fourth season in the Championship. As their recent results show, they have gathered points in games at difficult venues, including away at Easter Road and then at home to Morton. While the relegation battle will possibly go to the last day of the season, it would not be a surprise if Dumbarton finish in 7th or 8th position and avoid automatic relegation or a play-off, and begin season 2017/18 in the Championship.

Numbers game
Dumbarton have scored in all of their last 11 games.
Dumbarton have scored 27 of their Championship goals in the second half of games: 64% of their total of 42 goals. 
With the exception of the recent 4-0 home win against Raith Rovers, Dumbarton have not won a home game by a margin of more than 1 goal this season, their other 4 home victories being three 1-0 wins and a 2-1. 

In the dugout
Stephen Aitken
After a relatively successful period as manager of Stranraer, Stephen Aitken was appointed Dumbarton manager in May 2015. Aitken was a midfielder in his playing days, appearing over 100 times for Morton and then moving to Stranraer where he played 156 League games. He became the assistant manager at Stranraer in 2009 while still playing, and then was made manager in 2012. ​

Picture

Michael Paton challenges for the ball: Dumbarton v Pars, 29 October 2016

Pars & Dumbarton facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 8
Draws: 1
Dumbarton wins: 1

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

6 August 2016 – Pars 4, Dumbarton 3
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-4-dumbarton-3​

29 October 2016 – Dumbarton 2, Pars 2
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-dumbarton-2-pars-2​

4 March 2017: Pars 5, Dumbarton 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-5-dumbarton-1​

Connections
Three Dumbarton players have previously played for Dunfermline: Gregor Buchanan played 1 season for Dunfermline in 2014/15, making 36 appearances. Andy Stirling also was a Pars player for that solitary season, playing 18 times before going on loan to Stirling Albion for the remainder of his Pars contract. Robert Thomson made 9 appearances for the Pars in 2013. 
From the current Pars squad, only Andy Geggan has played for Dumbarton. He spent 5 years there, from 2006 to 2011, making 158 appearances. ​

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
11 April – Championship – v Dundee United (A)
8 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith (H)
1 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Hibs (H)
25 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Morton (A)
18 March – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Ayr United (H)
​
Pre-game comments
The lack of goals in the Pars team is a growing concern, with strikers Nicky Clark and Michael Moffat both going through lean spells: Clark, although the third top scorer in the Championship this season, has scored in just 1 of his past 13 games, while the Moff’s has scored in only 1 of his past 19 games. The other strikers in the first team squad are Gavin Reilly, who has 1 League goal this season, and David Hopkirk, who didn’t even make the bench on Tuesday against Dundee United.  
Preferred line-up:
Lack of options up front mean I would name the same team that started the last 2 games.
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Picture Picture

A game to forget. Tannadice was the scene of some of Dunfermline’s greatest victories over the years, but lately it has become a ground that almost guarantees a home win whenever the Pars are the opposition. This current Dundee United side went into the game as the division’s most off-form team, gathering just 5 points from the last 8 games. They are also undoubtedly the worst Dundee United side I have seen in my lifetime – even the team who played in the second tier in the mid 1990s would destroy this current mob.  
Allan Johnston named the same starting 11 who played against Raith Rovers on Saturday, with the now free of suspension John Herron still injured. There was an early warning for Dunfermline when United’s Blair Spittal sent in a cross that Thomas Mikkelsen stretched to connect with and narrowly failed. Neither team took control of the game, but there were some muted attempts at breaking the deadlock, with Callum Morris heading a corner wide for Dunfermline and then Pars skipper Andy Geggan clearing a cross that was intended for Mikkelsen.
The game then swung on 2 incidents in the space of 30 seconds in the 30th minute. A great ball from Rhys McCabe found the Moff 6 yards from goal but he fluffed his shot. As if that wasn’t bad enough, the ball was then played upfield and in a situation reminiscent of the chance described in the paragraph above, Simon Murray sent a cross from the right that went across the Pars box to Mikkelsen who turned it in. 
Dunfermline then started to launch high balls to the diminutive pairing of Clark and Moffat. The passing game, so successful at difficult away venues such as Easter Road and Cappielow, was less evident and there were too many long, aimless punts to players who lack height and are also not the most physical of players. 
After an early second half scare when Sean Murdoch made a good clearance with Spittal in pursuit, the Pars then created another chance for Moffat. Kallum Higginbotham crossed from the right but Moffat allowed the ball to go past him, instead of launching himself at it. I have praised Moffat’s link up play in recent games, but when placed in a goalscoring position, he seems to lack the ability or real desire to score. One shocking miss and then this later chance that he allowed to by-pass him are evidence of this. Meanwhile, his partner in attack, Nicky Clark, was having a poor game. Indeed, when Gavin Reilly was brought on as a substitute for Moffat, he offered more than either of the 2 established forwards, which said it all. 
United almost scored a second when Tony Andreu was given time and space to run with the ball and shoot, his effort hitting the post and rebounding away from goal. Dunfermline’s play was becoming more ragged, with no lack of effort but a real absence of composure and never forcing United keeper Cammy Bell to make a serious save. 
To the surprise of many, Allan Johnston made 3 relatively early substitutions, although less surprisingly, they were all like-for-like; right back Ryan Williamson replaced Andy Geggan, Reilly replaced Moffat, and Joe Cardle replaced Paul McMullan, which led to booing from the Pars support. Clark and Higginbotham stayed on despite having awful games. The 4-4-2 formation remained as it always does.
United then started to time waste, which only highlighted the lack of quality and ambition on show. Referee Willie Collum avoided booking anyone, including some blatant time wasting from the home side. The game struggled on, and Murdoch prevented United from adding to their lead with good stops from Spittal and Nick Van Der Velden. 
A poor performance and one which dampened the optimism of the previous few weeks. 

​Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:

Picture

Match photo gallery
All photos by Pars Review

Picture

The view from the supporters bus on the way round to Tanndice

Picture

The match programme

Picture

The teams come out before kick-off

Picture

Sean Murdoch, and the sparse home support in the distance

Picture

Paul McMullan, with United’s Simon Murray in pursuit

Picture

Big Nat

Picture

The Pars push bodies up for a second half corner

Picture

Substitutions: Reilly and Williamson come on

Picture Picture

​Scottish Championship – Tuesday 11/04/17 – KO 7.45pm – Tannadice
Odds (McBookie): Dundee United 20/23; Draw 13/5; Dunfermline 16/5
www.mcbookie.com/en/sports/football/coupons/100/6265610/817268100/0/0/PE/0/0/0/0/0

The financial necessity of a return to the top division has been made clear by Dundee United chairman Stephen Thompson, who accepted foreign investment at the end of March to sustain the club financially through to the end of this season. United’s title challenge has evaporated but they have an excellent record against the Pars, losing just 1 of the last 10 meetings of the teams. Dunfermline go into the game in second place in the Championship current form table, while United are last, based on form over the past 8 games. This will still be a difficult game for Dunfermline, who have played 7 away games against the top 4 clubs this season and won just once. 

Picture

Joe Cardle: Pars v Dundee United, 12 November 2016. Photo: Pars Review

​Our opponents​ – 
Dundee United

Last five outings:
8 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Falkirk (H)
​1 April – Championship – Lost 4-2 v Queen of the South (A)
28 March – Championship – Won 2-1 v Ayr United (H)
25 March – Challenge Cup – Won 2-1 v St Mirren (Neutral venue – Final)
18 March – Championship – Lost 2-1 v Raith Rovers (A)

​Pre-game comments
United’s run of 8 wins and 23 draws in a 10 game sequence between September and December must seem a long time ago to their supporters, who more recently have seen their team win just 2 of the last 13 League games, including 1 win in the last 8. From Championship challengers, they have fallen to fourth place in the division, and while they will qualify for the promotion play-offs, they may now have to face 2 extra games, in a 3rd v 4th play-off quarter final, making the prospects of promotion and a much-needed return to the Premiership all the more difficult.

Numbers game
​United last kept a clean sheet in the League 9 games ago. 
They have scored in 93% of their home games, failing to score in just 1 home game this season. 
United have the best home record in the division, and have 4 more points at home than leaders Hibs. 
​United are bottom of the current form table in the Championship, with just 5 points from their last 8 games. 

In the dugout
Ray McKinnon
Capped 4 times by Scotland, McKinnon was a midfielder who played for 11 different clubs including 2 spells at Dundee United. Five of his clubs came in a period in 2001/2001 when he played a total of 8 games either as a trialist or on a short term contract, before he signed a 2 year contract with Montrose. His managerial career began at Lochee United in 2004. He has also managed Brechin City and Raith Rovers, and took over at Tannadice last summer.

Picture

Paul McMullan: Pars v Dundee United, 10 September 2016. Photo: Pars Review

Pars & Dundee United facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 1
Draws: 2
Dundee United wins: 7

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

31 July 2016 – Dundee United 2, Pars 0 (League Cup)
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-dundee-united-2-pars-0​

10 September 2016 – Pars 1, Dundee United 3 (Championship)
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-dundee-united-3​

8 November 2016: Dundee United 1, Pars 0 (Championship)
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-dundee-united-1-pars-0

12 November 2016: Pars 0, Dundee United 1 (Challenge Cup)
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-0-dundee-united-1

28 January 2017: Pars 1, Dundee United 1 (Championship)
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-dundee-united-1​

Connections
None of the Dundee United first team squad have previously played for Dunfermline. 
Only one current Pars player has played for United – Callum Morris, who made 45 appearances for United between 2014-2016.

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
8 April – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith Rovers (H)
1 April – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Hibs (H)
25 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Morton (A)
18 March – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Ayr United (H)
11 March – Championship – Drew 0-0 v St Mirren (A)
​
Pre-game comments
Saturday’s win over Raith Rovers eased any relegation fears for Dunfermline, and while the Pars are still not safe from at least a relegation play-off place, it would take a huge collapse for Allan Johnston’s team and an unlikely positive sequence of results for the teams currently below Dunfermline, to bring that scenario about. The trip to Tannadice should not be feared despite our poor recent record there: United are not in good form, and if the players perform in the same manner as they did at Easter Road and Cappielow in the past month, 3 points could be taken back to Fife. 
Preferred line-up:
No change to Saturday’s team.
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image.
​A match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings will be uploaded on Wednesday morning.

Picture

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture