|
For the first time in his 17 months as Dunfermline Athletic manager, Allan Johnston is coming under sustained criticism over his team’s performances, and his own recruitment policy and tactics. After winning League 1 last season in a canter, the Championship was always likely to present a far greater test of the squad’s capabilities. Yet after a return of only 7 points from the first quarter of League games, Johnston stated last week that “there is not much of a gap” between the divisions, talking instead about the recurring mistakes that have led to goals being conceded, and not the clear difference in quality of player the team are up against this season. A series of errors and mistakes have lead directly to goals being conceded, and while the manager is not on the pitch and is relying on his players to prevent needless goals being conceded, part of any manager’s role in any workplace is to identify reasons for ongoing errors and to rectify the problem. It is the very fact that mistakes are being made almost on a weekly basis that actually undermines the manager’s own weekly post-match repetitive claims that another loss of points was simply due to errors and that the players “are better than that”. While Johnston has stated that mistakes must be cut out, there is no evidence of the situation improving. Hibs’ second and third goals on Saturday were basic errors, in the same way that the same opposition’s two goals in the first quarter meeting were also the result of Dunfermline errors. The team’s formation has also played into the opposition’s hands this season. Johnston rarely deviates from 4-4-2, yet in games including the defeat to Hibs, who had 3 central midfielders to Dunfermline’s 2, the Pars midfield were over ran and outplayed, which contributed hugely to Hibs’ complete second half domination, controlling possession. The midfield is not helped by the faith that manager has in a woefully out of form Andy Geggan, and the reliance on Rhys McCabe, a situation the manager created by giving the player a new contract in the summer and releasing Josh Falkingham, who kept McCabe out of the team last season. Photos by Pars Review. |
Blog Archive
|

