Manager blames fans for second half performance as team achieve first win in 8 games
TEAM NEWS: Michael Paton replaced Kallum Higginbotham as the only change from last week’s starting 11. Formation changed at different points in the game, from 4-1-4-1 to 4-3-3 and briefly 4-4-2.
MINUTES THAT MATTERED: 3′ Joe Cardle’s shot was charged down by the Brechin defence 18′ Liam Watt’s free kick for Brechin deflected off the top of the Pars defensive wall and behind 22′ GOAL From a Nat Wedderburn cross, Nicky Clark headed the ball across goal for Declan McManus to turn in 1-0 Dunfermline 26′ Clark had an effort that just missed the goal 44′ Another chance for Dunfermline when Clark’s header went just wide 49′ GOAL Michael Paton hammered in a shot from a Joe Cardle pass to make it 2-0 59′ GOAL Brechin sub Connor McLennan pulled a goal back with a tremendous shot from 25 yards 71′ Liam Watt’s shot from 20 yards was well saved by Sean Murdoch to prevent an equaliser 82′ Pars sub Kallum Higginbotham missed a chance to make it 3-1 when given a chance to shoot from a few yards out
Declan McManus celebrates his goal which, as seen here, takes him to 10 for the season
OPINION: No one would deny that securing 3 points was essential today, and having done so, the team moved up 2 places in the Championship table to third, with Queen of the South and Livingston both losing. However – and it’s a big however – the nature of the win, against the worst away team seen at EEP for some time, was far from impressive; Brechin City are the only club in the top 8 divisions in Scotland and England this season not to have won a League game. Manager Allan Johnston then came out with a series of criticisms of the fans in his post-match interview, while also claiming that the team’s first half performance was “brilliant” and that as soon as Brechin scored, the fans’ negativity caused the players to become anxious. This included an inability to make a simple pass, or avoid lumping the ball into one of the empty stands or straight to a Brechin player (specifically, Jason Talbot and Callum Morris). The vast majority of fans want to win, and will be naturally disappointed by a disjointed display against a very poor team, that was characterised at the end by the sight of us rolling the ball about at the corner flag, killing time until the final whistle blew. At half time, Ivo Den Biemen was introduced to the crowd as he made the half time draw. Shouts of “Ivo, Ivo” were heard and the applause he received was genuine and touching. THAT’S how a Dunfermline crowd want to react to one of their players. I honestly believe the manager went too far with his comments. I will leave it at that, for now. Further comments on this game will posted in tomorrow’s Stat Pack, Monday’s 5 Things We Learned, and Tuesday’s 2 Good, 2 Bad articles.
Photos and edits by Pars Review Tomorrow: Stat Pack Match photo gallery
Winless run continues in controversial circumstances
TEAM NEWS: A return to 4-4-2 with what could be regarded as the strongest 11, a familiar starting line-up that saw Dean Shiels and Kallum Higginbotham replace Lewis Martin and Michael Paton.
MINUTES THAT MATTERED: 6′ Ryan Williamson had a glorious chance to score his first ever goal when he was played in by Kallum Higginbotham. His effort was deflected wide when he should have scored 9′ Sean Murdoch raced out of his goal to make a clearance. The ball appeared to hit Murdoch’s hands outside the penalty box, then Saints forward Gavin Reilly made contact with Murdoch’s legs and a foul was given. Murdoch was booked and from the resultant free kick Saints shot wide 24′ Reilly headed straight at Murdoch – a glaring miss 38′ GOAL Ian McShane sent a ball across the box that was turned in by Cammy Smith. 1-0 St Mirren 43′ Declan McManus’ header almost gave Dunfermline an equaliser 44′ Reilly was put through on goal and with Murdoch rushing out, the dud ex-Pars loanee lifted his shot wide of the post 64′ Dunfermline were awarded a penalty for a foul on Williamson. Higginbotham placed the ball on the spot but with St Mirren players harrassing the linesman, referee Craig Charleston changed his decision and gave St Mirren a free kick 74′ Lee Ashcroft headed down a Cardle corner but Morris could not make good enough contact with the ball 82′ Sub Michael Paton’s first touch was a free kick that picked out Nicky Clark but his header was easily saved – it ought to have been a goal 87′ The Pars’ other sub, Fraser Aird, sliced a shot wide when he looked certain to grab a late equaliser
Referee Craig Charleston, seconds before overturning his decision to give Dunfermline a penalty
OPINION An improved performance that deserved at least a point but ended in another defeat. A return to 4-4-2 should not have been a surprise, as when under pressure, people often revert back to what gives them most comfort. In Allan Johnston’s case, it seemed odd that he would start a home game against Queen of the South with a 4-1-4-1 formation yet go with 4-4-2 away to St Mirren the following week. It was not the formation that was to blame for the defeat, however. St Mirren were not a side capable of dominating the midfield, and so Johnston’s favoured formation was not placed under undue pressure. Referee Craig Charleston is no friend of the Pars, and he made several decisions that raised doubts as to his supposed neutrality. While the home fans were unhappy with his decision to only book Sean Murdoch early in the game, St Mirren manager Jack Ross admitted post-match that a yellow card was probably sufficient, after he had watched the incident on video. What was undeniable was Charleston’s reluctance to book any Saints players, while issuing 5 yellow cards to Dunfermline. This included 2 incidents involving Saints’ Adam Eckersley, who kicked out at Declan McManus in front of the linesman – no action taken – then later in the second half made a 2 footed lunge that saw a free kick given against him but not even a word, far less a card, from the Falkirk-based referee. Dunfermline missed 3 golden chances to score: Ryan Williamson should have burst the net in the first half but saw his eventual effort deflected wide; Nicky Clark had a chance with a second half header but missed the goal; and Fraser Aird sliced a shot wide near the end of the game from a few yards out. For the home side, Gavin Reilly missed with a header and then a lob wide with the goal gaping. We are at the stage now of praising the team for showing some determination. They are struggling and have now gathered only 3 points (all draws) from the past 7 League games. Earlier in the season we would have won a game such as today’s. St Mirren and Dundee United are the poorest teams in many seasons to be fighting out the top spot in this division, which says something about the quality of the teams below them. Johnston now faces a game at home to Brechin next week that must be won.
Photos and edits by Pars Review Tomorrow: Stat Pack Match photo gallery
Shameful performance that surely puts the manager’s position in doubt
TEAM NEWS: Last week’s 4-1-4-1 formation was retained but with the returning Nicky Clark in the lone striker role, and last week’s forward Declan McManus wide right in place of Kallum Higginbotham. After 35 minutes the formation was changed to 4-4-2 with Nat Wedderburn subbed, Michael Paton moved to the right wing and Dean Shiels brought on, meaning the club’s only actual central midfielder was withdrawn, and the 2 centre midfield positions were filled by a centre half (Lewis Martin) and a former striker (Shiels).
MINUTES THAT MATTERED: 4′ Queens’ Andy Stirling hit a shot that was saved by Sean Murdoch 8′ GOAL 1-0 to Queens. Stirling back heeled the ball to Chris Kane who shot past Murdoch 14′ Joe Cardle’s effort was saved by Queens’ keeper Alan Martin 27′ GOAL Dobbie turned Ryan Williamson inside out and passed to Kane to score his second 30′ Stirling had a chance to make it 3-0 with the Pars defence AWOL but shot at Murdoch 35′ Wedderburn subbed, Shiels on, formation changed to 4-4-2 46′ Queens almost made it 3-0 seconds into the second half but Kane’s shot narrowly went over the bar from distance 47′ GOAL Williamson’s cross was met by Nicky Clark to pull a goal back 75′ GOAL Dobbie got his first goal and Queen’s third after Shiels lost possession. Murdoch was forced to run out of his goal but his attempted clearance fell to Dobbie who placed the ball into the empty goal 80′ GOAL Morris, already booked, and who had been saved from a second yellow minutes earlier, gave away a penalty from which Dobbie scored to make it 4-1 to Queens 85′ GOAL Clark pulled the ball back for McManus to head into the net from a yard out. 4-2 Queens. 90′ GOAL With the Dunfermline team having lost interest in the game, Dobbie got his third with zero resistance from the home side
OPINION A complete shambles from start to finish and a game that brought shame on our club. Starting with 1 up front, changing formation after 35 minutes and subbing the club’s only available central midfielder (Nat Wedderburn, who sat in the dug out in the huff at half time before walking back down the track at the start of the second half). A defence that was all over the place, with Ryan Williamson made to look foolish by Queens’ Stephen Dobbie, and captain Callum Morris having a nightmare, booked and then saved from a second yellow card by a sympathetic referee – you know it’s bad when Willie Collum takes pity on you. From the start, when Queens almost scored with their first attack, the signs were there: disjointed and lacking any semblance of decent organisation, the team looked like a collection of drunks meandering out of the pub after closing time. Johnston, meanwhile, stood on the touchline waving his arms around in a manner reminiscent of Dick Campbell in his time as Pars boss. No clue. Just get the ball up the park. This performance went beyond “unacceptable”. It was an insult to the history of our club. We have no divine right to win, but this certainly is not how to lose a game. After the fourth goal, the team gave up. They simply stopped trying. Dobbie was outstanding for Queens, and as a football fan credit must be given to him for taking full advantage of the situation. He can be glad that Johnston isn’t his manager, otherwise he’d probably be playing at left back.
Photos and edits by Pars Review Tomorrow: Stat Pack
A spirited display with a new formation but another Tannadice defeat
TEAM NEWS: Nicky Clark was an unexpected absentee in a depleted squad that featured just 5 players on the bench. Allan Johnston changed the team formation to 4-1-4-1 with Big Nat in defensive midfield, Lewis Martin in centre midfield and Declan McManus as a lone striker.
MINUTES THAT MATTERED: 13′ United striker Scott McDonald delayed a shot inside the penalty box when presented with a great chance to open the scoring 15′ GOAL Kallum Higginbotham tried to shield the ball out of play on the by-line but it was kept in by United who played it across to their right. Jason Talbot then conceded a free kick which was, predictably, converted by Scott Fraser 17′ Declan McManus led a breakaway and played the ball across goal where it was met by Higgibotham who put the chance wide 42′ GOAL Higginbotham and Wedderburn both allowed Scott Fraser to advance into the box unchallenged after a United throw-in on the Pars’ right. Fraser took advantage to shoot past Murdoch and make the score 2-0 55′ Higginbotham, who had been booked 5 minutes earlier, was substituted after a completely inept display 75′ GOAL Fraser Aird, who had replaced Higginbotham, made a superb run which ended in him being fouled inside the penalty box. Declan McManus scored with the spot kick to bring Dunfermline back into the game
Fraser Aird
OPINION: Another defeat at the home of Dundee United but this was not the meek capitulation that we have seen so often and were probably fearing again. Poor defending in the first half saw the team go 2-0 behind but an improved second half, led by Michael Paton and sub Fraser Aird, almost led to what would have been a deserved point. Defeat is never satisfactory but there was a steely determination within the team that has been missing in recent weeks. There was a rare change in formation – would Nicky Clark have played up front on his own had he been available? Was the change to 4-1-4-1 planned all along? Whatever, the change made a difference and although it was unusual to see Lewis Martin in centre midfield, the extra physical presence and athleticism meant that there was no soft centre in the Dunfermline line-up. Michael Paton was the team’s best performer – the best passer of the ball in the squad, all he lacks is a burst of pace otherwise he would be in the division above. Sadly, Kallum Higginbotham had another poor game, and as noted in the “minutes that mattered” above, he had a role in both United goals and was, generally, very poor. His replacement Fraser Aird was a huge improvement on the right midfield and his run that won the penalty kick, plus several other good passages of play, will surely see him included from the start next week. Sean Murdoch lost yet another free kick goal, another shot on his stronger left side that beat the wall and the Pars keeper. At this stage, almost every opposition free kick is a goal and we appear unable to prevent ordinary Championship players from looking like Zico in these situations. The squad needs a refresh in certain areas but the manager will be pleased with the impact of Paton and Aird, who have barely featured this season but who look like a better option than certain “regulars”.
Photos and edits by Pars Review Tomorrow: Match photo gallery Stat Pack
|
|