Blog Archives

Picture

​Scottish Championship – Saturday 01/04/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park
Odds (Ladbrokes): Dunfermline 10/3; Draw 5/2; Hibs 5/6

Dunfermline go into tomorrow’s game against division leaders Hibs on a run of just 2 defeats in the past 16 League games, yet only 4 points clear of the relegation play-off position. Hibs failed to take a huge step towards winning the title with a goalless draw against second place Morton in midweek, but in avoiding defeat they also prevented their lead being cut. After scoring an injury time winner in their game against Falkirk last weekend, while Dunfermline were ending Morton’s 364 day unbeaten home record, this has been a good week overall for Hibs. If Hibs are to be promoted, Lennon will have done the job he was brought in last summer to do.

Picture

Michael Paton in action against Hibs, in the game at East End Park in October. Photo: Pars Review.

Our opponents​ – 
Hibs

Last five outings:
29 March – Championship – Drew 0-0 v Morton (H)
25 March – Championship – Won 2-1 v Falkirk (H)
18 March – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Dumbarton (H)
10 March – Championship – Drew 1-0 v Dundee United (A)
4 March – Scottish Cup – Won 3-1 v Ayr United (H)

​Pre-game comments
Hibs fans have claimed that their team has played “winning” football as opposed to the more attractive brand of play they enjoyed under previous manager Alan Stubbs. That was presumably Neil Lennon’s remit: win. Promotion is essential to the club which is now in its third season in the second tier. That is unacceptable for a club that are the current Scottish Cup holders and who attracted a crowd of over 15,000 to the midweek home game against Morton. Hibs belong in the Premiership and are likely to be back there very soon.

Numbers game
Hibs have spent an average of just 9 minutes behind in League games this season: contrast that to Dundee United, rated pre-season as Hibs’ biggest rivals for the Championship title, who have spent an average of 21 minutes per game trailing.
Hibs have only had a half-time lead in 2 of their 15 away League games this season. They have gone onto win 9 of those 15 games, more than they have won at home (7).

In the dugout
Neil Lennon
A divisive figure, who has been a controversial character ion Scottish football for many years, as a player and manager at Celtic, and now as Hibs manager. Sent to the stand in the midweek game against Morton, despite protesting his innocence, he also said that “I didn’t start it, but if it comes to blows, it comes to blows”, referring to his part in the scenes below when a player from each side was sent off late in the game. 

Picture

Pars & Hibs facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 2
Draws: 3
Hibs wins: 5

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

13 August 2016 – Hibs 2, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-hibs-2-pars-1

22 October 2016 – Pars 1, Hibs 3
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-hibs-3

25 February 2017: Hibs 2, Pars 2
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-hibs-2-pars-2​

Connections
Only 1 player in Hibs first team squad has Dunfermline connections – striker Lewis Allan, currently on loan to Edinburgh City, played 8 games for the Pars in a loan spell from Hibs in 2015.
From the current Pars squad, Sean Murdoch was at Easter Road from 2012-2014, mainly as a back-up keeper, making just 2 appearances.

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

Dunfermline
Last five outings:
25 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Morton (A)
18 March – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Ayr United (H)
11 March – Championship – Drew 0-0 v St Mirren (A)
7 March – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Queen of the South (H)
4 March – Championship – Won 5-1 v Dumbarton (H)
​
Pre-game comments
Last week’s win at Morton was one of the Pars best performances of the season, and with the return from injury after a 1 game absence for both Andy Geggan and Paul McMullan, saw the established first 11 back in action. As covered in “The Squad” article on this site 2 days ago (www.parsreview.org/blog/the-squad) the 11 players who started against Morton, plus Rhys McCabe and Michael Paton from the substitutes, would form a good squad for next season, with around 6 additions in certain areas to provide competition and back-up. Ben Richards-Everton continues his recovery from long-term injury, while Lewis Martin is training and may feature on the bench. David Hopkirk has another niggling injury. 
Preferred line-up:
Although Rhys McCabe did well in his appearance as a sub last week, I would start with the same team that began the game at Morton.
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Picture

A round-up Championship news, latest results, statistics and a look ahead to this week’s fixtures  ​

The destination of the Championship title has moved strongly in Hibs’ direction over the past few days. On Saturday, Hibs scored an injury time winner against Falkirk, while Morton were losing at home for the first time in 364 days to Dunfermline. Last night, Hibs faced Morton at Easter Road and the game ended goalless, which will suit Hibs far more than their visitors. Morton still have a game in hand over Hibs, and the teams meet each other once more this season at Cappielow in April. The gap is now 10 points, but it could just as easily have been 5, or even 2. 
Falkirk have now lost consecutive games to Morton and Hibs, ending a 7 game unbeaten run that had taken them to second place. They are now a point behind Morton and have played a game more, and as it stands would face Dundee United home and away in the promotion play-off quarter finals, for teams that finish 3rd and 4th in the division. The winner of that round then play the division runners up, with the winner of that tie playing the 11th place Premiership team to decide who goes up or who stays down. 

Picture

Ross Forbes, Morton. Photo: Pars Review

Dundee United won the Irn Bru Challenge Cup on Saturday, defeating St Mirren 2-1 with goals from their top scorer Tony Andreu and Thomas Mikkelsen. Both United scorers are on loan, and given the well-documented financial problems at Tannadice, will be likely to return to their parent clubs at the end of this season, especially if United fail to win promotion. United followed up their Cup win with a 2-1 home win over Ayr United in the Championship on Tuesday, their first League victory since early February, a run of 5 games without a win. 

Picture

Tony Andreu (Dundee United)

The bottom of the division continues to be highly competitive, with St Mirren still last but sitting second in the current form table (past 8 games). Saints have now lost just once in 7 games, and have a crucial home game this weekend against Ayr United, the team directly above them in 9th place. St Mirren also have a game in hand, and should they win it, there would only be 3 points separating the bottom 4 clubs. Sixth place Dunfermline also have a game in hand over the 3 clubs directly below them in 7th, 8th and 9th positions, but are currently just 4 points off the 9th place relegation play-off place, such is the congestion at the lower end of the division.
Here is the Championship table:

Picture

This weekend’s Championship fixtures:
Dumbarton v Morton
Dunfermline v Hibs
Falkirk v Raith Rovers
Queen of the South v Dundee United
St Mirren v Ayr United

Championship top scorers (League games only):
16 goals – Jason Cummings (Hibs)
13 – Stephen Dobbie (Queen of the South)
12 – Nicky Clark (Dunfermline)
11 – Tony Andreu (Dundee United)
10 – Craig Sibbald (Falkirk)

Odds to win the division (Ladbrokes):
Hibs 1/40
Morton 25/1
Dundee United 25/1
Falkirk 50/1

In numbers:
Of the 4 teams leading the SPFL divisions this season, Hibs have by far the poorest goalscoring record, with 46 League goals. Premiership leaders Celtic have scored 76 League goals; League 1 top side Livingston have 65; while League 2 leaders Forfar have scored 59 times. Even the second placed teams in the other divisions (Aberdeen, Alloa and Arbroath) have scored more than Hibs.  ​
Ayr United have won 3 of their past 5 League games, after going 15 games without a win. 
Perhaps surprisingly given their battle against relegation, Dumbarton are the division’s third top scoring team, and have scored in every one of their past 9 games. 

Following yesterday’s article on the Pars squad for next season – who to retain or release from the current group of players – today we look at the areas of the team/squad identified for new signings to challenge the current players and provide competition within the squad. 
After stating that I would retain the entire established “first 11” – the team that played Morton, which is Allan Johnston’s regular starting 11 when all players are fit and available – the following positions were listed as requiring new signings – partly because some current players are not providing enough competition in these positions, and also to improve on what we already have within the squad:

Goalkeeper (a quality number 2 keeper)
Right back
2 Central defenders (preferably 1 of whom is left-sided and can also cover at full-back)
Winger
2 forwards (including 1 tall striker)

Whoever might be brought in would be in competition with the current starting 11, with the objective being to ensure that in the event of injuries and suspensions, replacements are at least of the same quality as the players they are replacing.

Some of Allan Johnston’s best signings have been players who have been released from Premiership clubs and who are still at a good age (22-27) and have the quality to rebuild their careers in the second tier and aim to return to the top division with Dunfermline: Lee Ashcroft, Callum Morris, Kallum Higginbotham and Nat Wedderburn all were released from top flight clubs but have made a big impact at East End Park. With that recruitment policy in mind, this article looks at some Premiership players who would be realistic signing targets for Dunfermline, and who play in the positions listed above. I have focused mainly on players who are out of contract this summer, and so would not involve a transfer fee. The article also looks at some of the better options from the Championship and League 1. All the players featured in this article are under 30.

Goalkeeper
There are only 6 Premiership first team squad goalkeepers out of contract this summer. Some, such as Craig Samson, Allan Mannus and Neil Alexander are either unrealistic or the wrong age to be targeted by Dunfermline. One option could be 26 year old David Mitchell of Dundee, who has been restricted to just 4 appearances this season. He signed for Dundee in 2015 and had previously played 227 times for Stranraer from 2009-2015. 

Picture

David Mitchell

Right back
Motherwell’s David Ferguson (21) has had first team chances limited this season but could be a good addition to the Pars squad. He has been loaned to Airdrie, Annan and Alloa over the past 2 seasons, gaining first team experience, but has found it hard to break into the Motherwell team. 
Ayr United captain Nicky Devlin (23) will be a target for clubs this summer and would be a very good option at right back. 

Central defenders
One of the Championship’s most consistent central defenders this season has been Queen of the South’s Darren Brownlie. At 22 years old, he has good experience with 127 appearances in his career to date. He has been a regular for Queens this season and is no stranger to Fife, having played for Cowdenbeath in season 2014/15.
Jean Yves M’Voto has been a standout player for Raith Rovers this season, and is out of contract in June. The 28 year old French defender has played in the UK since 2008, with this season being his first in Scotland. He is a dominant centre-half and has made 33 appearances this season for Rovers.

Winger
Depending on Paul McMullan’s future (on loan from Celtic, where his contract expires this summer), another left winger and Celtic loanee could be an option for Dunfermline – Aidan Nesbitt (20), currently on loan at Morton (as was McMullan last season). 
Another on loan winger could be temped to East End Park – Motherwell’s Dom Thomas (21), currently on loan at Queen of the South. Motherwell might prefer him to gain another year’s experience on loan at a good level.

Picture

Dom Thomas

Forwards
Inverness striker Henri Anier (26) has also played for Motherwell and Dundee United in recent seasons and would offer a greater physical presence than our current strikers. He has not featured regularly for Inverness since signing for them on a 6 month deal in January but was a success during his time at Motherwell in 2013/14, and has also played for Dundee United.
In League 1, 22 year old Airdrie striker Andy Ryan has scored 20 goals in 34 games this season. He is under contract until 2018 but a deal could be possible, especially if Airdrie do not achieve promotion this season.

Some of the players included in this article would be more realistic than others to Dunfermline. There will, of course, be many other players that the club will have in mind, from other divisions and other countries. If you have any suggestions, please leave a comment here, or via the Pars Review Facebook or Twitter pages. ​​

Yesterday, Pars Review put a poll on Twitter asking fans about the number of new players needed to improve the current playing squad. This is on the basis that we retain our Championship status. We are still just 4 points off the relegation play-off place, which seems incredible given that we have lost only 2 League games since November. However, our goal difference is better than any of the teams below us, and we have a game in hand over 2 of the teams who are immediately below us. 
In the same way that Morton consolidated their Championship place in 2015/16, after winning League 1 in 2014/15, and this season have made a promotion bid, the Pars will be looking to do the same next season, after last season’s League 1 title triumph, and this season’s return to the Championship. The team’s form has fluctuated, with excellent recent performances at Hibs and Morton in between dire home displays against Queen of the South and Ayr. At their best, Dunfermline can compete with the current top 4 clubs, but the squad will require some changes to produce wins in games that have been drawn this season. 
The Twitter poll is shown below. I would agree with the majority vote.

Picture

The Hibs and Morton away games set the standard for how the team can perform. I have approached this article with that in mind, taking a positive view of how well these players can play, and not based on how poor they have been in other games.  To compete at the top end of the division next season, I believe that the current first 11 are all capable and should all be retained if possible. Players such as Paul McMullan are on loan and in McMullan’s case out of contract with his parent club, Celtic, at the end of this season.
Greater strength in depth is required. New signings should not just be marginal improvements on the current substitutes, but players who are on the same level – or better – than the current starting 11, and who will put greater pressure on the current team than the players who are squad members this season, few of whom have made a strong case for being part of the team. Some are decent subs and are good options as cover – I would retain Rhys McCabe and Michael Paton from this season’s regular substitutes. Others are not good enough, and some have another year left on their contracts, and so may remain because they would struggle to secure full time football with other clubs. Loaning certain players out, if possible, would be a good option. Any new signings should then be players who would put in a strong challenge for a first team place. Despite my criticism of the team in recent match reports, I believe the starting 11 are good enough to challenge for a play-off place next season, especially if they are supplemented by a stronger group of players than the current substitutes. 

Picture

2 players currently on loan: Gavin Reilly and Paul McMullan. Photo: Pars Review

Conclusion:
In reality, some players will move on, others may be retained due to their contracts still having a year to run. I have listed the players who are out of contract this summer and who I would retain or release; also listed are players under contract until 2018, and others who are on loan. Of the players contracted until 2018, I have indicated whether they should stay or whether a deal to release them (which would involve renegotiating the final year of their contract) or loan them out should be considered. I am aware that this might not be possible in reality.

Contracts ending summer 2017
Goalkeepers
David Hutton – release
Defenders
Callum Fordyce – release
Andy Geggan – retain
Callum Morris – retain
Ben Richards-Everton – release
Jason Talbot – retain
Ryan Williamson – release
Midfielders & Wingers
Kallum Higginbotham – retain
Rhys McCabe – retain
Michael Paton – retain
Lewis Spence – release
Nat Wedderburn – retain
Forwards
Michael Moffat – retain

Contracts ending 2018:
Goalkeepers
Sean Murdoch – retain
Defenders
Lee Ashcroft – retain
Lewis Martin – loan out if possible
Midfielders & Wingers
Joe Cardle – release/loan out if possible
Forwards
Nicky Clark – retain
David Hopkirk – release if possible

On loan:
John Herron – retain
Paul McMullan – retain
Gavin Reilly – return to parent club

New signings needed in the following areas:
Goalkeeper (mainly as number 2 to Sean Murdoch)
Right back (competition/cover for Andy Geggan)
Centre half (or 2 centre-halves, including 1 who can cover at left back)
Winger
2 forwards

Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture Picture

A vastly improved performance that combined skill, tenacity, hard work and with every player making a positive contribution. After the dismal team display against Ayr, this week the game was played on the floor, no aimless high balls, and some of the link-up play was tremendous to watch. There was a steely determination to win the game despite the hosts being unbeaten at home for 364 days, and the joint top of the current form table. 
Andy Geggan and Paul McMullan returned from injury and the team was along familiar lines. The contrast between today and the past 2 home games was evident from the start. Dunfermline were playing a fluent passing game, a return to the standard set against Hibs at Easter Road. This is the standard that the team are capable of. 
The game kicked off in glorious sunshine, and the teams both attacked each other from the outset. Nicky Clark had an early attempt that went wide, while former Pars loan striker Lawrence Shankland went close for Morton. After 16 minutes, the Pars took the lead when a Kallum Higginbotham corner was touched on by Nicky Clark to Nat Wedderburn to tap in, for his first Dunfermline goal. Referee Mat Northcroft harshly booked big Nat for celebrating with the Pars fans behind the goal. 
The referee was card-happy and was to book a total of 7 players. One booking that was fully deserved was a penalty box dive from ex-Par Ross Forbes, an embarrassment from a talented player who does not need to resort to such cheating. 
Morton were pressing for an equaliser but the Pars defence held firm. Goalkeeper Sean Murdoch was assured, and his handling excellent. His defenders all had very good games, with captain Andy Geggan a driving force. Jason Talbot had his best game for some time, an always-consistent player who had a particularly good game today. Central defenders Lee Ashcroft and Callum Morris were in great form, with Morris having his best game for the club since returning in January.  In midfield, Nat Wedderburn was dominant, a human shield who simply cannot be knocked off the ball, while John Herron played well before going off injured. Wingers Paul McMullan and Kallum Higginbotham had good games, and both worked very hard to help their full-backs. Up front, the Moff was at the heart of all the best Pars passing moves, never wasting possession, a creative force who is indispensable in this form. Nicky Clark was unlucky not to score, and showed phenomenal work rate throughout, often seen helping back in defence. 

Picture

Big Nat

​The second half saw more chances for each team: a great move involving some one touch play from Nat Wedderburn, John Herron and Nicky Clark ended with Clark’s shot being turned round the post by Morton keeper Derek Gaston. Referee Northcroft then controversially disallowed a second Pars goal, scored by Morris with a firm header. Initially no one realised it had been disallowed, but the referee saw an infringement. 
Murdoch was alert save a long range effort from Morton’s Andy Murdoch, and then reacted well to tip over a Kudus Oyenuga header. Up the other end, Pars sub Rhys McCabe’s goal-bound shot was well saved by Gaston, while Paul McMullan failed to capitalise on a pinpoint Higginbotham pass, that left him with only Gaston to beat, but finished weakly. The Moff was denied by Gaston when a long run up the wing from Jason Talbot saw the full back find Moffat with a deep cross, and only Gaston’s outstretched hand prevented a goal. 
McCabe had replaced the injured John Herron, and later in the game there were 2 further Pars substitutions: the Moff, who had a superb game, was replaced by David Hopkirk, and then Joe Cardle was brought on late for McMullan.
The final whistle ended Morton’s long unbeaten home run, and the Pars players celebrated with the travelling supporters. All except sub David Hopkirk, who ran straight up the tunnel, for reasons only known to himself. Togetherness is a huge part of any provincial team’s success, and the players and fans enjoyed the moment on what was another memorable trip to Cappielow.
Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:

Picture

Photos by Pars Review.
​Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.

Picture Picture

​Scottish Championship – Saturday 25/03/17 – KO 3.00pm – Cappielow Park
Odds (Ladbrokes): Morton 7/5; Draw 9/4; Dunfermline 19/10

Tomorrow’s opponents have set a standard that Dunfermline will hope to emulate themselves next season, challenging for promotion in a second season back in the Championship, after a season of consolidation following promotion. Morton won League 1 in season 2014/15 and have exceeded expectations by climbing to third place this season, and with 2 games in hand on second place Falkirk, who they defeated last weekend, and a game in hand over leaders Hibs, who they play on Wednesday next week. Dunfermline will be looking to bounce back from the dismal 1-0 home defeat to Ayr United, a result which combined with wins for St Mirren and Raith and a draw for Dumbarton meant that the group of clubs at the lower end of the League table were pulled closer together.

Picture

Lewis Martin, Morton v Pars, 17 September 2016

Our opponents​ – 
Morton

Last five outings:
11 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Falkirk (A)
11 March – Championship – Won 1-0 v Queen of the South (H)
25 February – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Dundee United (A)
18 February – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Falkirk (H)
12 February – Scottish Cup – Lost 2-1 v Rangers (A)

​
Pre-game comments
With the best home record in the Championship this season, and currently joint top of the recent form table, Morton are strong contenders for not only for promotion through the play-offs but also the title itself, with a crucial game against Hibs following the Pars’ visit to Greenock tomorrow. Their season began with no wins in the opening 5 League games, until a 2-1 win over Dunfermline on 17 September. The loss of star striker Jai Quitongo, to an injury sustained in the 2-1 loss to the Pars at East End Park on 10 December, has not derailed Morton’s progress. That defeat is one of only rwo losses in the League in the past 20 games.

Numbers game
If Morton avoid losing tomorrow’s game, they will complete a full 12 months undefeated at home, with their last defeat at Cappielow coming on 26 March 2016. 
Morton have won 13 consecutive home games. 
Morton have scored in 24 of their 27 League games so far this season. 

In the dugout
Jim Duffy
A Morton legend as a player, Jim Duffy was a talented central defender who won the Scottish Players’ Player of the Year award in 1985 when playing for a Morton team who were relegated from the Premier Division. Injury curtailed his career progress and he entered management with Falkirk at the age of 29. He has since managed Dundee (twice), Hibs, Brechin and Clyde, and was a temporary manager at Norwich, in addition to coaching jobs at Chelsea and Portsmouth. Duffy has a strong case for winning Manager of the Year this season, transforming his team into promotion contenders and having reached the semi finals of the League Cup and the fifth round of the Scottish Cup . This was despite enduring heavy criticism from Morton supporters earlier in the season, before leading his team to their current run of form, and remaining undefeated at home.

Picture

Andy Geggan, Morton v Pars, 17 September 2016

Pars & Morton facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 2
Draws: 1
Morton wins: 7

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

17 September 2016 – Morton 2, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-morton-2-pars-1​

10 December 2016 – Pars 2, Morton 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-2-morton-1​

Connections
Two Morton players have previously played for Dunfermline: Ross Forbes was at East End Park from January 2014 until the end of season 2014/15. He spent the second half of that season on loan at Morton before signing for them in July 2015. Lawrence Shankland scored 7 goals for the Pars in a 14 game loan spell from Aberdeen in 2014.
From the current Pars squad, Paul McMullan was at Morton on loan from Celtic from February to June last year, while David Hutton played 3 games for Morton in season 2012/13. 

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
18 March – Championship – Lost 1-0 v Ayr United (H)
11 March – Championship – Drew 0-0 v St Mirren (A)
7 March – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Queen of the South (H)
4 March – Championship – Won 5-1 v Dumbarton (H)
25 February – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Hibs (A)
​

Pre-game comments
Allan Johnston was forced to change his starting line-up last week due to injuries to Andy Geggan and Paul McMullan. Both players are now back in training, and McMullan’s call-up to the Scotland Under 21 squad will not prevent him featuring in tomorrow’s game, if he is fit. Two other players are definitely unavailable – Ben Richards-Everton is continuing his recovery from long term injury and Lewis Martin is still a week away from full fitness.
The team were poor against Ayr last week, despite Allan Johnston now doing his usual revisionism as the week goes on, talking up a performance that he initially criticised a few days earlier. The last time there was such disappointment after a game was following the dire penalty shoot-out loss at Hamilton, after which Dunfermline produced a great display against Hibs at Easter Road. Let’s hope for a repeat of that tomorrow. 
Preferred line-up:
If Geggan and McMullan are fit, they have to return to the starting 11. I would also rest John Herron and give Rhys McCabe a start. 
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Michael Moffat is now in his third season as a Pars player and is possibly the most enigmatic player in the squad, dividing opinion among fans, mainly due to the differing expectations relating to his output. Signed from Ayr United in the summer of 2014 by then-Pars boss Jim Jefferies, the move was greeted enthusiastically by Dunfermline fans. Here was a striker who had scored 46 goals in 77 appearances for Ayr in the previous 2 seasons, and a total of 65 goals in total for the club. Seen as a natural finisher, he opened his Pars account with a very well taken goal against Annan in the League Cup in August 2014. By mid-September he had scored 4 goals, but then went on a run of 16 games without scoring; when he ended that sequence in January 2015, it was followed by a further 10 game goalless run, and he ended the season with 6 goals in 41 appearances. He was not helped by the miserable displays of a massively under-performing Dunfermline side, who finished seventh in League 1 and who had one manager (Jefferies) “resign” in mid-season, and another (John Potter) relieved of first team manager duties at the end of the season but retained by the club as a coach. 

Picture

The Moff in the Scottish Cup game against Hamilton at EEP on 11 February 2017

Last season was to prove much more successful for Moffat and the team, winning League 1 in style, with Moffat scoring 15 times, and proving to be the perfect striking partner for the emerging Faissal El Bakhtaoui. Moffat was the ideal foil for the French-Moroccan, and used his experience to guide the young forward through games, and unselfishly watched as El Bakhtaoui hit 30 goals and won multiple Player of the Year awards. Moffat’s contribution did not go unrecognised by the fans, and indeed this blog named him as the Player of the Season based on having the most Man of the Match awards on the blog’s match reports over the season – one more than El Bakhtaoui. The photo below shows Moffat accepting his Pars Review award at the club’s end of season awards event. 

Picture

This season has seen the Moff evolve into a play-maker as opposed to a typical number 9 goal poacher. His goal return has been modest – 5 goals to date, with echoes of his first season, as he has played through spells without a goal that have lasted 14 games, and then another of 12 games. During these lean periods, he has continued to contribute with a total of 9 goal assists – the second highest of any player in the squad, behind Kallum Higginbotham, averaging a goal assist every 234 minutes. As a striker, his assists total compares favourably with strikers from other Championship clubs: Jason Cummings of Hibs has 4 assists (1 every 563 minutes), Stephen Dobbie of Queen of the South has 11 assists (playing more minutes than Moffat, with an average of 1 assist every 273 minutes) while Falkirk’s John Baird has 6 (an assist every 403 minutes). However, these players have out-scored Moffat, and so the debate as to his value to the team will continue. 

Picture

Moffat in the pre-season friendly against Hearts on 9 July 2016

A highly likeable character, Moffat has possibly the best footballing ability of any current Pars player – his touch, link-up play and passing ability are of a high standard, and for a player who is now 32, he still has a fair degree of pace, and is a very hard worker. At times he has appeared to lack confidence in front of goal, looking to pass to a team mate instead of shooting. At other times he has been unlucky not to have scored more, including the most recent game, against Ayr, when he hit the post with a glancing header and then forced an excellent save from Ayr keeper Greg Fleming with a shot from inside the penalty box. 
If Moffat was more clinical he would be playing for a Premiership side, as the other key elements of his game, as noted above, are all in place. I would like him to remain at East End Park beyond the end of his current 1 year contract, as I feel he still has much to contribute to the team, despite his goal tally being less than hoped for. ​

​Photos by Pars Review.

Picture Picture

Most goal assists for Pars players this season, in League & Cup competitions:
10 – Kallum Higginbotham
9 – Michael Moffat
5 – Nicky Clark, Gavin Reilly
4 – Jason Talbot

Picture

Dunfermline have kept a clean sheet in just 1 of this season’s 14 home games in the Championship. In contrast, there have been 5 shut-outs in the 14 away fixtures. 

Picture

36% of the Pars home League games  (5 out of 14) have ended 1-1. No away games have had that scoreline. In total, 39% (11 out of 28) of the Pars’ League games have been drawn – the highest total in the division (7% above the division average for all teams). ​

Picture

Dunfermline have scored an equal number of goals (18) in both the first and second half of League games this season, for a total of 36 goals. For goals against, 17 have been conceded in the first half, and 21 in the second half, with the final 15 minutes the period with most goals conceded (13).  

Picture

Most used Pars subs (subbed on) in League & Cup games this season:
13 – Joe Cardle
11 – Paul McMullan
10 – Farid El Alagui, David Hopkirk, Gavin Reilly

Picture

Most substituted Pars players in League & Cup games this season:
15 – Michael Moffat
13 – Kallum Higginbotham
12 – Nicky Clark
​8 – Rhys McCabe, Paul McMullan

Picture Picture

​Join the Moff as he travels through time and space to visit Pars games from the past, in his PARDIS time travel machine.
As seen in the photo above, the PARDIS touched down at McDiarmid Park, Perth, in 2000 to see Dunfermline play St Johnstone in a Premier League match. 

November 4, 2000 – Premier League – St Johnstone 0, Dunfermline 2
The previous week’s 1-0 home win over Dundee had ended a run of 6 games without a win for Jimmy Calderwood’s Dunfermline side. Having won promotion back to the top division the previous season, Calderwood’s team had gathered 13 points from the opening 12 games. Four days before this game, they had lost to the other Saints, St Mirren, in the quarter finals of the League Cup.
St Johnstone went into the game having defeated Rangers in their last match. It was the Pars who started the game as the more dominant team, with David Moss seeing his header from 6 yards hitting the bar in the opening minutes. St Johnstone did not force Pars keeper Marco Ruitenbeek into making any saves throughout the first half, but Dunfermline were unable to turn their superiority into goals.

Picture

Scott Thomson and Marco Ruitenbeek block a St Johnstone attack

The second half began with Barry Nicholson hitting the bar with a shot. After 67 minutes, Moss seemed to have given Dunfermline the lead but his goal after he had turned in a shot from an Ian Ferguson pass was ruled out as being offside. Just one minute later, the Pars did go ahead when Jason Dair struck a shot that took a slight deflection and beat Alan Main in the Saints’ goal. Nicholson then doubled Dunfermline’s lead in the 85th minute, chipping the ball over Main from outside the penalty box. This was the first time that the Pars had scored more than one goal in a League game that season. It was also the team’s third consecutive clean sheet in the League.

Pars team: Marco Ruitenbeek, Jason Dair, Justin Skinner, Andrius Skerla, Scott Thomson, David Moss, Barry Nicholson, Ian Ferguson, Stevie Crawford, Owen Coyle, Chris McGroarty. 
​
On the same week this game was played, the UK number 1 single was Holler, by Spice Girls. The UK number 1 album was Texas- The Greatest Hits.

Picture Picture Picture

A pathetic display that highlighted the severe lack of quality in the squad and confirmed the utter cluelessness of our manager. Against part-time opponents who had 1 win in the past 18 meetings of the clubs, who had won 1 game since October (and that was against a team with no registered goalkeeper, and who played a midfielder in goals), and who were missing at least 5 starters from their team due to injury, Johnston’s team produced a performance to shame the club. Fans were leaving with 15 minutes still remaining, and the team were even spared much in the way of booing at the end, almost as though the fans had had enough and realised it would have been pointless.
Although stating that he had a full squad to choose from, Johnston brought in Ryan Williamson and Joe Cardle, with Andy Geggan and Paul McMullan out of the squad, injuries being the reason we can assume. For Williamson it was his first appearance since December, and having played only 60 minutes for the Under 20s since recovering from injury, he did very well to complete the game, and offered an attacking threat down the right wing. The least said about Cardle, the better. He is a pony who has lost his one trick. Cutting inside, losing possession, slicing shots wide, and drifting round the park aimlessly. 

Picture

The Moff – treated abysmally once again. Photo: Pars Review

After Moffat’s early header from a Williamson cross somehow failed to find the net, the first half settled down into a complete shitfest. Early in the second half, Ayr keeper Fleming tipped over a Moffat shot. The Moff was playing well, but was subbed by the manager along with a hopelessly out of form Kallum Higginbotham. Paton replace Higginbotham, and Moffat was replaced by David Hopkirk, which was a terrible decision. At that point, I lost any slither of faith I had left in Johnston. Naturally, the formation remained 4-4-2. Later in the game, Gavin Reilly came on, with Cardle going off, and Hopkirk moving to the wing. 
Ayr scored a scrappy goal and had breakaways that they failed to take advantage of. Dunfermline had most of the ball but had no clue what to do with it. 
The club’s official site will give you a detailed account of the intricacies of the game. 
As a Pars fan for 26 years, and having been at every first team game this season, it pains me to write this match opinion. We all want our team to succeed, but the basics have to be there, and there are many issues that have to be addressed if the club is to move forward on the field.  ​

Starting line-up, with marks out of 10:

Picture

A full match photo gallery will be posted tomorrow. 
​All photos in this article by Pars Review.

Picture Picture

​Scottish Championship – Saturday 18/03/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park
Odds (Ladbrokes): Dunfermline 3/5; Draw 14/5; Ayr United 19/4

Two teams who have become very familiar to each other over the past 4 seasons meet again at East End Park tomorrow. From season 2013/14, when Dunfermline fell into League 1, the teams have met 18 times in League and Cup games, with Dunfermline winning 13, Ayr 1 and the 4 other games being drawn. Ayr are in the 9th place relegation play-off position, while the Pars would put any lingering relegation fears behind them with a win, and with a game in hand to come. 

Picture

Jason Talbot, Ayr v Pars, 1 October 2016. Photo: Pars Review

Our opponents​ – 
Ayr United

Last five outings:
11 March – Championship – Lost 4-1 v Falkirk (H)
4 March – Scottish Cup – Lost 3-1 v Hibs (A)
28 February – Championship – Won 1-0 v Raith Rovers (H)
25 February – Championship – Lost 2-0 v St Mirren (H)
18 February – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Dumbarton (A)

​
Pre-game comments
As one of only two part-time clubs in the Championship, Ayr were expected to battle relegation. After losing their first 3 League games, they went on a run of only 1 defeat in 7 games. However, in recent months they have won just 1 game since the third week of October. They currently occupy the relegation play-off place, and have injury problems, with manager Ian McCall claiming up to 8 first team players are either carrying injuries or are ruled out because of injury. 

Numbers game
Ayr have drawn their last 7 away matches.
Their only victory in the past 18 League games was the 1-0 win over a Raith Rovers team that had midfielder Ryan Stevenson in goals. 
Ayr have scored the lowest number of goals of any team in the Championship (25).

In the dugout
Ian McCall
In a playing career that included spells at 10 different clubs, Ian McCall had 2 periods as a Pars player, in season 1986/87 and then in 1990/91. He has had almost as many clubs as a manager (8), and if he remains Ayr boss until the end of this season, will have more games as Ayr manager than at any other club he has managed, with the exception of his first job, at Clydebank.

Picture

Lee Ashcroft, in the first meeting of the teams this season. Photo: Pars Review

Pars & Ayr United facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 7
Draws: 2
Ayr United wins: 1

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

1 October 2016 – Ayr United 0, Pars 0
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-ayr-united-0-pars-0​

3 December 2016 – Pars 1, Ayr United 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-ayr-united-1​

7 January 2017 – Ayr United 0, Pars 2
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-ayr-0-pars-2​

Connections
Three Ayr players have previously played for Dunfermline: goalkeeper Greg Fleming was on loan from Oldham Athletic in season 2009/10 and made 33 appearances. Left back Paddy Boyle was at East End Park for 2 seasons (2011/12 & 2012/13), the second season being spent on loan at Gateshead. He made 23 appearances for the Pars. Farid El Alagui played 16 times, including sub appearances, for Dunfermline this season before rejecting a contract extension in January. As recorded above, Ayr boss Ian McCall had 2 periods as a Pars player. 
From the current Pars squad, Andy Geggan had a season at Ayr (2011/12) before joining Dunfermline; David Hutton played 84 times for Ayr between 2013-2015; and Michael Moffat made 148 appearances for Ayr, scoring 65 goals. 

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

​Dunfermline
Last five outings:
11 March – Championship – Drew 0-0 v St Mirren (A)
7 March – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Queen of the South (H)
4 March – Championship – Won 5-1 v Dumbarton (H)
25 February – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Hibs (A)
14 February – Scottish Cup replay – Drew 1-1 v Hamilton (A) (lost on penalties)

Pre-game comments
Consistency of team selection has seen Dunfermline lose just one game since November. While the current starting 11 would, for many people, be the strongest available, 8 of the past 14 League games have been drawn. At times, more adventurous substitutions could have turned 1 point into 3 against tiring opposition defences. The opposite argument is that the team’s rhythm could have been broken, and games could have been lost. It would not be a great surprise to see the same 11 players start the game tomorrow. 

Preferred line-up:
Same line-up as in recent weeks. 
Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Pars Review gives a rating out of 10 for the starting 11 in every game. 
With 2 months remaining, here are the current top 5 rated players (average points per game) based on the criteria of having started a minimum of 50% of the 38 League and Cup games so far this season. Substitute appearances are not rated, or included. 
A squad list with total points and average points per game for all players will be posted at the end of the season. 

Picture Picture

All photos by Pars Review

Picture

Allan Johnston’s draw specialists came away from Paisley with a deserved point in what was a very competitive game. The lack of goals should not suggest a lack of entertainment – both teams created openings and were fully committed to winning the game. St Mirren’s need of the full 3 points was clear, as games run out in their bid to lift themselves off the bottom of the Championship table. They began by taking the game to Dunfermline, and were helped by the atrocious referee, Stephen Finnie, who once again in a Dunfermline game showed a mixture of incompetence and strange decision making. 
The Pars team was once again unchanged, and it was Kallum Higginbotham who was Finnie’s first target, booking the winger for a foul after 3 minutes. This clearly upset Higginbotham, who cut a frustrated figure for the remainder of his time on the park, eventually replaced by Michael Paton. 
Sean Murdoch once again excelled, making a superb finger tip save from a 25 yard piledriver from Saints’ Adam Eckersley. Murdoch was assured throughout, his handling, decision making and command of his penalty area faultless. 

Picture

Stephen Finnie prepares to book Kallum Higginbotham

Saints midfielder Stephen Mallan showed why he is one of the Championship’s best talents with 2 efforts on goal that Murdoch dealt with. In the Pars midfield, John Herron looked off the pace, but Nat Wedderburn had another impressive game. 
Dunfermline were dealing with the home side’s greater possession, defending resolutely and threatening on the break. One such Pars attack saw Paul McMullan challenged in the box but, predictably, Finnie was not interested. 
The Moff was linking up play well, and with the second half a few minutes old, he burst forward and hammered a shot from 20 yards that narrowly went over the bar. 
Rory Loy and Lewis Morgan both came close for Saints, and it was only determined Pars defending that prevented a goal, Andy Geggan and Lee Ashcroft in particular defending well. Jason Talbot was under pressure at times but could not be criticised for his attitude. Callum Morris had a couple of lapses of concentration that could have proved costly. 
St Mirren were now getting frantic in their attacks, and the Pars defence, although tested, did not buckle. Then after the out-of-sorts Higginbotham was replaced, the best chance of the game fell to sub Michael Paton. Played through on the right side of the penalty area, he delayed when an early shot was possible, and his eventual shot was saved by Saints keeper Billy O’Brien. 
The home side’s Morgan, Loy, Mallan and McGinn all had crosses or half chances saved or cleared, and continued to be aided by the dreadful referee, who awarded them very debatable fouls in dangerous areas. The game ended with the Pars support appreciative of their team’s effort.

​Pars player ratings:

Picture

Photos: Pars Review.
​Match photo gallery will be posted tomorrow.

Picture

Edited image by www.instagram.com/thedunfermlineway/ 
Original photos: Kallum Higginbotham (colour): Gary, used with permission
Paul McMullan & Kallum Higginbotham (black and white): Pars Review

Match report/opinion will be posted later today.

Picture

​Scottish Championship – Saturday 11/03/17 – KO 3.00pm – Paisley 2021 Stadium
Odds (Ladbrokes): St Mirren: 8/5; Draw 23/10; Dunfermline 13/8
Two teams who had pre-season ambitions of achieving a top 4 promotion play-off place meet in Paisley tomorrow, with the home side bottom of the Championship and the visitors in 6th place but still not safe from at least a relegation play-off place. This is despite St Mirren staging something of a revival in recent weeks, and Dunfermline losing just 1 of the past 13 League games: both teams’ current run of results is closer to top four form, but both are paying the price of poor starts to the season. 

Picture

​Our opponents​ – 
St Mirren

Last five outings:
8 March – Championship – Lost 2-0 v Raith Rovers (A)
5 March – Scottish Cup – Lost 4-1 v Celtic (A)
1 March – Championship – Won 2-0 v Hibs (H)
25 February – Championship – Won 2-0 v Ayr United (A)
19 February – Challenge Cup – Won 4-1 v The New Saints (H)
​
Pre-game comments
St Mirren’s relegation from the Premiership in 2014/15 was followed by the sacking of the manager who took them down and then the subsequent appointment of 4 other “permament” managers and one stand-in. Current boss Jack Ross, who took over in October 2016, had a difficult start to his time in charge, losing the first 6 games, but was allowed to struggle on until the January transfer window, during which he revamped his squad with 5 new signings plus 5 other players brought in on loan, with an almost equal number of departures. The new-look team have produced an improvement in results, and St Mirren have gradually reduced the points deficit between themselves and the teams immediately above them. The comments by Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers after his team defeated St Mirren in the Scottish Cup last weekend will give all Saints fans encouragement for the weeks ahead. Rodgers said: “I think St Mirren are the best team we have played this season, domestically, including Premiership teams. Jack’s done an excellent job in a short space of time. They are very well coached and brought in some signings in January. They are very well organised and have mobility and speed.”

Key player
Stephen McGinn
Midfielder McGinn is now in his second spell with St Mirren, where his career began, making his debut in 2007. He made 84 appearances and also played 8 times for the Scotland Under 21 team before moving to Watford in 2010. He made 40 appearances for Watford but missed an entire year with a knee injury. After playing for Shrewsbury on loan, he signed for Sheffield United before returning to Scotland to play for Dundee in 2015. He then moved back south to Wycombe, and after 18 months had his contract cancelled by mutual consent, allowing him to sign for St Mirren in January this year. His brothers both play professional football – John, for Hibs, and Paul for Chesterfield. 
​
Numbers game
St Mirren failed to win any of their opening 14 Championship games this season, finally recording a first victory in December.
They have kept just 3 clean sheets in 26 League games.
They have won the fewest games of any club in the Championship: 4, with these victories all coming in the past 12 games.

In the dugout
Jack Ross
After a playing career that included spells at Clyde, Hartlepool, Falkirk and St Mirren, Ross retired in 2011 while under contract with Dunfermline but without playing a first team game. He moved into coaching, becoming the became assistant manager at Dumbarton, and in 2014 moved to Hearts as a coach. In December 2015 he was appointed manager of Alloa, and in his 10 months at the club achieved a club record of 10 consecutive victories at the start of this season. In October 2016 he became manager of St Mirren.

Picture

St Mirren’s Andy Webster challenges Nicky Clark during the last meeting of the teams, at East End Park in January. Photo: Pars Review

​​Pars & St Mirren facts & stats​
Head to head record – last 10 meetings:
Pars wins: 3
Draws: 4
St Mirren wins: 3

Previous meetings
Pars Review match reports from the games between the teams this season:

24 September 2016 – Pars 4, St Mirren 3
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-4-st-mirren-3​

19 November 2016 – St Mirren 0, Pars 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-st-mirren-0-pars-1​

14 January 2017 – Pars 1, St Mirren 1
www.parsreview.org/blog/match-report-pars-1-st-mirren-1​

Connections
Three current St Mirren players have previous connections with Dunfermline: Jamie Langfield spent a season at East End Park in 2004/05 without playing a first team game; Rory Loy made 23 Pars appearances on loan from Rangers in 2008/09; and Josh Todd was a pre-season trialist last year but was not signed. As recorded above, manager Jack Ross was a Pars player when he retired as a player through injury in 2011, without having played for Dunfermline. 
From the 2016/17 Pars squad, Paul McMullan played 22 times for St Mirren on loan from Celtic in 2015/16. Coach John Potter made 232 appearances in a 6 year spell at St Mirren between 2005-2011. 

​Here is the current Championship table:

Picture

Dunfermline
Last five outings:
7 March – Championship – Drew 1-1 v Queen of the South (H)
4 March – Championship – Won 5-1 v Dumbarton (H)
25 February – Championship – Drew 2-2 v Hibs (A)
14 February – Scottish Cup replay – Drew 1-1 v Hamilton (A) (lost on penalties)
11 February – Scottish Cup – Drew 1-1 v Hamilton (H)

Pre-game comments
After playing so well against Hibs and Dumbarton, Dunfermline were involved in a dreadful game against Queen of the South on Tuesday evening at East End Park. The 1-1 result was the Pars’ 8th drawn game in 13 League and Cup games since mid December. The team have lost just once in the League since November but still sit just 6 points above the relegation play-off place. Manager Allan Johnston is still targeting a higher placed finish with 10 League games remaining, but with a 9 point gap to fourth (and with the third and fourth place teams having a game in hand over the Pars), overtaking fifth place Queen of the South might be the most realistic option, and would represent a satisfactory season back in the Championship after last season’s promotion.

Preferred line-up:
The team line-up has been very settled and although Allan Johnston spoke about utilising his squad with 3 games in a week (the last of which is tomorrow’s game) this has involved giving substitutes game time rather than changing the starting 11. Five different substitutes have played in the past 2 games. The defence will be unchanged but in midfield there could be a recall for Rhys McCabe if John Herron, who has looked tired in the past 2 games, is rested. On the wings, Kallum Higginbotham was out of form in the Queen of the South game but will probably retain his place. Paul McMullan is still the better option on the left wing, as opposed to bringing in Joe Cardle. Up front, the Moff and Nicky Clark are by some distance the best front pair available to the manager. So once again, with no changes (I have kept Herron in midfield but as noted, McCabe could start in his place), here is my preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:

Picture

​​Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.

Picture Picture

Celebrations after the Moff had put the Pars 1-0 up

Picture

Cardle flights in a late free kick

Picture

Edited image of the Moff’s goal celebrations. Edit by https://www.instagram.com/thedunfermlineway/ using a photo by Pars Review

Blog Archive
Original blog created July 2015.
Moved to current site July 2016.

Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture Picture
Picture

joe Cardle, Lee Ashcroft, Nat Wedderburn

Picture

Sandy Clark, Rhys McCabe, Nicky Clark and Gavin Reilly

Picture

Callum Fordyce

Picture

Allan Johnston and Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

Gavin Reilly, Kallum Higginbotham, Joe Cardle, Michael Moffat, Michael Paton, Nicky Clark

Picture

Rhys McCabe, Michael Moffat (hidden), Joe Cardle and Nicky Clark

Picture

Allan Johnston

Picture

Referee Bobby Madden and his fellow baldies

Picture

Ryan Williamson

Picture

David Hutton and Nat Wedderburn

Picture

Sean Murdoch leads the team out

Picture

Sammy and pals

Picture

Ryan Williamson

Picture

Callum Morris and ex-Par Farid El Alagui

Picture

John Herron challenges El Alagui

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

Ryan Williamson overlapping

Picture

Michael Moffat

Picture

Sean Murdoch

Picture

Home and away dug-out areas

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham, with John Herron & Nicky Clark

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Nat Wedderburn and John Herron

Picture

John Herron makes a defensive clearance

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham

Picture

The Moff

Picture

“Cut inside, Joe”

Picture

David Hopkirk

Picture

Michael Paton

Picture

Jason Talbot

Picture

David Hopkirk

Picture

Michael Paton

Picture

Allan Johnston

Picture

Nicky Clark

Picture

Walking to the stadium pre-match

Picture

Stadium main entrance & club shop

Picture

St Mirren’ Airdome

Picture

Match ticket & programme

Picture

Goakleeper coach David Westwood with Sean Murdoch

Picture

Sean Murdoch

Picture

Rhys McCabe

Picture

Michael Paton

Picture

Callum Fordyce, with Gavin Reilly

Picture

Rhys McCabe, with Fordyce & Lewis Spence to his right

Picture

John Potter takes the pre-match warm up

Picture

Jason Talbot (centre)

Picture

Big Nat, John Herron and other Pars players, pre-match

Picture

Lee Ashcroft

Picture

Andy Geggan

Picture

Geggan leads the team out

Picture

Morris, Ashcroft, Talbot & Herron

Picture

Andy Geggan applauds the Pars support just before kick-off

Picture

Nicky Clark

Picture

Murdoch makes a clearance

Picture

Murdoch & Morris

Picture

Finnie prepares to book Higginbotham

Picture

The Pars bench

Picture

Geggan jumps highest to clear the ball

Picture

Getting ready for a Saints corner kick

Picture

John Herron

Picture

Big Nat

Picture

AJ and Lee Ashcroft have a discussion

Picture

Sean Murdoch recorded his 6th shut out of the season

Picture

John Herron with Saints’ Cammy Smith

Picture

Callum Morris

Picture

Murdoch, Pars Review man of the match

Picture

Paul McMullan, with Higginbotham in support

Picture

The Moff hits a shot that went narrowly over

Picture

Jason Talbot

Picture

Higginbotham, with sub Paton watching

Picture

Nicky Clark & the Moff

Picture

5’8” Jason Talbot out-jumps 6’1” John Sutton

Picture

Kallum Higginbotham had a frustrating afternoon

Picture

McMullan runs direct at the Saints defence

Picture

Michael Paton

Picture

The Moff, Ashcroft, Clark & Big Nat thank the fans

Picture

Wee Paul had another good game

Picture

Sean Murdoch applauds the Pars support

Picture

John Herron and Big Nat

Picture

Sean Murdoch

Picture

Rhys McCabe (left) and others, pre game

Picture

Cammy Gill

Picture

AJ

Picture

60% of all outfield players in this congested area

Picture

Punt

Picture

Punt

Picture

Jason Talbot with Lee Ashcroft

Picture

Ex-Par Scott Mercer

Picture

Higgy and the hopeless North Stand linesman

Picture

“Cut inside, Joe”

Picture

Big Nat

Picture

Cardle with ex-Pars team mate Chris Higgins