Pars Review’s build up to our next match starts here, focusing specifically on options for the Pars starting 11, formations and tactics, with the team’s current form and our next opposition in mind. Later today, the regular Match Preview will be posted.
FORMATION With the weekend game at Livingston postponed, manager Allan Johnston will have the same the same personnel available to him for tomorrow’s game against Falkirk. Captain Callum Morris, who was due to serve a 1 match suspension in the Livi game, will now be unavailable tomorrow. Morris’ replacement will be either Jean Yves M’Voto or Lewis Martin, with M’Voto more likely to be selected. There are no known new signings early in the January transfer window, unless there is a pleasant surprise before the game (and let that be a central midfielder, please). 4-4-2 remains the manager’s favoured formation, although he has used 4-1-4-1 recently. 4-3-3 or even 4-3-1-2 could also be considered, playing Dean Shiels behind the strikers, his best position but one that he has never played in since joining the club. That is highly unlikely to happen, and so with a 4-4-2 line-up, here is my team:
TEAM SELECTION – SUITABILITY – CURRENT FORM The squad is so light on numbers that we will, once again, not have a full subs bench, despite having only 2 players unavailable – the suspended Morris and the injured Aaron Splaine. There is still scope for changing the starting 11 and the formation depending on the opposition and other factors. We must approach the game positively and the team must be set up to win the game, and not merely contain the opposition, so I would have no thoughts about using a defensive midfielder. Michael Paton could start in central midfield but I have selected him on the right wing. As much as I would have liked to see Fraser Aird being given a run in the team in that position, it would be a surprise if he was suddenly started in a derby game having been overlooked for weeks. The other contender for the right wing slot, Kallum Higginbotham, cannot be trusted in games against Falkirk, having been booked and sent off in the past 2 meetings, and on current form he does not merit a start in any case. Later this afternoon: Pars v Falkirk match preview
Pars Review’s build up to our next match starts here, focusing specifically on options for the Pars starting 11, formations and tactics, with the team’s current form and the weekend’s opposition in mind. Tomorrow (Friday) the regular Match Preview will be posted.
FORMATION Last week’s game at home to Brechin began with an unexpected return to the 4-1-4-1 formation of the previous home game against Queen of the South (that was ditched before half time). As last week’s game went on, the formation morphed between 4-3-3 and 4-4-2, mainly due to Joe Cardle being given a free role to float around the front line, and Nicky Clark and Declan McManus both spending time on the right of the attack, swapping positions with each other in the first half. That was an encouraging development – a more fluid set-up than the previously rigid 4-4-2. It also makes it difficult to predict how we will line up against Livingston. Allan Johnston may prefer the loan striker formation in such an away game (as he did away to Dundee United earlier this month); then again, he preferred 4-4-2 away to St Mirren 2 weeks ago. For this weekend, I would line up with a 4-4-2 formation, as in the image below. As mentioned above, being able to change the formation during the game makes us far less predictable and we have the players to do so; if we switched to 4-3-3 during the game, Cardle could move to the left of a front 3, with Shiels or Paton then switching to the left or right of Wedderburn, who would be the central midfielder in a midfield 3.
TEAM SELECTION – SUITABILITY – CURRENT FORM Even though the squad is light on numbers (Callum Morris’ suspension for the Livi game means we will not be able to fill the subs bench) there are still options for the manager in his starting 11. Jean Yves M’Voto would seem to be the most likely replacement for centre half Morris, although Lewis Martin is also available. In midfield, Wedderburn and Shiels are selected partly because there are so few alternatives; Michael Paton can, of course, play in central midfield but I feel he would be better utilised wide right. I cannot put forward an argument for starting Kallum Higginbotham on the right wing given his current form, which includes his sub appearance against Brechin. Fraser Aird is a player I would like to see be given a start, especially in the game following the Dundee United away game, when he did well after coming on as a sub; since then, he has barely featured and so will once again be a substitute. Aird could also replace Cardle on the left. Up front, the Clark/McManus partnership has performed well recently and will start, with Andy Ryan a good option from the bench. January will hopefully see 2 central midfielders join the club, together with a right back to challenge Ryan Williamson. Tomorrow: Livingston v Pars match preview
Pars Review’s build up to our next match starts here, focusing specifically on options for the Pars starting 11, formations and tactics, with the team’s current form and the weekend’s opposition in mind. Tomorrow (Friday) the regular Match Preview will be posted.
FORMATION Last week’s article (here) looked at possible formations for the St Mirren game – an away match against a title challenger that could have led to different formations being used. As it turned out, Allan Johnston clung to his comfort blanket of 4-4-2. This weekend’s game is against a side at the bottom of the league, who haven’t won a League game all season. With that in mind, plus Dunfermline desperately needing a victory, an attacking line-up will be selected. I have disregarded any thoughts of 4-1-4-1 or 3-5-2 (although the manager did start the last home game with 4-1-4-1) and have gone with 4-4-2. In terms of team selection, the starting 11 in Paisley would be regarded by many as the strongest available team, certainly in terms of early season results when those 11 players were selected almost every week. The late introduction of subs Michael Paton and Fraser Aird against St Mirren will have given the manager options for this weekend’s game, without having to change his favoured formation.
Formation: 4-4-2
TEAM SELECTION – SUITABILITY – CURRENT FORM With attack as the only required tactic, and given the form of Joe Cardle and Kallum Higginbotham, I have selected Aird and Paton to start against Brechin. Nat Wedderburn only retains his place because there are no other options (having selected Paton for the right wing) and it highlights the ridiculous state of our midfield that to drop Nat, we have to play someone else out of their natural position. I cannot retain Higgy just to shoehorn Paton into central midfield, not with Higgy’s current form, which is marginally poorer than Nat’s. That’s how desperate things are, and that’s why we MUST sign actual midfielders in January, who are also fit and agile. The subs bench does not currently offer any other better options in defence or attack, although Andy Ryan might be considered in a week or two. Clark and McManus should start on Saturday but I would definitely give Ryan a decent amount of game time in the second half, assuming he is fit enough. Is this tough on Joe Cardle? Possibly but while no one can doubt Joe’s effort, he has not recaptured his pre-injury form and his recent displays have all been a bit too manic. We need a winger who stays mostly on the wing. If anything, Joe is TOO keen at the moment. You wouldn’t be surprised to find him in the concourse in the Norrie stand during a break in play, selling half time draw tickets, such is his heightened level of enthusiasm at the moment. Tomorrow: Pars v Brechin City match preview
A new weekly feature that starts the build up to our next match, focusing specifically on options for the Pars starting 11, formations and tactics, with the team’s current form and the weekend’s opposition in mind. Tomorrow (Friday) the regular Match Preview will be posted.
ST MIRREN AWAY 16/12/17
SELECTIONS, FORMATION -SUITABLITY & CURRENT FORM With a first team squad of just 17 available players (18 if Andy Ryan is fit for Saturday) it is inevitable that most of the same players have been selected for the various formations I have outlined below. There are many players who, although in poor form, remain the best option in their position. I have only dropped certain players if I feel there are better options from the bench, and not change for the sake of change. Some players, such as Lewis Martin, are best suited to specific positions in particular formations. There are many possible formations – I have not included 4-3-3 or 4-3-1-2, for example – but for the purpose of Saturday’s game, I have concentrated on the following 3 formations and player selections. Feedback is much appreciated, either here in the comments section, or via the Pars Review Facebook and Twitter pages. Due to current form, plus the availability of other players to more than adequately take their places, I have not selected Nat Wedderburn and Kallum Higginbotham. They could still factor in Allan Johnston’s thinking but I have selected other players, some of whom appear in all 3 formations and some in only 1. I have also not selected Callum Smith, as I feel regardless of formation, the front pairing of Nicky Clark and Declan McManus is the best current option.
Formation 1: 4-4-2 For months, this was the manager’s preferred formation regardless of opposition. It was only at Tannadice 2 weeks ago that he shifted to a more pragmatic 4-1-4-1 line-up which was entirely appropriate for that game. St Mirren away on Saturday is a similar proposition, and so I would not expect 4-4-2 to be utilised. Johnston started last week’s home game against Queen of the South with 4-1-4-1 (an error) but reverted back to 4-4-2 after 35 minutes. If 4-4-2 was to be used on Saturday, I would drop Nat Wedderburn and Lewis Martin from last week’s team, and bring in Dean Shiels to play alongside Michael Paton in central midfield. There would be a temptation to select either Wedderburn or Martin for their more defensive qualities, but I feel that Nat’s form has dipped so much that he is more of a hindrance at the moment; and I would not select Lewis Martin as a midfielder in a 4-4-2. I would also play Fraser Aird in right midfield, where he impressed as a substitute at Tannadice.
Formation 2: 4-1-3-2 Why this and not 4-1-4-1? I would have no problem with the Tannadice formation but there is next to no chance of Johnston not playing Nicky Clark – and Clark deserves to keep his place after a goal and an assist last week on his return from a 1 game injury absence. However, Clark is not a suitable lone forward, and Declan McManus (the lone striker against Dundee United) is also wasted in right midfield in a 4-1-4-1, where he started against Queen of the South last week. I would always have McManus in the team, but I would not shoehorn him in as Johnston did at the start of last week’s game. Neither could I see Clark dropping back to right midfield. So with a slight tweak, 4-1-4-1 becomes 4-1-3-2, with Lewis Martin as a defensive midfielder, something he is far better equipped for than as a central midfielder. Once again, I have brought Fraser Aird back into the team, with Joe Cardle also playing but as part of a 3 man central midfield. I feel this formation and line-up represents our best chance to take on St Mirren, as it gives the extra insurance of a defensive midfielder, Martin, who is mobile and would not be by-passed by his opponents in the way that Wedderburn has been, at the cost of 2 opposition goals, in the past 2 games.
Formation 3: 3-5-2 I have kept faith with a faltering back 4 in the first 2 formations, but this third option sees Jean Yves M’Voto brought in as a third centre half, with fullbacks Williamson and Talbot deployed as wingbacks – dropping back to a 5-3-2 when required. The midfield central trio remain the same as in the other options, with Shiels a possible replacement for Cardle if deemed necessary. Paton would be in my team in all 3 formations, as would Aird, and the same front 2. As noted earlier, playing 1 up front would only be my choice if the lone striker was McManus. I prefer to play with 2 up front in any case as I feel we lack the guile and support from midfield to play with just 1 forward.
So it’s option 2 (4-1-3-2) that I would prefer, with Martin in defensive midfield giving the team a stronger and more athletic spine. Martin should not be selected in a flat midfield 4 as he is simply not a good enough footballer. What all the line ups show, however, is that we require an injection of fresh faces and fresh legs come January. There is a distinct lack of pace and energy in midfield and this has to be addressed. The defence also need to up their game and not feel as though they are automatic choices regardless of form.
Tomorrow: St Mirren v Pars match preview
|
|