Blog Posts

Following the recent upgrade of parsreview.org to a website format, this blog page will now become an archives section for all previous articles which were posted on the blog since July 2016.

They appear in chronological order, dating back to the start of the 2016/17 season. The articles, from July 2016 – September 8th 2017, are in blog format, shown in list form. Articles from July 2015 (when Pars Review began) – June 2016 are no longer available as they were on a previous webhost which is no longer accessable. 

For all the latest articles from Pars Review, please now visit the various different sections within the site by using the dedicated buttons on the home screen, or use the menu tabs at the top of the screen. The layout of articles is similar to the previous blog format but each article category now has a page of its own for easier navigation. 

Thank you for reading, following and supporting Pars Review since it’s beginning in July 2015. We will continue to produce daily content and aim to improve week on week. Every reader is very much appreciated!

Picture

Above: the original Pars Review banner, used on the first version of the site when it began in 2015.

A new feature where we focus on a game that doesn’t involve DAFC

Picture

Making a late decision to go to the game, the result was significantly more pleasing than the Scotland team’s performance. In his post-match press conference, manager Gordon Strachan was typically prickly. Once a sore loser, he has now adopted the manner of a sore winner. Does it matter if his team keeps winning? Probably not. 
A half full Hampden greeted the players and were soon cheering when Christophe Berra put Scotland into a 9th minute lead. Scotland dominated possession but rarely tested the Malta goalkeeper. There were, according to Strachan, 25 shots at goal. Few of them were serious attempts ON goal, however. 

Picture

Leigh Griffiths celebrates after scoring. Photo: Pars Review

The second half was only 4 minutes old when Leigh Griffiths doubled Scotland’s lead with a tap in. The crowd wanted more goals, but did not get any; expectations had to be readjusted to avoid a sense of disappointment, and so any number of football cliches were trotted out to make the result seem more satisfying than it actually was: getting the job done; seeing the game out, etc, etc.
Scotland have 2 excellent left backs and one of them, Kieran Tierney, is being played at right back to allow both players a place in the starting 11. While Andy Robertson got up the left side of the pitch with ease, Tierney had to switch to his left foot over on the right side of the park, and so was less effective.
This win plus last Friday’s far more impressive victory in Lithuania means that Scotland can still qualify for a World Cup play-off place. If Strachan can guide his team to wins over Slovakia and Slovenia, he will be hailed as a kind of Scottish Mourinho: a testy little man who doesn’t exude warmth but who gets the best out of his players and – as stated above – gets the job done. 
One final point: quite how James Forrest was given 7 out of 10 in the Sun and Daily Record reports is a mystery. This is a player who at one point in the second half, took 3 touches in an unchallenged area near the side of the pitch and succeeded in walking the ball out of play. He must have many friends in the Scottish media. 
​Photos (Hampden does not allow cameras, so some of these pictures are not the usual standard for this site, as they were taken by phone, and mostly focus on the crowd and stadium).

Picture

Pre-match outside Hampden

Picture

Most of the crowd were in this are of the stadium

Picture

Seconds after the opening goal

Picture

The crowd had moments of excitement but were mostly subdued

Picture

Leigh Griffiths taps in the second Scotland goal

​Photos by Pars Review

Picture Picture

All photos & video content by Pars Review.
​The Pars Review matchday vlog is hosted by DA Talk YouTube channel: goo.gl/D5x2sm

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

3 headers, 3 goals and a safe passage into the next round of the Irn Bru Cup

Picture

Allan Johnston made 8 changes to his starting 11, using the Irn Bru Cup as an opportunity for fringe players and others returning from injury to be given game time, as he did in the previous round against Arbroath. Only Sean Murdoch, Lee Ashcroft and Joe Cardle remained from the team that defeated Dumbarton in the Championship last weekend. 
Team line-up:
Murdoch;
Aird, M’Voto, Ashcroft, Martin;
Lochhead, Splaine, Paton, Cardle;
​Clark, Ryan

Picture

3′  Andy Ryan’s shot is tipped over by Buckie keeper Daniel Bell
7′  GOAL! Great crossfield ball from Aaron Splaine to Joe Cardle, whose cross is headed in by Nicky Clark
34′ GOAL! Splaine’s cross to Lee Ashcroft is headed back and met by Clark to make it 2-0
40′ GOAL! Fraser Aird plays in a cross for Andy Ryan to head in the third goal
59′ Splaine’s first effort is saved by Bell, then the Pars midfielder crashes the rebound off the bar – very unlucky not to score
78′ Ryan’s on target shot is saved by Bell
86′ Cammy Gill, on earlier as a sub and making his first team debut, makes an excellent diving save from a Kevin Fraser shot

Picture

Nicky Clark is congratulated by Scott Lochhead after one of his goals

Picture

10 months ago, a full-strength Pars team travelled to Buckie and were made to fight for their 5-3 victory, with the final goal coming in injury time during a period when the home side could easily have equalised to make the score 4-4. Today’s line-up was far from the familiar first team of the past few weeks. Nicky Clark, who scored in a sub appearance last week, started his first game since returning from injury.
The new-look Pars team controlled the game from the start. There were no scares, with the only save of any significance made late in the game by sub keeper Cammy Gill. In a pattern that is becoming increasingly familiar, as in many recent games the team scored goals early then saw out the second half. 
There were no failures today – Lewis Martin had a good game at left back, getting up the pitch regularly; Aaron Splaine showed class in midfield – he has ability and great potential; Michael Paton never wasted a pass; and both strikers that started the game scored. Fraser Aird showed that he is an option at right back, and in the 45 minutes in which both players featured, Joe Cardle (who played in the first half) and Kallum Higginbotham (on at half time for Cardle) were creative and constantly involved. Splaine is my Man of the Match for his involvement in 2 of the goals, plus his second half thunderbolt that deserved to go in. 
The long journey would have felt even longer had we not won – back home at 10.20pm! Here’s to a home draw in the next round. 

Picture

​Tomorrow: match photo gallery & matchday vlog will be uploaded. 
Photos & edits in this article by Pars Review.

Picture

Changes will be made for the long trip north with fringe players given a chance to impress

Irn Bru Cup – Saturday 2 September 2017 – Victoria Park – KO 3.00pm

Returning to the far north to the scene of last season’s 5-3 Scottish Cup third round win, Dunfermline will look to progress to the next round of the Irn Bru Cup with a team that will be a mixture of regulars and squad players. Both teams have started the season in goalscoring form, so an open, entertaining game is anticipated.

Picture

Our opponents: Buckie Thistle

Wednesday’s 3-0 win over Rothes kept up Buckie’s average of having scored 3 goals per game so far this season in the Highland League, with 7 games played. They sit in second place with 5 wins, 1 draw and 1 defeat. Buckie won the Highland League last season and qualified for the Scottish League 2 Play-offs. They lost 4-3 on aggregate to Lowland League champions East Kilbride, missing out on the chance to play Cowdenbeath in the play-off final for entry to League 2. 
Here is a link to the article I posted last season before the Buckie v Pars Scottish Cup game, about Buckie – the town and the football club: www.parsreview.org/blog/way-way-way-up-north

Picture

Victoria Park, Buckie’s home ground, before the Buckie v Pars game last season

Dunfermline

Allan Johnston used the game against Arbroath in the last round of the Irn Bru Cup to give game time to fringe players and has confirmed he will do the same this Saturday. Lewis Martin, who was suspended for the Arbroath game, will feature and such is his versatility in defence, could come in for right back Ryan Williamson, left back Jason Talbot, or either Callum Morris or Lee Ashcroft in central defence. With centre half Big Jock M’Voto likely to play, I would rest Williamson and play Martin at right back, retaining Morris or Ashcroft to play alongside M’Voto. 
In midfield, Johnston has several options. His preference for 4-4-2 means that 2 of the 4 positions will be filled by natural wide players as opposed to shoehorning in other players into the 4 man midfield. So with that in mind, I have gone for MIchael Paton in right midfield and David Hopkirk on the left. Hopkirk has been used as a striker this season but played the last 20 minutes of the win over Dumbarton last week on the left wing, with his cross setting up Nicky Clark’s goal. In the middle of the pitch, Johnston could select Paton, meaning Fraser Aird could be brought in to play on the right. To have a balance of some first teamers alongside fringe players, I have retained Dean Shiels, and selected Aaron Splaine to come in alongside him. 
Up front, Callum Smith is away with the Scotland Under 19 squad but changes were anticipated in any case. We have 4 (5 including Hopkirk) strikers battling for 2 places, and I would expect to see Nicky Clark play this weekend after making his first appearance after injury as a sub last week. Andy Ryan, who made his Pars debut in the last round of this cup, scoring twice in the at game, would be my choice to partner Clark. 
My team below selection means that Ryan Williamson, Callum Morris, Kallum Higginbotham, Nat Wedderburn, Joe Cardle and Declan McManus are all rested. The criteria for team selection for this game is completely different from a League game, or even a Scottish Cup or League Cup game. I would expect to see a mix similar to the team I have picked, but that could just as easily see other players rested with some of the players mentioned at the start of this paragraph starting the game. Other fringe players, such as Aird and Scott Lochhead could also play. The manager certainly won’t make 11 changes – there will be some continuity but up to 6 or 7 changes could be made. 
Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Victoria Park photo plus Graeme Stewart edit by Pars Review.
​Match report/opinion with photos will be posted when we return home from Buckie.

Picture

In what was a very good month for the team, going top of the Championship and undefeated in the League, Joe Cardle was the stand-out player. Joe had a disappointing 2016/17 season but it was obvious in pre-season games that he was determined to fight for his place in the team. His goal tally for this season is now 8, which includes 5 in the past 5 games. Joe’s trademark move of cutting inside has been added to with what seems to be an extra burst of pace. He is possibly enjoying the best form of his career. Mention must be made too of his attitude towards his team mates – always encouraging others and showing great team spirit. 

Picture

​Joe is now aiming for the third League title of his Pars career, in his second spell with the club. He was a key part of the teams that won the First Division (now Championship) in 2011 and League 1 in 2016. Joe has now played 213 games for DAFC (154 starts plus 59 sub), scoring 52 goals (2009-2013; 2015 – present). 
Photos & edit by Pars Review
​Man of the match stat is for Pars Review selections in match reports.

Picture Picture

Here’s a 61 year old piece of DAFC memorabilia – a postcard issued by the Daily Express, showing the Pars team line-up from season 1956/57. ​

Picture

A run of only 1 victory in the final 13 games saw Dunfermline relegated from Division One that season, in an era when there were 2 divisions of 18 and 19 teams. Had they gained 1 extra point, they would have avoided relegation. Charlie Dickson, in his second season with Dunfermline, scored 13 goals in 27 League games plus 2 more in Cups.
Here is the 1956/57 Division One table (2 points for a win):

Picture

In the Scottish Cup, Dunfermline defeated Morton 3-0 before being knocked out in the last 16, going down 1-0 to Morton at Cappielow.
The Pars won their League Cup group,  winning 3, drawing 2 and losing 1 game in home and away games against St Mirren, Queen of the South and Kilmarnock. In the quarter finals, played over 2 legs, Dunfermline lost 6-0 to Celtic at Parkhead before winning the home leg 3-0. Celtic went onto win the competition.
The seeds of future Pars teams, including the 1961 Scottish Cup winning side, were contained in the 1956/57 squad. Charlie Dickson, George Peebles and Ron Mailer all remained with the club and were in the Cup winning team of 1961. 
The following season, 1957/58, saw promotion gained from Division Two, finishing runners-up to Stirling Albion. Charlie Dickson scored 38 goals in all competitions that season. The team scored 120 League goals in 36 games. Dunfermline spent the following 14 seasons in the top flight until relegation in 1971/72.

Picture Picture Picture

All photos & video content by Pars Review. The Pars Review matchday vlog is hosted by DA Talk YouTube channel: goo.gl/D5x2sm

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

Pars go top of the league with convincing win

​Four goals and 3 points put Dunfermline top of the Championship table after a resounding victory against Dumbarton. Allan Johnston named the same starting 11 that defeated Falkirk last week. There were 2 changes on the subs bench – Aaron Splaine and Fraser Aird dropped out, replaced by Nicky Clark, deemed fit enough to be named amongst the substitutes after his month-long injury absence, and Big Jock M’Voto.
​Line-up:

Picture

A big Pars travelling support was in the Your Radio 103FM stadium, situated at the foot of Dumbarton Rock, possibly the most picturesque setting of any stadium in the SPFL. Dumbarton went into today’s game with just 1 victory from 8 League and Cup games this season and were soon under pressure from a vibrant Dunfermline attacking unit. Joe Cardle, who has been in tremendous form recently, was involved from the start, while in the centre of the attack, Callum Smith and Declan McManus never gave the home defence any respite. On the right side of the attack, Kallum Higginbotham enjoyed his best game of what has already been a very good season for him. 
The opening goal came in the 5th minute from Cardle, with his 8th of the season. Callum Smith’s effort looked certain to hit the net but was cleared off the line, with the ball reaching Cardle who shot home. The players then ran to the dugout to hold up a shirt in honour of fan Bill Edwards, who sadly passed away earlier this month. 
In the 20th minute, former Pars defender Andy Dowie pulled down Declan McManus when the Dunfermline striker was running in on goal. Referee Barry Cook produced a yellow card, for what was surely a sending off offence. Dumbarton were guilty of continuous fouls, but were aided by an astonishingly weak referee. They had 3 different players booked during the game (Dowie later received a second yellow card) but a stronger official would have clamped down on their actions far harder and not been so lenient. 
The Dunfermline lead was doubled after 27 minutes. Smith’s pass to Cardle was played through to Higginbotham, who coolly slotted the ball past Scott Gallacher in the Dumbarton goal. The game was completely one-sided at this point. Dumbarton would have been relieved to reach halftime only 2 goals down. ​
The second half unfolded in a familiar pattern in recent games. As against Arbroath and Falkirk, first half dominance was not followed by an almost-expected flood of second half goals, against teams who had players sent off. For much of the second period, Dunfermline found the home defence hard to break down, although it should also be pointed out that Sean Murdoch had to make just one save of any difficulty, from a Craig Barr header, after the same player had hit the bar with another header. Meanwhile Dumbarton continued to rely on constant fouling and packing their defence to keep the score down. ​​

Picture

Nicky Clark celebrates his goal

​The same double substitution as last week was made again in the 63rd minute, with Andy Ryan and David Hopkirk replacing Smith and McManus. After 77 minutes, Hopkirk had a great chance to score when put clean through, but took the wrong option, shooting from distance when he could have run closer to goal, or played in one of his team mates who were closer to him than the Dumbarton defenders. In the build up to that breakaway, Andy Dowie had fouled a Pars player well behind the run of play but the referee correctly waved play on. Referee Cook then showed Dowie a second yellow card and the defender, a member of the Jim McIntyre title winning side of 2011, was dismissed.
The third Pars substitution saw Nicky Clark replace Cardle in the 79th minute, with Hopkirk moving to the left wing. This proved successful, with Clark getting the Pars’ third goal after 87 minutes with a close range finish from a perfect Hopkirk cross. Three minutes later, Clark’s backheeled pass found Ryan, who expertly put the ball past Gallacher.
With results from other games going Dunfermline’s way, the team moved top of the table. Confidence is flowing through the squad and games are being won convincingly.

Picture

​Tomorrow: match photo gallery & matchday vlog will be uploaded. 
Photos & edits in this article by Pars Review.

Picture

Pars travel to the Rock hoping to build on an encouraging start to the season

SPFL Championship – Saturday 26 August 2017 – Your Radio 103FM Stadium – KO 3.00pm

Dumbarton host the Pars on Saturday with the 2 teams experiencing contrasting form and results. While Dumbarton have yet to win a League game, Allan Johnston’s team go into the game full of confidence and seeking a third consecutive win in this season’s Championship, which could put them top of the division depending on other results. 

Picture

The opposition: Dumbarton

The great survivors of the Championship, every season Dumbarton are written off by bookies and others as relegation candidates, yet this is their sixth consecutive season in the second tier. They continue to defy their part time status while so-called bigger clubs have dropped down into League 1 over the past few seasons. Dumbarton’s season so far has been disappointing: their Betfred Cup group games resulted in a 3-1 home defeat to League 1 Ayr United, a 2-1 away loss at League 2 Clyde, a 0-0 home draw with Annan, also from League 2, with Annan winning a bonus point in the penalty kick shoot-out, and finally a 3-0 defeat at Kilmarnock.
In their 3 League games so far, Dumbarton have yet to win, with 2 draws and a defeat. In fairness, the 2 draws were against 2 of the teams that made up last season’s top 4 – Morton and Falkirk. Their most recent Championship game was last weekend when they lost 1-0 at Queen of the South. Dumbarton’s only victory in 8 competitive games this is season came in the Challenge Cup, when they defeated Rangers Under 20s 2-1. 
Dumbarton boss Stephen Aitken brought in 13 new players this summer, among them ex-Pars Andy Dowie and Kyle Hutton, plus Mark Stewart, Craig Barr and Chris Johnston from the Wee Team. 

Picture

Joe Cardle, seen here against East Fife earlier this season, scored 4 times against Dumbarton last season. He has 7 goals so far this season.

Dunfermline

Second in the Championship and with victories over Inverness and Falkirk in the past 2 games,  the Pars go to the newly-named Your Radio 103FM Stadium tomorrow, in the shadow of Dumbarton Rock, with hope and expectations of another 3 points. Taking lessons from the second half against a 9 man Falkirk last weekend, complacency cannot be allowed to creep in, and it should also be noted that while the team have only lost 1 competitive game this season, they have also not won a game away from home in 4 attempts (not counting the penalty kick bonus point at Tynecastle after the game ended 2-2 in 90 minutes). 
The squad is almost fully fit – only Nicky Clark is a doubt, and although he has returned to training, next week’s Challenge Cup game at Buckie might seem the more obvious game for his return. I have selected the same starting 11 as last week. Callum Smith retains his place alongside Declan McManus – new signing Andy Ryan’s time will come, but I feel that Smith and McManus work better as a partnership at the moment. 
​Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

​Joe Cardle photo plus Stephen Aitken edit by Pars Review.
​Match report/opinion with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

On Wednesday this week, Pars Review set a Twitter poll to get fans’ feedback and opinions on the cost of football in our division. 
The results of the poll are shown below. Fans were ask to select a realistic admission price, and for the purpose of the poll only adult prices were included. Expanding the poll to cover concessions, parent and child deals, and other categories, would require a whole study rather than a 24 hour Twitter poll. So while the poll does not cover admission prices for every type of supporter, it still reflects the biggest supporter category – non-concessionary adults.  
Looking at admission prices across the division, with the exception of Brechin City (who have by far the smallest stadium and also the least expensive admission prices), the differing facilities, stadium capacities and general standard of the venues are not always reflected in prices (it is more expensive to get into Morton or Dumbarton than East End Park). Clubs set their own prices and the complete list of all adult and concession prices are also listed below. 
So the poll asked fans to assess the cost of entry for the second tier of Scottish football, regardless of the merits of each club’s stadium. What amount do fans deem as a fair amount to watch a Championship game? For the sake of realism, the lowest price option was set at £10. It would not be possible for clubs in the division, the vast majority being full-time, to survive on current attendances while charging, for example, £5 for adults. 
Pars Review Twitter poll results (poll ran from 11am on Wednesday this week, for 24 hours).

Picture

The most acceptable price for Championship football, (£15) with 53% of the total votes, is only available at Brechin City. Only 4% of those who responded thought the most common price (£20) was acceptable for an adult.
Here are all current walk-up prices for this season’s Championship clubs. I went through all 10 clubs’ websites to gather this information. For clubs with main stands that had slightly higher prices, I used prices for their other stands, to reflect standard admission prices. As you can see from the list, clubs have varying types of concession categories. Some did not list specific types of concessions, such as disabled prices; some listed more concession types than others. The information below is exactly as it is listed on the clubs’ websites. 
Most clubs did not list “Parent and Child” prices, unless noted below. There has been a shift from Parent and Child deals to lowering admission prices for younger children, with the assumption being that they will be accompanied by a parent in any case. 

Picture

This is the second of a 2 part feature where I look at the performance of all 12 Dunfermline managers in the time I have supported the club (since September 1991). To rate their time at the club as fairly and objectively as possible, I have based the markings on the players they had available, the club’s status at the time of their period in charge, together with factors that influenced their success and/or failures. Understandably, this can be like comparing apples to oranges, but I hope the article is fair and allows each manager’s time to be seen in context.

Picture

A contender for best ever Pars assistant manager, during his 6 years working with Bert Paton. Dick took over from Paton in January 1999 but was unable to prevent relegation to the First Division after 3 seasons in the Premier. Despite guiding the team to second place (with the top 2 clubs being promoted), Dick was sacked before Christmas 1999 when John Yorkston and Gavin Masterton took control of the club. An enthusiast as opposed to being a master tactician, Dick’s most successful periods as a manager since leaving Dunfermline have been with lower league clubs from Angus. 

Picture

Jim Jefferies

Picture

Jefferies is the only manager in this feature to have been in charge for 2 relegations, yet his time at the club has to be seen in context more than any other Dunfermline manager of the past 30 years. He was brought in with the club heading out of the Premier League, but rebuilt the squad in the summer of 2012 and by Christmas that year had led the team to the top of what is now the Championship. Financial problems followed by administration decimated the squad and the club were relegated to League 1. A second place finish behind Rangers in 2013/14 was followed by a promotion play-off defeat, with a team robbed of some of its few experienced players. The next season was a huge let down and Jefferies left the club in December 2014. His leadership of the club during administration should never be forgotten, and had it not been for the financial mismanagement of Masterton and Yorkston, he could well have taken the team back to the Premier League. 

Picture

With his playing career coming to an end, Jim McIntyre was made interim boss after the sacking of Stephen Kenny in 2007 before being given the manager’s job permanently. He gradually built up a squad capable of winning promotion to the Premier League in 2011. Perhaps too loyal to certain players who were either too old or not good enough for a season in the top flight, McIntyre was sacked before season 2011/12 ended. He has since proved himself to be one of Scotland’s best homegrown managers, particularly with his work at Ross County. 

Picture

Season 2014/15 ended with Dunfermline seventh in League 1 – the lowest ranked full time club in the SPFL and the club’s worst League position for 30 years. Allan Johnston was brought in as manager in May 2015 and made several new signings in addition to releasing every out of contract player. When the new season began, Dunfermline began with 2 League games, a League Cup tie and a Challenge Cup game, scoring 4, 5, 6 and then 7 goals in those 4 games. That set the pattern for a title winning season, which also saw a victory over Premiership Dundee in the League Cup. A fifth place Championship finish last season continued the progress under Johnston. He is an attack minded manager and although not the most flexible tactician, it could also be argued that he has faith in his system and has been very successful as a result.

Picture

Brought in by new owners to replace Dick Campbell, Calderwood did not actually improve the club’s League position that he inherited from Campbell (second in the old First Division) but in 2000 that was enough to win automatic promotion to the Premier League. Armed with almost certainly the largest budget of any Dunfermline manager (which later cost the club dearly), he built up a quality squad including players such as Craig Brewster, Ian Ferguson, Andrius Skerla, Marco Ruitenbeek and Barry Nicholson. The team’s League position improved every season under his management, peaking in 2004 with a fourth place SPL finish and a Scottish Cup Final defeat to Celtic. He moved to Aberdeen immediately after the Cup Final which soured his legacy at the time. Looking back at his time, over 10 years later, he achieved more than any manager since the 1960s but with a much larger budget than his immediate predecessors. 

Picture Picture

In a case of history almost repeating itself, a former Pars player, a Fifer, breezed into East End Park to breathe life and enthusiasm into a depressed club in the same way that another true character of the game had done ten years before. Bert Paton, along with his assistant Dick Campbell, raised spirits and brought success and fun back to the club in a style reminiscent of Jim Leishman in the 1980s. Just as Leishman took over from the dark days of Tom Forsyth in 1983, Paton followed Jocky Scott into the manager’s chair in 1993 and set about reinvigorating the club, the players and the supporters. Paton was one of the greatest Pars players of the club’s golden years of the 1960s but was faced with an entirely different challenge as Dunfermline manager. With a modest budget, he built the team around some players who were already stalwarts of the club, including Norrie McCathie, Craig Robertson, Ian Westwater and Paul Smith, and added players from lower leagues (among them Stewart Petrie), juniors (Andy Tod), others released from rival clubs (Ivo Den Biemen) and the occasional veteran who Paton had worked with before (Kenny Ward). In Paton’s first season, promotion to the Premier League was missed out on narrowly but the team finished top goalscorers in Britain. Two seasons later, despite the tragic loss of club legend McCathie, the team won the First Division. A year later, Paton’s Pars finished fifth in the Premier League. 
Paton resigned in early 1999 and left a legacy of attacking football, his teams containing some of the best-loved Dunfermline players in the club’s history. It was a great period to be a Pars fan, and there was a real connection between the man in charge and the fans. It is great to see Bert back at the club, with fellow ex-Pars and team mates of his from the 1960s and 70s, promoting the club and attending supporters events. It’s time for a stand to be named after him. 

This is the first of a 2 part feature where I look at the performance of all 12 Dunfermline managers in the time I have supported the club (since September 1991). To rate their time at the club as fairly and objectively as possible, I have based the markings on the players they had available, the club’s status at the time of their period in charge, together with factors that influenced their success and/or failures. Understandably, this can be like comparing apples to oranges, but I hope the article is fair and allows each manager’s time to be seen in context.
Here are the six bosses ranked 7-12. Caretaker managers Jimmy Nicholl (28 days in 1999) and Craig Robertson (15 days in 2006) are not included. Tomorrow I will continue with the top 6 managers since 1991. 

Picture

After Jimmy Calderwood left the club, Davie Hay was appointed manager in summer 2004. A disastrous UEFA Cup exit followed early in his reign, and he was eventually sacked with 3 League games remaining, with the team facing relegation from the Premier League. This was with a squad that included Craig Brewster, Noel Hunt, Scott Thomson, Andrius Skerla, Scott Wilson, Greg Shields and Barry Nicholson, all key members of the team that had finished 4th the previous season and reached the Scottish Cup Final – a remarkable case of managerial incompetence. He failed to complete a full season at the club and seemed oddly remote and disconnected from the club and the supporters. Possibly the worst case of “performance against budget (resources)” of all 12 managers. 

Picture Picture

A dour, miserable man who as unable to prevent relegation from the top division, then blew the chance of promotion the following season with just 1 win in the final 9 League games, those of us who were at Meadowbank in April 1993 will remember him making an obscene hand gesture to Pars fans, which he later apologised for. Scott led the team to the 1991 League Cup final but his lack of personality was reflected in his team the cautious, defensive tactics that he employed.

Picture

Appointed after the controversial decision to relieve Jim Leishman of his role as manager in 1990, Munro was unpopular and ill-equipped to lead the team. Munro was the first Pars manager in my time as a fan, with my first game at EEP as a supporter ending in a 4-1 defeat to St Mirren. Another managerial tenure that was devoid of passion, Munro is now a youth team coach in America, a position he would seem better suited for.

Picture

A Cathro-esque appointment, with the aim to bring new, inventive coaching ideas into the club that backfired spectacularly. Despite reaching the 2007 Scottish Cup Final, Kenny (age 34 at the time) was unable to prevent relegation from the Premier League that season. Promotion favourites the following season, his Pars team won just 1 of the opening 7 League games, then a few weeks later he oversaw a 3 week period of results that began with a 5-0 home loss to Hamilton, followed by a 3-0 away defeat at Stirling, with a 4-0 home defeat to Livingston the week later. He held on for a further fortnight (producing a draw and another defeat) before being sacked after 13 months in the job. He has since returned to Ireland and enjoyed great success, including winning 3 League of Ireland titles, 3 League of Ireland Cups and 2 Irish FA Cups. 

Picture

In stark contrast to managers such as Jocky Scott and Iain Munro, John Potter was (and remains) a very popular figure at East End Park, with a particular talent for coaching and developing young players. His spell as first team manager came after Jim Jefferies departed the club, in the dreadful 2014/15 season. Potter was unable to turn the team’s fortunes around with the club finishing in 7th place in League 1. We will never know how he would have fared had he been given the following season (and summer transfer window) to build his own team. Now an important part of Allan Johnston’s coaching team, maybe his time as manager came too soon, and in the wrong circumstances. 

Picture

Leishman celebrates Dunfermline’s win at Tannadice in 2005, a crucial result that helped to avoid relegation

Picture

Leishman’s second spell as manager of the club began when he stepped in following the sacking of Davie Hay, and in a remarkable end to season 2004/05, led the club to Premier League safety when relegation seemed a certainty. With 3 games remaining, wins were achieved over Dundee United and Dundee which moved the Pars out of the relegation place. The final game of the season almost ended in disaster, when a heavy defeat at Kilmarnock could have undone the work of the previous fortnight; Dunfermline were saved from the drop when Dundee lost their last game on the same day. Leishman decided to stay on as manager but could not replicate the success he enjoyed during his 1980s heyday. He resigned as manager in October 2006. 

Picture Picture

All photos & video content by Pars Review. The Pars Review matchday vlog is hosted by DA Talk YouTube channel: goo.gl/D5x2sm

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

Bairns lose the plot and the 3 points to a Cardle-inspired Dunfermline

​After 6 long years, Dunfermline defeated rivals Falkirk in a game that saw Allan Johnston’s team enjoy first half superiority then find it harder against a 9-man Falkirk after half time. The win gives Dunfermline a 6 point lead over today’s visitors in the early season Championship table.
The Pars lined up with Declan McManus replacing David Hopkirk from last weekend’s victory over Inverness, with the rest of the team unchanged. None of the fringe players who played in Tuesday’s Challenge Cup win over Arbroath started this game, with Aaron Splaine, Fraser Aird and others listed amongst today’s substitutes.
​Pars starting 11 & subs:

Picture

Falkirk were without the injured Miles Hippolyte who was seen on crutches. The player, whose dive to win a penalty in the last meeting of the clubs was punished retrospectively by the SFA, had clearly passed tips onto his team mates as time after time the Falkirk players went to ground at the slightest sign of contact. It reached the point of pure farce as it was so clearly a tactic, possibly their only tactic, in a first half that saw them outclassed by a Dunfermline team keen to record a long overdue win in this fixture.
Kallum Higginbotham, who played for Falkirk earlier in his career, provided yet another goal assist to help put the Pars ahead in the 5th minute. His pass found Declan McManus, who held off his marker and placed the ball firmly past Robbie Thomson in the Falkirk goal. Six minutes later it was 2-0 when a rampaging run from Ryan Williamson ended in a perfect cross to Joe Cardle who struck the ball sweetly past Thomson. 
Callum Smith then had a chance to make it 3-0 when he took a McManus pass and saw his shot hit the left post and stay out. 
The closest Falkirk came to a first half goal was when Tony Gallagher’s shot was saved well by Sean Murdoch. 

Picture

Declan McManus celebrates his goal

The second half was to produce even greater drama, beginning with Bairns midfielder Craig Sibbald’s sending off for kicking Joe Cardle off the ball after 52 minutes. It was an act of supreme idiocy, matched only by the Falkirk support who immediately began to sing Sibbald’s name as he walked off. There is nothing heroic about reducing your team to 10 men when 2-0 down against your biggest rivals. 
Cardle then set up Smith for a shot from 6 yards but the young striker got under the ball and put his effort over the bar. 
Falkirk’s indiscipline continued when veteran striker Lee Miller, on as a substitute, elbowed Big Nat and was red carded, with 62 minutes gone. 
As often happens, the weight of expectation – surely more goals would now follow? – began to impact on the flow of Dunfermline’s natural game. Passes went astray, and the home crowd were getting anxious, their expectations not being met as the minutes ticked by. David Hopkirk and Andy Ryan were brought on in place of Smith and McManus but the Pars were making life hard for themselves against the nine men. Falkirk pulled a goal back with 7 minutes remaining when Gallagher’s shot hit the post with such force that the rebound came all the way out of the box at an angle to Tom Taiwo who hit a first time rocket into the top corner. 
Pars’ nerves were settled in the final minute when Cardle, the game’s outstanding player, got his second and the Pars third with a trademark run inside from the left, and shooting past Thomson to the delight of his team mates and the home support. 
The expectation of a last half hour goal rush that failed to materialise should not diminish the importance of this victory. To reduce our biggest rivals to a play-acting, violent mob shows the difference in quality that was most evident when the teams both had 11 men. 

Picture

​Tomorrow: match photo gallery & matchday vlog will be uploaded. 
Photos & edits in this article by Pars Review.

Picture

A chance for Dunfermline to make a real mark on the League when rivals Falkirk visit East End Park

​​SPFL Championship – Saturday 19 August 2017 – East End Park – KO 3.00pm

Dunfermline and Falkirk meet for the first time since the controvesiral match at East End Park on 22 April, when Bairns player Miles Hippolyte dived to win a penalty for his team when Dunfermline were 1-0 ahead. Falkirk went on to win 2-1 and although Hippolyte was retrospectively banned by the SFA for the dive, it did not redress the injustice that occured that day, and will doubtless be a strong motivating factor for Dunfermline tomorrow.

Picture

The opposition: Falkirk

Falkirk go into tomorrow’s  game with just 1 point from the opening 2 Championship games and having lost at home to Livingston in the second round of the Betfred Cup. Second favourites to win the Championship, they last played in the top division in 2010/11. Since then, they finished third in what is now the Championship for 3 seasons (2010/11, 2011/12 & 2012/13) before promotion play-offs were introduced. A further third place finish in 2013/14 saw them fail to progress via the new play-off system; 2014/15 ended in a fifth place finish, their lowest for several seasons. For the past 2 seasons, they have finished second, but again did not succeed in gaining promotion through the play-offs. 
They will be strengthened by the return tomorrow of Craig Sibbald, who had trials at Luton over the summer. Other clubs were interested in him but were ultimately put off by the development fee that Falkirk would have been due for the out of contract midfielder. He signed a new Falkirk contract last week. 
Falkirk have signed 4 new players this summer, the fewest of any club in the Championship: goalkeepers David Mitchell and Robbie Mutch, winger Alex Harris and striker Rory Loy (for his second spell with the club). 

Picture

Sean Murdoch and Jason Talbot

Dunfermline
Victory tomorrow would put the Pars 6 points ahead of Falkirk in the Championship. With new signing Andy Ryan netting twice on his debut in midweek against Arbroath, manager Allan Johnston now has real options up front, even in the absence of Nicky Clark, who himself is back in training. The previous League game, before Ryan signing and with Declan McManus completing a 2 game League suspension, saw Callum Snith and David Hopkirk start the game as the team’s front two, with both scoring. Ordinarily it would be almost unfair to replace one, far less two, goalscorers, but McManus has also started the season well, while Ryan has been a long-time target and it would not be a surprise if he started the game. 
In defence, after missing the Challenge Cup game on Tuesday through suspension, centre half Lee Ashcroft will return, while left back Jason Talbot has been a steadying influence on the back 4 since his return to the team last Saturday. The midfield should be the same as in the Inverness game. None of the fringe players who started against Arbroath did enough to force their way into the starting 11 for games such as this.
​Preferred starting 11, based on comments above:

Picture

Sean Murdoch/Jason Talbot photo plus Peter Houston edit by Pars Review.
​Match report/opinion with photos will be posted here around 9.00pm tomorrow evening.

Picture

Tuesday’s 2-0 win over Arbroath marked Allan Johnston’s 100th game in charge of Dunfermline. In modern day football management, 100 games is almost an eternity: consider that in Johnston’s time at East End Park (since May 2015), St Mirren have had 5 different managers (go back a further 12 months and the figure becomes 7). Continuity is a rare element in football, yet it can be rewarding, and not only at the very top end of the game with Sir Alex Ferguson or Arsene Wenger; in Scottish football, St Mirren’s managerial revolving door has coincided with relegation from the Premiership, near-relegation to League 1, while a similar size club such as Partick Thistle, where Alan Archibald has been manager since January 2013, have risen from the Championship to become an established Premiership club, culminating in a top 6 finish last season, their highest League position in 36 years.
Allan Johnston’s record at East End Park, with a starting point further down the SPFL pyramid than Archibald at Partick, has similarities: at the end of season 2014/15, Dunfermline were the lowest-ranked full time club in the 4 senior divisions, having finished the season in 7th position in League 1, the club’s second season in the third tier of Scottish football. The first season, 2013/14, saw the club finish runners-up to Rangers but lose a promotion play-off final to Cowdenbeath. The second season saw manager Jim Jefferies leave the club, replaced by coach John Potter. The hardy bunch of fans, who included myself and my son, who went to Stranraer on a soaking wet day in February 2015 to see Dunfermline lose 5-1, will remember that day as being representative of that awful season. All the more reason for not falling into the trap of diminishing Johnston’s achievement in romping to the title the next season. The theory that as the “biggest” club in the division, promotion was almost a given, was certainly not the case the season before Johnston arrived. 
A raft of new signings joined the club upon Johnston’s arrival, among them Callum Fordyce, Joe Cardle, Michael Paton and Sean Murdoch. The emergence of Faissal El Bakhtaoui, who had been at the club since 2012 but who had only broken into the first team on a regular basis in 2014/15, saw a new, exciting Pars team begin the season in scintillating form: the first 4 competitive fixtures resulting in the following victories:
​25 July (Challenge Cup): 4-1 v Arbroath
1 August (League Cup): 5-1 v Cowdenbeath
8 August (League): 6-1 v Brechin City
15 August (League): 7-1 v Cowdenbeath
Soon after, on 25 August, Dunfermline defeated Premiership Dundee 3-1 in the League Cup and then took Dundee United, then a top 6 Premiership club, to extra time in the same competition at Tannadice before going down in extra time.

Picture

The League 1 title was won, and last season Johnston led the club to fifth place in the Championship, narrowly missing out on a promotion play-off place despite a poor start to the season. From November onwards, the club went on a run of just 1 defeat in 14 League games as Johnston’s team, with new arrivals Kallum Higginbotham, Nicky Clark and Paul McMullan all key to his attacking formation, all making significant contributions. 
Johnston is not without faults: he sticks rigidly to 4-4-2, a policy which backfires on occasion, most notably last week at Ibrox when what was already a slow centre midfield was out numbered and overrun by Rangers. He can be slow to make substitutions, except when really pushed to do so, as was the case at Livingston this season, and at Ibrox a few days later, when he made first half substitutions in games that were not going Dunfermline’s way. There is a reluctance to freshen up the side during the second half of games, but that is a minor quibble in what has been a very successful period in charge: in his 100 games, he has won 51, drawn 25 and lost 24. 193 goals have been scored with 114 conceded. His teams have scored goals in big numbers: 4 goals have been scored in 6 different games, 5 goals on 8 occasions, 6 goals in 3 different games, plus the 7 goals scored in the game against Cowdenbeath, listed above. While Johnston is primarily an attack-minded manager, a club record was set in 2015/16 for minutes without conceding a League goal.
As with many things in life, his time at the club might not be fully appreciated until it is over. His managerial career started well at Queen of the South, winning League 1 and the Challenge Cup, which earned him a move to Premiership Kilmarnock. He resigned from that job after a disagreement with his directors, before joining Dunfermline 3 months later. At 43, he is still a relatively young manager but has the experience of 5 years in management, on a mostly upward trajectory. Hopefully his next achievement, during his second 100 games in charge, will be leading Dunfermline back into the top division of Scottish football. 

​Photo and edit by Pars Review.

Picture

​All photos & video content by Pars Review. The Pars Review matchday vlog is hosted by DA Talk YouTube channel: goo.gl/D5x2sm

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

Irn Bru lacks fizz despite Ryan’s debut double

New signing Andy Ryan marked his Dunfermline debut with 2 first half goals that were the highlight of an Irn Bru Cup tie that felt more like a pre-season friendly than a game in a national cup competition. As always with Dick Campbell’s teams when they visit East End Park, Arbroath had a player red carded. Conner Duthie was also sent off, in the final minute, for a second yellow card. 
As he stated at the weekend, Pars boss Allan Johnston made 6 changes to the team that defeated Inverness at the weekend. In came Conner Duthie, Fraser Aird, Scott Lochhead, Aaron Splaine, Michael Paton and Andy Ryan. Jason Talbot moved from his usual left back slot to central defence, alongside Callum Morris. 
Dunfermline began the game shooting towards the away end. The much-changed team were understandably taking time to link up with the fluidity of the recognised first choice 11. Fraser Aird was a busy figure on the right, eager to make an impression after a disappointing start to his Pars career, subbed at Livingston on his debut after 37 minutes and not having played since. The midfield duo of Paton and Splaine, together with Scott Lochhead on the left, were industrious but did not do enough to threaten players such as Joe Cardle, Kallum Higginbotham and Big Nat when it comes to team selection for Saturday’s League game with Falkirk. 
Ryan was a prolific scorer with previous club Airdrie and he took just 25 minutes to open his Pars account, shooting past ex-Par David Hutton in the visitors’ goal. Arbroath were then reduced to 10 men after half an hour when Ricky Little pulled down David Hopkirk just outside the penalty box. A fairly uneventful first half briefly lit up again after 40 minutes when Ryan headed his and Dunfermline’s second goal. 

Picture

Andy Ryan

The second half saw Arbroath press the Pars goal despite being a man down. Dunfermline’s attacks were sporadic and ineffectual, with Aird coming closest with a 20 yard shot. Subs Declan McManus, Callum Smith and Big Nat were brought on, but the Pars were unable to test Hutton. Late in the game, Arbroath hit the bar from a free kick, then with seconds remaining Duthie was sent off for 2 bookable offences. 
The game suggested that players such as Lochhead and Splaine are better utilised as substitutes rather than starters. Andy Ryan can be very satisfied with his debut, fitting in well and enhancing his reputation as a natural finisher.
Pars starting 11 & subs:

Picture

Tomorrow: match photo gallery & matchday vlog will be uploaded. 
Photos & edits in this article by Pars Review.

Picture

Andy Ryan. Photo: Pars Review

22 year old striker Andy Ryan joined Dunfermline today on a 2 year contract from Airdrie. An (undisclosed) fee was involved as the player still had a year remaining on his Airdrie contract. Back in May, my son and I were at the Airdrie v Alloa promotion play-off first leg game, when Ryan scored the only goal in a 1-0 Airdrie win. We were immediately impressed with the young striker (see Tweet below), and having spotted Allan Johnston and Sandy Clark in the stand, also remarked on Twitter:

Picture

Andy Ryan was also among the players listed in the Pars Review article “Scouting”, from March this year: www.parsreview.org/blog/scouting. He began his career at Hamilton, starting 21 games but spending the majority of his time on loan at Brechin and Arbroath. His next move, signing for Forfar in 2016, produced 9 goals in 17 games. It was during that period that I first saw Ryan play, in the 2-2 draw between the Pars and Forfar at EEP in April 2016, in which Ryan scored. A move to Airdrie followed last summer, and he ended the season as the top scorer in Scotland, with 27 goals in 41 games. 

Picture

Ryan in action v Alloa, May 2017. Photo: Pars Review

This is exactly the type of player required for a promotion challenge this season. A proven goalscorer, Ryan is also pacy and physically bears a resemblance to Faissal El Bakhtaoui in his build and movement. As the Tweets and the blog “Scouting” article referenced above would suggest, I am delighted with this signing. 
The YouTube video below shows all 27 of his Airdrie goals from last season.
Pars Review makes no claim to the video content, which belongs to the uploader (Airdrie Supporters Trust) and has been posted here as a link from their YouTube channel, with no infringements:

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture Picture
Picture

George Peebles

Picture

Ron Mailer

Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture

Match Previews

PREVIEW: DUNDEE UNITED (H) 27/08/19

After the diversion of last week’s memorable trip to Parkhead in the Betfred Cup, it’s back to League [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: QUEEN OF THE SOUTH (A) 10/08/19

The long trip to Dumfries tomorrow will reunite several members of the Pars squad and staff with familiar [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: CELTIC (A) 17/08/19

And so, into the lion’s den we go. Attempting to do what no other Scottish club has done [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: ARBROATH (A) 31/08/19

Dunfermline travel up the Angus coast tomorrow in the fourth week of games of this season’s Championship, looking [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: PARTICK THISTLE (A) 21/09/19

The Championship’s bottom 2 teams go head to head at Firhill tomorrow with both Dunfermline and Partick Thistle [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: INVERNESS (H) 14/09/19

Still searching for a first League win of the season, Dunfermline take on an in-form Inverness team on [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: MORTON (A) 05/10/19

Dunfermline travel to Greenock tomorrow, hoping to become the first team in this season’s Championship to take even [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: ALLOA (H) 28/09/19

Dunfermline go into tomorrow’s Championship game against Alloa on the back of a first League win of the [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: AYR UNITED (H) 19/10/19

The first quarter of the Championship season ends tomorrow with all teams having faced each other once by [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: ROSS COUNTY (A) 09/04/19

First plays fifth in tomorrow’s Championship match at The Global Energy Stadium in Dingwall.  Hosts Ross County have [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: FALKIRK (H) 13/04/19

Fifth plays tenth in tomorrow’s Championship game at East End Park, with Dunfermline still clinging onto faint hopes [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: PARTICK THISTLE (H) 26/02/19

Fifth plays tenth in tomorrow’s Championship match at East End Park, with Dunfermline looking for a third consecutive [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: AYR UNITED (A) 23/02/19

Second plays seventh in tomorrow’s Championship match at Somerset Park, with Dunfermline looking to build upon last week’s [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: QUEEN OF THE SOUTH (H) 02/03/19

Fifth plays seventh in tomorrow’s Championship match at East End Park, with Dunfermline in form and having recorded [...]

Match Previews

PREVIEW: ALLOA (H) 07/09/19

After a winless start to the League campaign, Dunfermline have a Tunnock’s Caramel Wafer Challenge Cup fixture this [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v Queen Of The South

The first meeting of the clubs in 5 years sees a host of former players and coaching staff [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Dumbarton v Pars

Scottish Championship – Saturday 29/10/16 – KO 3.00pm –​Cheaper Insurance Direct Stadium, DumbartonOdds (Skybet): Dumbarton 13/8; Dunfermline 29/20; [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v Arbroath

Betfred Cup – Tuesday 19 July 2016 – East End Park – KO 7.45pm Dunfermline’s first competitive fixture of [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v Hibs

Scottish Championship – Saturday 22/10/16 – KO 3.00pm – East End ParkOdds (Skybet): Dunfermline 7/2; Draw 13/5; Hibs [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Falkirk v Pars

Scottish Championship – Saturday 15/10/16 – KO 3.00pm – The Falkirk StadiumOdds (Skybet): Falkirk 5/6; Dunfermline 14/5; Draw [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v Dundee United

Dunfermline’s next test in what is a predictably challenging Championship campaign comes against the second favourites for the [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Raith Rovers v Pars

Dunfermline go into the Fife derby facing an on-form home side who are already top of the Championship [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v St Mirren

Scottish Championship – Saturday 24/09/16 – KO 5.15pm – Live on BBC AlbaOdds (Skybet): Dunfermline 21/20; St Mirren [...]

Match Previews

Match preview: Pars v Queen’s Park

Irn Bru Challenge Cup – Saturday 08/10/16 – KO 3.00pm – East End ParkOdds (Skybet): Dunfermline 4/11; Draw 7/2; [...]