|
2 years ago today: Dunfermline defeat Stenhousemuir 3-0 at Ochilview. Andy Geggan scored twice. One of his goals was captured by Pars Review and can be seen by clicking the link below, which takes you to the video on our Twitter page. Faissal El Bakhtaoui got the other Pars goal. Pars team that day: Murdoch, Reid, Talbot, McKay, Richards-Everton, Geggan, Paton, Falkingham, Moffat, El Bakhtaoui, Cardle. A screenshot of Andy Geggan celebrating the goal in the above video. It has been a pleasure to have had long-time Pars fan, Sammer, as guest writer on Throwback for the past 6 weeks, during which he gave his own first-hand account of games he attended from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in his final article, he looks back on a Pars v Dundee United game from December 1973. “TWILIGHT ZONE” Dateline: 22nd December, 1973 Match: Dunfermline 2, Dundee United 3 Charts: Merry Xmas Everyone
This was one of these Dark Days of the 1970s The Tories like to frighten voters with in their Party Political Broadcasts. The match, played on a murky, winter afternoon kicked off at 2pm since use of floodlights was being restricted during the run-up to the Three Day Week. The miners were about to go on official strike. People were stocking up on candles in case of power cuts. With a sharp wind howling towards the Halbeath End, on a pitch made sodden with torrential rain, this had all the ingredients for a miserable day out. Forget the propaganda- this was a Xmas cracker. Before kick-off, Slade’s Xmas anthem blared out from the tannoy, its stomping, defiant beat a reminder of our pagan duty to eat, get drunk and be merry whatever else, and both supporters and teams joined in the spirit. Dundee United were a well-liked team since their emergence in the early 1960s, played decent football and were capable of beating anyone on their day. Under Jim McLean, a manager whose face was as dreich as the weather, the team had developed a more serious approach but the Tannadice supporters retained a gift for self-mockery: We’re up to our knees in tangerine blood Surrender or we’ll cry Pars line-up: Dundee United lined up with: McAlpine, Rolland, Kopel, Copland, D.Smith, W.Smith, Payne, Knox, Gray, Fleming, Traynor. Both sides settled early to play attractive football. Dunfermline had the gale force wind first half and were a side who liked to hit the strikers early. If left back Jim Wallace was a trifle ponderous in defence, he could move play 40 yards downfield with one mighty strike of his left boot; his main problem today was trying not to overshoot strikers Mackie and Shaw. With Campbell and Scott energetic in midfield Pars pressed their wind advantage and Shaw used his height to open the scoring from an in-swinging Sinclair corner. Captain Kinninmonth was an experienced midfield general who had netted a belting volley against Rangers, Leishman looked willing, while new keeper Karlsen seemed to fill the goal. When Mackie received a pass on the left side of the box he used the wind beautifully to bend a shot high and wide of McAlpine into the far corner. Mackie was a penalty box predator and had forged a good partnership with the bounding, loping Shaw who enjoyed taking the ball past defenders. The Pars team, season 1973-74 That corner for Shaw’s opener had come from a backward pass from Graeme Payne and was possibly the only negative move Dundee United had made all of the first half, their quick, short passing game highly effective against the strong wind. Payne at the time was considered a better prospect than Gordon Strachan as a right sided midfield winger, catching the eye with his intelligent use of the ball. The other teenager, striker Andy Gary, pulled back a goal on the half time whistle when he got his head to a weak cross from the left and somehow squeezed the ball home at the near post. 2-1 to the Pars. Alex Kinninmonth, Kenny Thomson, Jim Wallace, Graham Shaw The second half was more a procession than a contest. Keeping the ball on the ground, United out-passed the Pars to such an extent that the match was played almost entirely in Dunfermline’s half. There were a host of experienced professionals in this Dundee United side and they knew how to play to the conditions. Doug and Walter Smith, Jackie Copland and Archie Knox, realising that Wallace’s long flighted balls would be redundant against such a strong wind, compressed the play with the result that the few Pars attacks which materialised were ruled offside. Fleming and Traynor, two ex-Hearts signings, were a revelation as they swapped passes at will down the left flank, completely bamboozling Thomson and Leishman who looked like men in search of a white flag. United’s fluorescent tangerine strip was very progressive for the time and might have helped in the gathering gloom, although in all seriousness this was a well-drilled team who looked like they could have found each other wearing sunglasses in the dark. Fleming and Traynor exchanged passes at least twice before Traynor slipped inside and steered a hard, low centre into the box. Fleming had timed his run to perfection and rapped home a firm sidefoot, with his poncy white boots, past the exposed Karlsen. A beautifully engineered goal and the winner was almost as impressive. Traynor and Fleming combined yet again with the winger turning Leishman inside out before cutting a low, left-foot cross into the danger zone. Gray announced himself as a genuine No 9 with a brave, sliding finish to hold off McCallum and slide the ball below Karlsen’s smothering dive. The Tangerine Terror tagline was starting to be justified, for this team had just drawn 3-3 at Parkhead and Gray would score four against Dumbarton the following week. In April 1974 Dundee United would contest their first ever Scottish Cup Final, losing to Celtic. For Dunfermline, the end of the season had a silver lining. Manager Miller’s attacking policy owed more to the influence of Cunningham rather than Stein, producing results like a 5-1 win at Dens Park followed by a 5-1 loss to Dundee at home later in the season. Our position was looking grim come the run-in, although there remained a positive vibe amongst the supporters which was vindicated by events. Three away games remained but against all odds the Pars went to Easter Road and salvaged a draw, with Leishman defending in the spirit of Roy Barry and Geir Karlsen making an astonishing save in the final minute by touching an Alan Gordon header on to the post. Next up were the bruisers of Dumbarton at Boghead, a team managed by Alex Wright containing John Cushley, John Bourke, Tom McAdam and Colin McAdam. A Bring your own Band Aid sort of clash which was lost 0-1 and seemed to seal our fate. The final fixture at Tannadice was a bad omen given the final day relegation in April 1972, but George Miller had a vision. Literally. He fell asleep in front of his coal fire and dreamt that Graham Shaw would score the goal which kept the Pars in the First Division. And that is exactly what happened! A 1-0 victory saw DAFC retain their spot in the 18 team top league on goal difference. Whether George Miller ever had a vision again is unknown, but the Scottish League certainly did and planned reconstruction of the divisions for season 1975-76. This was bad news for Dunfermline who in season 1974/75 survived by one point in the old Division 1, but missed out on the new top 10 team league. It was to take another 15 years before the Pars returned to the top division, under stalwart defender turned manager Jim Leishman. Once again, my thanks to Sammer for the articles he has written for Throwback on Pars Review, and to Auld Boab for his articles in the weeks before Sammer. If you would like to contribute to Throwback, please contact me here, or via the Pars Review Facebook or Twitter pages (links below). Pars Review Facebook Pars Review Twitter
I am delighted to have long-time Pars fan, Sammer, as guest writer on Throwback for 6 weeks, during which he will give his own first-hand account of games he attended from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in part 5, he looks back on a Pars v Hibs game from March 1972. “SHINGUARD SOCCER” Dateline: 11th March, 1972 Match: Dunfermline 2, Hibernian 1 Attendance: 7,277 Charts: American Pie The news broke around lunchtime as we hung around a smoky, corner shop across from the school. The owner sold us cigarettes as 3d singles, but had sparked a near riot the week before when, on the D-Day of decimalisation, he had rounded up the price to 2 new pence for a fag. Old Jock needed a long handled brush to drive the mob back from the counter that February day, a day you might say planted the roots of Brexit Britain. There was also a currency problem at East End Park: goals. We just couldn’t find any and were sitting bottom of the league. Our last effort, in a surprise 1-0 win over Aberdeen, had come after a defensive mix up allowed Jim Gillespie to net from one yard out. That was just about our range these days. The Pars manager’s son, Brian, was standing very quiet in the corner. Alex Wright’s been sacked! It’s on the radio. Wright’s been sacked! Some were excited, some were pleased, some had no interest. We offered what comfort we could muster then picked up some inside info from Brian that had till then been secret. About Alex Wright turning down the Dundee job which went to ex-Rangers boss Davie White. How the directors had made his father an offer they knew he could only refuse – a salary cut. How John Cushley had gone out of his way to walk across to the car park and shake Wright’s hand. How Brian had laughed at his father’s team selection for the next match – Barrie Mitchell was down to play at right back – but the directors did not see the joke. The Pars now had nine games to save themselves from relegation starting with Hibernian on the Saturday, under newly installed manager George Miller. Pars line-up: Hibs lined up with: Herriott, Brownlie, Schaedler, Stanton, Black, Blackley, Davidson, O’Rourke, Baker, Gordon, Duncan. On paper it was a no contest. Eddie Turnbull had most of the ‘Tornadoes’ in place and his Hibs side were about to knock Rangers out of the Scottish Cup en route to the final. When Dunfermline had gone into freefall at the start of 1970-71, new manager Alex Wright had barely managed to slow the descent, the Pars escaping relegation on goal average at the end of that season. The signing of Joe McBride had proved crucial but, now that he had retired due to injury, every game seemed a war of attrition from which a meagre point might occasionally be won. There was talk of putting shin guards on the goalposts. Good professionals like Paton, Gardner, Robertson and Lunn had not been replaced, placing too heavy a burden on the youngsters coming through. So it was surprising that Manager Miller handed a debut to young Ken Mackie in a desperate effort to pep up the attack, but it was a gamble which was to pay off. Ken Mackie, John Cushley and George O’Neill The pitch was sticky on top which suited the Pars’ clog and clatter style, especially a midfield digger like George O’Neill. This ex-Partick stalwart had featured in a Sunday Post article with a photo of his wife dropping a medicine ball on to his stomach, evidence of his strength and stamina. Or maybe’s his wife’s. The problem was, the limited range of O’Neill’s passing suggested he practised passing with a medicine ball as well. Wearing their all white strip, an economy measure which had not endeared Wright to supporters, the Pars opened in lively fashion as is often the case under new management and took the lead. Mackie had already troubled Hibs defence and when the ball landed at his feet from a corner about 12 yards out he drove a rising shot high past Herriott at the Halbeath End to make it 1-0. Brimming with confidence, he then threw Black off balance on the left side of the box and narrowly failed to curl a shot into the far corner. For a support resigned to the flat beer of relegation battles this was champagne soccer, but could it last? After all, in Brownlie and Stanton, Hibs had two players with more football ability than the entire Pars team put together. And they also had Joe Baker. Joe Baker through the years: playing for England v Scotland in 1960; at Nottingham Forest, 1968; and pictured in his second spell at Hibs, 1972 Even now, at the age of 32, Baker could still generate a crackle of anticipation when he moved towards the ball for although the blistering pace of his youth was more muted, he still retained an edge and awareness to make defenders nervous. Baker’s return meant Hibs’ appeasement policy had now come full circle, since the veteran striker was easing the pain of Peter Cormack’ transfer down south. His journey from Hibernian to Torino, Arsenal, Notts Forest and back again had been an unlucky one in that Joe Baker was fated to play for teams either going into decline, or a few years short of a golden age. He turned up in the wrong place this day as well. When a ball was knocked down the right touchline Baker, an exceptional player with his back to goal, set himself to control the ball on his thigh. Unfortunately for him the ball arrived at the same time as John Cushley, a muscular defender in the same vein as Jim Holton, then breaking into the Scottish international team. Cushley had remained a part-time player, even when playing alongside the likes of Billy McNeill and Bobby Moore, so had never reached the heights he might have done. But he was determined to reach thisparticular ball and went right through the back of Baker to do so, sending ball and striker spinning on to the cinder track. Cush all together, Cush all together, Cush all together now- Cushley! Barrie Mitchell, with a photo of himself and Pele taken when Barrie played in the US; Jim Scott; Jim Gillespie scores against Aberdeen in 1972 It took two minutes of spray and massage to his lower back before Baker got back gingerly to his feet. Worse was to follow. Within minutes O’Rourke lobbed a pass over the Dunfermline rearguard, one that Baker had anticipated before it was played, and it was now a race between Baker and keeper John Arrol as the ball bounced towards the penalty spot. Arrol got a fist to the ball first, then carried through to the face of the fearless Baker who was laid out for a second time. There was no malice in the challenge, indeed it could have gone either way, but to the Pars support these two moments signified the determination needed in the battle against relegation. Ultimately the Pars squeezed out a 2-1 victory, Pud Paterson sweeping home an opportunistic effort inside the 6-yard box. Miller’s team had played with a positive mindset, taking the field with the belief that they could actually win the game, a rarity at that time. Negativity had ruled for too long. Miller was a breath of fresh air and there was a feeling, not just that relegation might be avoided, but that a new team with Mackie leading the line could be emerging. That did not happen, but not for want of trying. Results picked up and there was a momentous 4-3 win at Ibrox which meant a draw in the last home game would be enough. Too much ground had been lost however. The final match, a 0-1 defeat by Dundee United, is remembered best for a lack lustre display by Barrie Mitchell who had already secured a transfer to Aberdeen. Little good did it do him. He flopped there and ended up at Tranmere, first as a player then later as a publican with a spell in America in between. Mitchell had shown potential as a youngster but never became as good a player as he thought he was, lacking the character required of a top professional. Maybe Alex Wright had been correct and he was just a hard-tackling hard-running right back. Mitchell was inadequate, as were the Pars for top division football. We deserved to go down. The football had been ghastly for over a year. The sixth and final part of Sammer Looks Back will be posted next Wednesday.
I am delighted to have long-time Pars fan, Sammer, as guest writer on Throwback for 6 weeks, during which he will give his own first-hand account of games he attended from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in part 4, he looks back on a Pars v Celtic game from September 1969. “LAST HURRAH” Dateline: 6th September, 1969 Match: Dunfermline 2, Celtic 1 Attendance: 23,336 Charts: Bad Moon Rising You sometimes see them push their glasses up on the bridge of their nose, those social historians from Oxbridge who were born yesterday, and pronounce that the Swinging Sixties actually started in 1963, with the scandalous Profumo Affair and only really ended with the Oil Price Rise of 1973. We know better. They started when Jock Stein arrived in March 1960 and won his first game, against Celtic, 3-2. They ended in January 1970, almost exactly a decade later, when the Pars won 3-2 against Anderlecht but left the main stage. This was a mild, autumn afternoon and East End Park was buzzing. Nowadays I hear some fans say they want the Old Firm to get out of Scottish football and leave us in peace. I have no desire to be left in peace. I want more days like this, when the ground was packed, when boisterous supporters mixed on unsegregated terracing and Pars fans, with good reason, anticipated victory over the Old Firm. Pars line-up: Celtic lined up with: Fallon, Craig, Gemmill, Murdoch, McNeill, Clark, Johnstone, Hood, Wallace, Chalmers, Lennox. Nine Lisbon Lions on show, with both sides a bit light in midfield, Hughie Robertson and Bertie Auld being absent, Tommy Callaghan angling for a transfer. The first half, Pars attacking the Town End, was a masterclass in bustling, bullying forward play by Barrie Mitchell from the moment he shouldered Gemmell aside to cross a beauty, low across the six-yard box. No takers that time, but after brushing inside Gemmell and clipping a shot off the top of the bar the inevitable was only delayed, when Mitchell switched to the left flank, bundled past Craig, then set up Gardner in front of goal. 1-0 the Pars after 10 minutes. DAFC team photo from 1969 Suddenly a punch up between Wallace and Renton, near the touchline, with quite a few blows landing and the referee pointing both towards the pavilion. Now it was 10 v 10, tension in the North Enclosure, jostling and goading amongst the pockets of rival fans, Bovril splashed, nervy Special Constables moving in to earn their stripes. Gardner dropped deeper to support Paton and Edwards in midfield, then emerged in the 20th minute to double the Pars’ lead. A high, wedged clearance from Barry caught Clark back- pedalling in the Celtic penalty area, where he made a pig’s ear of the header, miscuing the ball across the box where Gardner, Craig and Fallon all converged before the ball trundled in off a post. 2-0. Celtic struggled to respond, Edwards controlling play alongside Paton, both relishing the extra space available. Another flashpoint: Chalmers, obstructing keeper Duff from taking his four steps, had the ball rammed in his face and collapsed theatrically near the bye line. Play On said the referee as Duff kicked clear. Just as the forward was getting back to his knees, a Celtic attack was intercepted by Willie Callaghan who, with the whole of the touchline to aim for, deliberately aimed a lusty clearance straight off the face of Chalmers and out for a bye-kick. Right aff the puss. Well done Willie, as Chalmers was floored for a second time. Before half time George McLean brought the whole crowd to its feet. ‘Dandy’ Mclean was a playboy footballer who might have been happier hanging around the Barrowland Ballroom eyeing up the burdz. He was a tall, confident dude with fancy footwork and a quick mover too, so might have scored a few times, although to be fair his goal tally over the years with St. Mirren, Rangers and Dundee was pretty impressive too. His goals came from sporadic flashes of inspiration, for Dandy was no team player, in fact he had perfected a technique for avoiding tackles. Loitering up front, when the ball arrived he would move towards it, sell a dummy, then try to nutmeg the defender on the turn.
3 players from the team that defeated Celtic: George McLean, John McGarty and Willie Renton But McLean could loiter with intent. He’d just missed out making it 3-0 from a disguised Edwards reverse pass, when a bouncing ball came his way inside the centre circle. In an instant he flicked it not only over his own head, but crucially that of Billy McNeill, turning to knee the ball forward into his path. He now had a clear run on goal and, in truth, nothing compares with the elemental thrill of the chase, a chase Mclean looked like he might win. As the pack closed on him at the edge of the penalty box and the crowd noise verged on delirium, McLean, perverse as ever, opted for a chip on the run, probably the hardest skill in the game. Yet he was only a fraction out, the ball dropping on to the roof of the net with Fallon helpless. What a moment that was, only taking a few seconds to unfold, but living so long in the memory. The second half was all Celtic, a team who had recovered from 4-2 down at East End a couple of seasons before, so they would have fancied their chances. Gemmell thrashed home a blur of a shot from 25 yards, possibly the most powerful shot ever seen at East End Park, and the supporters in green nearly lifted the roof off the enclosure, sensing another famous comeback. George McLean in action for Dunfermline at Cowdenbeath It never materialized. Barry was a colossus, choking the life out every attack, rising, arm across the chest of his opponent, bulleting headers away from danger. Even in his finer moments an air of menace and illegality always hovered around Barry. Jim Fraser and previously Jim McLean defended in the manner of uniformed policemen dealing with a fracas at closing time; Barry’s style was more that of a bouncer slinging a drunk down the steps of a dance hall. This explains part of his enduring popularity amongst Pars fans, for although we feared that these Old Firm wide boys with their cheap, weegie tricks, dodges and fly moves might put one over on us provincials, in Roy Barry we knew we had a man who could match them and more. After a trademark block, Barry was laid low on the bye-line, giving Jimmy Johnstone the opportunity, while trailing the ball over to take the corner kick, to tramp sneakily on his chest. More uproar on the terracing. It mattered none. Barry was soon back on his feet rallying the troops, the Pars even managing a few breakaways late on courtesy of McLean tormenting Craig with his dummy+nutmeg routine. 2-1 to the Pars it finished. What we did not know, was that the 1960s were finishing too. Autumn 1969 was a pivotal moment. Armstrong had walked on the moon, Woodstock had just ended, Manson was on his warped hippie mission in California, the British Army had entered the streets of Belfast, The Beatles were cutting their last LP. Optimism was in retreat. Barry never played for the Pars again, nor did Bert Paton following his leg break in December. After Anderlecht in January the team suddenly looked middle-aged. We hadn’t brought through a youngster since Stein left in 1964. The sixties had seen Stein at his zenith, but he would never enjoy the same authority again. Within a year his Celtic team would lose three consecutive cup finals, including a European Final to Feynoord, and although he was still developing young players, Stein’s teams never had the same edge to them. For DAFC it was a precipitous decline. One month after this victory Dunfermline sat at the top of the league: one year later Dunfermline were rock bottom of that same 18 team league. We had sacked Manager Farm, and were not to win a single game until Christmas Week. The sixties were over.
Part 5 of Sammer Looks Back will be posted next Wednesday.
I am delighted to have long-time Pars fan, Sammer, as guest writer on Throwback for 6 weeks, during which he will give his own first-hand account of games he attended from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in part 3, he looks back on a Pars v Hearts game from January 1969. “JAMBOREE” Dateline: 2nd January, 1969 Match: Dunfermline 4, Hearts 2 Attendance: 15,202 Charts: Ob-La Di-Ob-La Da Hearts supporters were in what psychologists call The Denial Stage of their grief. For the 20 years following WW2 Hearts had turned out good sides, indeed for a few years they had been acknowledged as the best team in Scotland. Now they had fallen on hard times, were playing stodgy football, yet the Tynecastle faithful travelled over to EEP in good numbers for the first game of 1969, believing that glory days were just around the corner. They were on a fool’s errand. This was Manager Farm’s strongest Dunfermline side, the reigning Scottish Cup holders who had dispatched Hearts comfortably in the 1968 Final, were lying just behind Celtic in the League and were to on their way to a ECWC semi-final. Farm’s 4-3-3 formation made for a cohesive unit that could control the pattern of play or, if required, absorb heavy pressure There is an iconic photo of Lunn and Barry lunging at Jimmy Johnstone which captures the essence of the Pars’ competitive character at this time. Hearts had no chance. Pars line up:
The Pars team v Hearts Hearts lined up with: Cruickshank, Clunie, Holt, Anderson, A.Thomson, E.Thomson, Ford, J.Fleming, Gordon, G.Fleming, Traynor. This Hearts team was an uncomfortable mix of bully boys and choir boys. They played three hulking centre halves, including a bull-necked ogre by the name of Arthur Thomson with a crew-cut rarely seen outwith a prison exercise yard. The full backs, Sneddon and Holt, could be nasty. In contrast the attack was led by two Chartered Accountants- Donald Ford and Alan Gordon. Gordon, with his thoughtful approach play and outstanding aerial ability, could lay some claim to the crown worn by Bauld and Young whereas Ford was no more than useful. Perhaps predictably then, it was Ford who was granted heroic status by the Hearts support, demanding that this frail, cricket playing, part-time footballer should be in the Scotland team. In truth, far from being the best striker in Scotland, Ford was not even the best striker in Armadale, for Colin Stein was on the rampage for Rangers at this time. The Hearts support had arrived early and commandeered the terracing in the North Enclosure, normally the location for the Pars’ choir. Gorgie, Gorgie, Gorgie Rule! Gorgie, Gorgie Rule! This would prove to be another misjudgment on their part. The Pars’ choir numbered a few hundred, ranged in age from about 14-22, comprising dockyard apprentices, errant school students, a few local loudmouths and a smattering of drunks. Rather than force a confrontation, this hardcore support packed behind the goals at the Town End which, whether by luck or judgment, the Pars attacked first half. A wall of sound greeted the very first Pars attack and scarcely let up, as wave after wave of black-and-white incursions into enemy territory left Hearts overwhelmed. Mitchell provided the muscle, Gardner the hard running and Paton the guile. When Edwards cut his foot across a corner kick, making the ball fly low and flat like a frisbee, Mitchell dived to head home a flick-on. The Pars’ choir cranked the volume up to 11 as our midfield trio of Robertson, Edwards and Renton took total control, regularly releasing Callaghan and Lunn to overload Hearts on the flanks. After 16 minutes Edwards flighted another flat corner, this time from the left, and Paton, slim and poised as a matador, applied the coup de gras. 4 Pars players from the team that defeated Hearts: Pat Gardner, Willie Duff, Hugh Robertson and Willie Callaghan Hearts could barely get out of their own half. Jim Fraser, the bolt in the defensive system, was a reliable cover defender who was very strong in the air, granting Barry and the full backs licence to attack any ball played up to the Hearts forwards. On one occasion Davie Holt, a veteran full back who had known better days in maroon, had no option other than blooter a clearance on to the roof of the North Enclosure for which he was roundly cheered by the visiting support. Holt had been recalled after the Arthur Mann affair, another example of Hearts’ delusional support. Mann, from Burntisland, was a promising player who week after week, was being voted the best player in Scotland according to a Daily Express poll. This newspaper had a high readership amongst Tynecastle tradesman and clerical workers, who organized a write-in campaign to vote exclusively for Arthur Mann come hell or high water. They not only convinced themselves that Mann was the next Nilton Santos, but also Manchester City who coughed up money to take him south, from where he found his level in lower divisions. Mann was unusual. Whereas Hibernian would develop youngsters like Cormack, Marinello and Cropley before selling for big money south of the border, the Hearts equivalent would be shipped out to Tranmere or Doncaster after a couple of seasons. Just before the interval Dunfermline struck again to make the score 3-0. The goal was made by Willie Renton who had replaced Tommy Callaghan, the midfielder whose long raking runs had been a feature of Dunfermline teams in the 1960s. Renton covered far less ground than Tid Callaghan, being a passer rather than a carrier of the ball, but he played with a swagger and had a left foot that could tidy up play or set the attack moving. A stylish player but one who enjoyed a good scrap as well. Renton flighted a free kick over Hearts’ defensive wall for Gardner to steer in off the far post with a well-judged header. The Town End choir erupted, knowing that Hearts were well beaten, then battled its way through a demoralized Jambo support over to the Halbeath End, in anticipation of more goals in the second period. Images from 1968/69: Roy Barry in Football Monthly magazine; Barry & John Lunn both tackle Jimmy Johnstone; Jim Fraser In the event there was only one Pars goal, a nonchalant 8-iron chip by Paton which left Cruickshank stranded on his 6-yard line. Hearts made a decent fist of things in the second half, bringing on Willie Hamilton for some much needed creativity. Hamilton was thick around the midriff, had thinning hair, podgy knees and looked about 40 years old. For all that, he did have a football brain and Ford and Gordon pulled a couple of goals back, but this was a battle-hardened Dunfermline side who had faced bigger challenges than Hearts. John Lunn was typical of the competitive mentality that had been forged at DAFC. He was only 22 years old but had been on winning sides against The Old Firm on around 8 occasions, had appeared in two Scottish Cup Finals and played in rearguard actions by the Pars in Germany, Czechoslovakia and Spain. Another one was soon to follow down in West Bromwich. John Lunn was a fast, powerful defender who drove into tackles and attacks with the confidence of a fully-fledged professional, yet unlike Davie Holt, Jim Kennedy, Davie Provan or Billy Dickson he never wore the number 3 jersey for Scotland.
Hearts’ Willie Hamilton As for Hearts, their supporters became if anything more desperate. In 1971 more than 20,000 of them packed into Fir Park midweek to watch Hearts play Motherwell in the semi-final of the Texaco Cup, a consolation tournament for teams unable to qualify for Europe. This was a contest that had drawn a crowd of around 6,000 for the League fixture but after Donald Ford netted the winner in extra time – Fordie for Scotland – the Hearts support were convinced glory was within their grasp. Outside Tynecastle nobody much cared, though in the event they were beaten by Wolves in the final. It took a 7-0 hammering from Hibernian in 1973 before reality sunk in. Part 4 of Sammer Looks Back will be posted next Wednesday.
I am delighted to have long-time Pars fan, Sammer, as guest writer on Throwback for 6 weeks, during which he will give his own first-hand account of games he attended from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in part 2, he looks back on a Pars v Motherwell game from 1966. ”LATE HARVEST” Dateline: 8th January, 1966 Match: Dunfermline 6, Motherwell 1 Charts: Keep on Running
You would think that a six goal win at home would be a landmark in any season, but not in 1965-66: Partick Thistle (twice), Clyde, Hamilton Accies and Falkirk were all hit for six. There were plenty of fives as well. Fergie was on fire, his name being chanted to a variety of handclaps, from the emerging Kop in the North Enclosure. If manager Cunningham had opened the throttle the previous season, then this was a turbo-charged Pars outfit. With Stein’s Celtic setting new standards this was never a Pars team in contention for the title although all our matches against the top teams were decided by a goal either way. Motherwell lined up with: McCloy, Thomson, R McCallum, W McCallum, Martis, Murray, Cairney, Campbell, Delaney, McLaughlin, Weir. The goal machine of season 1965/66 had come about partly through accident. The transfer of John McLaughlin, who played for Motherwell in this match, meant the number 9 jersey was up for grabs but there were no obvious takers. Manager Cunningham had initially tried Ian Hunter, made a panic buy for the gangling Hugh Maxwell, then, incredibly, a Brazilian was flown over from Sao Paulo to lead the line. Extravagant tales of ball-juggling and banana bender shots swept the town but Chico Filho’s first game at Cappielow turned out to be his last. Most Pars fans never saw him play. By mid-October, when the clocks were being put back, the forward line had yet to gel. There was the added problem of Edwards being out injured. Future Pars winger Hugh Robertson (with guitar), then with Dundee, is seen here in 1962 with the Beatles. His Dundee team mate George Ryden is second from right. Jim Fleming, a journeyman footballer who had spent time at Luton Town and Partick Thistle, was the obvious replacement for Edwards. In fact, there lingered a suspicion Fleming had been signed as cover for Alex Edwards should the DAFC directors decide to cash in their chips and take the first big transfer offer from south of the border. But the centre forward problem was now becoming critical. Maxwell’s coltish caperings had so incensed the support they were baying for him to carted off to the nearest glue factory. Given this consumer resistance, Cunningham instead selected the promising Pat Wilson on the right wing and, purely as a stop gap measure, gave Fleming the number 9 jersey. What followed was scarcely believable. 455 564 615 This is not a padlock number nor a mobile number either. It is the number of goals scored by DAFC in the nine consecutive games after Fleming led the line. The forward line just clicked. What exactly Fleming brought to the side was hard to quantify at first, for he was not a prolific scorer. Then it dawned on us. He was an attacker who always made himself available for the simple pass, was strong enough to take a rattle from behind, then would play the right ball to a colleague moving into a good position. He had learned the basic football truth when your team is in possession: Get-Give-Go. It was as simple and as effective as that, allowing Paton and Ferguson to plunder defences for the remainder of the season. Motherwell were well beaten by half time. Ferguson opened the scoring at the Town End with a scissors kick early on, a flamboyant technique he’d used before. Ferguson’s goals during his years at EEP were of three types: the six yard box slide; the placed header; the low, skidding shot, taken on the run, across the goalkeeper. These low shots proved troublesome to the tall Motherwell keeper Peter McCloy, and Paton gobbled up a rebound from one of them. Paton was the opposite in so many ways to Ferguson, a player with a sure touch who sauntered around and drifted into space unnoticed. You had the feeling he could have played in his slippers. Even when chances fell his way in the box, Paton would often take that extra touch to wrong foot the defender or goalkeeper before placing his shot just inside the post. Unlike Ferguson he could shoot from outside the box and a week earlier had placed a 25 yard curler into the top corner at Ibrox in a 3-2 win. After McLaughlin was ordered off for kicking Ferguson on the ground, Motherwell were put to the sword. This Dunfermline side played an expansive game, making full use of the width of the park. Both Edwards and Robertson were playmakers rather than wingers who took on the full back, but they operated in very different styles. Edwards’ game was about distribution, whether working a tight triangle to release Callaghan on the overlap, sweeping across field ball to switch the play, or flighting a ball between the central defenders to pick out a forward run. Robertson was more a give-and-go type, a small, stocky player with a cheerful grin who had probably the fastest feet in the game. Hughie Robertson was playing tiki-taka Iniesta style back in the mid1960s; he had such a short, staccato stride that he could never be boxed in, even when he seemed trapped on the touchline. He liked to come inside to link up play and unlike Edwards he was a regular scorer throughout his career, slotting several vital goals at Ibrox and Parkhead. Pars team photo from season 1966/67 Both were involved in the later goals. Edwards pulled back a fast corner to Callaghan, running in from the corner of the box, and his steered header was eventually stroked into the net by Paton. Edwards himself was put through wide right, tried to fox McCloy by clipping the ball inside the near post, and when his effort rebounded from the woodwork Fleming lashed the rebound home via the underside. Robertson tidied up by netting a typical goal,continuing his run after making an initial pass and sweeping home. This was vintage turbo-Pars, and had Tommy Callaghan played instead of Thomson, then the score might well have been more. The Pars scored 94 League goals by the end of the season, for the second time running a higher total than Rangers. Ferguson scored 31 of those, making him Scotland’s joint top scorer with McBride. That was as many as the entire Pars team managed five years later. In all competitive games Ferguson managed 39. In all games, the Pars scored 131 times. Within two years both Smith and Ferguson had found their way to Ibrox where they enjoyed limited success, partly due to being played out of position. After the trauma of Berwick, Smith was pushed up as a support striker and played in the 1967 ECWC final. Like Smith, Ferguson finished his first season as top scorer at Ibrox, in a Rangers side which only lost one league game, but he was played as a number 9 and never really settled. McCloy also became a Ranger, had a long career, and managed to win a ECWC medal in 1972. His massive punts from hand have no doubt accelerated research into Alzheimer’s. And what about poor, forgotten Chico Filho, the one game wonder? A happy ending as it turns out. Filho had a decent career in the French lower division before becoming a respected national youth coach, working with Eric Cantona and Thierry Henry. Filho eventually teamed up with his one-match striking partner Alex Ferguson, as a youth coach at Old Trafford. Part 3 of Sammer Looks Back will be posted next Wednesday.
Following Auld Boab’s 6 weeks as guest writer on “Throwback”, I am delighted to have another long-time Pars fan, Sammer, take over the reigns for the next 6 weeks. Sammer will give his own first-hand accounts of games from the period 1964 to 1973. Here, in part 1, he looks back on a Pars v Hibs game from 1964. “WHITE HEAT” Dateline: 11th August, 1964 Match: Dunfermline 2 Hibernian 0 Crowd: 8,934 Charts: House of the Rising Sun A new season is about optimism, possibility, rebirth. This was the first home game of season 1964/65, a midweek League Cup tie with Jock Stein’s Hibernian, and there was no Charlie Dickson. Saturday had been no aberration. He was dropped. The man who had taken the number 9 jersey on his debut, the very month I was born, and worn it ever since. The man who had routed George Young, embarrassed Bobby Evans, unsettled Brian Labone. The man who had walked round Haffey in ’61 and brought a whole town out onto the streets that unforgettable April night. The man who had scored in the very first game I ever attended. The man I had seen bang in five goals in a cup tie. This seemed more like death than birth. A pensioner wearing a bunnet tried to console me. Charlie’s feenished, son. He’s feenished. I’d heard the talk. Talk that Charlie’s bounding, ostrich stride had lost a little spring, as had his legendary leaping for crosses. Of an injury he could not shake off. So now, it had come to this. Charlie’s time was up. To replace Dickson, Cunningham had bought three replacements- McLaughlin, Ferguson and Kilgannon – players who had decent scoring records but mostly in the lower division. The Ferguson swap for Dan McAlindon received some grudging approval: That’s better value. The support had never really taken to McAlindon, picking up on a wild rumour that he only got selected because he was married into Stein’s family. The teams were: Dunfermline Hibernian 1 .Herriott 1. Wilson 2. Callaghan 2. Fraser 3. Lunn 3. Leishman 4. Smith 4. Stanton 5. McLean 5. MacNamee 6. Millar 6. Stevenson 7. Edwards 7. Hogg 8. Ferguson (30) 8. Hamilton 9. McLaughlin (44) 9. Martin 10.Melrose 10.Cormack 11.Sinclair 11.Scott Pars captain (and future manager) Willie Cunningham with Alex Edwards and Jackie Sinclair in 1962 Attacking the Halbeath End, this was a new, lively Pars side, displaying a hunger Hibernian struggled to match. The team appeared younger than before. Gone was the post-war austerity look of Dickson and Peebles who you could imagine in army fatigues, rifles on shoulder, cheerfully doing some square-bashing as a Sergeant Major bellowed across the courtyard. Sinclair, Edwards and Ferguson were sharper, wore Italian suits, sported smart haircuts, probably listened to The Shadows or The Beatles rather than Shirley Bassey or Frank Sinatra. It was a well-balanced team too. George Millar dropped back to cover McLean, thoroughbred Alex Smith was joined by workhorse Melrose in midfield, Edwards developed play from wide right, Sinclair went direct on the left. Full backs Callaghan, with pace, and Lunn, with power, pushed up in support of attacks. Here was a more attacking approach than the cagey, measured style that had been developed under Stein. Cunningham’s Pars, playing open, attacking football, were now over-powering the Hibs’ tactical master. The Pars’ thin black and white stripes, flashing under the floodlights, seemed to emphasise an electric quality to their approach play, to exaggerate their speed of movement and thought.
Alex Ferguson (no.10) challenges for the ball during Dunfermline’s Inter Cities Fairs Cup game at Athletic Bilbao in 1965 Both Ferguson and McLaughlin had scored on their debuts and there were to score again this evening. McLaughlin was a burly centre forward who could play with his back to goal and was quite prepared to mix it with Big Bad John MacNamee, a centre half who tested physical courage before he got around to skill. Ferguson was slim, restless and looking to dart through the channels while keeping away from MacNamee. When Edwards slipped a ball round the side of the left back, McLaughlin ran into the space before flighting an inviting cross into the 6 yard box. Ferguson was already up waiting, like all good headers of a ball, having split the central defenders. He headed down, powerfully, in text book fashion, to Wilson’s left and the crowd roared their approval of a genuine striker. It looked uncannily like a header from Charlie D. There was never any doubt after that- Ferguson would score goals. Just before half time his striking partner McLaughlin, around the penalty spot, pulled down a sharp pass from Melrose on his thigh. As the ball came off the ground, McLaughlin put his left foot through it and the ball exploded into the roof of the net. A spectacular strike, and from his weaker foot too. There nobody could hit a baw like that since Wardhaugh. And from under the bunnet. Aye, and he was feenished when he come. So, 2-0 at half time and 2-0 it ended. Alex Ferguson (no.8) looks on as the Pars score in an 8-0 win over Third Lanark at EEP in March 1965 Hibs did not just have a good manager, they had some very good players. Stanton, Cormack and Willie Hamilton were international quality. Hamilton, sweating profusely under the floodlights, probed, twisted, dribbled, earning purrs of admiration from the terraces, many fans recalling a performance he had given at EEP in his Sheffield United days, the first floodlit match at EEP. Neil Martin was to score 100 league goals both sides of the border, MacNamee and Jim Scott (along with Sinclair) won the Fairs Cities’ Cup with Newcastle a few years later. However, the evening belonged to Cunningham’s invigorating Pars side. This was our taster of the greatest season Dunfermline Athletic would have in their history, of a team which so nearly won the double of League and Cup. In hindsight, George Miller’s transfer to Wolves early in the season probably cost us that Double. You don’t sell your captain if you want to win trophies. Then again, with DAFC paying the highest wages outside the Old Firm, and with no big European gate the season before, the money was simply too inviting to turn down. It took two players – Jim Thomson as a defender and Tommy Callaghan as a driving midfielder- to replace Miller. That reduced the options up front, although unusually for the time, Cunningham rotated his players to keep the team fresh. Kilgannon and Paton came in and delivered goals, as did Melrose who bagged all five when played as a striker against Falkirk. Peebles was a reliable option on either wing while Smith could be deployed deep or behind the forwards. This team went on to score 83 League goals yet remained as tight defensively as Stein’s sides, Cunningham’s credo being that attack was the best form of defence. The quality of football displayed at EEP in victories over Hearts (3-2), Rangers (3-1), Celtic (5-1) and in the semi final defeat of Hibs (2-0) was surely as good as any Pars side has ever produced and it was first displayed that warm, August evening in 1964. Next month came two major events: the opening of The Forth Road Bridge saw the traditional, much loved ferry boats removed from service and Harold Wilson became Prime Minister, promising the white heat of modernisation. It seemed like old news. I had the feeling I’d seen them both already. Part 2 of Sammer Looks Back will be posted next Wednesday.
Auld Boab is a long-time Dunfermline fan who has agreed to share some of his Pars memories each week. Over the past 6 weeks, he has looked back on the 1950s and 60s era with a different theme each week (Local Boys, Defenders, Goalkeepers and Wingers) and then his top 3 Pars players from the period. Last week, he focused on players 2 & 3 in his top 3. This week, in his final article for Pars Review, he writes about his favourite player. Auld Boab, near exhaustion as he was, had a shine in his eyes when he began to recall his numero uno:-
“Where on earth do I begin when I remember the top man, Charlie Dickson? Well, let’s try at the beginning. In the early fifties, we had a great centre-forward called Jimmy Millar, an ox-strong holder of the ball with finishing ability which belied his solid appearance. But so good was he that Rangers snapped him up, and in the search for his successor, Pars turned to Penicuik Athletic and in early 1955, signed their rangy centre-forward, Charlie Dickson, who went straight into the first team for the next game V Stenhousemuir at Ochilview. When Charlie arrived at the ground for his debut, he received a telegram from Jimmy Millar, wishing him good luck. How classy was that?
Many fans travelled through to see our new signing. My journey was in the back of Bruce and Glen’s delivery van, with ten other fans, all seated on cushions on the floor, backs against the van interior on either side, no seat belts in those days! Bruce and Glen was the class grocer in town, situated post-war in Bridge Street, on the north side across from the town clock, but in the early fifties, the shop moved to the south side of Bridge Street, near the Glen Gates, where it remained until it was squeezed out by the large supermarkets in the 70s. Both shops were characterised by the exotic aroma of freshly ground coffee, allied to polished wood. Whatever your requirements, a smart white-aproned man behind the counter would go and collect your order, awaiting the completion so that the cost could be totted up. This gracious style of shopping was, of course supplanted by the arrival of self-service supermarkets Charlie Dickson looks on as St Mirren keeper Jimmy Brown gathers the ball in the 1961 Scottish Cup semi final. The Pars won after a replay. Our first sight of our replacement for Jimmy Millar was a lanky gangling lad, fast, keen, sprightly, like an adolescent leveret. Subsequently in his career, Charlie never did anything the easy way, and his very first goal for us in his very first senior game was a harbinger of what was to come. Somehow, a ball from left-winger Anderson struck the bar and fell, squirming, to find Charlie all alone on the 6-yard line, with what should have been an easy tap-in. But the ball was bouncing awkwardly for an excited Charlie to control, and at waist-height, too low to header, too high to knee in; with instinct rather than a considered option, Charlie moved the ball forward, partly waist, partly chest, partly thigh, and worked the ball into the net before any defender could react. Unexpected, unconventional, two words which came to define Charlie’s playing style. A second goal followed later via Charlie’s head, a very promising debut, (with George O’Brien inside him, Joe Mackin in goals), followed the very next week by his sterling performance in that Gentleman George Duthie match V Partick in the Cup – though Charlie did not score, he ran the Partick defence ragged, and created the chaos for our goals and the two winning penalties. The Dunfermline Press described his having come through his home debut ‘with flying colours’. So, a favourite was launched!
Charlie’s Dunfermline stats are impressive. 340 appearances for Dunfermline, 215 goals, the highest tally in our annals. But how do I give a picture of him to our younger fans who never saw him? How can I put the finger on what made him so loved by the fans? I can but try.
He was all heart, fast, bouncy, never-say-die, chasing everything to the final whistle. He was awkward on the ground, with ball control which, frankly, was poor, but his unorthodoxy enabled him to beat defenders, plus round keepers when they represented the last line of the defence. On any number of occasions, he could beat a centre-half with his speed, deceive the keeper with an unconventional change of direction, only to sclaff the ball past the post of a yawning empty goal. With other players, such an outcome might lead to hoots of derision, but with Charlie, everybody would laugh, knowing the next train was just two minutes away round the corner, and sure enough the goalie would fumble a shot from midfield, and who was there to poke it home? Charlie! Or Peebles would break down the wing, sling over a cross begging to be headed home, and who was there? Charlie!
Indeed, Charlie was the ultimate in his use of the head to score goals. He jumped high, and also jumped long, covering yards in the air to meet a cross, most regularly from that right wing. And his headers were accurate, timed to perfection, hardly ever over the bar, rarely stopped by the keeper, but more often projectiled into a space in the goals. He always seemed to know where to be to meet a cross, unlike our forwards in recent years who have by-passed prolific service from Ryan Williamson; indeed, Williamson has been criticised for the quality of his deliveries, but Charlie Dickson would have exercised his striker’s sixth sense, and would have known exactly where to situate himself to apply the finishing touch.
Charlie was never greedy, but proved to be a prolific penalty-winner, and a great provider, laying on chances for his fellow-forwards. Bill Shankly spoke in the recent programme about instructing a forward to drop hand grenades – that was exactly what Charlie did! With his unorthodoxy and tireless running, he created merry mayhem in the opposition box, exactly the conditions for his colleagues to thrive. We used to speculate that defences could not possibly know what Charlie would do next, when Charlie himself had no idea what he would do next!
Pars line-up from season 1963/64, with Charlie centre of the front row I hope I have given our younger readers some kind of picture of Charlie in action, so let me turn now to his memorable games. That famous 1955 Cup victory over Partick Thistle in the Cup, Charlie’s second game for us, when he created confusion, at times clapping his hands to rouse his team-mates! And then, at the end of season 1956/7, ending in relegation by a single point, we played Rangers at home in our final match, losing 4-3 to a last-minute goal! Centre-half for Rangers, playing his last League game before retiral, was big George Young, Scotland’s celebrated Captain, who by this time was slowing, and dependent on his experience to handle centre-forwards, though he was still playing for Scotland; but he had never met in his career anyone like Charlie Dickson, who proceeded to run rings round him. Before the match, George may have been sad at the prospect of hanging up his boots, but post-match after the roasting Charlie gave him, turning him every which way, George must have been delighted with his decision to go!
Then against Partick once more in that memorable 10-1 Melrose game in April 1959, Charlie scored only one (with his inevitable head), but the Press described ‘Dickson the irrepressible who by his enthusiasm and unselfishness, made five of the goals possible’. Then Jock Stein’s very first game in charge, March 1960, and Charlie scored in ten seconds V Celtic (hope the turnstiles were working!) to send us to a shock 3-2 win, and on the march to win our last six games to avoid relegation. On to the Cup Final V Celtic, when Alex Smith’s speculative lob, nearly secure in Haffey’s hands, was chased at speed by Charlie, and while he did not get a touch on the ball, his attempt was enough to deceive Haffey into letting the ball squirm through past him; but while most keepers might have retrieved the situation with an about turn, Haffey was not quick enough, for as he turned, Charlie was already through to tap it home before leaping high into the air in celebration. A Cup-winner!
But highlight of Charlie’s career has to be that double hat-trick (who nowadays ever scores a double hat-trick?) against St Mirren at East End in January, 1962, on a snow-covered pitch. Seven of my favourites were playing (Connachan, Mailer, Miller, Peebles, Smith, Dickson, Melrose) – some team! Here is the cavalcade of goals (and misses!):-
14th minute – Melrose nods home a McDonald corner;
20th minute – Charlie nets after a keeper fumble of a Mailer shot;
Pre-half-time – Charlie misses two easy chances;
46th minute – Charlie misses another good chance;
47th minute – Charlie nods home a Melrose shot rebound off the goalie;
53rd minute – Charlie beats three men before shooting home;
55th minute – Charlie scores from a Peebles cut-back from the bye-line;
87th minute – Charlie heads home another cross from Smith on the right;
89th minute – Charlie side-foots ball in from a left-wing cross from Peebles.
By which point, we were all freezing on the terracings, but could not bear to leave such a memorable spectacle, the pinnacle of Charlie’s career, and his best-ever game for the Pars. He always took such joy in his goals, not by running straight to the crowd like Higgy to receive the fans’ acclaim, nor by wheeling away like an aeroplane, Faiss-style, but by leaping gleefully in the air with his arms up, before turning to embrace, and be embraced by his team-mates (while still upright, trotting back to the centre – no rolling-on-the-ground orgy in those days!).
Like Mailer and Duthie, Dickson played the game in the finest spirit, and a quiet modest pleasant nature meant that he was incapable of any shoddy or vindictive action on the field. He sadly died in Whitburn in 2013 aged 79, but he remains an Athletic icon, a man whose name inevitably brings a smile to the face of anyone who saw him. What a wonderful way for a wonderful player to be remembered – with a smile!
Charlie Dickson in a word – ENTERTAINMENT!”
Auld Boab slumped back, “My dram now, my boy, make it a Lagavulin, with a wee splash of water. And, Michael…… remember…… a large one!”
(Now that Auld Boab has shared some reminiscences with us for now, we have another guest writer lined up who will take us through his memories of the next decade, 1965 to 1975. Coming soon!) (Some of you may recognise the writer’s identity but for the purpose of the articles he has agreed to write for Pars Review, he has asked me to refer to him as “Auld Boab”). Many thanks to Auld Boab for his fantastic series of articles over the past 6 weeks.
Auld Boab is a long-time Dunfermline fan who has agreed to share some of his Pars memories each week. Over the past 4 weeks, he had looked back on the 1950s and 60s era with a different theme each week (Local Boys, Defenders, Goalkeepers and Wingers). Over the next 2 weeks, he will write about his top 3 Pars players from the club’s golden period. This week: numbers 2 & 3…….. Auld Boab indicated with an airy wave of his hand that he was nearly ready for the dram I had promised him, (though I don’t know how) but he obviously wished to finish his piece first, telling me he was down to his favourite three players from his era, the 50s into the early 60s:-
“The word ‘intelligent’ is usually applied to midfielders or inside men, but intelligent full-backs are not unknown. Through the eighties, we watched Dr Bobby Robertson entertaining us, and he was following in the footsteps of Gentleman George Duthie, who arrived with us from Hibs in 1953 at the age of 27, and played until 1959. His build was similar to Bobby Robertson’s, around six feet, slim, and like Bobby, he was equally at home in the full-backs or at centre-half, though to be fair, Bobby played centrally only once, in an inspirational cameo V Falkirk. George had a distinctive running style, tippy-tappy on the outsides of his feet, and he never seemed rushed, being possessed of great anticipation and positioning ability.
George was a teacher who finished his career in education as a much loved tutor in Moray House Teachers’ Training College. He was amateur in style, by which I mean he played the game in true spirit, never committing any shabby foul or vindictive act, and his bearing was consistently erect, elegant, balanced, assured, ice-cool. He was two-footed, and always selected watching and biding his time rather than lunging in. Intelligence in action!
But George had one particular asset which elevated him in Pars’ memories. He was, and surely remains, Dunfermline’s most successful penalty-taker, rivalling Aberdeen’s star right-back of the time, the legendary Don Emery; but Emery fired full-blast low cannon-balls in, and any keeper attempting to stop one would waken up in a hospital ward, while George was a placer, stroking the ball low to the stanchion, in the days when keepers were not allowed to move until the foot made contact with ball. His penalty style was reminiscent of my own in the mid 50s, when I won the Golden Boot twice in a row in the Dunfermline and West Fife Scout League. George maybe missed one in his career though I do not know for sure, but he certainly scored 21 goals in his six seasons with us, and I believe all were penalties.
I have mentioned previously our win in 1955 in the Cup V Partick Thistle at East End, and anyone who was there will recall the match as one of the top five domestic games we have ever seen at East End. Partick were a flying A Division team at the time, and went two up by half-time; but in the second half, winger Colin McKinlay scored a great goal after some superb ball control, and then inside-left Felix Reilly crashed a beauty high into the net from the edge of the box. Two all, and Pars pressure continued.
With a few minutes to go, left-winger Anderson was hauled down in the box – penalty! Up the field trotted centre-half George Duthie in his characteristic tippy-tappy style. I have to say that in recent years, penalties have been a bit of a trauma for us, and we have watched a variety of players, pre-Higgy, hoping they would score. With George on duty, we did not hope – we knew! Sure as fate, he ambled up to the ball and despatched it efficiently low into the goalie’s left-hand stanchion. Game won, but could we hold out for five minutes?
Two minutes later, Charlie Dickson released McKinlay who was felled by goalie Ledgerwood. Penalty again! Up the field once again trotted George Duthie in his characteristic tippy-tappy style. Sure as fate, he ambled up to the ball and despatched it efficiently low into the goalie’s right-hand stanchion, ie the opposite corner. What excitement in the terracings!
That’s why I remember Gentleman George Duthie with such affection and respect – the cool penalty king! He sadly died early from cancer in Edinburgh in 1982 aged 56.
In a word – poise!
George Duthie (left) and Ron Mailer Among the panoply of Pars’ stalwarts, the Pars’ stalwart of all Pars’ stalwarts is my number two favourite, Ronnie Mailer, who achieved everlasting fame as the Captain of our 1961 Cup-winning team. Ronnie signed in 1951 as an inside-right, but moved to right-half where he played for us until 1964, with a one-year stay at Darlington in season 1954/5, possibly as a consequence of National Service.
Ron was the archetypal bustling wing-half, of small/average height, but a continual thorn in the flesh for any attacker trying to pass him. He was brave, industrious, indefatigable, and it was these qualities which led to him being appointed Captain. I read recently some criticism of Morris for failing to shout at his team-mates; well, I never heard Ron Mailer shouting at his team-mates. He always led rather by example, getting stuck in, tackling again and again, being everywhere, making passes, driving forward. He was never going to be capped, but as a Club man of orthodox playing style, he was supreme.
180 minutes V Celtic in 1961, Ron his customary high profile terrier in defence, Celtic goal-less, and it was no coincidence that as soon as the game finished, Jock Stein’s first run, en route to Eddie Connachan, was to Ronnie Mailer, his brave inspirational Captain, for an embrace which transferred some Hampden mud from Ron’s strip on to Jock’s flapping white raincoat!
Ron’s game of games had to be against a rampant Kilmarnock in that end-of-season run of six winning matches to avoid relegation after the arrival of Jock Stein. So far two wins had helped, but Killie were challenging Hearts for the title, had already reached the Cup Final, and had played 21 games without defeat when they arrived at East End for this Monday night fixture in April, 1960. The match was keenly contested with chances at both ends, but goal-less at half-time, when Pars turned round to play to the town end. Five minutes in, and Ron picked up the ball in his midfield position, with just enough space to strike perfectly a shot from 35 yards. The ball whistled through the air at the speed of light and dipped in to the Martin Hardie postage-stamp corner of the goal past an apparently unsighted Jimmy Brown. A third win in a row for the Pars and two more points towards safety, thanks to goal of the season, if not century!
Killie’s keeper, Jimmy Brown, was a larger than life character, and a great favourite with all Scottish football fans for his humour and engagement with the terracings. He had some rare shoulder-charge jousts with Charlie Dickson but, even though Jimmy was solid, with thighs like tree trunks, and probably twice Charlie’s weight, at any contact he would drop to the ground like a dying hippo, but with enough presence of mind to keep a hold of the ball. Ref would back the keeper and blow for a foul, whereupon Jimmy would rise to his feet, still clutching the ball, and have a good laugh with the crowd at the success of his subterfuge. The crowd would join him in laughing, probably unlike today when they would be more likely to boo, gesticulate or throw coins!!
I had the pleasure of playing golf with the late Jimmy at Crail some twenty years ago, and on the way round, I reminded him of his jousts with Charlie Dickson, which made him smile, and I also mentioned Ron Mailer’s strike, commenting that Jimmy did not seem to have made an effort to save it. ‘Save it?’ said Jimmy, ‘It was going that hard, I never even saw it!’ So Jimmy too remembered Ronnie’s wonderful goal.
I also spoke with Ronnie at the Alhambra night celebrating the 60s some ten years ago, and found him to be the most pleasant, modest unassuming man, a man whose on-field enthusiasm demonstrated that he loved football, and a man whose playing record showed that he loved the Pars. To the best of my knowledge, Ronnie, now in his mid-eighties, still lives in his native Auchterarder.
In a word – lion-heart!”
Auld Boab subsided wearily back in his chair after this memory, but promised that he would summon the energy to reveal his number one favourite before accepting the dram he had somehow managed to wheedle out of me. Final episode from Auld Boab next week (Some of you may recognise the writer’s identity but for the purpose of the articles he has agreed to write for Pars Review, he has asked me to refer to him as “Auld Boab”). His final article, on his favourite ever Pars player, will be posted next Thursday.
Auld Boab is a long-time Dunfermline fan who has agreed to share some of his Pars memories each week. He continues to reminisce……….. Auld Boab seemed to be slowing a little, his eyes rheumy, but he perked up when he started to reminisce as follows about three of his favourite wingers:- “What a character George Peebles was, and what a player! Small, with short legs (though admittedly few small men have long legs), he was fast, nippy, tricky and endowed with excellent balance. He was most at home speeding down that right touch-line, black hair flopping as he ran, and the quality of his crossing was second to none. He was no Jimmy Johnstone in the dribbling stakes, twisting every which way, but was more direct and goal-orientated, with a unique double-shimmy which deceived defenders, even from a standing start.
George was the prime provider of crosses for a grateful Charlie Dickson to power home with his napper, but George himself was happy to pop up inside and he was a regular scorer. He had 431 appearances for the Pars (fourth highest in our history) and scored a staggering 79 goals (seventh highest in our history). A winger scoring one goal nearly every five games is some player, and George Peebles was some player!
He scored a superb hat-trick against Raith at the start of the 1962 season, but my favourite memory of him, which I have watched over and over again, is that cross from the left wing at Hampden in 1961, a left-footed cross, perfectly weighted, which found Davie Thomson kneeling to the ground, like a Dad offering to give a cuddy-back to a two-year-old, to time a flicked header past the fingers of Haffey diving to his left.
George Peebles, one of our mainstay stars of the golden days!
In a word, trickery!
George Peebles, Harry Melrose, Alex Edwards How bizarre that our wingers should be nicknamed the Borders twins, Peebles and Melrose! Harry Melrose too was a small man who took up the left-wing berth with a playing style very different from Peebles. His instinct was always to come inside and lurk in the penalty box, ferreting any opportunity to exercise his shooting skills which could cope with balls moving in from the left or right, after the style of Davie Wilson, Bobby Lennox, even Davie Dodds. In his six seasons with the Pars, Harry made 271 appearances, and scored a staggering 106 goals, ie nearly two every five games. An excellent free transfer in from Rangers in 1958!
Harry’s goals almost all came after a team move, and many of them were crackers; but two games stand out above all, namely V Everton (who’s Dunfermline?) in the Fairs’ Cup in season 1962/3. 1-0 down from Goodison, George Miller scored an early goal at East End to level the tie, which then went ding-dong until near the end, when Willie Cunningham cannon-balled a long ball out over Everton’s last defenders at the halfway line, with only Harry reacting to race on to it. Never offside, claimed Harry, more down to his natural speed! He sprinted in on the celebrated Gordon West in goals, ball under perfect control, and from the edge of the box, slipped it past the advancing keeper’s left hand into the net. Routine for Harry, but a top moment in Pars’ history!
Second memorable game was that miraculous 10-1 win to avoid relegation in the final match of season 1958/9 against Partick Thistle. Now I know the sceptics cry ‘Fix!’ at such a score, but I was there, behind the goal at the Dunfermline end first-half, and there was absolutely no evidence of Partick not trying – they were simply run ragged by a Pars’ attack, with Harry pouncing on any loose ball to hammer it home. Two years later, we were knocking in six against Valencia, a top-notch European team! So big scores can happen when chances are taken, though nowadays, defences are maybe more savvy as regards shutting up shop for damage limitation, while at that time, a much more porous 2-3-5 formation prevailed. But back to Harry!
His six Partick goals went like this :- 16th minute – Dickson sets to shoot, squares the ball, Melrose fires home; 22nd minute – Dickson again provider, Melrose shoots home; 37th minute – Watson heads on a Peebles’ corner, Melrose shoots viciously, ball deflected into the net; 40th minute – Dickson’s cross handled, Melrose converts the penalty; 79th minute – Smith splits the defence, Melrose runs in on goalie to slip the ball home; 86th minute – Peebles’ shot handled on goal-line, Melrose scores from the penalty for number six!
Partick Manager Davie Meiklejohn himself pointed out that all of the goals were beauties – it was just one of those days when nearly all chances created resulted in goals!
Harry Melrose, a great Par, a successful future Manager at East End, and the first (and only?) winger in the Scottish League to score a double hat-trick.
In a word – predator! Third and last winger is the wonderful Alex Edwards, who burst in to prominence with that superb right-wing performance against Valencia in 1962, on a frozen pitch which suited his style of wrong-footing opponents by catching them off balance. Alex was always more of a provider than a scorer, though he could shoot, and was never averse to trying; but it was the quality of his crossing from that right-wing which was his great strength, especially with strikers like Charlie Dickson and later Fergie waiting, like hyenas drooling in anticipation.
Alex had good vision and was one of those wingers capable of making the conversion from winger to inside-forward (think Hugh Robertson, who did exactly that from the left-wing). Indeed, my memory of an Edwards goal was against Kilmarnock, at the time when Killie were a force so early sixties probably. A very tight game (0-0 or maybe 1-1), and Pars were shooting second half towards the Dunfermline end, when a penetrating ball was played through centrally for Edwards to run on to, in a race with the Killie goalie rushing out. It seemed to take ages to resolve as they both converged, but Alex’s speed saw him arrive fractionally first, touching the ball left past the floundering goalie, after which it was an easy tap into an empty goal.
If Alex had a weakness, it might have been his fiery temperament, which occasionally led him to have an early bath. But his lip led to that wonderful story of his brush with the enormous black-liveried referee, Tiny Wharton, whom I always rated, despite his lack of mobility. Alex was protesting too volubly when Tiny drew him up, towered over him, and said, ‘Mr Edwards, I am six feet four, and you are the smallest man on the park, so you would be well advised to shut the f………k up!’
Alex Edwards remains a Pars’ legend, despite his moving to Hibs in 1971, and is still a regular attender at East End Park.”
In a word – artistry! (Some of you may recognise the writer’s identity but for the purpose of the articles he has agreed to write for Pars Review, he has asked me to refer to him as “Auld Boab”). Part 5 will be posted next Thursday.
|
|