A new weekly feature that starts the build up to our next match, focusing specifically on options for the Pars starting 11, formations and tactics, with the team’s current form and the weekend’s opposition in mind. Tomorrow (Friday) the regular Match Preview will be posted.
ST MIRREN AWAY 16/12/17
SELECTIONS, FORMATION -SUITABLITY & CURRENT FORM With a first team squad of just 17 available players (18 if Andy Ryan is fit for Saturday) it is inevitable that most of the same players have been selected for the various formations I have outlined below. There are many players who, although in poor form, remain the best option in their position. I have only dropped certain players if I feel there are better options from the bench, and not change for the sake of change. Some players, such as Lewis Martin, are best suited to specific positions in particular formations. There are many possible formations – I have not included 4-3-3 or 4-3-1-2, for example – but for the purpose of Saturday’s game, I have concentrated on the following 3 formations and player selections. Feedback is much appreciated, either here in the comments section, or via the Pars Review Facebook and Twitter pages. Due to current form, plus the availability of other players to more than adequately take their places, I have not selected Nat Wedderburn and Kallum Higginbotham. They could still factor in Allan Johnston’s thinking but I have selected other players, some of whom appear in all 3 formations and some in only 1. I have also not selected Callum Smith, as I feel regardless of formation, the front pairing of Nicky Clark and Declan McManus is the best current option.
Formation 1: 4-4-2 For months, this was the manager’s preferred formation regardless of opposition. It was only at Tannadice 2 weeks ago that he shifted to a more pragmatic 4-1-4-1 line-up which was entirely appropriate for that game. St Mirren away on Saturday is a similar proposition, and so I would not expect 4-4-2 to be utilised. Johnston started last week’s home game against Queen of the South with 4-1-4-1 (an error) but reverted back to 4-4-2 after 35 minutes. If 4-4-2 was to be used on Saturday, I would drop Nat Wedderburn and Lewis Martin from last week’s team, and bring in Dean Shiels to play alongside Michael Paton in central midfield. There would be a temptation to select either Wedderburn or Martin for their more defensive qualities, but I feel that Nat’s form has dipped so much that he is more of a hindrance at the moment; and I would not select Lewis Martin as a midfielder in a 4-4-2. I would also play Fraser Aird in right midfield, where he impressed as a substitute at Tannadice.
Formation 2: 4-1-3-2 Why this and not 4-1-4-1? I would have no problem with the Tannadice formation but there is next to no chance of Johnston not playing Nicky Clark – and Clark deserves to keep his place after a goal and an assist last week on his return from a 1 game injury absence. However, Clark is not a suitable lone forward, and Declan McManus (the lone striker against Dundee United) is also wasted in right midfield in a 4-1-4-1, where he started against Queen of the South last week. I would always have McManus in the team, but I would not shoehorn him in as Johnston did at the start of last week’s game. Neither could I see Clark dropping back to right midfield. So with a slight tweak, 4-1-4-1 becomes 4-1-3-2, with Lewis Martin as a defensive midfielder, something he is far better equipped for than as a central midfielder. Once again, I have brought Fraser Aird back into the team, with Joe Cardle also playing but as part of a 3 man central midfield. I feel this formation and line-up represents our best chance to take on St Mirren, as it gives the extra insurance of a defensive midfielder, Martin, who is mobile and would not be by-passed by his opponents in the way that Wedderburn has been, at the cost of 2 opposition goals, in the past 2 games.
Formation 3: 3-5-2 I have kept faith with a faltering back 4 in the first 2 formations, but this third option sees Jean Yves M’Voto brought in as a third centre half, with fullbacks Williamson and Talbot deployed as wingbacks – dropping back to a 5-3-2 when required. The midfield central trio remain the same as in the other options, with Shiels a possible replacement for Cardle if deemed necessary. Paton would be in my team in all 3 formations, as would Aird, and the same front 2. As noted earlier, playing 1 up front would only be my choice if the lone striker was McManus. I prefer to play with 2 up front in any case as I feel we lack the guile and support from midfield to play with just 1 forward.
So it’s option 2 (4-1-3-2) that I would prefer, with Martin in defensive midfield giving the team a stronger and more athletic spine. Martin should not be selected in a flat midfield 4 as he is simply not a good enough footballer. What all the line ups show, however, is that we require an injection of fresh faces and fresh legs come January. There is a distinct lack of pace and energy in midfield and this has to be addressed. The defence also need to up their game and not feel as though they are automatic choices regardless of form.
Tomorrow: St Mirren v Pars match preview
|
|