The story of this decade: Dunfermline have played in 3 different divisions of the Scottish League, partly caused by the plunge into administration in 2013 that saw a Pars team that led the First Division (now Championship) following relegation from the Premier League losing the vast majority of the first team squad through redundancies and also being given a points deduction. The effects of administration continue to be felt but the club are definitely on an upward trajectory, as the graph above shows. From the depths of 2 consecutive play-off defeats, then the embarrassment of a seventh place finish in the rebranded League 1, the current management team, appointed in summer 2015, have overseen a recovery and have taken the team to 18th place in the Scottish football pyramid.
Allan Johnston. Photo: Pars Review
The club have ambitions to get into the top 10 but this will be achieved properly and without the reckless overspending of the old regime. The club is now run on prudent financial lines with a responsible set of directors led by Chairman Ross McArthur. The appointment of Allan Johnston as manager has been a success with the playing budget being spent wisely with very few unsuccessful signings. The Under 20s team have also improved greatly this season and are currently sixth in the SPFL Development League, above Celtic, Rangers, Aberdeen and Hearts.
The chart below shows the number of League points won since season 2010/11. With the exception of season 2011/12 (38 games), 36 League games were played each season. The points total for the current season has been projected based on the average number of points gained per game so far.
Nat Wedderburn in the snow, pre-match
Andy Geggan leads out the Pars team
The away support (1141)
Sean Murdoch, the sponsor’s man of the match
John Herron celebrates his goal
Herron celebrates with Sandy Clark before waving to the main stand
All photos by Pars Review
Pars keeper Sean Murdoch
Dunfermline extended their unbeaten run to 11 games and gained a first point of the season from games against Dundee United in today’s game at a wintery East End Park. Manager Allan Johnston brought Jason Talbot and Michael Moffat back into the team, with Callum Morris making his League debut in his second spell with the club. The game began with snow falling, and temperatures around zero Celcius. The first chance fell to the Pars when Nicky Clark broke forward and passed to the Moff, whose shot beat United keeper Cammy Bell, but was cleared off the line by William Edjenguele. Dunfermline fell behind after 18 minutes when the defence stood back and allowed Tony Andreu to shoot from just outside the penalty box. The strike beat Sean Murdoch, who went onto have a great game but may feel he could have got down earlier to the shot. Murdoch then made a poor clearance which put United straight on the attack, but luckily the visitors failed to take advantage. The Pars equalised in the 28th minute with a well made goal. Kallum Higginbotham played a pass to Nat Wedderburn, who found Higginbotham with a return pass. The Pars winger then sent an accurate cross into the box which was met by John Herron, to score his first Dunfermline goal. Murdoch made the first of several crucial saves shortly before half time from a shot by Thomas Mikkelson. The first half ended level, with United keeper Cammy Bell limping back to the changing room, to be replaced by substitute keeper Luis Zwick at the start of the second half.
Nat Wedderburn pre-match
Dunfermline had most of the ball in the opening 20 minutes of the second period. Nat Wedderburn was having a tremendous game in midfield, dominating the ball, using his physique to win physical challenges, and also displaying a great range of passing. The Pars fans in the North West stand sang the big midfielder’s name, appreciating what was another impressive game from the Pars number 8. Murdoch was the team’s other standout performer today, making excellent saves from Andreu (twice) and, best of all, from a Blair Spittal freekick that looked a goal all the way until Murdoch’s acrobatic leap to tip the ball over the bar. Paul McMullan had a chance to put Dunfermline ahead but spooned his shot over the bar. Wedderburn then met a cross but his goalbound header was blocked and cleared. Although United were the more threatening team as the second half progressed, that did not prevent Pars sub Gavin Reilly from squeezing a shot from a tight angle that Zwick saved. This was an entertaining game that deservedly did not have a losing team. Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:
Photos by Pars Review. Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.
Scottish Championship – Saturday 28/01/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park Odds (Ladbrokes): Dunfermline 11/5; Draw 12/5; Dundee United 6/5 Dunfermline and Dundee United meet up for the fifth time this season at East End Park tomorrow, with the home side keen to extend a 10 game unbeaten run, and the visitors aiming to record a first League victory of 2017. United were the last team to defeat the Pars, in November, with the other 3 games between the teams also resulting in United wins, in the League and also in the Challenge Cup and League Cup. With the exception of the first game, at Tannadice in the League Cup in July, when United were comfortable 2-0 winners, the teams have been evenly matched. The 3 missed Pars penalties in the League game against United at East End Park in September and the sending off of Nat Wedderburn with the game goalless at Tannadice in November, were factors that denied Dunfermline more positive results.
Paul McMullan, Pars v United at East End Park, 10 September 2016
Dundee United: After topping the Championship earlier in the season, during a run of 12 undefeated games (9 wins and 3 draws) between 24 September to 24 December, United then suffered 2 consecutive defeats in the League, with a third straight loss prevented by 2 late goals at home to QOS to rescue a point in a 3-3 draw on 14 January. This has seen United fall 6 points behind Hibs at the top of the Championship. The Tannadice team then lost 6-2 against Ross County in the Scottish Cup last week. Based on results in the past 8 League games, United have gained only 3 points more than bottom of the table St Mirren. Despite this, United will be difficult opponents tomorrow, and as noted above, have defeated Dunfermline in all 4 of the previous games between the teams so far this season. Manager Ray McKinnon’s only signing in the January transfer window is Danish striker Thomas Mikkelsen, signed on loan from Odense. Here is the current Championship table:
Dunfermline: Injured: Ben Richards-Everton, Ryan Williamson Suspended: None Manager Allan Johnston used last week’s Scottish Cup game at Alloa to make 3 changes to his settled line-up, giving game time to Lewis Martin and Gavin Reilly, and a debut to Callum Morris. The players they replaced – Jason Talbot, Callum Fordyce and Michael Moffat – will be in line for recalls for tomorrow’s game, with Johnston expected to revert back to what would be considered to be his strongest line-up. Morris could be preferred over Fordyce. The team are undefeated in 8 League games (10 competitive games in total, including the Scottish Cup) and the same approach that has contributed to the recent good run will certainly be required against United, who despite a recent dip in form, remain the second strongest team in the division. Preferred line-up: I would make 2 changes to the team that defeated Alloa in the Scottish Cup last week: Jason Talbot and Michael Moffat would replace Lewis Martin and Gavin Reilly. I would start Callum Morris (as unfair as it may seem on Callum Fordyce). Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:
Photo by Pars Review. Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.
The Pars are undefeated in 8 League games – the longest current unbeaten run of any team in the Championship.
Based on first half results only, Dunfermline would be fifth in the Championship but only 2 points off the fourth place play-off position – instead of the actual 6 point gap. The Pars would be above Falkirk, who we trail by those 6 points, and only 2 points behind Dundee United, and only 3 points off second place. (See tables below).
Lewis Martin (pictured above) made his 100th appearance for Dunfermline at Alloa (96 starts, 4 sub), with 3 goals in those 100 games. Still only 20 years old, Lewis made his first team debut as an 89th minute substitute in the 1-0 win at Morton in April 2013, aged 17. His first start for the team was in the 4-2 win at Ayr in December 2013.
Only 2 Pars players have been in every match day squad this season: David Hutton and Michael Moffat. Neither, however, are among the top 6 players for minutes played. Lee Ashcroft has played more minutes this season than any other Dunfermline player. Here are the players who have played most minutes in all competitions this season:
Minutes played/player 2610 – Lee Ashcroft 2160 – Andy Geggan 2004 – Lewis Martin 1872 – Jason Talbot 1842 – Kallum Higginbotham 1725 – Nicky Clark
Lewis Martin photo by Pars Review.
Join the Moff as he travels through time and space to visit Pars games from the past, in his PARDIS time travel machine. Today, he has travelled from his previous stop in Glebe Park, Brechin (above) and has landed in Dunfermline at the end of 1961 to see the Pars demolish St Mirren. December 30, 1961 – Scottish Division One – Dunfermline 7, St Mirren 0 Certain games define a player’s career, and while the star of this victory had a long and successful period at East End Park (and is still the club’s record goalscorer to this day), he was never to equal or better the astonishing 6 goals he scored on that December win over St Mirren: Charlie Dickson wrote himself into the club record books with this haul of goals, a double hat trick that has rarely been achieved in any top flight professional game. The East End Park pitch was declared playable despite having a covering of snow. Dunfermline took the lead after 14 minutes, when Harry Melrose headed home from a Tommy McDonald corner. In the 26th minute, the Pars went 2-0 ahead when Saints keeper Brown could only parry a 25 yard shot from Ron Mailer, the ball falling to Charlie Dickson (pictured below) who scored from close range. Dickson almost got his second a few minutes later but shot wide after good play from Melrose and George Peebles.
The score remained 2-0 at half time, but the second half saw the Pars score a further 5 goals. The first came a minute into the second period when Dickson headed in after Melrose’s shot was saved. The fourth goal, and Dickson’s hat trick, came after 54 minutes when Mailer’s pass found Dickson, who shot into the corner of the net despite being surrounded by 3 Saints defenders. A minute later, Dickson got his fourth goal of the afternoon, turning in a Peebles cross. Peebles almost scored a sixth Pars goal but his shot was cleared off the line. With 3 minutes remaining, the sixth goal did come, and it was Dickson who scored it, heading in a McDonald cross. The crowd were singing Dickson’s name and this spurred him on to score his double hat trick with a goal in the final minute – Peebles made a run down the wing and his accurate cross was side footed in by Dickson to make the score 7-0. Dickson’s six goals made him only the second Pars player to have scored so many in a game – the other player was his team mate on that day, Harry Melrose, who had achieved his double hat trick 2 years earlier in a game against Partick Thistle. Pars team: Connachan, Fraser, Cunningham, Mailer, Williamson, Miller, McDonald, Smith, Dickson, Melrose, Peebles.
On the same week this game was played, the UK number 1 single was Moon River, by Danny Williams. The UK number 1 album was Blue Hawaii by Elvis Presley.
Michael Paton takes on the County defence
A hat trick from David Hopkirk helped the Pars Under 20s to a resounding win in today’s SPFL Development League game against Ross County, played at Kelty Hearts’ New Central Park. Pars coach John Potter named 5 overage players in his starting line-up, although 3 of them (Ryan Williamson, Euan Spark and Lewis Spence) are all 20 years old and just a year over the age limit. The other 2 players, Michael Paton and Hopkirk, will have impressed watching manager Allan Johnston. Dunfermline dominated the game, restricting the visitors – who are second in the Development League table – to very few chances. From the start, the Pars pressed for an opening goal. Conner Duthie saw his 22 yard free kick hit the bar after 4 minutes, and Paton and Callum Smith also had good early efforts. Ryan Williamson had several trademark runs up the right wing that almost created an opening goal. The goal finally came after 26 minutes with a well struck shot from Paton. Williamson then collapsed after an overlapping run and was clearly in some pain. Thankfully, although he had to be substituted, he was able to walk off and had an icepack strapped to his leg. It can only be hoped there is no long term damage done to the talented fullback who has been so unlucky with injuries. Reece Duncan came on in place of Williamson. Hopkirk put the Pars 2-0 up in the 42nd minute with a shot from the edge of the penalty box. The same player got his second and Dunfermline’s third after 49 minutes when he evaded a challenge and hit a shot past the County keeper from 20 yards. County almost pulled a goal back when a shot from their centre forward Morrison hit the bar. Hopkirk then completed his hat trick with a superb goal after 62 minutes. His curling shot from 22 yards flew into the top corner of the net, one of the best goals he is ever likely to score. Evan Horne was then brought on for Scott Lochhead. A few minutes later Hopkirk was substituted, his work done, with Ciaran Lafferty replacing him, and although the Pars continued to attack, there were no more goals. This was another great performance from the Under 20s. Cammy Gill was assured in goals, the defence was solid with Euan Spark and Stuart Morrison forming a good partnership in the middle, and fullbacks Williamson, then Duncan and Duthie keen to get forward. In midfield, Johnny Galloway was industrious as always. Lewis Spence combined skill with hard work, and in the wide areas Michael Paton proved again what a good footballer he is, with excellent close control, while on the left side Scott Lochhead had less of an impact but rarely wasted a pass. Up front Hopkirk was without doubt man of the match, while alongside him Callum Smith was very unlucky not to score. The win moves the Pars up to seventh place in the Development League table. A special mention too for Kelty Hearts, whose New Central Park has been improved even further in recent weeks, with a new entrance and landscaping work done around the terracing. Always a good venue, the improvements that include new enclosures built last summer and the more recent landscaping have enhanced the ground and made it one of the best venues outwith the SPFL (and better than many grounds within the senior divisions). Pars team: Cammy Gill, Ryan Williamson (Reece Duncan), Conner Duthie, Euan Spark, Stuart Morrison, Lewis Spence, Michael Paton, Johnny Galloway, Callum Smith, David Hopkirk (Ciaran Lafferty), Scott Lochhead (Evan Horne). Match photos (all photos by Pars Review):
The new entrance to Kelty Hearts’ ground
Farid El Alagui has decided not to take up the offer of a contract extension with DAFC, and instead further his career in Asia. Farid scored 4 goals in his time at East End Park and was a popular player with the fans and his team mates. Photos by Pars Review.
3. John Herron, pre-match
4. Various views in the Indodrill Stadium
7. Lee Ashcroft, with Alloa’s Greig Spence
10. Paul McMullan is congratulated by his team mates on scoring the second goal
11. Callum Morris
12. Nat Wedderburn & Andy Geggan
13. Pars players celebrate Joe Cardle’s goal
Photos by Pars Review, except numbers 2, 3, 7 & 12 (thanks to Gary for those).
Dunfermline players congratulate Paul McMullan on his goal
Progress to the next round of the Scottish Cup was achieved with a 1 goal victory that did not reflect the long spells of dominance that Dunfermline enjoyed for most of the game. As in the previous round, a 4-3 win at Buckie, this was another game that produced several goals and an all-important away win. Manager Allan Johnston made 3 changes to the team that drew with Ayr last week: Lewis Martin, Callum Morris and Gavin Reilly replacing Jason Talbot, Callum Fordyce and Michael Moffat, who were all named as substitutes. This was Morris’ first start of the season, having not played for previous club Aberdeen prior to his return to Dunfermline 2 weeks ago. He fitted in well alongside Lee Ashcroft in central defence, although the defence will be disappointed to lose two late goals. The fog that caused fans to doubt of the game would take place lifted sufficiently by early afternoon, and the large travelling support filled the small Indodrill stadium, outnumbering the home support by at least 4 to 1. After a fairly uneventful opening 10 minutes, with Dunfermline having the majority of possession, the game’s first bookings were issued after Kallum Higginbotham reacted to a crunching tackle from Steven Hetherington. Both players were booked. Two minutes later Dunfermline took the lead. A through ball to Gavin Reilly was blocked by Alloa keeper Neil Parry. The ball fell to Nicky Clark who swept it into the net. Higginbotham was showing some great touches on the left wing despite the moronic element of the Alloa support shouting abuse at the Pars winger. The new Zero Tolerance rules have yet to be applied at the Indodrill, with the same small group of home fans encouraging their players to break Paul McMullan’s legs at one point, in colourful language. It was from a Higginbotham cross that Clark almost scored again, his header well saved by Parry. Alloa’s best chance of the first half then fell to Kevin Cawley who got his shot on target but was unable to beat Sean Murdoch. The Pars second goal came after 43 minutes, after a series of corners, Higginbotham then varied the routine by playing the ball short to Paul McMullan, who rounded a defender before shooting low into the far corner.
Callum Morris, impressive on his return
With Dunfermline 2-0 ahead, and Higginbotham already booked, Allan Johnston made a half time substitution, replacing Higginbotham with Joe Cardle. The Pars continued the second half in control of the game, with Cardle and McMullan both coming close to extending the lead further. Nat Wedderburn was in imperious form in midfield, showing a range of passing, short and long, and dominating the middle of the park. In the 61st minute Cardle got on the scoresheet when he took a pass from Clark and shot home. At 3-0 up, the game looked over such was the Pars apparent superiority. Alloa got a goal back after 68 minutes, substitute Stefan McCluskey scoring with his first touch, a header that evaded the Pars defence. Two more Pars substitutions were made, with Michael Moffat and Rhys McCabe replacing Nicky Clark and John Herron. Cardle had a great chance to score again when Moffat played him through on goal but the winger shot straight at Parry. The Moff looked to have put his team 4-1 up with a header from a Cardle cross, but the goal was disallowed due to offside. The Pars lead was then reduced to 1 goal in added on time when Alloa striker Greig Spence, standing in a suspiciously offside position, got in between Sean Murdoch and Lee Ashcroft to turn the ball into the net. Pars left back Lewis Martin then almost gifted Alloa an equaliser when he was caught in possession and from the ball played across, ex-Par Graeme Holmes had a shot that the Dunfermline defence charged down. Ultimately all that matters in Cup games is progression into the next round, but the win could, and should, have been much more comfortable. Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:
Photos by Pars Review. Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.
Scottish Cup 4th round – Saturday 21/01/17 – KO 3.00pm – Indodrill Stadium, Alloa Odds (Ladbrokes): Alloa 21/10; Draw 13/5; Dunfermline 23/20 Memories of the dismal 2013 play-off defeat to Clackmannanshire’s only senior football club will be fresh in the minds of all Pars fans and will ensure that nothing will be taken for granted in tomorrow’s Scottish Cup game at the same venue. Dunfermline go into the game on a 9 game unbeaten run and face a lower division opponent but the host team will aim to make it difficult for Allan Johnston’s team to progress into the next round. The Pars were most recently at Alloa in June last year for a pre-season friendly that ended 1-1.
The Moff during the pre-season friendly at Alloa on 29 June last year
Alloa began the season in great form, qualifying for the knock-out stages of the League Cup and suffering just 1 defeat in their opening 7 League 1 games. Their League Cup victories included 2 wins over Premiership sides: Ross County (in the group stage) and Inverness (in the second round). However, more recently they endured a run of 6 games without a win between mid November and Christmas Eve that severely dented their title winning prospects. This winless run ended with a 4-2 win at Stenhousemuir and was followed by another victory last week, 2-1 at Stranraer. Manager Jim Goodwin, signed as a player in the summer of 2016, took over as manager after Jack Ross was appointed St Mirren manager in October. Alloa are currently in second place in League 1, 9 points behind leaders Livingston, and at the top of a mini-group of 4 teams that are separated by only 3 points. Alloa are rarely involved in no-scoring games, with all of their most recent 9 games featuring both at least one goal for and against. Their artificial surface, which was laid in the summer after the previous much-criticised surface became very worn, has not been the advantage to them that may have been assumed: almost two-thirds of their points in League games have come from away games.
Joe Cardle, Nat Wedderburn and Andy Geggan, pre- season v Alloa
The Scottish Cup represents a chance for Dunfermline to progress and secure the financial rewards that would follow if drawn against a well-supported top division team in the later rounds. Unlike certain teams in England’s FA Cup, who field virtual reserve teams and prioritise League games over the national Cup competition, Allan Johnston will field a strong team, with few changes likely to be made to the team that drew with Ayr last week. Pars line-up: the manager’s selection Injured: Ben Richards-Everton, plus 2 unnamed players with minor niggling injuries. Suspended: None The manager rarely makes wholesale changes to his starting 11 (a habit that also includes a reluctance to utilise substitutes during games) and has already stated that there will only be a couple of changes for tomorrow’s game. Team selection will be influenced by the unnamed players who have what the manager described as niggling injuries. New signing Callum Morris is likely to be included in the team, although neither Lee Ashcroft or Callum Fordyce deserve to lose their place to the new centre half. Preferred line-up The importance of this competition means that a strong, settled team should be fielded. Morris needs game time and should start, possibly in place of Fordyce, while I would also give Joe Cardle a start, with Kallum Higginbotham shifting to the right wing. Cardle would replace Paul McMullan, who may benefit from a week’s rest after being kicked around the park by Ayr’s cluggers last week. The remainder of the team would be unchanged. Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:
Photos by Pars Review. Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with photos and Pars player ratings.
Looking at the current Pars squad and how they have performed individually and as a team. Today: the forwards
The loss of last season’s top scorer Faissal El Bakhtaoui was felt in the opening weeks of the season, with new loan signing Gavin Reilly paired with Michael Moffat, and only David Hopkirk in reserve, plus 2 untested Under 20s strikers. The signings of Farid El Alagui and Nicky Clark strengthened the forward positions, although some players have contributed more than others. Michael Moffat (pictured below) has evolved from a high scoring striker to more of a playmaker, and is one of the best footballers at the club. His link-up play is of a very high standard for this division, and although approaching his 32nd birthday, he still has pace. The one criticism of the Moff is that for a player who wears number 9, he simply doesn’t score enough goals and seems to lack the confidence or instinct to shoot, preferring to pass. Gavin Reilly had previously played for Allan Johnston when the player and manager were at Queen of the South. Signed on a season long loan from Hearts, and seen as a natural goalscorer who would profit from Moffat’s inventiveness, Reilly has, unfortunately, been underwhelming and has scored just 2 goals to date, 1 in the League and the other in a Challenge Cup game at Brechin.
Farid El Alagui (pictured below) was signed on a 6 month deal after a trial period, which was not so much to assess his ability, which is not in doubt, but rather his fitness, after he had suffered injuries in the past few seasons. A very popular player, he scored 4 times in the first few weeks but has since lost his starting place and has featured as a late substitute (if used at all) in the past month. His injuries have had an impact – it is difficult to watch him try to chase down a pass, as his speed is all but gone – but he has talent and could still be an asset. His contract ends next week and his future at Dunfermline is currently uncertain.
Nicky Clark is the club’s top scorer this season with a record of a goal every other game. Another player who had been at Queen of the South with Allan Johnston (plus his dad, Pars assistant boss Sandy Clark), he is a penalty box striker who is an instinctive goalscorer. Most of his goals have come from quick strikes when there has been no time to think – he has been less effective in one on ones. An automatic first team starter, Clark is one of the best poachers the Pars have had in several years. David Hopkirk, who can also play on the left or right wings, has been seen only occasionally this season due to recurring injury problems. He has been played as a striker during his substitute appearances. 17 year old striker Callum Smith has been impressive in the Under 20s this season and will be pushing for a place among the first team substitutes soon, having already been involved in the match day squad this season.
Looking at the current Pars squad and how they have performed individually and as a team. Today – the midfield
With manager Allan Johnston preferring a 4-4-2 formation in almost every game, the Pars midfield falls into 2 categories: central midfielders and wingers. The summer of 2016 saw Josh Falkingham allowed to leave the club, and new contracts offered to 2 players (Rhys McCabe and Lewis Spence) who were unable to break into the team in season 2015/16 due to Falkingham’s good form (Johnston’s own words). The early weeks of this season saw a central midfield of McCabe and Andy Geggan, with new signing Nat Wedderburn struggling with injury. Spence made one appearance and was then loaned to Brechin City. Rhys McCabe was not in the best of form in the opening weeks of the season, unable to impose himself on games and lacking accuracy with his passing. Gradually, he began to improve, and without being outstanding, the months of November and December saw him in the best form of his time at Dunfermline, although he has since lost his place in the team to Wedderburn. Andy Geggan (pictured below) began the season in goalscoring form in the League Cup, but a series of yellow cards in League games, and poor displays in central midfield, saw him moved to right back where he showed better form, despite a tendency to back off the opposition attacker. There is no denying Geggan’s will to win but he has not made the step up to the Championship as hoped.
Lewis Spence is a hardworking young midfielder who is currently out of the first team squad, and having enjoyed a run of games on loan at Brechin, it would be no surprise to see him loaned out again. Nat Wedderburn provides defensive cover in the centre of the pitch. After 3 League Cup appearances in July, injury prevented him from returning to the first team until the end of October. Not the most mobile of players, he has demonstrated what he can bring to the team in the past few weeks, and the most recent 2 games (at Ayr and home to St Mirren) have been his best performances for Dunfermline so far. John Herron has, perhaps, been the best performing Pars midfielder this season. Signed on loan from Blackpool on 31 August, had an excellent game in his first start for the team at home to St Mirren, but suffered an injury the following week at Ayr. Since his return in November, he has started weekly. Significantly, the team have only lost once in the 11 games he has played. Herron has the ability to open up play in midfield and combines well with Wedderburn, the pair’s different styles working well together. As a former winger himself, Allan Johnston’s Pars teams have almost always featured 2 wide players. Joe Cardle, so outstanding in League 1 last season, was expected to be one of Dunfermline’s main players in 2016/17 but after scoring a hat-trick in the opening League game against Dumbarton, he has found life difficult against higher quality opposition. He has only started 2 League games in the past 10 weeks, and one of those was due to Kallum Higginbotham serving a 1 game suspension. Michael Paton is another of last season’s regulars who has been used sparingly this term. After missing pre-season training and the opening League Cup games due to a summer hernia operation, Paton has been in and out of the team, and while clearly a talented player, the manager has preferred the pacier and more direct options available to him in the squad. Kallum Higginbotham (pictured below) has been the team’s talisman in the past few months. A maverick talent who is also a hard worker with a great attitude, all that prevents him becoming a truly great player is, perhaps, not scoring enough goals. He is critical to Dunfermline’s season and has been one of Johnston’s best signings. Paul McMullan was signed on loan from Celtic and after featuring as a substitute for much of the first few weeks of this season, has now been a regular starter over the past 2 months. A throw-back to the old fashioned winger that Scotland once produced regularly, McMullan has impressed through his direct running at his opponent, and his ability to play on either wing.
Tomorrow: the forwards Photos by Pars Review
Looking at the current Pars squad and how they have performed individually and as a team. Today: the goalkeepers and defence
Dunfermline have been well served in recent years with quality goalkeepers and the current Pars number 1 continues that pattern. Sean Murdoch (pictured below) has been one of the team’s top performers since returning from an injury that caused him to miss the first few weeks of the season. In addition to being a very good goalkeeper, he has an authority and presence about him that undoubtedly helps his defenders. Deputy keeper David Hutton filled in for Murdoch in the early part of the season and while he did not conceded any howlers, he simply wasn’t Murdoch and did not radiate confidence. Added to that, his tendency to jump like a starfish when attempting a save was disconcerting. Under 20s keeper Cammy Gill signed a new contract extension last week and will be challenging for a place on the first team bench soon. Having seen Gill in many Under 20s games this season, he is vocal and appears confident and is a good shot stopper.
In defence, there has been a huge improvement in recent weeks. In the opening games of the season, almost every week a goal was conceded through a needless error. These have largely been eliminated now, with a noticeable change to clearing the ball quickly and without fuss. The team have had several right backs this season, and it is still a position that could be filled in the January transfer window. Ryan Williamson has not adapted well to Championship football, and has been defensively suspect and also less effective on his gallops up the right wing, compared to last year in League 1. He is currently out of the first team matchday squad and could benefit from going on loan. Lewis Martin has played all across the back 4 this season and is a solid, dependable player. Two red cards this season, the first of his career, have not helped his case for a regular first team spot, and he is currently being used more as cover than in the starting 11.
Jason Talbot (pictured above) has bounced back from a red card early in the season to become the team’s most consistent player. He has eliminated the rash challenges that have led to disciplinary problems, and is now an automatic choice at full back. He also scored one of the Pars goals of the season with a 20 yard screamer at Queen Of The South. Callum Fordyce initially found his return from long-term injury to be a greater challenge than was hoped for. Unfortunate mistakes in games led directly to goals, and he was then removed from the first team squad and played as an overage player in the Under 20s. That seems to have built up his confidence as he has been outstanding for the first team in recent weeks, and has regained the team captaincy. Lee Ashcroft has played every game that he has been available for (missing just one, after a red card in the opening League game). A very mature player for a 23 year old, he has been one of the team’s top performers throughout the season and could become a cornerstone of the defence for years to come. Ben Richards-Everton struggled with the demands of Championship football before suffering a long-term injury in training. He has a great attitude but questions remain over his ability to play at this level. New signing Callum Morris will be pushing Fordyce and Ashcroft for a first team place, while young full back Conner Duthie has been given first team game time this season and looks a good prospect.
Tomorrow: the midfield Photos by Pars Review
Higginbotham scoring from the penalty spot
This second half free kick from Higginbotham missed the goal by inches
All photos by Pars Review.
Kallum Higginbotham celebrates scoring
An eighth straight League game without defeat and a move up to fifth place in the Championship were achieved with today’s point against St Mirren. A draw at home against a side 7 points adrift at the bottom of the division may not be the ideal result, the team have at least learned how not to lose games and on the balance of play today should have won convincingly. There were no changes from last week’s starting 11. New signing Callum Morris was an unused substitute. St Mirren had a disastrous run of 6 defeats in a row under new manager Jack Ross, but had won 2, drawn 2 and lost 2 of the past 6 games – mid table form. The visitors were first to threaten when Stephen Mallan’s 20 yard free kick narrowly missed Sean Murdoch’s goal. A few minutes later, Lee Ashcroft headed straight at Jamie Langfield when he might have done better. Michael Moffat was having a good game, running direct at the Saints defence, and he almost opened the scoring after 8 minutes when Nicky Clark found him with a well-placed pass. Unfortunately, the Moff’s shot hit the out-rushing Langfield. Clark then narrowly missed a chance to score when Paul McMullan played a ball across the box which was cleared near the goal line by Andy Webster, with Clark waiting to turn the ball in. Moffat was then fouled by Gary MacKenzie, but referee Willie Collum waved away penalty appeals. The same two players were involved again in the 37th minute, and this time MacKenzie’s challenge on Moffat was deemed to be a foul by the referee. Kallum Higginbotham, whose most recent penalty attempts (against Dundee United) were both saved in the same goal as the first half today, stepped up to take the kick and he confidently shot past Langfield. St Mirren were guilty of some heavy and dangerous tackling, and although Collum eventually booked 3 of their players, he could – and should – have yellow carded far more but his lenient approach merely encouraged the Saints players to continue. MacKenzie almost atoned for conceding the penalty when his header hit the post and was cleared. One minute into the second half, the same player got the better of the Pars defence again to rise and head home a Mallan corner kick.
Nat Wedderburn bossed the Pars midfield
After 53 minutes, Higginbotham flighted a superb cross-field pass to Clark, who ran into the box and passed to Moffat, who sent an effort wide from 5 yards out. This was typical of the Moff’s performance today (and in many other games ) – his general play was excellent but his finishing not so impressive. Higginbotham then had a long range shot that narrowly missed. In the 60th minute, Langfield made a miraculous save from a Clark header. St Mirren were under pressure but were still capable of looking dangerous from breakaways. Indecision and backing off by Andy Geggan invited the Saints attack to threaten Murdoch’s goal. Higginbotham was involved in most of Dunfermline’s attacks, and it was from a free kick awarded for a foul on Moffat that the winger almost put the Pars ahead again. His shot missed the left hand post by a couple of inches with Langfield beaten. With a minute remaining, St Mirren broke away and had a chance to shoot but were blocked by the Pars defence. Dunfermline then broke upfield and Clark’s header was agonisingly close to giving the Pars a late winner. Allan Johnston then made his only substitution, bringing on Joe Cardle for McMullan, which was greeted with shouts from the stands asking why the switch was made so late. Nat Wedderburn had a tremendous game in midfield, breaking up countless Saints counter attacks. Higginbotham was the main creative threat for Dunfermline, while the Moff showed what a great footballer he can be, but lacking the ruthlessness required of a great striker. The final whistle signaled some booing from the home support. This was, hopefully, a reaction to the lack of substitutes used and not the team’s performance. Pars starting 11, with marks out of 10:
Photos by Pars Review, and Pars fan Gary (thanks to him for that). Tomorrow: full match photo gallery.
Scottish Championship – Saturday 14/01/17 – KO 3.00pm – East End Park Odds (Labrokes): Dunfermline 20/21; Draw 13/5; St Mirren 13/5 Dunfermline will aim to extend the unbeaten run of Championship games to 8 on Saturday, with visitors St Mirren in desperate need of points to avoid relegation. Once rivals in the Premier League or fighting for promotion to the top division, the two black and white teams are now adjusting to a different set of priorities – at least in the short term – with Dunfermline playing in the second tier of Scottish football for the first time since season 2012/13, following 3 seasons in the third tier, and St Mirren trying to avoid relegation to the third level for the first time in their history.
Dunfermline’s Nat Wedderburn had his best game for the Pars in the win at Ayr last weekend and will make his first appearance against St Mirren this season if selected tomorrow
After achieving an 8th place finish in the 2013/14 Premier League, and having won the League Cup in March 2013, the St Mirren directors decided against extending manager Danny Lennon’s contract. At the time, the Paisley club’s board did not give an actual reason for the non-extension/sacking, saying “The board of directors have decided not to offer Danny Lennon an extension to his contract that expires in June 2014. Decisions like this are never easy.” Whether the directors were misguided, or deluded, their ambitions for the club were not to be achieved in the following seasons. The board’s choice as Lennon’s successor was to start a downward spiral of short-term appointments. Tommy Craig, who had been Lennon’s assistant, was given the manager’s job. In a 30 year coaching career after retiring from playing in the mid 1980s, 64 year old Craig had been employed almost exclusively as an assistant manager, except for one season (2009/10) as boss of Belgian side Charleroi. Quite why the St Mirren directors decided that Craig was now, finally, a year short of his pension, ready to be a manager, and given his involvement with the Lennon era, remains unanswered. Craig lasted 7 months before being sacked. Having appointed one assistant of a sacked manager, the St Mirren directors did the same thing again by replacing Craig with his assistant Gary Teale, who lasted until May 2015 (6 months), during which time the club were relegated to the Championship. Teale was followed by Ian Murray (May 2015 to December 2015), Alex Rae (December 2015 to September 2016) and then interim manager Allan McManus, before current manager Jack Ross was appointed in October 2016. There was no “new manager bounce” and Ross suffered 6 straight defeats after taking charge. A minor resurgence in December (2 wins, 2 draws and 1 defeat in a 5 game period) was abruptly ended last week with a damaging 3-0 home defeat against Queen Of The South, a team who had not won in 13 League games. Here is the current Championship table:
Dunfermline are the Championship’s form team, unbeaten in 7 games and the only team not to have suffered a defeat in the past 6 matches. The recent good run has been the result of the team operating as a cohesive unit, working hard for each other, defending efficiently and avoiding needless errors. The same approach will be required tomorrow, as no positive results come without applying 100% effort in this division. The Pars have won both previous meetings of the teams this season, both by 1 goal margins (4-3 at East End Park in September, and 1-0 in Paisley in November.) Pars line-up: the manager’s selection Injured: Ben Richards-Everton Suspended: None Allan Johnston has almost a full first team squad to choose from. In last week’s game at Ayr, Ryan Williamson and Lewis Spence both missed out on even a place on the bench, and if new signing Callum Morris is selected in the squad tomorrow, another first team squad regular will be watching the game from the stand. With this in mind, and with possible other deals to come in this month’s transfer window, Johnston has stated that one or two players may go out on loan. The manager is not known for changing a winning line-up, as was evidenced last week when the returning Rhys McCabe and Lewis Martin were not selected, having missed the win over Raith the week before, but having been in the team prior to that. It would be a surprise if any changes are made for this weekend’s game, with no injuries reported except for Ben Richards-Everton’s longer term absence. Preferred line-up Same team as last week – no need for change. Preferred starting 11, with squad numbers:
Photo by Pars Review. Tomorrow: Game Day image, then later in the evening match report/opinion with Pars player ratings and photos.
Dunfermline are now unbeaten in 7 League games, during which the team have scored at least once in every game.
The clean sheet at Ayr on Saturday was the first time this season that Dunfermline have had two consecutive shut-outs in the League.
Nicky Clark’s goal at Ayr took his total for Dunfermline to 8 in 15 League appearances this season, a ratio of one goal every 1.8 games. In this decade, only 3 other Pars players have a similar ratio of better than one goal every 2 games over the course of a season. The other players are Faissal El Bakhtaoui (22 goals in 31 games, 2015/16, ratio of a goal every 1.4 games); Lawrence Shankland (7 goals in 13 games, 2013/14: a goal every 1.8 games); and Martin Hardie (8 goals in 14 games, 2010/11: a goal every 1.7 games). Figures apply to League games only, and only players who played a minimum of 10 League games in a season were included in this statistic.
Kallum Higginbotham has more assists (7) than any other Pars player this season (total applies to all competitions).
For the second consecutive week, Dunfermline are top of the Championship current form table (most recent 6 games) with 12 points, one point ahead of Hibs. The Pars are also the only undefeated club in those past 6 games.
Dunfermline have the fourth highest average home attendance in the Championship this season, 4613. Hibs have the biggest average crowds at 15,251 followed by Dundee United (7105) and Falkirk (5159), then the Pars.
Two young players who have become important figures in the Pars’ current 8 game unbeaten run have agreed to remain with Dunfermline to the end of this season. John Herron and Paul McMullan, both on loan from Blackpool and Celtic, have contributed hugely to the team’s improved form and points total. They have also replaced two of the Pars’ most experienced players, with Herron taking Andy Geggan’s place in midfield, and McMullan replacing the left sided Joe Cardle (and also right midfielder Michael Paton, with his ability to play on both wings).
John Herron
22 year old John Herron is a former Celtic Youth captain, who won the Scottish Youth Cup with Celtic, defeating Dunfermline in the 2013 Final. He made 2 appearances for Celtic’s first team and played a further 5 games on loan at Cowdenbeath in 2015. In the summer of 2015, he joined Blackpool and made 20 appearances for the Lancashire club, mostly as a substitute. Arriving at East End Park on August 31st on a loan deal that would run until January 2017, he impressed on his first team starting debut at home to St Mirren on October 1st, but was injured the following week at Ayr, causing him to miss the rest of that month. He returned to the team on November 5th. In his 10 League appearances for Dunfermline so far, the team have lost just once. In the other League 10 games that he did not feature in, the team lost 7 times. A cultured midfielder, Herron has quickly established himself as a virtual automatic choice for one of the 2 central midfield places, and has also had the effect of making players who were not in the best of form play better when he is beside them: both Andy Geggan and Rhys McCabe have performed better when partnered by Herron, compared to when they played beside each other. Nat Wedderburn also had an excellent game alongside Herron at Ayr, and while credit has to go to these other players, they will doubtless be confident going into games with Herron at their side. Herron’s desire to remain with Dunfermline and extend his loan deal saw him accept reduced terms compared to his Blackpool contract, for which he deserves great credit.
Paul McMullan
Paul McMullan’s loan deal was provisionally agreed to last the whole 2016/17 season, but Celtic had a recall option this month. Yesterday’s news confirmed that he would remain at East End Park until the end of the season. McMullan has now been on loan to 4 clubs during his Celtic contract. His first loan spell was at Stenhousemuir in the second half of the 2014/15 season, during which he had several outstanding games, including one against Dunfermline. He caught the eye of many fans that day and scored one of Stenny’s goals in their 3-2 defeat. Further loan periods at St Mirren and Morton then led to him moving to Dunfermline in July last year. He was unable to break into the team initially but impressed as a substitute, and eventually won a first team starting place. His direct style of play, and the variations in his game, combined with his work ethic have seen him becoming one of the key Pars players in the second quarter of the season. He also scored one of (and possibly THE) Pars goals of the season, in the Scottish Cup tie at Buckie, when he weaved through the opposition defence and dinked the ball past the goalkeeper. Still only 20 years old, he has now started 50 games for his various loan clubs, and made a further 8 substitute appearances, giving him valuable first team experience for a young player.
Both deals are excellent news for Dunfermline and many Pars fans would be delighted if both players remained at the club permanently at the end of their loan periods.
Photos by Pars Review.
|
Blog Archive Original blog created July 2015. Moved to current site July 2016.
|